Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare

409 replies

ChickenRacer · 07/05/2023 06:58

Ive heard so many stories about grandparents not wanting to help/be particularly involved with their grandchildren.I understand it’s not all grandparents, but their is a big proportion who just don’t help and support their children when they have small children.

Explanations for this often seem to be that the grandparents did their time parenting and now it’s their time to enjoy life. Which I do understand.

But to me though this seems so sad.

They say it takes a village to raise children - but grandparents are a huge part of many peoples village, so if they aren’t part of the village that’s less support for parents of young children.

This might upset some people, but I also wonder those grandparents that do not feel they want to help with the care of their grandchildren- do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Please don’t be all upset by this, they are genuine questions.

I have 3 children and for various reasons have ZERO help from grandparents. But I very much hope if I am lucky enough to have grandchildren that I will be able to help my children with them in the best way for them. And I wouldn’t want them to have to care for me in my old age. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 10:23

You must see the difference between 'spending time with family' that doesn't require you to change nappies, supervise on the toilet, be constantly vigilant for their safety, be entirely responsible for their entertainment, dress them, prepare, supervise and clean up after their meals, haul about various weighty pieces of equipment and engage in lengthy activity that you may find extremely tedious, and being in sole charge of GC?
While it's possible to enjoy all of the above, there can be no denying its not 'work' or childcare. Have you ever tried suggesting otherwise to a SAHM?

My children are school aged. They don't require any of that, just being fed now and again like any adult guest would.

But no, even when they did need more physical help I wouldn't have described it as "work", I've always thought that is a bizarre way to speak about spending time with your family. I work full time and time with family/ friends is leisure time, not work.

5128gap · 08/05/2023 10:11

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 09:33

Taking care of children is childcare.

As I and others have said, it's extremely sad for you and the younger members of your family that you view spending time with them as a tedious obligation equivalent to a job people have to be paid for. Most people look forward to occasional time with family and view it as a joy and a privilege, not a chore. But of course it's entirely your choice to do that, and have distant and superficial relationships. Just don't expect other people to validate it or pretend it's normal. And believe me, children know, so they won't grow up anywhere near as close to their grandparents as those who grandparents regularly spent time on them rather than being entirely focused on endless holidays etc.

You must see the difference between 'spending time with family' that doesn't require you to change nappies, supervise on the toilet, be constantly vigilant for their safety, be entirely responsible for their entertainment, dress them, prepare, supervise and clean up after their meals, haul about various weighty pieces of equipment and engage in lengthy activity that you may find extremely tedious, and being in sole charge of GC?
While it's possible to enjoy all of the above, there can be no denying its not 'work' or childcare. Have you ever tried suggesting otherwise to a SAHM?

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 09:34

We get out of life what we put in and most things tend to come full circle.

Exactly this.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 09:33

Taking care of children is childcare.

As I and others have said, it's extremely sad for you and the younger members of your family that you view spending time with them as a tedious obligation equivalent to a job people have to be paid for. Most people look forward to occasional time with family and view it as a joy and a privilege, not a chore. But of course it's entirely your choice to do that, and have distant and superficial relationships. Just don't expect other people to validate it or pretend it's normal. And believe me, children know, so they won't grow up anywhere near as close to their grandparents as those who grandparents regularly spent time on them rather than being entirely focused on endless holidays etc.

AnneElliott · 07/05/2023 21:13

I think it's sad if the GPs aren't involved but some are still working etc. And I think asking for several full days each week (as I've seen on MN) is too much.

My mum did 1 day for my DS and one day for my brothers DD. And later when they were both at school they picked them up and took them to dinner. My parents have fond memories of those days. But I wouldn't have accepted more than 1 day per week even if it had been offered.

Hyppogriff · 07/05/2023 20:25

My parents were both dead before my DC arrived (they were older parents). My husband’s are great but they are both still working. I agree with what others have said that’s there’s a huge different between expecting regular weekly childcare and being willing to have the kids for the odd weekend / here and there and I’d be really sad if we didn’t hVe the latter but would never expect the former.
Would I expect my kids to care for me in old age ? No I hope they wouldn’t and will focus on their own lives (having had a father with Alzheimer’s it sucks). But I would hope they would keep a general eye !!

Norriscolesbag · 07/05/2023 20:19

Wow a few typos on there but hopefully clear enough…

Norriscolesbag · 07/05/2023 20:18

To be honest it’s not dissimilar to crap parents who don’t want to know their own children- it hurts at the time as the solo parent but the one who didn’t bother but will be the one who regrets it later in life. Absent without good cause grandparents can make every excuse they want for not bothering- when they are older then their children/ grandchildren l won’t want to know. We get out of life what we put in and most things tend to come full circle.

hiredandsqueak · 07/05/2023 20:09

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:58

What else would it be? If you’re asking them to care for your kids- it’s childcare. That’s not vile. It’s a fact.

Just being a family! When I'm with my children I'm not "doing childcare", it's just family time. When I sit on the sofa and they're in bed it's not "babysitting". People who look after ageing parents haven't become "care workers". It's just a normal part of behaving as normal families do, to spend time together and help each other out and most people enjoy most of the time they spend as a family, tragic circumstances and severe illness etc aside. They don't resent it and view it as an imposition or somehow equivalent to work that a stranger would have to pay you for. If that is how you view it then as I said, your notion of what "family" means needs a good rethink.

Yes when you are looking after your kids that isn't childcare as they are your kids and your responsibility. Anyone else looking after your kids is providing childcare though. FWIW I do childcare for my grandson as well as spend time as a family including grandson but I'm in no expectation that my dc should provide for me in my old age in fact quite the opposite, I shall take myself off to a care home so that their middle aged years aren't blighted.

GwynethP123 · 07/05/2023 20:07

I agree that grandparents shouldn't have to provide constant childcare especially if they're older. What bugged me about both our sets of grandparents was the complete lack of help in general and almost wilful uselessness. Also the demands for our presence at family events with no concessions made for tired toddlers and breastfeeding babies. Not even an offer to hold a baby or take the pram for a short walk. Complaints about us putting fully wrapped nappies in the outdoor wheelie bin when visiting. Sighing when we had to tie blankets over their thin cotton bedroom curtains when staying overnight so baby wouldn't wake at 4am. DHs parents swanning off on 10 holidays per year, plenty of energy, but only happy to see us on their terms and not very often. No offers of occasional babysitting. Resentment from my mum when she had my daughter for one night due to an evening family occasion on DHs side. Just an awful attitude. Children are genuinely lovely, not naughty, but have a fairly distant relationship with their gparents as a result. I would feel so lucky to have grandchildren one day and would definitely want to help and have a closer relationship with them. I used to stay with my grandparents most holidays but my mum conveniently forgets this and pretends it hardly happened, but I was often there for a full week at a time. I feel sad my children haven't had a loving, close relationship like that with their grandparents. I don't understand it at all, they've missed out massively.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 20:06

CleverLilViper · 07/05/2023 20:02

Taking care of children is childcare.

You can dress it up all you want to try and paint anyone who dares not provide you with what you feel entitled to but it is childcare.

if you want someone, family or not, to look after your children in your absence, they are providing you with childcare.

Exactly.

Grandparents should never feel pressured into being in sole charge of grandchildren. They can come and visit them with the parents present, or join them on family days out, or host everyone at their house.

That's how it worked in my family growing up and it was absolutely fine. I loved my grandparents and we were very close despite them never having sole care of me - which was the case for a whole variety of reasons.

CleverLilViper · 07/05/2023 20:02

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:58

What else would it be? If you’re asking them to care for your kids- it’s childcare. That’s not vile. It’s a fact.

Just being a family! When I'm with my children I'm not "doing childcare", it's just family time. When I sit on the sofa and they're in bed it's not "babysitting". People who look after ageing parents haven't become "care workers". It's just a normal part of behaving as normal families do, to spend time together and help each other out and most people enjoy most of the time they spend as a family, tragic circumstances and severe illness etc aside. They don't resent it and view it as an imposition or somehow equivalent to work that a stranger would have to pay you for. If that is how you view it then as I said, your notion of what "family" means needs a good rethink.

Taking care of children is childcare.

You can dress it up all you want to try and paint anyone who dares not provide you with what you feel entitled to but it is childcare.

if you want someone, family or not, to look after your children in your absence, they are providing you with childcare.

LolaSmiles · 07/05/2023 20:01

WildFlowerBees
Some people definitely have that mentality.

I do think there's some truth in it taking a village, and am certainly grateful for the friends/family/neighbours we have, but don't think that the 'village' automatically equals expecting (female) grandparents to provide childcare. Sometimes people use the phrase "it takes a village" to focus on what they can get out people, rather than creating and nurturing authentic relationships with people and all being there for each other in different ways.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:58

What else would it be? If you’re asking them to care for your kids- it’s childcare. That’s not vile. It’s a fact.

Just being a family! When I'm with my children I'm not "doing childcare", it's just family time. When I sit on the sofa and they're in bed it's not "babysitting". People who look after ageing parents haven't become "care workers". It's just a normal part of behaving as normal families do, to spend time together and help each other out and most people enjoy most of the time they spend as a family, tragic circumstances and severe illness etc aside. They don't resent it and view it as an imposition or somehow equivalent to work that a stranger would have to pay you for. If that is how you view it then as I said, your notion of what "family" means needs a good rethink.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:55

WildFlowerBees · 07/05/2023 19:52

This takes a village nonsense is just another way of saying we/I don't want to parent alone. People who have kids should know it's their kids and are not entitled to think that anyone else will help out.

And it's pretty much always women who are expected to give their time up as well - these threads are rarely ever about how dad/FIL won't provide several days of free childcare.

WildFlowerBees · 07/05/2023 19:52

This takes a village nonsense is just another way of saying we/I don't want to parent alone. People who have kids should know it's their kids and are not entitled to think that anyone else will help out.

Bresia · 07/05/2023 19:52

Neither side were very involved grandparents but now they need elderly support - I’m too busy be self sufficient and living my life to care for them - we visit occasionally though. What goes around..,,

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:48

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:47

so I'm not sure where you get off on calling me the unpleasant one 🙄

The views you have expressed are unpleasant, yes.

And I think you'll find it was actually you that accused me of being unpleasant.

I don't have time for this, I have a family to spend time with. 😆 Clearly you are spending your time not bothering with yours to great effect, so I'll leave you to it.

Ooh, I'm hurt 😂

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:47

so I'm not sure where you get off on calling me the unpleasant one 🙄

The views you have expressed are unpleasant, yes.

And I think you'll find it was actually you that accused me of being unpleasant.

I don't have time for this, I have a family to spend time with. 😆 Clearly you are spending your time not bothering with yours to great effect, so I'll leave you to it.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:44

Your thinking seems very black and white - like anyone who doesn't agree with your idea of family is automatically a horrible person.

There's just not much point in them having a family if they have no interest in being around other family members, is there?

I'd love to know what this alternative and better definition of family is that involves not caring about the other members or spending any time with them and how that would be more beneficial for everyone. Ridiculous.

Not everything is subjective. It is possible to look at and study human behaviour and social structures and determine what tends to create healthy, happy families and relationships and what doesn't. You proposal that families treat each other like acquaintances - based on the copious research on these topics - does not appear to be one that is likely to have better outcomes for individuals or society as a whole.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:43

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:40

I find it interesting that you've decided that anyone who doesn't want to provide childcare is "selfish and callous".

How many times? I have never asked my family to do "childcare." I have nannies for that.

I thought they might occasionally want to spend some time with their grandchilden.

Why is your definition of "family" the right one, and why do you feel that anyone who disagrees is "undeserving"?

Because people who have no interest in spending time with their wider family clearly don't understand the notion. If you don't spend time with your family, how could the idea mean anything of significance?

Sounds pretty unpleasant to me.

Well yes, your posts have indeed shown a very unpleasant attitude.

Grandparents can come and visit and have quality time with their grandchildren without taking sole responsibility for them though, surely?

My grandparents never had sole care of me when I was growing up (for a whole variety of reasons) - it never impacted the closeness our relationship and I was devastated when they passed away.

I'm not the one calling people callous and selfish and telling them they don't deserve a family, so I'm not sure where you get off on calling me the unpleasant one 🙄

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:40

I find it interesting that you've decided that anyone who doesn't want to provide childcare is "selfish and callous".

How many times? I have never asked my family to do "childcare." I have nannies for that.

I thought they might occasionally want to spend some time with their grandchilden.

Why is your definition of "family" the right one, and why do you feel that anyone who disagrees is "undeserving"?

Because people who have no interest in spending time with their wider family clearly don't understand the notion. If you don't spend time with your family, how could the idea mean anything of significance?

Sounds pretty unpleasant to me.

Well yes, your posts have indeed shown a very unpleasant attitude.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:39

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:36

It’s funny isn’t it?

Yeah, hilarious.

All because they didn’t cater to the demands to provide childcare for children they had no say in creating.

It's vile to refer to the idea that one might very occasionally spend time with one's grandchildren as "childcare".

Do you genuinely feel like grandparents have to spend time with their grandchildren alone in order to be considered family?

CleverLilViper · 07/05/2023 19:38

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:36

It’s funny isn’t it?

Yeah, hilarious.

All because they didn’t cater to the demands to provide childcare for children they had no say in creating.

It's vile to refer to the idea that one might very occasionally spend time with one's grandchildren as "childcare".

What else would it be? If you’re asking them to care for your kids- it’s childcare. That’s not vile. It’s a fact.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 19:37

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 19:34

Good for you. But such people don't deserve the benefits of family if they also won't lift a finger to help anyone else and make children feel like they are unimportant because they are far, far too busy sat on their backsides doing sweet FA to inconvenience themselves to spend any time with their own grandchildren. Anyone with such a definition of family doesn't really understand the purpose of it.

No, they just have a different definition to you.

Your thinking seems very black and white - like anyone who doesn't agree with your idea of family is automatically a horrible person.

Swipe left for the next trending thread