Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad about grandparents not helping childcare

409 replies

ChickenRacer · 07/05/2023 06:58

Ive heard so many stories about grandparents not wanting to help/be particularly involved with their grandchildren.I understand it’s not all grandparents, but their is a big proportion who just don’t help and support their children when they have small children.

Explanations for this often seem to be that the grandparents did their time parenting and now it’s their time to enjoy life. Which I do understand.

But to me though this seems so sad.

They say it takes a village to raise children - but grandparents are a huge part of many peoples village, so if they aren’t part of the village that’s less support for parents of young children.

This might upset some people, but I also wonder those grandparents that do not feel they want to help with the care of their grandchildren- do they still expect their adult children to care for them in their old age when they themselves need care? Will they pay their children to care for them, as some expect to be paid for caring for their grandchildren?

Please don’t be all upset by this, they are genuine questions.

I have 3 children and for various reasons have ZERO help from grandparents. But I very much hope if I am lucky enough to have grandchildren that I will be able to help my children with them in the best way for them. And I wouldn’t want them to have to care for me in my old age. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
IBlinkThereforeIAm · 07/05/2023 12:10

I think it's awful. I'd never expect regular help from family but my family have never spent a day with my children without me present, never had them to stay overnight without me there too, never babysat them even once. I have been a lone parent since my children were tiny and they are school age now. I can't imagine treating family like that. I think some people have really twisted views on what family should be. They refer to spending even an hour with them in my garden as "childcare" which is an horrific way to speak about spending time with the younger members of your family, like they are some kind of inconvenience.

unsync · 07/05/2023 11:43

Why should they though? It's their choice. They have worked for their retirement and should be able to enjoy themselves and do what they want for a bit whilst still fit and healthy.

Imagine working for all that time, bringing up your kids etc, then helping with their kids once you've stopped work, then being too old to do the stuff you worked for and dreamt about. You might as well not bother with any of it.

Don't say the reward is the grandchildren either, because reading on here about all the rules grandparents have to follow, most parents suck the joy right out of grandparenting.

starbabys · 07/05/2023 11:32

I don't have a parents, but have in laws, mil lives 10 mins away. My children are they only grandchildren they will ever have. I wouldn't ask her to look after the children as that's mine/dh responsibility. However I would like her to be involved in dc's lives. She will see them to drop off presents but that's it no involvement in their lives. Fil lives in the same city as us. Will see us every now and then. But that's it. Neither of them can answer any questions about the children's likes/ dislikes etc.
I find it very sad that my children don't have any kind of relationship with their grandparents.

To answer your question no I will not be doing any kind of looking after for in-laws as they get older. They have decided they don't want to be part of ours/ children's lives which is fine but they can't do that then expect help as they get older. If my dh decides he wants to care for his parents that's up to him (he won't as he doesn't understand why his parents act the way they do).

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 07/05/2023 11:30

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2023 10:50

They say it takes a village to raise children
Indeed, but that also meant that the 'village' was entitled to make their own decisions about the children whilst under their care.

Nowadays, parents want grandparents to mere babysitters. They are expected to adhere to a long list of 'do and don't do'. That's not what grandparents are about. They are not there purely to make their kids life easier. They deserve, and more importantly the children deserve to build a bond that is not restricted unnecessary rules.

Being raised by a village mean being exposed by other lifestyles, rules and expectations.

Yes, exactly 👏👏

I've said exactly this on previous threads - if you want a village to raise your child, you need to let go of that control and accept that other people won't raise your children the way your raise them.

It reminds me of a recent thread where the OP was angry because her mum was using an iPad while providing free childcare for her 3yo. The consensus was basically if you don't like it, then you need to pay for childcare - you can't dictate how someone cares for your child when they're giving up their time for free.

icanneverthinkofnc · 07/05/2023 11:16

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2023 10:50

They say it takes a village to raise children
Indeed, but that also meant that the 'village' was entitled to make their own decisions about the children whilst under their care.

Nowadays, parents want grandparents to mere babysitters. They are expected to adhere to a long list of 'do and don't do'. That's not what grandparents are about. They are not there purely to make their kids life easier. They deserve, and more importantly the children deserve to build a bond that is not restricted unnecessary rules.

Being raised by a village mean being exposed by other lifestyles, rules and expectations.

Exactly. On mn many cut their nose off to spite their face by the 'my way or highway' rules/ standards.

BreathesOutSlowly · 07/05/2023 11:12

For all that grandfathers are capable the vast majority of requests are I assume aimed at grandmothers. Women who will have brought up their own dc, many while working and then quite possibly shouldering the care of their parents (and in laws) in later years.

No one owes anyone anything and in this case and if the grandparent wants to provide care whether or ad hoc then that is their gift to give not an expectation.

So many threads on here complaining about the childcare provided by DM & DMIL I'm inclined to steer clear when my time comes.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 07/05/2023 11:09

I agree it’s very sad and potentially hurtful if dgp’s don’t want to be involved at all but I don’t think that’s the same as refusing to commit to regular childcare.

Both my dm and dpil were great with the kids and loved to see them. But dpil had practically raised one set of dgc so we’re quite rightly much more protective of their time by the time ours came aound. They were still great and always happy to help in an emergency.

My dm had my dc1 when 1-2 days per week when I briefly returned to work. She was in her 50’s then and i soon realised it was a lot for her so I made other arrangements pretty quickly, although we continued to spend time with her so she wasn’t missing out. My dsis only had her dc when my dm was turning 70. She expected regular childcare from dm and my dm wanted to help so she agreed. In reality it was far too much for her but my dsis kept asking for more and more, even though dm was still working pt. I ended up taking holidays from work to help as dm became ill and just couldn’t manage in the end.

We lost my dm after a very short illness and I feel very sad that she didn’t get to enjoy her well earned retirement. Dh and I want to retire early and have agreed that we are going to take some time for ourselves. We want to be involved with any dgc we might have and are happy to babysit and help in emergencies but will not commit to regular childcare. We will happily help with childcare costs though.

I certainly don’t expect or want my children to take care of me in my old age. We have the money for private care and intend to use it so that we aren’t a burden on our dc. That being said, I willingly helped my dm a lot towards the end which brings me some comfort now, and dh and I will help his dp’s if required. Not because they expect it but because we love them and want to support them.

MoreCloudsThanYouCanImagine · 07/05/2023 11:09

WhatNoRaisins · 07/05/2023 08:49

To be fair elderly people don't always want care from their children. My own grandfather found the idea really humiliating and much preferred us visiting for tea and a chat and leaving that side to carers much like grandparents who want to do fun things with their grandkids.

Why is it just assumed that it's what everyone wants?

We've talked my mother into accepting daily carers for this reason. She loves seeing them and they help her with personal care. My siblings and I are also actively involved, but we take her shopping, or out on trips, or pop in for a cuppa. We are all much happier knowing we are maintaining the sort of relationships that we would if 'care' wasn't required. Also we have peace of mind with professionals going in every day.
I posted earlier to say she helped me with my children, but not as a regular thing to help me with a full time job.
We all have a lovely relationship with each other and I'm grateful for that. She still enjoys the company of all her grandchildren too, and they love her to bits.

WandaWonder · 07/05/2023 10:56

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2023 10:50

They say it takes a village to raise children
Indeed, but that also meant that the 'village' was entitled to make their own decisions about the children whilst under their care.

Nowadays, parents want grandparents to mere babysitters. They are expected to adhere to a long list of 'do and don't do'. That's not what grandparents are about. They are not there purely to make their kids life easier. They deserve, and more importantly the children deserve to build a bond that is not restricted unnecessary rules.

Being raised by a village mean being exposed by other lifestyles, rules and expectations.

Absolutely all this

I really feel in here grandparents/ils are treated like chess pieces to be moved around a board to only be there to suit the person posting

Brotherlove · 07/05/2023 10:56

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 07/05/2023 07:15

My parents don't have the capacity to help as my mum has a severe mental illness. In laws are great but in their 80s so sadly unable to help either.
My son has special needs and his school have put him on a reduced timetable at just 1 hour a day. They say he can't cope with more. They say there's no support for ALN and the funding has been cut.
I have absolutely no village, can't even get a state school to look after my child while I work. Its hard not to feel resentful when ive worked all my life and paid tax.Needless to say I'm massively struggling.my son wakes up at 5.00am every single day
I'd do anything for a morning off and a lie in.

Similar here. I think those of use with children with ALN often end up in the same boat sadly.

No grandparents visit us let alone babysit or provide childcare - though they did for my siblings children for years, which causes deep pain and resentment.

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2023 10:50

They say it takes a village to raise children
Indeed, but that also meant that the 'village' was entitled to make their own decisions about the children whilst under their care.

Nowadays, parents want grandparents to mere babysitters. They are expected to adhere to a long list of 'do and don't do'. That's not what grandparents are about. They are not there purely to make their kids life easier. They deserve, and more importantly the children deserve to build a bond that is not restricted unnecessary rules.

Being raised by a village mean being exposed by other lifestyles, rules and expectations.

Livelovebehappy · 07/05/2023 10:50

If/when I have grandchildren, I will of course help and support. But there is a big difference between babysitting for the odd night, weekend, and then providing childcare during the week daily on a regular basis, when you’ve retired, and your child is working full time. I wouldn’t be up for that, but it is an expectation of a lot of mums and dads these days. It’s just not fair to expect that level of child care. If you can’t afford child care then you shouldn’t be having children. And no, I definitely do not expect my children to look after me in old age.

5128gap · 07/05/2023 10:45

I look after my GC. But this is my free choice and not my obligation. Just as it was my DCs free choice to have children and mine before that.
I strongly oppose the idea that people should make their unilateral decision to have children then place other people under obligation to help with them.
As for care in old age, well, should we need it, most of our children will have to choose between providing it themselves or having their inheritance reduced by the cost of the professional alternative. Very little to do with whether we provided free childcare or not.

iimm · 07/05/2023 10:45

@ChickenRacer I agree. I find it baffling. My parents love being around dc but actual scheduled help? Not a chance. They are both retired, one not even 60! I always think I hope dc have children ASAP so I am around and able to help! I think it’s very sad and I see childcare within a family as a privilege, so it’s something I would embrace, personally. Of course as grandparents you’d want a break and not to have constant demands but not even committing to one day childcare a week? It’s sad.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 07/05/2023 10:39

I don’t have DC but I do help out with childcare for DB and his DW, with DM snd stepdad.

SIL works some evenings and some weekends too and they’re expecting DC2 later this year. DB works in film and tv on contracts and does a lot of childcare in between jobs.

My DM is 81, stepdad 10 years younger and we all live the other side of London to DB. We can look after DNephew but it’s exhausting for a day especially factoring in the Blackwall tunnel.

DB and DW are now planning to move to our side of London as they do need help at least with nursery/school pick up.

DB’s BIL (his wife’s DB) moved to SW England from London over lockdown, have DC2.5 and DC6. His MIL does date night childcare once a week and I think helps with nursery and school pickups drop offs when the DP can’t do it.

I think it depends on grandparents and their health as to what they can help out with re childcare.

Thebelleofstmarys · 07/05/2023 10:36

I am 63, taken early retirement at 61 due to bring diagnosed with a life limiting health condition which is managed by taking hideously toxic drugs with grim side effects. Other than having endless GP and hospital appointments every single week, I can never tell when I'm going to need to rest . Will suddenly become v unwell and exhausted. For both reasons , I can't make plans in advance , not theatre visits, meals out , holidays let alone childcare when the parents need to know they won't be let down if I get I'll at the last minute. It's not that I don't want to help raise my grandchildren, it's that I simply am not physically well enough to . This is saddening for everyone but personally , a total disappointment to me as I moved countries to be nearer them so I could be a hands on Nanna. Life gets in the way of hopes and plans at times.

HBGKC · 07/05/2023 10:30

OP, I'm sorry that neither set of grandparents shows much interest in their grandchildren. I agree that that's sad.

I think you're drawing a false equivalence between grandparents caring for their grandchildren, and adult children caring for their own parents. There's an extra degree of separation there.

Your parents looked after you when you were young. Natural social norms dictate that then you, when adult, will help look after them when they are old.

Grandchildren play no part in that equation.

I do agree, though, that it can be very difficult for (mostly) women who find themselves with children needing care on one side, and aging parents needing care on the other.

Regardless, I would never expect a regular (by which I mean every week) childcare commitment from anyone I wasn't paying; I don't think it's fair to curtail others' freedom like that.

Also women are having children later and later, which means that the grandparents in question are going to be older and older. Young children are exhausting to spend time with, no matter how much you love them!

80sMum · 07/05/2023 10:23

RegainingTheWill2023 · 07/05/2023 07:18

What you are actually promoting is that women who spend their younger years putting their lives and careers on hold to rase children, should then do the same a few years later to provide childcare for their grandchildren whilst also caring for their own aging parents ....
Retirement age is 67. How are women supposed to do all this?
And of course its down to women. All these caring commitments mean their earning potential would continue to lag way behind men so it's inevitable.
The answer is affordable childcare and adequate state funded care for the elderly.

^This!

Timeforchangeithink · 07/05/2023 10:22

When someone chooses to have a child/children it is entirely their responsibility to work out how they are going to bring them up and look after them. Not the 'villages'. The rest of my life won't be ruled by my children's decisions. I am still working fulltime, I barely have time to look after myself properly. I actually think it's crazy anyone wanting to bring kids into this world now.

CheeseLouisePlease · 07/05/2023 10:22

I know people who have organised their whole lives around the fact their parents will do all their childcare etc for them. I had a manager briefly who didn’t understand why I didn’t want more hours work. She then explained her 2 children basically lived with her parents during the week so she could work uninterrupted and seemed confused it wasn’t the same for everyone.

I know someone who was basically bullied into looking into her GC by her son. She would have done it, but I don’t think to the extent that she has done. They are also well off but pay for no childcare. It was meant to be split between her and in-laws but they are busy people so cancel and leave her to pick it up (widowed). They also live well over an hour away. She’s had calls in the middle of the night to come down as there is a sick child, so they can go back to sleep.
The worst of it is, they spend no time socially with her. She looks after GC as otherwise she wouldn’t see them. When they come home from work she’s been asked to leave. They never take her out for the day as that’s ‘family time’, they never come to visit her. It’s ruined her relationship with her friends as she won’t commit to anything in case her son rings for help. They have taken her on holiday and she said she felt like a nanny the whole time.
She’s in her 80s and doing it wipes her out, she sleeps on a sofa bed when she visits and doesn’t sleep well.
She actually tried to move house closer so she didn’t have to do the drive and her son has said absolutely not. I know why, because he doesn’t want to be responsible when she gets infirm. She was very poorly once and went in hospital and he never came to visit, just shouted at her about his childcare issues.
He very much believes she owes him because his own GM was very involved in his care when he was little. It’s not the same though.

OKwhatsNext · 07/05/2023 10:19

We have three kids age 5, 3 7months. We receive zero childcare from either side. One set of parents are fully retired, the other has one parent working part time. My parents will help in an emergency (recently needed an a&e trip) but that's it. I don't expect them to have them on set days etc as an alternative to childcare but I do WISH with every bone in my body they would babysit just once. I won't ask because I know they will flap about and make excuses/pull out at the last minute (guaranteed). What's annoying is they both moan they want to see the kids more, right up until the point that we ask to see them (as a family).

When my kids are grown I want to be able to see them, babysit but not do fixed childcare. I think I just appreciate how bloody miraculous a couple of hours child free will be for me and DH right now (and assume our parents have forgotten!)

Mythicalcreatures · 07/05/2023 10:16

I have no intention of offering childcare, I want the freedom to do what I want and when. I have had no help, single parent with both sets of grandparents dead and dc dad dead, I'll have done all my childcare. Saying that I will offer to babysit and if I'm around for ad hoc childcare due to sickness I will step in there but regular childcare, no chance and actually as a parent it was the babysitting or sickness cover I needed not regular childcare which I paid for.

ChiefPearlClutcher · 07/05/2023 10:15

@ChickenRacer Not a chance. They can be involved if they want to be, but expectation and obligation is the killer of any loving relationship.

MintJulia · 07/05/2023 10:13

OP, I'm a single mum to a 15yo, I'm 60 next month and will work full time for another couple of years. I'm shattered. And I'm in good health, not overweight, physically fit.

I literally could not cope with a toddler. Maybe after I've had six months rest I would do one afternoon a week, but no more.

Do not underestimate how energy levels drop as people get to 60.