Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare

409 replies

ChickenRacer · 07/05/2023 06:58

Ive heard so many stories about grandparents not wanting to help/be particularly involved with their grandchildren.I understand it’s not all grandparents, but their is a big proportion who just don’t help and support their children when they have small children.

Explanations for this often seem to be that the grandparents did their time parenting and now it’s their time to enjoy life. Which I do understand.

But to me though this seems so sad.

They say it takes a village to raise children - but grandparents are a huge part of many peoples village, so if they aren’t part of the village that’s less support for parents of young children.

This might upset some people, but I also wonder those grandparents that do not feel they want to help with the care of their grandchildren- do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Please don’t be all upset by this, they are genuine questions.

I have 3 children and for various reasons have ZERO help from grandparents. But I very much hope if I am lucky enough to have grandchildren that I will be able to help my children with them in the best way for them. And I wouldn’t want them to have to care for me in my old age. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:33

No one on this thread but you (for now, at least) is talking about occasional days out. It is, as always, about childcare.

All of my posts made it completely clear that I have nannies for childcare, have never asked for or expected any "childcare" from family and was speaking entirely about how sad it is that my children's grandparents have never spent any independent time with them for even a few hours, to go to the park or have them visit for lunch without me, ever. Not once. And that my children notice this: that other people's grandparents do this and theirs don't, so are less close to theirs as a result. They do not have the bond that their friends do with theirs, who have bothered to develop a relationship and don't view them as an inconvenience.

So if mine are not the posts you disagree with or what you mean by "childcare", then I'm not sure why it is my posts in particular that have elicited all of these outraged responses insisting that my parents spending a few hours once in a blue moon with my children to have them visit for lunch or go for a walk with them would have been me expecting them to "rear them" for me. In fact, if it wasn't so absurd that it can't be taken seriously it would be rather insulting.

Being expected to "rear their grandchildren", if they had spent a couple of hours with them alone, ever. I mean, honestly. You're making yourselves look beyond ridiculous.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 11:32

And yes, while the things you listed may also be enjoyable and done in your leisure time, they are also work.

According to the definition. I go to the gym and ‘work out’ and I ‘work hard’ in the gym. I enjoy it. It achieves a result. It’s tiring and draining and something I still enjoy.

Just like grandparents who look after their grandkids and enjoy doing so. They are doing something they want to do. And also putting in effort and, often, find it tiring. It’s no less work because they also enjoy it. It is still work and often hard work looking after kids all day, especially when you are older. Still can be enjoyable.

StarryCup · 08/05/2023 11:30

So you consider anything that requires physical or mental effort to be work? Sports, going to the gym

Isn't that called doing a work out?

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 11:28

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:24

Parents put in physical or mental effort. Therefore it’s work. Wether it’s something you also enjoy, doesn’t change that it’s work.

So you consider anything that requires physical or mental effort to be work? Sports, going to the gym, reading a book, playing a musical instrument, going on holiday, somebody even mentioned having to "chat" to people as "work" 😆 so going out for a meal must be an endurance exercise. On this definition it seems pretty much any kind of hobby or social activity has now apparently been reclassified as work. Going for a walk was mentioned too. I'd love to know what such people consider to be a leisure activity given that all of that now apparently constitutes "work". I guess they must just sit completely still in a room in absolute silence.

As I said, bonkers.

I consider?

Do you know words have actual definitions?

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare
Effieswig · 08/05/2023 11:25

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:17

Lol. So when I have my parents to stay here should I consider that work? Hotelier, chef, entertainer, housekeeping service? The huge mental effort of having to speak to them (the horror) or maybe plan the odd trip out for us all or go for a walk with them? Yes, such an imposition, like a paid job!

Or, like most normal people, consider this just normal leisure time with family.

Yes. It’s both. It’s not employment. It’s not a job title.

But it requires mental and physical effort. So the definition of work. It’s also enjoyable.

You may class it as leisure time. Some people may not As you are not free to do as you wish, as you have guests. But that doesn’t mean it’s not enjoyable, doesn’t mean you aren’t happy to do it, look forward to and are glad you do it.

Work doesn’t mean it’s not enjoyable. Work doesn’t only applied to paid work. Work doesn’t mean you don’t want to do it or do not enjoy something.

You seem to be unable to admit that being in sole charge of a child requires mental and physical effort, so is work. No child is going to have a good relationship with a grandparent, if the grandparent is not putting in mental and/or physical effort in. No matter how much time they ‘spend together’.

Again, how would a grandparent in sole charge of a child do so without any mental or physical effort.

Being in charge of a child is work. Your own, made up definition, or the word work does not apply.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:24

Parents put in physical or mental effort. Therefore it’s work. Wether it’s something you also enjoy, doesn’t change that it’s work.

So you consider anything that requires physical or mental effort to be work? Sports, going to the gym, reading a book, playing a musical instrument, going on holiday, somebody even mentioned having to "chat" to people as "work" 😆 so going out for a meal must be an endurance exercise. On this definition it seems pretty much any kind of hobby or social activity has now apparently been reclassified as work. Going for a walk was mentioned too. I'd love to know what such people consider to be a leisure activity given that all of that now apparently constitutes "work". I guess they must just sit completely still in a room in absolute silence.

As I said, bonkers.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 11:21

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:17

Lol. So when I have my parents to stay here should I consider that work? Hotelier, chef, entertainer, housekeeping service? The huge mental effort of having to speak to them (the horror) or maybe plan the odd trip out for us all or go for a walk with them? Yes, such an imposition, like a paid job!

Or, like most normal people, consider this just normal leisure time with family.

Well, the fact that there are threads most days about how much work it is to have family coming to stay, most people clearly do think it's work.

Hosting someone in your home, especially for a long period of time, is hard, whether they're family or not.

Sceptre86 · 08/05/2023 11:20

My mum was 50 when she became a nana to my eldest and has always been hands on when we visited. She would happily do childcare for me and does for my sister but it is very much on her terms. She is very clear that she can only do 2 days and as my dad's health has taken a turn he is a bigger priority.

I think it should be up to the individual grandparent to decide without guilt tripping or judgement.

5128gap · 08/05/2023 11:19

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:05

So you believe that a SAHPs life involves no work then, and is one of complete leisure?
Its a rather controversial view.
It also seems overly simplistic to describe anything you may enjoy doing as leisure. I find pleasure in my paid employment, it's work nonetheless.
If you think GPs should share the work of rearing their GC, then that's the opinion to defend. Trying to reframe it as a leisure activity is unfair in its lack of recognition of what the role requires.

For goodness sake. 🙄 Don't try to start the tedious SAHP discussion again, it's been done to death.

Expecting grandparents to rear children?! What an utterly ridiculous thing to say. My parents have been retired since their early 50s, perfectly healthy, go on 5 or 6 holidays per year. They have plenty of time to see their grandchildren if they wished to and no barriers to them doing so. All I've said is it is sad for my children that their grandparents have not once had them to stay over, or spend a day with them, or taken them out anywhere without me. If they had done so one or two times it would hardly qualify as "rearing" them. 🤣🤣 Some of these comments are completely bonkers.

The gnashing of teeth in sorrow at GPs failures to look after GC threads appear with equally tiresome regularity as SAHP threads. It's a valid link. You don't like it being made because it highlights the contradiction in your argument and you're (wisely!)not going to put yourself out there to accuse SAHPs of a life of leisure.
No one on this thread but you (for now, at least) is talking about occasional days out. It is, as always, about childcare. You're moving the goalposts to something else because it's easier than explaining why you think GPs should look after children for you as part of their 'leisure'.

StarryCup · 08/05/2023 11:17

Given the number of mil threads on here, most aren't capable of looking after their DGC

Ain't that the truth. They're manipulative, needy, and over-emotional.
They're intrusive, controlling, and downright interfering. And on top of that, the bastards won't even look after the kids a few days a week.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:17

Lol. So when I have my parents to stay here should I consider that work? Hotelier, chef, entertainer, housekeeping service? The huge mental effort of having to speak to them (the horror) or maybe plan the odd trip out for us all or go for a walk with them? Yes, such an imposition, like a paid job!

Or, like most normal people, consider this just normal leisure time with family.

Sceptre86 · 08/05/2023 11:16

Good for you if you want to help them when you're older but don't want anything in return. I'm not like you. I have 3 kids, no help from grandparents and make plenty of sacrifices for my own children. I do not begrudge it because I chose to have them. If they go on to have children great but they will be their responsibility not mine. I would be happy to help each child one day a week if needed and I am physically well enough to. Is happily help out on anniversaries etc. I wouldn't want to do anymore than that because I hope dh and I will be able to have time together to put our relationship first again.

It's easy enough to say you intend to help when you are young and fit but thrown in a chronic health condition or two and the fact that you are older and perhaps less fit, have less patience and it isn't easy to run after a toddler.

I'm not expecting my kids to take care of me when old although we are asian so ds may well choose to live with us. I intend to remain independent as long as I can though.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 11:13

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:07

Time doing what? Spending time with someone isn’t a thing on its own. You spend time together doing something. Chatting, going for a walk, doing an activity. ‘Spending time’ means nothing at all.

Oh yes, agree, that sounds hideous. Who'd want to do such awful things with their family? Frightful. <shudder>

You comprehension is appalling.
You said spending time with grandparents. Spending time doing what?

Where did I say spending time with family is awful? But when you spend time with someone you do something. You don’t just sit there in a silent room or is that you what you think would foster a good relationship?

If you spend time with someone you do something. Work is anything that requires mental or physical effort. If a grand parent is in charge of a child, even an older child, they are putting in mental and physical effort.

Parents put in physical or mental effort. Therefore it’s work. Wether it’s something you also enjoy, doesn’t change that it’s work. The fact that you see work as something negative, means nothing. It’s not a negative thing. I love my job, doesn’t mean it’s not work.

You just keep saying ‘they should spend time with them’ and that grandparents should want to be in sole charge of the children. Whilst saying it’s not work.

so how does a grandparent spend time with a child, in sole charge of the child and not engage mentally or physically with them? Because that would make it work.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:07

Time doing what? Spending time with someone isn’t a thing on its own. You spend time together doing something. Chatting, going for a walk, doing an activity. ‘Spending time’ means nothing at all.

Oh yes, agree, that sounds hideous. Who'd want to do such awful things with their family? Frightful. <shudder>

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:05

So you believe that a SAHPs life involves no work then, and is one of complete leisure?
Its a rather controversial view.
It also seems overly simplistic to describe anything you may enjoy doing as leisure. I find pleasure in my paid employment, it's work nonetheless.
If you think GPs should share the work of rearing their GC, then that's the opinion to defend. Trying to reframe it as a leisure activity is unfair in its lack of recognition of what the role requires.

For goodness sake. 🙄 Don't try to start the tedious SAHP discussion again, it's been done to death.

Expecting grandparents to rear children?! What an utterly ridiculous thing to say. My parents have been retired since their early 50s, perfectly healthy, go on 5 or 6 holidays per year. They have plenty of time to see their grandchildren if they wished to and no barriers to them doing so. All I've said is it is sad for my children that their grandparents have not once had them to stay over, or spend a day with them, or taken them out anywhere without me. If they had done so one or two times it would hardly qualify as "rearing" them. 🤣🤣 Some of these comments are completely bonkers.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 11:03

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 10:58

So if your kids don’t require any engagement or planning of activities, why would they go to grandparents? To sit there in silence?

To spend time with them?! The same reason anybody visits their family or friends. Children aren't aliens, they are just people who happen to be a bit younger than you are.

Time doing what? Spending time with someone isn’t a thing on its own. You spend time together doing something. Chatting, going for a walk, doing an activity. ‘Spending time’ means nothing at all.

If your children don’t require any physical or mental effort from anyone looking after them, what do they spend time together doing?

and no children aren’t just small adults. Do you know nothing about children or brain development? About the differences between children and adults? Developmental stages?

notice you ignored the rest of my post though.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 10:59

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 10:58

So if your kids don’t require any engagement or planning of activities, why would they go to grandparents? To sit there in silence?

To spend time with them?! The same reason anybody visits their family or friends. Children aren't aliens, they are just people who happen to be a bit younger than you are.

They can spend time with their grandparents with their parents around.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 10:58

My children are school aged. They don't require any of that, just being fed now and again like any adult guest would.

I'm pretty sure your children require a lot more input than "just being fed every now and again" 😂

But no, even when they did need more physical help I wouldn't have described it as "work", I've always thought that is a bizarre way to speak about spending time with your family. I work full time and time with family/ friends is leisure time, not work.

So do you not think SAHP's work? What about nannies or babysitters - is that not work either?

Or is it only work when it's not family members doing it?

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 10:58

So if your kids don’t require any engagement or planning of activities, why would they go to grandparents? To sit there in silence?

To spend time with them?! The same reason anybody visits their family or friends. Children aren't aliens, they are just people who happen to be a bit younger than you are.

5128gap · 08/05/2023 10:52

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 10:23

You must see the difference between 'spending time with family' that doesn't require you to change nappies, supervise on the toilet, be constantly vigilant for their safety, be entirely responsible for their entertainment, dress them, prepare, supervise and clean up after their meals, haul about various weighty pieces of equipment and engage in lengthy activity that you may find extremely tedious, and being in sole charge of GC?
While it's possible to enjoy all of the above, there can be no denying its not 'work' or childcare. Have you ever tried suggesting otherwise to a SAHM?

My children are school aged. They don't require any of that, just being fed now and again like any adult guest would.

But no, even when they did need more physical help I wouldn't have described it as "work", I've always thought that is a bizarre way to speak about spending time with your family. I work full time and time with family/ friends is leisure time, not work.

So you believe that a SAHPs life involves no work then, and is one of complete leisure?
Its a rather controversial view.
It also seems overly simplistic to describe anything you may enjoy doing as leisure. I find pleasure in my paid employment, it's work nonetheless.
If you think GPs should share the work of rearing their GC, then that's the opinion to defend. Trying to reframe it as a leisure activity is unfair in its lack of recognition of what the role requires.

Whenisitsummer · 08/05/2023 10:36

I won’t be committing to having grandchildren all day every day to accommodate their parents working. I’d be disappointed if my dc’s expected this of me. Having worked all my
life to provide for my dc’s, I see retirement as a time for being able to relax. I would of course want my grandchildren to visit , have sleepovers etc but purely for the pleasure of them being there, not because it is a commitment I am left with five days a week. Caring for me In my old age is the last thing I’d expect of my dc’s - they’ll have their own lives to live.

LakieLady · 08/05/2023 10:33

Unless GPs have been fortunate enough to have built up a fantastic pension, most of them will have to work until they're 67 (soon to be 68). And that generation is more likely to have started work at 18 or even younger, as far fewer people went to uni then.

After almost 50 years of graft, I'd be astonished if they still had the energy to care for young children, and see no reason why they should. They're entitled to enjoy their retirement after all those years, and lif ooking after GCs is something they'd enjoy, that's great, but it shouldn't be expected.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 10:33

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 10:23

You must see the difference between 'spending time with family' that doesn't require you to change nappies, supervise on the toilet, be constantly vigilant for their safety, be entirely responsible for their entertainment, dress them, prepare, supervise and clean up after their meals, haul about various weighty pieces of equipment and engage in lengthy activity that you may find extremely tedious, and being in sole charge of GC?
While it's possible to enjoy all of the above, there can be no denying its not 'work' or childcare. Have you ever tried suggesting otherwise to a SAHM?

My children are school aged. They don't require any of that, just being fed now and again like any adult guest would.

But no, even when they did need more physical help I wouldn't have described it as "work", I've always thought that is a bizarre way to speak about spending time with your family. I work full time and time with family/ friends is leisure time, not work.

So if your kids don’t require any engagement or planning of activities, why would they go to grandparents? To sit there in silence?

You seem to have work and a ‘job’ confused. No one said spending time with family is work. But caring for them is also work. Pretending it isn’t, is to ignore the definition of the word.

Groutyonehereagain · 08/05/2023 10:28

Here we go again. 🙄

thecatsarecrazy · 08/05/2023 10:27

My mum has never spent time with my kids, she watched them once for me for a few hours but that's it. My husbands mum has had them from babies and staying over etc. Recently my mum said I'm not going into a home I'm moving in with you haha I think not mum. She left my dad and me snd my brother had to deal with him shitting himself etc and having dementia.