Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Increase in culture of envy

428 replies

BrighteyesBonnie · 06/05/2023 22:02

AIBU to think that the culture of envy has increased significantly in the UK (if Mumsnet is anything to go by)?

For example, a thread by a lawyer asking whether their current salary is fair given their qualifications and years of experience contained a lot of responses angry that the OP is earning more than them and also ridiculing the OP for wanting a better salary.

Another example are threads on private schools, where there is a strong undercurrent of anger at those who are sending or want to send their children to private schools. Privately educated people are viewed with harsh lenses and often insulted.

Ambition and doing well do not appear to be appreciated if you’re doing better than the average.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
GeeHDees · 07/05/2023 08:20

MintJulia · 07/05/2023 08:04

@GeeHDees Well done. I'm also sick of this 'recognise your privilege' stuff.

I'm from a FSM family, had a drunken abusive father who got his kicks bullying children, threw me out for the first time at 15, and literally fought to prevent me going to university because he hadn't been and 'his taxes shouldn't be wasted educating women'.

I didn't give up either, worked throughout to survive and have built a successful career enabling me to provide a decent life for me & my ds. Some of the things I've had to do to get here would cause horror on MN.

Very few people have perfect childhoods and it would be far better to recognise people's determination and achievement, than try to dismiss those achievements with 'it's all down to privilege'.

Brilliant, sounds like you've done amazingly well- I feel proud of us!

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 08:19

9outof10cats · 07/05/2023 08:14

I'm not sure it's envy.

However, it can be frustrating to hear individuals who earn six-figure salaries complain about financial difficulties while owning expensive homes and sending their children to private schools.

Such behaviour comes across as lacking perspective and understanding of the financial challenges faced by those genuinely struggling to make ends meet.

That's very much not what was happening in the thread the OP is referring to though.

A woman earning £62k as a commercial solicitor in Birmingham posted asking for people's views about whether she is underpaid and her thread was totally derailed by mainly public sector workers whose pensions will be much more valuable than hers telling her she should be grateful to earn such a high salary, and telling us all about how many PhDs they had to do or years they had to work to reach the lofty heights of £30k in a completely unrelated sector.

That absolutely is a culture of envy.

BadSkiingMum · 07/05/2023 08:19

It’s complicated.

There are people born into relative advantage who make bad decisions.

They leave education, are not sure of their direction, make a false start, spend a year or three traveling, or ‘finding themselves’, or ‘having fun’, spend money on retraining, finally get started in a career and then wake up at age thirty to realise that their friends who have been working during that time are all several steps up the career ladder and settling down around them.

Do I feel sorry for them? Not particularly.

It’s a bit like family size: by all means have three children and a period of SAHM for each of them, but don’t then be shocked that your CV is ten years out of date, you don’t have much of a savings buffer and things are expensive for a family of five.

If you start from a position of advantage then you have to recognise that your own decisions will all have an impact on your economic situation. I reserve my sympathy for people who are fighting the odds from the start.

GeeHDees · 07/05/2023 08:19

produ · 07/05/2023 08:13

Its not a sin to say youve worked hard to get where you are, if others get offended by that and assume people are then suggesting they havent then thats unfortunate but its sad people can't be proud of themselves without being torn down or accused of needing to check their privilege

It's not about that though. I worked hard as did DH. But our "success" is also attributed to parental investment, access to excellent schools, financial help etc which is now playing out in turn for my dc. It's also about the safety net which makes risk much easier.
Obviously some go onto to great success despite not have invested parents etc. But if I look at my peers at my work, neighbourhood, dcs school etc we tend to come from similar backgrounds

But I did work hard and my success is squarely down to that. Its great if you recognise that you had a leg up and support which has helped you, but it's taboo for anyone to say it and there are many of us out there who have succeeded against the odds but are shot down for talking about it or made to feel guilty for not living on the breadline anymore.

Fairislefandango · 07/05/2023 08:18

Explain the accident of birth please versus life choices. So the majority of those deemed to be doing well is not because of anything they did?

It's not that it has nothing to do with anything they did, it's that it's very likely that in many or most cases, what they did to make them do well was facilitated by accidents of birth. Obviously not in all cases, but very often.

I teach in a fantastic school which has a great record of supporting students with low income backgrounds in doing fantastically well at school and going on to do really well, but this isn't so common across the board.

produ · 07/05/2023 08:17

@BrighteyesBonnie you are still misunderstanding....

I don't have an issue with the removal of charitable status, it doesn't impact on my decision to use private schools or not. But your argument for keeping it is it won't make others better off, I have not said it would...It's not much of an argument.

MintJulia · 07/05/2023 08:15

@produ Don't assume your peers 'tend to come from similar backgrounds'.

Those who had a tough childhood seldom talk about it and allow those around them to think otherwise so they can fit in.

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 08:15

produ · 07/05/2023 08:13

@MargotBamborough I wasn't aware the more funded hours had started?

They haven't, yet. But people on here were moaning about that policy the moment it was announced.

I thought I was hallucinating.

Women on Mumsnet complaining about the government announcing plans for more subsidised childcare? What?

produ · 07/05/2023 08:14

And any threads I saw tended to be older people moaning about funding more free hours as opposed to the unemployed 🤷🏻‍♀️

9outof10cats · 07/05/2023 08:14

I'm not sure it's envy.

However, it can be frustrating to hear individuals who earn six-figure salaries complain about financial difficulties while owning expensive homes and sending their children to private schools.

Such behaviour comes across as lacking perspective and understanding of the financial challenges faced by those genuinely struggling to make ends meet.

BrighteyesBonnie · 07/05/2023 08:14

produ · 07/05/2023 08:01

@BrighteyesBonnie I don't really have an issue with private schools & may use them myself. However I don't see why they should have charitable status, why do you?

Removing charitable status is not going to help those doing worse-off than you.

Demonising the “boat people “ will not put more money in your pocket or improve your life markedly. Asking for policies to take more away from those doing better than you will not make your life better.

A more productive society, a growing economy will make your life better. There is inequality and a lot of that has been driven by low productivity and making working less attractive.

Most likely, the inequality gap people are most concerned with isn’t the solicitor on £62k but rather the millionaires and billionaires. People on 6 figure salaries are not living it up and drinking champagne. They do not get the support of benefits. They pay 60% tax on some of their income and can’t escape this compared to millionaires and billionaires who can avoid paying their fair share of taxes.

OP posts:
produ · 07/05/2023 08:13

@MargotBamborough I wasn't aware the more funded hours had started?

produ · 07/05/2023 08:13

Its not a sin to say youve worked hard to get where you are, if others get offended by that and assume people are then suggesting they havent then thats unfortunate but its sad people can't be proud of themselves without being torn down or accused of needing to check their privilege

It's not about that though. I worked hard as did DH. But our "success" is also attributed to parental investment, access to excellent schools, financial help etc which is now playing out in turn for my dc. It's also about the safety net which makes risk much easier.
Obviously some go onto to great success despite not have invested parents etc. But if I look at my peers at my work, neighbourhood, dcs school etc we tend to come from similar backgrounds

SunnyEgg · 07/05/2023 08:11

BrighteyesBonnie · 07/05/2023 07:58

@GrandpianoCoffee you said:

”*The last elections have indicated that Labour will probably win the next GE. Labour have already pledged to take charity status away from independent schools, meaning that all parents will have to find 20% more money to afford school fees. As it is the teachers in these schools are paid well under the odds for their skills so this cost will be passed on to parents.

Some parents won’t be able to afford this hike and hopefully things will start to become a little more equal.”

In other words drag them done to even things? So equality is obtained by bringing those doing better off a peg down?

Agree this kind of dragging things down isn’t going to improve anything

It’s depressing to see

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 08:09

produ · 07/05/2023 08:03

Sorry, but who exactly do you think should pay for you to stay at home until your youngest child is three?

I think there should be far more support for young families, have you seen birth rates? I would make child benefit universal as it use to be.

But more hours of funded childcare IS more support for young families.

I think it's terrible that so many women can't afford to go back to work because the cost of childcare would exceed what they can earn. It keeps women in a poverty trap and the effects last for far longer than the years their children are actually small. Subsidised childcare would/will help massively.

But there were women on here moaning about that policy because what they want is for the taxpayer - people like that solicitor in Birmingham on £62k, who is paying 40% tax and 9% student loan repayments on the top slice of her earnings - to pay for them to just stay at home.

hattie43 · 07/05/2023 08:05

Surely your financial status is the sum of your own efforts . Education is free , work hard , apply yourself , grab opportunities , be flexible . Good things will come . I've worked with some real achievers who've literally had nothing as kids and turned their lives around . Those kind of people were valued far more for their real grit and determination over someone essentially lazy because they've never strived for anything . It's all about aspiration but in this country we prefer to vilify and drag down anyone successful .

MintJulia · 07/05/2023 08:04

@GeeHDees Well done. I'm also sick of this 'recognise your privilege' stuff.

I'm from a FSM family, had a drunken abusive father who got his kicks bullying children, threw me out for the first time at 15, and literally fought to prevent me going to university because he hadn't been and 'his taxes shouldn't be wasted educating women'.

I didn't give up either, worked throughout to survive and have built a successful career enabling me to provide a decent life for me & my ds. Some of the things I've had to do to get here would cause horror on MN.

Very few people have perfect childhoods and it would be far better to recognise people's determination and achievement, than try to dismiss those achievements with 'it's all down to privilege'.

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 08:04

Totalwasteofpaper · 07/05/2023 07:58

Th 65k in bham is an interesting one. I knew before i clicked there would be a load of
"Im a nurse i make x" "i am a carer and i make y. You are disgusting and a money grabber"

Because no one wants to face the fact inequity is now rife and society is fucked salary wise. Social mobility is now basically extinct. Its a huge problem and people want to pretend its not happening.

There is this myth that 60k a year is enough to live like a king.
It is.... if you are 50 and mortgage free.
If you are late20s early 30s and not claiming benefits or in social housing its "okay" but you are shopping in aldi and you buy your clothes in the sales. You are not living it up and drowning in gucci.

Yes, absolutely.

If you're on £62k in Birmingham and you have a partner than I would expect you to be able to get on the property ladder. But so what? The fact that being able to buy a modest house at the age of 30 is seen as a sign of wealth these days says it all, doesn't it?

My dad never earned £62k but he did buy a town house in Guildford for £20k in 1979 when he was 24. That's the difference.

BrighteyesBonnie · 07/05/2023 08:04

@User98866 do you know what the bottom of the salary range is that takes you into 1%. What is your definition of wealthy?

OP posts:
produ · 07/05/2023 08:03

Sorry, but who exactly do you think should pay for you to stay at home until your youngest child is three?

I think there should be far more support for young families, have you seen birth rates? I would make child benefit universal as it use to be.

produ · 07/05/2023 08:01

@BrighteyesBonnie I don't really have an issue with private schools & may use them myself. However I don't see why they should have charitable status, why do you?

produ · 07/05/2023 08:00

There is this myth that 60k a year is enough to live like a king.
It is.... if you are 50 and mortgage free.
If you are late20s early 30s and not claiming benefits or in social housing its "okay" but you are shopping in aldi and you buy your clothes in the sales. You are not living it up and drowning in gucci.

This! Which is why I defended the OP. Housing & wage stagnation has really fucked things for younger people.

Totalwasteofpaper · 07/05/2023 07:58

Th 65k in bham is an interesting one. I knew before i clicked there would be a load of
"Im a nurse i make x" "i am a carer and i make y. You are disgusting and a money grabber"

Because no one wants to face the fact inequity is now rife and society is fucked salary wise. Social mobility is now basically extinct. Its a huge problem and people want to pretend its not happening.

There is this myth that 60k a year is enough to live like a king.
It is.... if you are 50 and mortgage free.
If you are late20s early 30s and not claiming benefits or in social housing its "okay" but you are shopping in aldi and you buy your clothes in the sales. You are not living it up and drowning in gucci.

BrighteyesBonnie · 07/05/2023 07:58

@GrandpianoCoffee you said:

”*The last elections have indicated that Labour will probably win the next GE. Labour have already pledged to take charity status away from independent schools, meaning that all parents will have to find 20% more money to afford school fees. As it is the teachers in these schools are paid well under the odds for their skills so this cost will be passed on to parents.

Some parents won’t be able to afford this hike and hopefully things will start to become a little more equal.”

In other words drag them done to even things? So equality is obtained by bringing those doing better off a peg down?

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 07:57

Garethkeenansstapler · 07/05/2023 05:21

There’s an awful lot of entitlement on here when it comes to benefits. They seem to be seen as a bottomless pit of cash that can be dipped into because you don’t fancy working full time, or because you want a change of job, or you’re going through a divorce, or have made crappy financial decisions. You see it all the time - poster announces they’re leaving their husband and rather than encourage them to find their own job and independence, it’s all ‘See what benefits you are entitled to’, ‘Can you put in a UC claim’ ‘Don’t worry UC will pay your rent’.

Simultaneously the high earners who are paying for others to have those benefits are routinely mocked and accused of being ‘out of touch’.

To me there’s nothing more ‘out of touch’ than expecting free money because you want to pick your kids up from school and don’t want to work more than 15 hours a week.

Absolutely this.

The number of posters on here moaning about the government announcing extra funded childcare was eye opening. All.this hand wringing about the fact that it is clearly better for children to be at home with a parent until the age of three and that the government doesn't care and wants children to be "brought up by strangers".

Sorry, but who exactly do you think should pay for you to stay at home until your youngest child is three?