Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare

409 replies

ChickenRacer · 07/05/2023 06:58

Ive heard so many stories about grandparents not wanting to help/be particularly involved with their grandchildren.I understand it’s not all grandparents, but their is a big proportion who just don’t help and support their children when they have small children.

Explanations for this often seem to be that the grandparents did their time parenting and now it’s their time to enjoy life. Which I do understand.

But to me though this seems so sad.

They say it takes a village to raise children - but grandparents are a huge part of many peoples village, so if they aren’t part of the village that’s less support for parents of young children.

This might upset some people, but I also wonder those grandparents that do not feel they want to help with the care of their grandchildren- do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Please don’t be all upset by this, they are genuine questions.

I have 3 children and for various reasons have ZERO help from grandparents. But I very much hope if I am lucky enough to have grandchildren that I will be able to help my children with them in the best way for them. And I wouldn’t want them to have to care for me in my old age. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:36

It’s funny isn’t it?

Yeah, hilarious.

All because they didn’t cater to the demands to provide childcare for children they had no say in creating.

It's vile to refer to the idea that one might very occasionally spend time with one's grandchildren as "childcare".

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:35

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:26

Indeed.

But some people's definition of it shows them to be extremely selfish and callous people who don't deserve a family.

I find it interesting that you've decided that anyone who doesn't want to provide childcare is "selfish and callous".

Why is your definition of "family" the right one, and why do you feel that anyone who disagrees is "undeserving"?

Sounds pretty unpleasant to me.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:34

Good for you. But such people don't deserve the benefits of family if they also won't lift a finger to help anyone else and make children feel like they are unimportant because they are far, far too busy sat on their backsides doing sweet FA to inconvenience themselves to spend any time with their own grandchildren. Anyone with such a definition of family doesn't really understand the purpose of it.

CleverLilViper · 07/05/2023 19:32

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:26

Indeed.

But some people's definition of it shows them to be extremely selfish and callous people who don't deserve a family.

It’s funny isn’t it?

How some people define a family to be whatever suits them and anything that goes against that from others equates to them being selfish and callous and undeserving of family.

All because they didn’t cater to the demands to provide childcare for children they had no say in creating.

CleverLilViper · 07/05/2023 19:31

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:16

I’m sorry for your situation and it’s genuinely sad but if you were disabled prior to having children that should have factored into your decision to have children, should it not?

I wasn't.

Your parents aren’t selfish for not wanting to cover for you for a decision that you made. That might be harsh but it’s the truth. It’d be nice if they offered no doubt but they’re not obligated to.

This is exactly the problem. Viewing children in the family as solely the parents' responsibility and nothing to do with anyone else, and that spending time with them is some kind of imposition or inconvenience. Most cultures are not like that. It's very unhealthy and unpleasant. To describe the idea that someone might be expected to very ocassionally, at their own convenience, spend a few hours with their own nieces/ nephews/ grandchildren as an "obligation" is really messed up. It's the whole point of family.

Everyone’s view of family is different.

Your view may differ from the views of your parents. Your kids are your responsibility and as none of your family got a say in bringing them into the world they’re not obliged to provide childcare. You didn’t consult the village before having children so why are they then made responsible for decisions they didn’t make?

Thats not to say that it wouldn’t be nice if they would offer to help in emergencies-it would. I have a nephew and I love spending time with him and want to be an active presence in his life.

I just don’t think it’s something that should be forced on people who don’t want it-even family.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:26

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:18

To describe the idea that someone might be expected to very ocassionally, at their own convenience, spend a few hours with their own nieces/ nephews/ grandchildren as an "obligation" is really messed up. It's the whole point of family.

There's no single definition of family though - everyone is different.

Indeed.

But some people's definition of it shows them to be extremely selfish and callous people who don't deserve a family.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:25

Milliways · 07/05/2023 18:55

When we had our DC all 4 grandparents were still working. Once MIL retired we would ask her to help cover sick days, help when DS broke his leg and couldn’t go to school etc, but never regular hours. They saw days with her as a treat then. They could also spend the odd night with my parents.

I now have a 5 year old GS and would love to be able to look after him, but I also still work full time and cannot retire for another few years. They also live too far away to visit without stayimg over! We do however travel up to babysit so they can go away for the odd night or weekend, and I have taken leave to help in a half term etc.

But this is fine. You babysit sometimes, you give them a break, you have them to stay over sometimes. That's normal.

The people who are really messed up are the ones who never do anything like that. In 7 years I've not had family take DC out for a day, or have them stay overnight, or babysit. Not once. They refer to spending an hour with my DC in my garden while I fold washing upstairs (has happened twice in their lifetime) as "childcare". They clearly resent the presence of the younger members of our family and view spending time with them as an imposition. It's insulting to the children and extremely unpleasant. They just want to "play" grandparents without lifting a finger with me present at all times to facilitate, and then wait on them hand and foot as well as the children. Never lift a finger. Knowing I'm a lone parent and disabled. It's so selfish and callous.

I don't think people are complaining about people like you who look after GC so parents can have a night away sometimes! Could only dream of that. When I was in hospital overnight I had to hire an overnight nanny...

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:18

To describe the idea that someone might be expected to very ocassionally, at their own convenience, spend a few hours with their own nieces/ nephews/ grandchildren as an "obligation" is really messed up. It's the whole point of family.

There's no single definition of family though - everyone is different.

5128gap · 07/05/2023 19:17

Surely any help you give to aging parents, if you want to be so transactional about it, is the pay back for the sacrifices they made in raising you.
If your parents need to put in 18 years with you plus another half dozen with your children, for maybe a couple of years of you picking up their shopping, setting up their internet, and taking them to hospital appointments In return; then you drive a pretty hard bargain, and may be in danger of pricing yourself out of the market.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:16

I’m sorry for your situation and it’s genuinely sad but if you were disabled prior to having children that should have factored into your decision to have children, should it not?

I wasn't.

Your parents aren’t selfish for not wanting to cover for you for a decision that you made. That might be harsh but it’s the truth. It’d be nice if they offered no doubt but they’re not obligated to.

This is exactly the problem. Viewing children in the family as solely the parents' responsibility and nothing to do with anyone else, and that spending time with them is some kind of imposition or inconvenience. Most cultures are not like that. It's very unhealthy and unpleasant. To describe the idea that someone might be expected to very ocassionally, at their own convenience, spend a few hours with their own nieces/ nephews/ grandchildren as an "obligation" is really messed up. It's the whole point of family.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:14

I also think if parents received help with their own children then don’t pay it forward then that’s pretty gross.

See, I can't agree with this.

Nobody should be obligated to provide any help - the fact that they happen to have received help themselves 30/40 years ago is totally irrelevant IMO.

Mary46 · 07/05/2023 19:08

Yes lola works both ways. Then you get told on here you petty about it! We dont bring my mam on breaks as I do feel we just ploughed on over the years 0 help. Thats how I feel about it

Milliways · 07/05/2023 18:55

When we had our DC all 4 grandparents were still working. Once MIL retired we would ask her to help cover sick days, help when DS broke his leg and couldn’t go to school etc, but never regular hours. They saw days with her as a treat then. They could also spend the odd night with my parents.

I now have a 5 year old GS and would love to be able to look after him, but I also still work full time and cannot retire for another few years. They also live too far away to visit without stayimg over! We do however travel up to babysit so they can go away for the odd night or weekend, and I have taken leave to help in a half term etc.

JonahAndTheSnail · 07/05/2023 18:50

My mum always said you don't have children with the expectation that they'll take care of you in old age. My dad's mum took the opposite view; she had 11 children, as it was the done thing back then and to ensure you 'had someone to look after you in old age'. At the end of my gran's life, my Mum was the person who visited most regularly, despite this lady being fairly nasty to my mum for being a divorcee before she met my dad.

LolaSmiles · 07/05/2023 18:40

You're right Mary46.
There's a big difference between not showing any interest in grandchildren and not signing up to provide year round childcare.

It's hardly surprising relationships are more distant where there's limited effort. Grandparents can be engaged and loving grandparents without having to provide childcare.

Norriscolesbag · 07/05/2023 18:38

I think if you expect to ask for help from your children when you are older- if you have done nothing for your grandchildren (for no good reason)- then you are truly taking the piss.

I also think if parents received help with their own children then don’t pay it forward then that’s pretty gross.

I am obviously excluding anyone who NEEDS to work to financially survive or is physically unable.

The people around me- the grandparents either seem to do far too much or nothing at all. There seems to be little healthy inbetween.

Mary46 · 07/05/2023 18:29

Its a few things. Hard when they dont show much interest in gc and wonder why theres not much of a bond in later years. I dont think its too big an ask maybe 2 nights babysitting a year lol. But I agree set days childminding is a big ask.

EerieSilence · 07/05/2023 18:27

Not this old thing again.
I signed up to bring up my child. Didn't sign up to bring up her children. As a parent, you need to be prepared for all possibilities and emergencies. It can be very hard but asking your parents should be something that's an emergency, not an obligation. I got no help from DM - she lives in another country and had no family around. It taught me to be self-sufficient and be able to sort out all sorts of emergencies.
DM deserves her child-free time now, she did a good job, now she can have her hobbies and freedom to choose what she does with her own time.

mimi0708 · 07/05/2023 18:26

I kind of agree with you OP. I have friends whose parents look after their grandkids a lot and are so close to them and it makes their lives so much easier and allow them to continue working. We don't have any grandparents help and it is fine but then they complain that my DD doesn't want to hang out with them or are not close to them when they rarely see her or play with her!!

Putyourdamnshoeson · 07/05/2023 18:20

5128gap · 07/05/2023 18:19

This is true. I'm a 'parent' GP, as in DCG practically lives here. I do the drudge stuff, the eat your veg and tidy your toys stuff. I get told 'I don't like you nanny' when I say its pyjama time but am the lap of choice for the pre bedtime cuddle.
Nanna Paternal on the other hand, who they see 4 times a year, is all fun, like a child herself with them. They get 100% of her when they're with her, never tired or distracted, and they adore her.
Two very different ways of being a GP, each bringing something different to DGCs life. Both loving and both of us loved.

You are likely the one she will speak most fondly of as an adult though.

5128gap · 07/05/2023 18:19

Noicant · 07/05/2023 18:01

I think also equating childcare with gps being interested is not healthy. The childcare isn’t for your kids it’s for you.

We’ve never had childcare it’s not easy but thats also why we have one child. We had the number of kids we can manage, financially and emotionally (we are both introverts who seem to have made an extrovert). I wouldn’t expect DD’s elderly gps to babysit here. I’m knackered and I’m significantly younger than them.

I imagine there are plenty of people with perfectly lovely relationships with their gps who have never actually been left in their care. Dd has a lovely relationship with one set of gps conducted pretty much entirely over facetime. They show an interest in what she likes and what she’s doing and she’s happy to talk to them regularly.

This is true. I'm a 'parent' GP, as in DCG practically lives here. I do the drudge stuff, the eat your veg and tidy your toys stuff. I get told 'I don't like you nanny' when I say its pyjama time but am the lap of choice for the pre bedtime cuddle.
Nanna Paternal on the other hand, who they see 4 times a year, is all fun, like a child herself with them. They get 100% of her when they're with her, never tired or distracted, and they adore her.
Two very different ways of being a GP, each bringing something different to DGCs life. Both loving and both of us loved.

CleverLilViper · 07/05/2023 18:09

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 18:01

Lol. I am disabled, in huge pain every day, much more ill than my parents. And I'm a lone parent. My children's grandparents have still done fuck all, ever, with them. Not babysat while they are in bed, not taken them out for the day, never had them to stay without me there. All these excuses. Some people are just utterly selfish and care for nobody but themselves.

I’m sorry for your situation and it’s genuinely sad but if you were disabled prior to having children that should have factored into your decision to have children, should it not?

Your parents aren’t selfish for not wanting to cover for you for a decision that you made. That might be harsh but it’s the truth. It’d be nice if they offered no doubt but they’re not obligated to.

blahblahblah1654 · 07/05/2023 18:07

@imnotsadyouresad I agree with this. Expecting to burden elderly grandparents with young children on a regular basis isn't on. I'm likely to be 70s/80s if I have grandchildren. Who knows what my health will be like? At the same time I wouldn't expect them to look after me in old age. I'll like to take an active role in any grandchildren's life but not as a free childminder. I don't expect it from my parents.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 18:01

Lol. I am disabled, in huge pain every day, much more ill than my parents. And I'm a lone parent. My children's grandparents have still done fuck all, ever, with them. Not babysat while they are in bed, not taken them out for the day, never had them to stay without me there. All these excuses. Some people are just utterly selfish and care for nobody but themselves.

5128gap · 07/05/2023 18:01

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 16:47

No emotionally healthy, loving person who actually likes and loves their family would want to watch their children struggle to cope with no break ever and turn down the opportunity to be spending time with their grandchildren for the occasional overnight stay or having them over for lunch or taking them for a day out or whatever is within their capabilities. Unless you are extremely disabled, a refusal to ever spend time with your own grandchildren/ nieces/ nephews etc and view it as an imposition is frankly weird and show you have a very messed up sense of what "family" means. It's not normal. No matter how indignantly these totally self-absorbed people want to argue it is. Mist of us would never dream of behaving like this, hence the regular threads on this topic because ultimately it is only very, very emotionally stunted or self-centred people who behave like this, unless they are extremely ancient or unwell so it's not possible, which is of course different.

The regular topics on this thread are not about the extreme situation you describe though.
The vast majority involve people being 'sad' not because GPs don't want to see their GC, but because they don't want to sacrifice large chunks of their own lives to provide free childcare to the level their own children require of them.
In the last week we've had people 'sad' that an OP was paying her mum £20 a week to provide childcare. Because its so so sad if the grandma doesn't realise she's the lucky one in being permitted to have the children!
Its interesting to me that while most parents would be in agreement that looking after children is very hard work, that can be tedious, relentless and exhausting (hence their own need for help), somehow when this same work is done by someone a generation older, it transforms itself into pure pleasure.
Oh and can we at least have a little honesty when we say 'grandparents' in these discussions? Because that's not what we mean really, is it? I have not seen a single thread with am OP complaining that their father isn't offering them a childcare service. Its always women. Women who've already done it once, being painted as unnatural, unloving, bad mothers, cold, unfeeling because they don't want to do it all again in their middle to old age.

Swipe left for the next trending thread