Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare

409 replies

ChickenRacer · 07/05/2023 06:58

Ive heard so many stories about grandparents not wanting to help/be particularly involved with their grandchildren.I understand it’s not all grandparents, but their is a big proportion who just don’t help and support their children when they have small children.

Explanations for this often seem to be that the grandparents did their time parenting and now it’s their time to enjoy life. Which I do understand.

But to me though this seems so sad.

They say it takes a village to raise children - but grandparents are a huge part of many peoples village, so if they aren’t part of the village that’s less support for parents of young children.

This might upset some people, but I also wonder those grandparents that do not feel they want to help with the care of their grandchildren- do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Please don’t be all upset by this, they are genuine questions.

I have 3 children and for various reasons have ZERO help from grandparents. But I very much hope if I am lucky enough to have grandchildren that I will be able to help my children with them in the best way for them. And I wouldn’t want them to have to care for me in my old age. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Beenalongwinter · 08/05/2023 14:42

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 14:37

Perhaps I should take a similar line @Beenalongwinter when I host my family of 9 here. The disabled person doing all the cooking and making up the beds and hosting them, without a husband around either I might add. And none of them ever lifting a finger to do anything with my children. Maybe I'm the one that's wrong and I should tell them all it's a huge imposition and family is an optional "work" I can't be bothered with. I guess we should scrap Christmas and birthday celebrations too while we're at it. So much work, all that physical and mental energy. Who'd do all of that adult social care out of choice?

I hope your efforts are appreciated. If I visit my grown up nieces and nephews I generally take a home made lasagna and a pudding and i like to help them with heavy gardening jobs, we take the tools and also take the garden waste home . When we leave I strip the bed and while we are guests I take them Out for a meal or offer to order and pay for a takeaway.

It all sounds one way In your house and most unfair.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 14:40

Far too exhausting. Ooooh the energy. So entitled for them to expect, I must set them straight and refuse any future visits.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 14:37

Perhaps I should take a similar line @Beenalongwinter when I host my family of 9 here. The disabled person doing all the cooking and making up the beds and hosting them, without a husband around either I might add. And none of them ever lifting a finger to do anything with my children. Maybe I'm the one that's wrong and I should tell them all it's a huge imposition and family is an optional "work" I can't be bothered with. I guess we should scrap Christmas and birthday celebrations too while we're at it. So much work, all that physical and mental energy. Who'd do all of that adult social care out of choice?

Beenalongwinter · 08/05/2023 14:32

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:17

Lol. So when I have my parents to stay here should I consider that work? Hotelier, chef, entertainer, housekeeping service? The huge mental effort of having to speak to them (the horror) or maybe plan the odd trip out for us all or go for a walk with them? Yes, such an imposition, like a paid job!

Or, like most normal people, consider this just normal leisure time with family.

This post made me smile .
My husband is of the opinion that my efforts to cook lovely meals for visiting family is leisure and enjoyable because I once said I enjoy cooking and I appear to the enjoy buying things for the house and making it all things "hygge", he absolutely has no idea about the amount of work involved when he invites guests for the weekend.
I have now clarified I see the tasks as work and NO i will not cook Sunday lunch for 12 or change 4 beds and cook a full English for breakfast without consultation.
Poor DH just assumed I enjoyed it!

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 13:30

You haven’t been able to answer how a grandparent can look after a grandchild and not expend any energy. Plenty of grandparents simply can not or do not want to expend energy in that way. They don’t want to be in sole charge a grandchild.

I haven't answered it because I never said it didn't involve using any energy, so it was a false question. Quite the opposite: I pointed out that anythinf worth doing involves expending some mental or physical energy, even breathing and running your brain and bodily functions. It's a false and ridiculous argument.

Your second sentence is the point. All of these excuses when the reality is these people do not bother with their families because they don't want to. So just own that.

The only person implying work means not enjoyable or not worth doing, is you.

I didn't say that either. Lots of people enjoy their work. That doesn't mean that all leisure activities are also work because they involve some mental or physical energy.

Looking after children is tiring. Especially, if you are elderly.

Often as people get older they find things more difficult. Mentally and physically. They may enjoy an activity but also acknowledge they can’t do it in the way they would like to. My Dad loves walking. He realises he can not do a week full of walks he likes anymore. He needs rest days in between. He enjoys it. But knows he can’t do what he used to. If I had young children, he probably wouldn’t cope that well at looking after a toddler. He would find it exhausting. He may not want to them spend the next day recovering because he has a walk planned later in the week. Does mean he wouldn’t also enjoy looking after one of my children.

Oh dear. Again, you are projecting. I have spoken about the issues with my children's grandparents. I can only give opinions on that.

As I said, I am a lone parent. I also have a disability, as I said, which means I am in chronic pain and often completely housebound. I am far more exhausted than they are. I stated clearly that my parents are in far better physical health than me. They are perfectly able to go for walks, off on holidays, do pilates and tennis and any other number of things. So yes, excuses about how hard it would be for them to spend a couple of hours with their grandchildren even once or twice in their lives are a bit ridiculous. As you admitted in the end, it's simply because they can't be bothered to and are completely wrapped up in themselves and utterly selfish. I can't imagine ever treating family in that way when I was perfectly capable of having a close relationship, treating my grandchildren as an inconvenience and not wishing to help my disabled child, ever, for even a couple of hours to have a break while I sit at a table and play a board game with my grandchildren or take them out for a meal or whatever. You'd have to be extremely self-centred and have no concept of family to think that's ok, especially with children who were struggling with their lack of a father and would have benefitted hugely from having strong family relationships. But there you go.

The only Person saying that if you acknowledge that spending time with family involves work and therefore they don’t like doing it, is you.

Huh? That's my whole point. It's weird for people to think it is "work" to spend time with their family and yes, they should instead simply acknowledge that they don't like doing it, they do not have a proper concept of what a family is and they prefer to be totally selfish and not build relationships with other family members, rather than trying to pretend that the rest of the family is weird for wanting them to actually engage in it.

You still can’t explain how you spend time with family and not expend any mental or physical effort. Doing that sounds absolutely dire. Either you spend time with people without interacting or doing anything with them, or you simply can’t admit you are wrong in your definition of ‘work’ People spend time together by doing things together. So therefore is work.

So fucked up. Of course all things use either mental or physical energy. Why you think this automatically makes it a huge chore or imposition is beyond me. All worthwhile things in life require effort, including family relationships.

Your, made up, definition isn’t relevant because it’s incorrect.

???

a sad way to live would be spending time in the vicinity of people but not interacting or doing anything with them at all.

Well, indeed. That's my point.

Mary46 · 08/05/2023 13:04

Your right not fair to feel entitled to help. My mam in 60s when mine born. But really hard when I had hospital apts and had ask a neighbour. That makes u fed up you no family help. Thank god my kids older now so i dont need help.

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/05/2023 12:59

I care for our young grandchild for one day a week, occasionally two, and the odd overnight, have done so for around a year. We adore him, he’s great fun. I much prefer the time we spend with him when his parents are present too and I’m not solely responsible, though. I’m nearly 60, my husband nearly 65. We’ve been parenting for nearly 30 years (youngest still at home) and we’re tired and looking forward to some time for us when we’re both retired. A one and two year olds are hard work, however loved they are, and I shan’t be sorry when I no longer have sole responsibility on a regular basis. We are a close family and shall see them as regularly, just with mum and dad around too.

in answer to your question, we absolutely do not expect our children to care for us in old age. Quite the opposite, would dislike it intensely and have planned accordingly. That’s not why we had children!

VestaTilley · 08/05/2023 12:58

YABU. They may still be working, live far away or not be able to help with cost.

All of the above were true for us. I never expected help. It’s perfectly reasonable not to want to - plenty of 60/70 year olds are ill or tired, or want to please themselves. That is fair enough.

StarryCup · 08/05/2023 12:57

I work 2 afternoons in a charity shop. I enjoy it. I don't get paid because I volunteer, I want to do it, it's rewarding and I'd miss it terribly if I had to stop.
It's also quite hard and tiring work dealing with the stock.

I have recently been offered the vacancy that's arisen for Assistant Manager.
A paid position. I suppose I've been offered it, even in my 60s because I know the ropes and I'm efficient and reliable. It's 6 afternoons a week so I've turned it down. Nobody seems to understand why I'd turn down getting paid for a job I do willingly for free.

Well, it's having the ultimate responsibility, and being knackered 6 times a week instead of 2. I just don't think I have the stamina to keep it up, nor do I want to get used to it. I have other things to do. I think this is all a bit like that.

SallyWD · 08/05/2023 12:44

We live hundreds of miles from my parents and inlaws which is something I'm sad about. I know for certain that if the grandparents lived nearby they would have helped on an ad-hoc basis. For example, if me and DH wanted a night out or an occasional night away they would have babysat. Or they would have have taken the children out for the day sometimes. That's all lovely and beneficial for all involved.
I personally think it becomes problematic when grandparents are expected to provide weekly childcare - I mean like having the children for 3 days a week when the parents work, every single week. I think this is too much expect. It means the grandparents lives are restricted. They are committed to giving up 3 or 4 days of their lives every week to look after exhausting young children at a time when the grandparents are probably feeling rather tired! I mean most of us mums know how exhausting and relentless it is to be stuck in the house looking after small children, even if we've only done it for a few months on maternity leave. We can appreciate it's tough! In this situation the grandparents can't be spontaneous or please themselves. Even if my parents or in laws lived nearby I would not have wanted them to provide that level of childcare simply because I'd feel it was unfair for them to be committed to so many hours of child care each week.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 12:40

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 12:11

If it takes energy, is an effort, tiring etc it also can’t be enjoyable?

I don’t get how you live like that.

That's the opposite of what I've been saying. Most worthwhile things to do use energy, all in fact. I mean, just breathing and staying alive consumes energy, does it not?

My entire point is that classifying anything that requires any effort or energy as "work" is a very sad way to look at life, and the implication that it is therefore a tiresome chore and an imposition, what an utterly miserable outlook.

Most people take great pleasure from time with family and friends and do not view this as "work". I think it's rather tragic that people find all leisure activities and family time so draining and seem to resent doing anything at all with their lives, from the descriptions here at how "draining" it is to talk to people or go for a walk or do anything that uses any mental or physical energy, when pretty much anything of interest or value can only be achieved by doing so. What a sad way to live.

The word work has a definition.

You claim grandparents looking after grandchildren is not work. By its definition it is. Also, by its definition, the word work doesn’t mean ‘not enjoyable’.

You haven’t been able to answer how a grandparent can look after a grandchild and not expend any energy. Plenty of grandparents simply can not or do not want to expend energy in that way. They don’t want to be in sole charge a grandchild.

The only person implying work means not enjoyable or not worth doing, is you.

Looking after children is tiring. Especially, if you are elderly.

Often as people get older they find things more difficult. Mentally and physically. They may enjoy an activity but also acknowledge they can’t do it in the way they would like to. My Dad loves walking. He realises he can not do a week full of walks he likes anymore. He needs rest days in between. He enjoys it. But knows he can’t do what he used to. If I had young children, he probably wouldn’t cope that well at looking after a toddler. He would find it exhausting. He may not want to them spend the next day recovering because he has a walk planned later in the week. Does mean he wouldn’t also enjoy looking after one of my children.

The only Person saying that if you acknowledge that spending time with family involves work and therefore they don’t like doing it, is you.

You still can’t explain how you spend time with family and not expend any mental or physical effort. Doing that sounds absolutely dire. Either you spend time with people without interacting or doing anything with them, or you simply can’t admit you are wrong in your definition of ‘work’ People spend time together by doing things together. So therefore is work.

Your, made up, definition isn’t relevant because it’s incorrect.

a sad way to live would be spending time in the vicinity of people but not interacting or doing anything with them at all.

LetsPlayShadowlands · 08/05/2023 12:22

Agree 100% OP.

SugarAndSpike · 08/05/2023 12:11

YouAreNotBatman · 07/05/2023 07:09

I’m so tired of parents saying how it ”takes a village”, when all they mean is village for me - but not for thee.

Wow this is so true. Well put.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 12:11

If it takes energy, is an effort, tiring etc it also can’t be enjoyable?

I don’t get how you live like that.

That's the opposite of what I've been saying. Most worthwhile things to do use energy, all in fact. I mean, just breathing and staying alive consumes energy, does it not?

My entire point is that classifying anything that requires any effort or energy as "work" is a very sad way to look at life, and the implication that it is therefore a tiresome chore and an imposition, what an utterly miserable outlook.

Most people take great pleasure from time with family and friends and do not view this as "work". I think it's rather tragic that people find all leisure activities and family time so draining and seem to resent doing anything at all with their lives, from the descriptions here at how "draining" it is to talk to people or go for a walk or do anything that uses any mental or physical energy, when pretty much anything of interest or value can only be achieved by doing so. What a sad way to live.

StarryCup · 08/05/2023 12:04

let's face it, there's enough posts on MN to say how much better working is to being at home with young children

Excellent point. I was always a SAHM. Had to be really because one of my dc has quite severe learning disabilities. I really enjoyed being at home with them and am so glad I was. That's not to say it wasn't extremely hard work most of the time, the only peace was when they were asleep. It was definitely work and not something I'd expect someone in their 60s to do with any regularity.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 12:02

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:40

If it's not negative then why would it be a basis to say it's a huge imposition to do it?

Because it’s tiring and not everyone’s choice to expend their energy that way.

You have a really narrow view. If something is enjoyable it can’t also be difficult, a lot of effort, tiring.

If it takes energy, is an effort, tiring etc it also can’t be enjoyable?

I don’t get how you live like that.

The word work is a neutral word.

Abracadabra12345 · 08/05/2023 11:55

hiredandsqueak · 07/05/2023 07:35

I have provided childcare for my grandson since he was nine months old. I have done so because dd's partner walked away when she was heavily pregnant with their planned child and has been nowhere near since. I wouldn't let my dd struggle but if her circumstances had been different I wouldn't have provided childcare for her and she is well aware that this is a one off offer. I love dgs I like his visits with his dm, I like taking him out, I like spending a couple of hours playing games on occasion whilst his dm goes shopping but childcare is hard work, pretty boring to me and limits the time I have to pursue my own interests.

Well said

Abracadabra12345 · 08/05/2023 11:52

Lollipop20 · 07/05/2023 07:28

I feel for you on this one as I have my parents and in laws who are all retired with my parents still being in their mid 50s and in laws 60s and my LG is in full time childcare and has been since 9 months (now 3) and my parents pick her up after nursery 1 day a week and that’s the only help we get between all of them. My in laws frustrate me as they set the tone from the get go, after having a traumatic birth and my LG in intensive care for the first 2 weeks with me also still in hospital, when travelling 2.5 hours to see them when she was 5 weeks old my partner asked if they could get up with her to basically give us one morning of rest bite his MIL reply was ‘no, been there done that’ and that was that. It’s even more frustrating as me and my partner were looked after a lot by our grandparents so our parents could work etc (so much so, our daughters middle name is my nans name as I was so close to her due to that) so obviously they needed it and utilised their parents but not the same here…

I think it is often the case that when we were looked after by grandparents a lot, it's an indicator that our parents weren't really into children / childcare and let's face it, there's enough posts on MN to say how much better working is to being at home with young children. Those who feel bored or tired by looking after their own children- will they really metamorphose into doting grandparents eager to look after their children's young children?

What's often not appreciated is how much bloody hard work those young grandkids are, to look after all day, and yes boring too!

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:50

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 11:44

speaking entirely about how sad it is that my children's grandparents have never spent any independent time with them for even a few hours, to go to the park or have them visit for lunch without me, ever. Not once.

.. and that would still be childcare, because they'd be taking sole responsibility of your children for you. The fact that they're family members doesn't stop it being work.

I don't understand why it's so important for their grandparents to have them alone - they can build a relationship with each other while you're there too, can't they?

Not in the same way, no. As is evident from the very different relationship my children have with their grandparents compared to their friends and their grandparents, who have made the effort to have a relationship with them, rather than treating them as an accessory at family occasions.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 11:44

speaking entirely about how sad it is that my children's grandparents have never spent any independent time with them for even a few hours, to go to the park or have them visit for lunch without me, ever. Not once.

.. and that would still be childcare, because they'd be taking sole responsibility of your children for you. The fact that they're family members doesn't stop it being work.

I don't understand why it's so important for their grandparents to have them alone - they can build a relationship with each other while you're there too, can't they?

Corkcobain · 08/05/2023 11:41

I have two DC both under 6, we only have my dm left out of mine and dh's parents.
My mum is in her 60's amd works full time as a primary school teacher so she is happy to help when she can for the odd day here and there (school holidays etc) but she still works full time and she lives a fair drive away. She would rather (understandably) be the fun grandma that joins us for family days out etc rather than just having the kids on her own from 9am-6pm.
With people having kids at a later age, and people having to work till an older age it's unreasonable in general for people to expect childcare from grandparents to facilitate their working patterns.
If I had my children at the same age my mum had me she would be in her 70's, I don't expect she would be able to chase a toddler easily for hours on end at that age (of course that's a generalisation)
When I'm a grandparent I would love to be as involved in my grandchildrens lives as possible, but realistically I'll also be working full time into my 70's so I won't have that luxury

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:40

If it's not negative then why would it be a basis to say it's a huge imposition to do it?

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 11:38

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:35

Oh my God.

This is just beyond silly now.

How do you people even function in daily life? It must be so hard to get through the day if you see every single thing that requires you to either move or think at all as a chore. 😆

There’s only you that has decided ‘work’ is a negative thing

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 11:35

StarryCup · 08/05/2023 11:30

So you consider anything that requires physical or mental effort to be work? Sports, going to the gym

Isn't that called doing a work out?

Oh my God.

This is just beyond silly now.

How do you people even function in daily life? It must be so hard to get through the day if you see every single thing that requires you to either move or think at all as a chore. 😆

StarryCup · 08/05/2023 11:33

somebody even mentioned having to "chat" to people as "work"

It can be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread