Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare

409 replies

ChickenRacer · 07/05/2023 06:58

Ive heard so many stories about grandparents not wanting to help/be particularly involved with their grandchildren.I understand it’s not all grandparents, but their is a big proportion who just don’t help and support their children when they have small children.

Explanations for this often seem to be that the grandparents did their time parenting and now it’s their time to enjoy life. Which I do understand.

But to me though this seems so sad.

They say it takes a village to raise children - but grandparents are a huge part of many peoples village, so if they aren’t part of the village that’s less support for parents of young children.

This might upset some people, but I also wonder those grandparents that do not feel they want to help with the care of their grandchildren- do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Please don’t be all upset by this, they are genuine questions.

I have 3 children and for various reasons have ZERO help from grandparents. But I very much hope if I am lucky enough to have grandchildren that I will be able to help my children with them in the best way for them. And I wouldn’t want them to have to care for me in my old age. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
OrderOfTheKookaburra · 10/05/2023 01:10

@CocoaAglow - there is a big difference between helping an aged parent do some grocery shopping, paying some bills, ensuring garden is maintained etc. it can be generally slotted around your own jobs and commitments (not counting full time career, that is completely different).

Whereas looking after toddlers stops you doing anything else at all during the day, generally can't be done ad hoc etc as other childcare needs to be arranged well in advance.

Being emergency back up, I get and support, picking up after school etc and letting them play quietly while you get on with making dinner, yep, generally fairly easy, occasionally babysitting so that parents can go out for the evening, fine. Gaps in holiday clubs, not so bad as long as only a day here or there.

Ad hoc, occasional stuff can really make a difference.

But being the go to childcare so that parents can avoid paying childcare costs on a daily basis? Nah... it is extremely limiting and quite frankly I'd prefer to keep working at my own job than do childcare as it's a damn site easier.

QueenBitch666 · 10/05/2023 00:44

Your kids, your responsibility.

JenniferBooth · 09/05/2023 23:22

@CocoaAglow Well then the Government shouldnt have kept raising the state pension age if they wanted family carers to be available at the drop of a hat. Cant have it both ways

CocoaAglow · 09/05/2023 21:01

@blahblahblah1654 I think the 15% are in nursing homes long term.
I was referring to the needing of help to stay at home, which is the sort of help that family members might provide, possibly combined with professional carers.
I think you're right about planning your own care for the future. I don't want my children having to care for me either, but i think it's fairly standard for most families to help each other out to a certain degree. And we never really know when the need for care will strike. I don't see myself as old - I'm not yet retirement age, but I know/knew people who've had heart attacks and strokes at my age. The ones who survived need suppport. I have discussed my wishes with DH and my children for if that happens to me, but I'll be relying on them to put those into place if it happens.
A single, childless friend of mine is planning to book herself into a residential home sooner than she'd like, but then she's not hoping to leave anyone any inheritance, so she can.
I think it's all more complex than it seems!

blahblahblah1654 · 09/05/2023 20:47

@CocoaAglow I read it was something closer to 15% of 84 plus year olds needing care. It was Age UK I think. Definitely not 70%. Statistics from other sources are much closer to 15%. If I have grandchildren I'll do my best for them, but I won't be expecting my children to care for me when they have their own lives, jobs, children etc. I'll have to plan for my old age myself. I didn't have children for them to look after me.

CocoaAglow · 09/05/2023 20:43

blahblahblah1654 · 09/05/2023 20:37

@CocoaAglow where is the evidence that 70% of elderly people need care? Genuinely interested.

Sorry, can't find it now. But also genuinely interested (promise I'm not being sarcastic) how would you see old age playing out for yourself, without any help at all?

CocoaAglow · 09/05/2023 20:40

@Effieswig no, I looked it up this morning but I can't find it now. But based on my experience not just in work but with friends and family, it doesn't seem too far off. Nobody thinks they are going to need care, but people heading towards the end of their life tend to become almost 'invisible' as they aren't getting out and about as much. Some are in care settings long term, but many many others just quietly start to struggle getting up and washed in the morning, have a fall here and there, and generally get frailer. They start to worry about getting to the loo, and drink less, and get dehydration, which can cause all sorts of problems.

I did just look at the Age Concern pages and there are worrying statistics about the people who die before care is put in place, due to lack of funding and a shortage of carers.

blahblahblah1654 · 09/05/2023 20:37

@CocoaAglow where is the evidence that 70% of elderly people need care? Genuinely interested.

Coxspurplepippin · 09/05/2023 20:28

Wait until you're in your sixties, still working (and will be for some years), having been working full time for nigh on fifty years, looking after a frail elderly relative, feeling aches, pains and just generally tired, and your child expects you to do regular childcare for toddlers and preschoolers. You know how exhausted you feel after looking after your kids. Imagine how you'd feel doing it 30 years from now.

CocoaAglow · 09/05/2023 20:22

Just to add. Most of the people I look after also have family assistance. Unless you have such a poor relationship with your family that you've gone minimal contact, caring for them creeps up on you. Very often it's started when you persuade them to get a lifeline for your peace of mind. Then they have a fall and you get a call saying can you go and help. Or if you're down as next of kin you'll visit in hospital, and if you don't want or aren't able to help them when they are discharged, you need to arrange care for them (or convince them they need care) You might find they are offered emergency carers, but that they don't cover nights, or they aren't responsible for getting groceries in. Who does the laundry and housework when your family member is recovering from a hip replacement or ulcerated legs? Even if next of kin can't physically get involved, they normally have to sort something out, or be prepared to explain to adult social services that they are unable to help (and they tend to note it down as unwilling) You'd have to be pretty hard hearted to refuse any support at all, unless your parent was abusive or particularly difficult.

Effieswig · 09/05/2023 20:22

CocoaAglow · 09/05/2023 20:06

70% of elderly people need care. The average age of a person needing carers for the first time is 84. The majority don't live healthy, mobile lives then drop dead at 80/90. They get weaker, less mobile, have falls. They stop being able to drive, go out alone, shop/cook for themselves. They might get confused and need support to get to appointments or sort out their medication. I work as a carer for people in their own homes. Some people become very ill and frail and need full time care, but many more just need some support to handle daily living.

Do you have the details of that study?

CocoaAglow · 09/05/2023 20:06

blahblahblah1654 · 09/05/2023 19:43

Not everyone will need carers in old age, the majority won't. So it's not something you can hold over someone's head. It just means your inheritance will reduce to nothing if they are needed.

70% of elderly people need care. The average age of a person needing carers for the first time is 84. The majority don't live healthy, mobile lives then drop dead at 80/90. They get weaker, less mobile, have falls. They stop being able to drive, go out alone, shop/cook for themselves. They might get confused and need support to get to appointments or sort out their medication. I work as a carer for people in their own homes. Some people become very ill and frail and need full time care, but many more just need some support to handle daily living.

blahblahblah1654 · 09/05/2023 19:43

Not everyone will need carers in old age, the majority won't. So it's not something you can hold over someone's head. It just means your inheritance will reduce to nothing if they are needed.

Boymum1005 · 09/05/2023 19:38

My mum had my DS a day a week when I was working full time (on maternity leave with second DS now), but she will have both boys 2 days a week when I’m back at work. She lives 110 miles away, but my company has an office in the same town so it works for us to drive down and stay there a day a week. She adores having them takes them for days out, bought extra car seats for her own car, has a stroller at her house for them etc.

MIL lives on the next street to us, appx 90 second drive, and won’t help unless we pay her. Not just a regular weekly help, but whenever she babysits she expects a taxi or a lift each way (refuses to walk), a takeaway, a caddy full of chocolate and snacks, and a thank you gift the next day (She will ring DH and ask “where’s my flowers/where’s my chocolates/you can get me XYZ as a thanks for yesterday”. Has never taken them out, even to the local park, and won’t have them at her house, it always has to be ours. Yet showers them with unnecessary plastic tat every week.

I’d say both sets of grandparents love the DGC equally but show it in different ways I guess

MsRosley · 09/05/2023 18:40

do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Well, you can choose between helping them out and getting a larger inheritance or not helping them out and getting bugger all.

Effieswig · 09/05/2023 16:22

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 09/05/2023 11:43

Yes that’s what I said?

Exactly. So no point pretending otherwise.

If you need to lie about what people wrote to make a point, you don’t have a point.

IBlinkThereforeIAm · 09/05/2023 11:43

Yes that’s what I said?

Exactly. So no point pretending otherwise.

Resembleflower · 09/05/2023 11:21

Resembleflower · 09/05/2023 11:20

I won’t be helping my mum and dad after they both choose not to help me even when I was ill and in hospital. Multiple times, I invite and try to involve her and my dad (they are divorced) neither are at all interested. They have minimal interest and contact with my teens. Mum dies a lot for my sisters kids now though, primary aged. I’m so jealous of the grandparents most of my friends have.

I will be living my life and hopefully being an involved parent to my kids and maybe grandkids!

Does not dies. And actually I’m jealous of the grandparent my sisters kids have!

Resembleflower · 09/05/2023 11:20

I won’t be helping my mum and dad after they both choose not to help me even when I was ill and in hospital. Multiple times, I invite and try to involve her and my dad (they are divorced) neither are at all interested. They have minimal interest and contact with my teens. Mum dies a lot for my sisters kids now though, primary aged. I’m so jealous of the grandparents most of my friends have.

I will be living my life and hopefully being an involved parent to my kids and maybe grandkids!

StarryCup · 09/05/2023 09:39

We are middle aged and we are the sandwich generation. We see everyone we know still supporting grown up DC, providing care for elderly parents and helping with grandchildren, IF they have arrived

I can add one more level to that. As well as 90+ year old pils, we also provide substantial assistance to my brother who is disabled and significantly older than me, and lives alone as never married, and my disabled dd. Some people are providing support for four generations.
Not me, as I don't yet have grandchildren. . . .but there's not much room on my calendar currently.

Quisquam · 09/05/2023 08:17

By the same token, no fair expecting adult daughters to exhaust themselves taking care of elderly parents at the same time as we're raising young children. Find another way.

How many mothers of young children are caring for elderly parents? Their mothers must have been on the verge of menopause, when they had the daughter?

Take DH - MIL had him at 32. We had first DC when he was 28. MIL was 60 - that’s middle aged. She was not an elderly parent; and she didn’t need care really until her mid 80s. She’s just died at 96 and DH is 64 - she was really frail, the last 2 years of her life after breaking her hip. That was when she needed the most care from SIL and DH - and when we had grandchildren.

It’s far more exhausting to provide care to 3 generations in your late 50s or early 60s, than it is for young daughters in their 30s or 40s to provide care to 2 generations.

We are middle aged and we are the sandwich generation. We see everyone we know still supporting grown up DC, providing care for elderly parents and helping with grandchildren, IF they have arrived.

5128gap · 09/05/2023 07:03

I find the linking of how much childcare GP provide with how much care people intend to offer their parents in their old age not only distasteful but so divorced from reality as to be ridiculous. Those gleefully imagining their revenge will likely find when they get there it looks nothing like they imagine.
If older people need care then their children either do it themselves or they go into a home. Decisions on this in reality depend on various factors including the level of care needed, as often its beyond relatives anyway, and a home is not a punishment but the most appropriate option; others weigh up the cost of helping out with the loss of their inheritance in fees, and muddle through with their eye on the prize.
Far more older people die without ever needing much more than someone to call in an emergency and the occasional assistance if they're ill etc.
If that person has been a good parent, (which they have, of course, or you wouldn't want them looking after your children anyway), I'd have though a few errands and some general oversight were the least they deserved in return for that, even if they didn't offer free childcare/babysitting services.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 09/05/2023 05:05

But I'll be front row for their sports or other activities to support and cheer them on, just as I am for my DC.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 09/05/2023 05:02

My DSs are in their teens, and I already can't imagine looking after babies/toddlers. I'm beyond that stage and have absolutely no desire to return there.

How will I feel as a GM? I'm not entirely sure. I'd like to help out, but I certainly wouldn't want to go through another phase of being tied down. Once with my own DC was enough, quite frankly. Perhaps when they're school age and more independent I would feel differently.

But then again I received no help when mine were younger because I was too far away. And I do help my DM now who is disabled (has carers coming in but still needs extra help sometimes).

GuestStars · 09/05/2023 02:36

There’s such a big difference between expecting full time childcare for multiple days every week and being appreciative of some occasional babysitting, help in the school hols etc.

We don’t get any help with childcare. When they’re visiting us, it’s like having extra kids/responsibility requiring catering and entertainment!! 🤦🏼‍♀️

Super jealous of friends who get lots of help from grandparents.

This past weekend we were watching a tv show with MIL. It showed relatives visiting a family member in a nursing home. MIL piped up very loudly “don’t ever put me in one of those”. DH and I kept watching and pretended not to hear 😂 Fuck that!! Not my problem now or in future. I’ll be busy with my future grandchildren 🥰

Swipe left for the next trending thread