Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare

409 replies

ChickenRacer · 07/05/2023 06:58

Ive heard so many stories about grandparents not wanting to help/be particularly involved with their grandchildren.I understand it’s not all grandparents, but their is a big proportion who just don’t help and support their children when they have small children.

Explanations for this often seem to be that the grandparents did their time parenting and now it’s their time to enjoy life. Which I do understand.

But to me though this seems so sad.

They say it takes a village to raise children - but grandparents are a huge part of many peoples village, so if they aren’t part of the village that’s less support for parents of young children.

This might upset some people, but I also wonder those grandparents that do not feel they want to help with the care of their grandchildren- do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Please don’t be all upset by this, they are genuine questions.

I have 3 children and for various reasons have ZERO help from grandparents. But I very much hope if I am lucky enough to have grandchildren that I will be able to help my children with them in the best way for them. And I wouldn’t want them to have to care for me in my old age. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
aloris · 08/05/2023 21:19

AhNowTed · 07/05/2023 09:05

So rather than be furious with your brother who royally took advantage of your parents, you're annoyed with them?

The grandmother in question perhaps didn't realize that babysitting fulltime for one child would use up all her reserves leaving her empty when her younger kids needed help. So, on the issue of grandma not helping with Littlewhitecat's children, I don't fault her there. But what the grandmother seems to have done here is given loads of help to the oldest son, none to her daughter, but yet expects her daughter to make large sacrifices to help her, and treats the daughter's inability to do so, as a moral failure on the daughter's part. This is not fair to Littlewhitecat, I think that's the main point here.

I think it stems from the unexamined social value that the daughters in a family are by default, the subordinates and servants of anyone in the family who is male and/or older. This, in turn, is, IMO, one aspect of the unexamined social value that the women in a family are, by default, the servants of anyone who is male and/or older . In other words, the belief that grandparents should babysit their grandchildren kinda stems from the same idea (notice how Little's mother babysat for her son but not for her daughter). Because, let's face it, when we suggest that grandparents should babysit their grandkids, we almost always mean grandmothers, even if we claim that we mean both grandfathers and grandmothers.

Summary: let's re-examine the whole value of putting women lowest on the hierarchy of whose needs should be considered. No fair expecting grandmas to wear themselves out in their last healthy years chasing after toddlers. By the same token, no fair expecting adult daughters to exhaust themselves taking care of elderly parents at the same time as we're raising young children. Find another way.

JenniferBooth · 08/05/2023 21:03

YY @fitzwilliamdarcy ive said this before but the village lot only want the rosy stuff Rarely do they like it when you tell their child off for running around a coffee shop

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 20:21

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 20:08

What? I didn’t say one way as in a one way relationship.

"You clearly have a stance that grandparents should only be one way."

Okaaaay. 😆😆😆

Yes that’s what I said?

where did I say you think it should be a one way relationships. You think grandparents should only be a certain way. One way.

Not sure what’s so difficult to understand really. Since you only clipped one part of the sentence, to avoid the context I put in it. I will assume you know exactly what I was saying.

But you have shown you keep making things up along this thread, so not sure why I would be surprised.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 20:08

What? I didn’t say one way as in a one way relationship.

"You clearly have a stance that grandparents should only be one way."

Okaaaay. 😆😆😆

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 19:43

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 18:08

You clearly have a stance that grandparents should only be one way. They should look after the kids at least occasionally, they must enjoy it and they should not find it tiring or hard work. That’s not realistic.

This and the rest of your post are utterly ridiculous given I've told you I host them, cook for them, have them to stay every Christmas, take them out for their birthdays, etc and they have never, even once looked after my children even for a couple of hours. In 7 years. Ever. Yet apparently I think the relationship should be "one way" with them doing things for me? Okay then. 🤣 Stop it now. You're embarrassing yourself.

What? I didn’t say one way as in a one way relationship.

You have a fixed idea of what grandparents should be. And that is the only right way. And anything outside that is selfish.

Oh and making yourself ill, putting yourself out massively for people who (you feel treat you portly) isn’t selfless. You are either deluding yourself and you do get something out of it. Or you are playing the martyr. People don’t keep doing something that harms them over and over if they aren’t getting anything out of it.

I look after my Dad. My gain is knowing he is ok, spending his last few years making sure he knows I care and he is loved, spending time with him because he won’t always be there and I won’t always be able to sit and chat with him.

Putting your own, significant, needs (especially health needs) ahead of people who don’t do anything in return isn’t a sign of a good person. It’s a sign of someone with poor boundaries.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 19:23

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 19:00

I waste my time on people who care about me and who treat me decently

Clearly not, based on your posts. You don't want to "waste your time" on anybody. So don't. If you believe family is a "waste of time" then I'm not sure anybody can help you.

I never once said "I don't want to waste my time on anybody" or "family is a waste of time".

Stop making shit up.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 19:00

I waste my time on people who care about me and who treat me decently

Clearly not, based on your posts. You don't want to "waste your time" on anybody. So don't. If you believe family is a "waste of time" then I'm not sure anybody can help you.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 18:28

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 18:22

And no, I wouldn't waste my time on people who clearly don't give a shit about me - I'm worth more than that.

Based on your posts you wouldn't waste your time" on anybody whether they give a shit about you or not. 😆

I'm not the unhappy one repeatedly bitching about my family and calling them selfish and undeserving, lol.

I waste my time on people who care about me and who treat me decently - life is too short to spend it worrying over people who don't give a shit - family or otherwise.

Daddydog · 08/05/2023 18:24

I look at most of the friends in our circle and most have support and a fair few seem to have parents pretty much co-parenting their kids. Some manage to almost maintain their pre-child lifestyles! While I am very envious at times (okay, all the time!), I do often wonder, when their folks get too old, sick & need caring for - will they be as selfless and generous with their time?

Crazycrazylady · 08/05/2023 18:22

GeeHDees · 07/05/2023 07:15

I think it depends what your expectations are. I'd be sad if my children never saw or didn't have a relationship with their grandparents, but I wouldn't expect them to do routine childcare (help in genuine emergencies would be great though).

do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

I find this a very odd emotional blackmail type question and probably demonstrates the expectations you have.

I agree.
What a horrible attitude. My parents worked very hard to support us when we were kids and give us every opportunity . They're older now and not that interested in small kids so according to some on here that means I don't need to give them any support in old age.

I think getting help is nice but it absolutely shouldn't be an expectation from anyone. People need to think about all of this before they decide to have kids

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 18:22

And no, I wouldn't waste my time on people who clearly don't give a shit about me - I'm worth more than that.

Based on your posts you wouldn't waste your time" on anybody whether they give a shit about you or not. 😆

Resembleflower · 08/05/2023 18:20

My parents are divorced. My dad doesn’t bother with me so no contact with my kids. My mum never worked her mum looked after my and my siblings all the time. My kids are late teens my mum does nothing even when I’ve been hospitalised.

my sister now has kids and my mum does everything for her. I know said sister is expecting to share our mums care.

In laws are fab but are aboard. They were straight on a plane when I was in hospital.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 18:20

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 18:12

Why do you do it, then?

Because I'm not a selfish twat and I actually care about family, even when they are people who have proved themselves to be incredibly selfish and don't deserve it.

I certainly wouldn't bother in your position.

Based on your posts you wouldn't bother in any situation so that's not a great measuring stick, tbh.

Constantly putting yourself out for people who can't be bothered to do the same for you isn't going to win you any prizes. In fact, all it's doing is making you seethe with resentment.

And no, I wouldn't waste my time on people who clearly don't give a shit about me - I'm worth more than that.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 18:20

People choose how they expend energy.

And this is exactly what I mean. It betrays a complete lack of any basic understanding of what the word "family" means, if someone thinks it's fine to justify to themselves hurting the feelings of young children in their family, making no effort whatsoever for anybody else, never doing anything that (shock, horror) might require a tiny bit of effort on their part because why should they put themselves out? Basically treating their own family with less consideration and care and effort than most people would spend on an acquaintance, let alone a friend. What a sad, selfish and isolating way to look at the world, which will inevitably come around to bite them on the arse in time.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 18:12

Why do you do it, then?

Because I'm not a selfish twat and I actually care about family, even when they are people who have proved themselves to be incredibly selfish and don't deserve it.

I certainly wouldn't bother in your position.

Based on your posts you wouldn't bother in any situation so that's not a great measuring stick, tbh.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 18:08

You clearly have a stance that grandparents should only be one way. They should look after the kids at least occasionally, they must enjoy it and they should not find it tiring or hard work. That’s not realistic.

This and the rest of your post are utterly ridiculous given I've told you I host them, cook for them, have them to stay every Christmas, take them out for their birthdays, etc and they have never, even once looked after my children even for a couple of hours. In 7 years. Ever. Yet apparently I think the relationship should be "one way" with them doing things for me? Okay then. 🤣 Stop it now. You're embarrassing yourself.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/05/2023 17:59

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 14:37

Perhaps I should take a similar line @Beenalongwinter when I host my family of 9 here. The disabled person doing all the cooking and making up the beds and hosting them, without a husband around either I might add. And none of them ever lifting a finger to do anything with my children. Maybe I'm the one that's wrong and I should tell them all it's a huge imposition and family is an optional "work" I can't be bothered with. I guess we should scrap Christmas and birthday celebrations too while we're at it. So much work, all that physical and mental energy. Who'd do all of that adult social care out of choice?

Why do you do it, then?

I certainly wouldn't bother in your position.

MenoRageisReal · 08/05/2023 17:09

RegainingTheWill2023 · 07/05/2023 07:18

What you are actually promoting is that women who spend their younger years putting their lives and careers on hold to rase children, should then do the same a few years later to provide childcare for their grandchildren whilst also caring for their own aging parents ....
Retirement age is 67. How are women supposed to do all this?
And of course its down to women. All these caring commitments mean their earning potential would continue to lag way behind men so it's inevitable.
The answer is affordable childcare and adequate state funded care for the elderly.

Well said 👏

Yogazmum · 08/05/2023 15:29

My parents made a point of telling my siblings and I that they wouldn’t be committing to childcare help when we announced pregnancies.
MIL helps us out randomly (DH and I both work shifts but try to work opposites so we can manage childcare between us)
When my parents have stepped in to help occasionally, I get reminded about how exhausting it is for them which I totally get. DS is a typical boy with activities that are physical and outdoors.
I don’t understand why a lot of people feel they are entitled to childcare from GP/parents. I had a discussion with an ex friend years ago about this as she was so aggrieved that her mum wouldn’t ‘want’ to help by having 2 small boys 3-4 days a week 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️ and regularly over the weekends so her and her DH could have alone time 🙄

BiddyPop · 08/05/2023 15:21

There is a greater expectation for help on 1 side than the other at present for elderly parents, but it's only a matter of time.

But there is also an expectation on 1 side that they will stay home and they have the funds to support that. So I am encouraging getting things in place early and building relationships and routines now.

On the other side, who knows. There would be more need to actively support due to less money available, but there are more people locally to the parent to help.

But as both DH and I are the eldest, there is a weight of expectation to organise and to do things on us more so than siblings.

BiddyPop · 08/05/2023 15:18

My DGPs weren't available to help on a regular basis as they lived hours away. There were occasional (I e rare) times when 1 or maybe 2 of the 6 would get to visit them. And I recall 1 week when my DPs went away and 2 DAunts came down to mind 5 with #6 (toddler) going to a friends house.

In my case, DGPs all live hours away. 2 we're working and the other 2 had busy lives with commitments that meant they weren't available regularly. But they have done occasional weekends and even come and covered a couple of times when both DH and my travel unavoidably clashed and we both had to be away the same night. (Usually we managed to juggle that 1 parent was there when dd went to bed and we had a couple of hours overlap middle of the night before that one left and the other parent was there when dd woke up in the morning.)

But we had always expected to use paid childcare and it never occurred to us that we were unusual.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 15:16

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 13:30

You haven’t been able to answer how a grandparent can look after a grandchild and not expend any energy. Plenty of grandparents simply can not or do not want to expend energy in that way. They don’t want to be in sole charge a grandchild.

I haven't answered it because I never said it didn't involve using any energy, so it was a false question. Quite the opposite: I pointed out that anythinf worth doing involves expending some mental or physical energy, even breathing and running your brain and bodily functions. It's a false and ridiculous argument.

Your second sentence is the point. All of these excuses when the reality is these people do not bother with their families because they don't want to. So just own that.

The only person implying work means not enjoyable or not worth doing, is you.

I didn't say that either. Lots of people enjoy their work. That doesn't mean that all leisure activities are also work because they involve some mental or physical energy.

Looking after children is tiring. Especially, if you are elderly.

Often as people get older they find things more difficult. Mentally and physically. They may enjoy an activity but also acknowledge they can’t do it in the way they would like to. My Dad loves walking. He realises he can not do a week full of walks he likes anymore. He needs rest days in between. He enjoys it. But knows he can’t do what he used to. If I had young children, he probably wouldn’t cope that well at looking after a toddler. He would find it exhausting. He may not want to them spend the next day recovering because he has a walk planned later in the week. Does mean he wouldn’t also enjoy looking after one of my children.

Oh dear. Again, you are projecting. I have spoken about the issues with my children's grandparents. I can only give opinions on that.

As I said, I am a lone parent. I also have a disability, as I said, which means I am in chronic pain and often completely housebound. I am far more exhausted than they are. I stated clearly that my parents are in far better physical health than me. They are perfectly able to go for walks, off on holidays, do pilates and tennis and any other number of things. So yes, excuses about how hard it would be for them to spend a couple of hours with their grandchildren even once or twice in their lives are a bit ridiculous. As you admitted in the end, it's simply because they can't be bothered to and are completely wrapped up in themselves and utterly selfish. I can't imagine ever treating family in that way when I was perfectly capable of having a close relationship, treating my grandchildren as an inconvenience and not wishing to help my disabled child, ever, for even a couple of hours to have a break while I sit at a table and play a board game with my grandchildren or take them out for a meal or whatever. You'd have to be extremely self-centred and have no concept of family to think that's ok, especially with children who were struggling with their lack of a father and would have benefitted hugely from having strong family relationships. But there you go.

The only Person saying that if you acknowledge that spending time with family involves work and therefore they don’t like doing it, is you.

Huh? That's my whole point. It's weird for people to think it is "work" to spend time with their family and yes, they should instead simply acknowledge that they don't like doing it, they do not have a proper concept of what a family is and they prefer to be totally selfish and not build relationships with other family members, rather than trying to pretend that the rest of the family is weird for wanting them to actually engage in it.

You still can’t explain how you spend time with family and not expend any mental or physical effort. Doing that sounds absolutely dire. Either you spend time with people without interacting or doing anything with them, or you simply can’t admit you are wrong in your definition of ‘work’ People spend time together by doing things together. So therefore is work.

So fucked up. Of course all things use either mental or physical energy. Why you think this automatically makes it a huge chore or imposition is beyond me. All worthwhile things in life require effort, including family relationships.

Your, made up, definition isn’t relevant because it’s incorrect.

???

a sad way to live would be spending time in the vicinity of people but not interacting or doing anything with them at all.

Well, indeed. That's my point.

You basically don’t have a point.

whilst bemoaning all the work you do when you have visitors, you claim it’s not work. Because you enjoy it. Although it’s doesn’t sound like you do to be honest.

The conversation started because you don’t know what the word work means. Which you don’t. You said grandparents shouldn’t find looking after grandchildren because you have a made up definition of what work is.

I didn’t say your parents are selfish. People choose how they expend energy. And yours don’t choose to use their energy to be in Sole charge of your children. You think they are selfish. And yet despite being a single parent, with chronic pain condition you insist you feel enjoyment hosting your selfish parents, when you and your kids appear to get nothing out of it. Why would you enjoy doing that whilst saying you think the way they treat their family members (you and your kids) badly because they won’t look after your children.

Sounds like loads of fun!

No one said good things aren’t worth effort. However, not everyone has or wants to use the energy to do things we think they should. Or that we think they should find enjoyable.

You obvious get something out of their visits. The kids get something out of their visits, because why else would you do it?

and the definition of work is something that uses mental or physical energy. So if you agree things take mental or physical energy. You agree it’s work. Which was the original point. It is work. Work your family choose not to take on. Again, enjoyment doesn’t change wether something is work or not.

Your parents visiting, is hard work. You put a lot of energy into it, to your own detriment. But you also claim to enjoy it.

I didn’t say all people see babysitting their grandchildren as in imposition. Even if they also find it hard work plenty don’t see it as an imposition. Not sure why you keep making that up. Plenty of grandparents willingly do it, enjoy it AND find it hard work. It’s not one or the other. It’s not enjoy it or find it hard work.

You clearly have a stance that grandparents should only be one way. They should look after the kids at least occasionally, they must enjoy it and they should not find it tiring or hard work. That’s not realistic.

If I look at my life, work is hard work and enjoyable. Going to the gym is hard work and enjoyable. Leaving work, driving to pick my dd up from Uni so she can spend a weekend with me and ds is tiring but also something I am happy to do. Helping my disabled son with his homework, is hard work and something I enjoy doing. Decorating my home, is hard work and something I find enjoyable.

Lcb123 · 08/05/2023 15:03

We don’t have kids yet but if it does happen, I would never expect anything from GPs. If they do chose to help, great. If not, it’s mine and DH choice to have kids and we have to pay for childcare.

FourTeaFallOut · 08/05/2023 14:52

I'm hoping to be able to be an active grandparent when my children have families. Health and location are the biggest barriers, I suppose.

We didn't have much family support because of the above and I suppose that has made things harder than it otherwise would have been.

At the same time, I don't expect to pull a full time shift and mirror my children's working week with childcare. I saw so many knackered out grandparents at playgroups when my kids were toddlers and I don't think that's fair.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 08/05/2023 14:45

@Beenalongwinter that sounds really lovely and thoughtful. Sadly nothing like that goes on here. It is all completely one way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread