Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if you think this salary is reasonable or am I being greedy?

437 replies

bkyegres · 06/05/2023 16:47

I qualified as a solicitor in 2016, so I’m around 7 years pqe. I’m paid 62k in Bham, commercial rather than private client work. I’ve only just paid off my student loan last year and honestly I feel like the firm are taking the piss… all the studying and expense feels ridiculous to be seven years on and barely over 50k. Obviously I know what some other firms pay and I can look into it further with recruiters but I am starting to wonder if you have to join a new company for any decent pay these days?! I could have skipped uni and worked my way up to this salary by now so it all seems a bit pointless.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 18:10

GeraltsBathtub · 07/05/2023 18:03

The only way someone earns £12k a year is if they don’t work full time or if they are under 18, so hardly a relevant comparison. And yes doctors earn more than this, as do majors in the army and upwards, and fire
service area managers, and police inspectors and upwards, etc.

Also, someone who earns £12k a year isn't paying little or even no income tax, whereas someone earning £62k a year and still paying off their student loan (i.e. the OP of that thread) is having 49% of that £12k deducted at source.

To pay teachers' and nurses' salaries and pensions (the latter of which are far more generous than her own) among other things.

GeraltsBathtub · 07/05/2023 18:03

NatM70 · 07/05/2023 17:48

£12K is what some people earn a year, so it is not 'barely' over £50K really is it.

Nurses, police, doctors, fire persons, soldiers, etc., aren't usually paid even near this amount.
And we would be up the proverbial without them.

Just my op.

The only way someone earns £12k a year is if they don’t work full time or if they are under 18, so hardly a relevant comparison. And yes doctors earn more than this, as do majors in the army and upwards, and fire
service area managers, and police inspectors and upwards, etc.

Mstxxx · 07/05/2023 17:59

I mean I think it is a good salary generally compared to other professions but for a solicitor with 7 years qualified experience, depending where you live and what company you work for, I don't think it is great. I think you could definitely earn more if you went elsewhere!

For example there is a 27 year old manager in my pension company who has only 5 years work experience earning 43k. She didn't start on a post grad role as a degree wasn't required for the role she has had in the past or presently. Yet my friend in the teaching industry has a degree, a post grad degree, 10 years experience in her industry and has only just got a job paying 27k.

GofE · 07/05/2023 17:58

Hmm. A lot of training involved.
So I’d say no, if you looked around you should get far more.
it’s all relative and everyone can say it’s good compared to some, but, as a highly trained qualified person; you can command more.
I’m based in London, but unskilled would get that kind of salary.
like others have said, you do have to move around for rises. 😬

NatM70 · 07/05/2023 17:48

£12K is what some people earn a year, so it is not 'barely' over £50K really is it.

Nurses, police, doctors, fire persons, soldiers, etc., aren't usually paid even near this amount.
And we would be up the proverbial without them.

Just my op.

monkeyoven · 07/05/2023 17:43

I think you need to take the culture of your firm into account. If you aren’t working 80 hour weeks you can’t compare to city/American firms. Also you aren’t getting a London weighing as your cost of living isn’t as high.

NoAprilFool · 07/05/2023 13:36

Executries!!! Not executives 🤦‍♀️

NoAprilFool · 07/05/2023 13:27

drinkeatsmile · 07/05/2023 11:08

She’s not working for a law firm - she’s commercial- big difference in salary.

Eh?? There’s been no hint of that. If she worked in house, she’d say in house. Commercial would generally be understood to be a commercial lawyer in private practice.
private client is executives, trusts etc

drinkeatsmile · 07/05/2023 12:30

Dibblydoodahdah · 07/05/2023 11:42

@drinkeatsmile I get a much bigger bonus in-house than I did when I worked for a law firm. And better pay too!

I can well believe it - we can really only rely on general trends and the reality can be very different - the op needs to go for a few interviews and test the market, some people seem very reluctant to do this.

Dibblydoodahdah · 07/05/2023 11:42

@drinkeatsmile I get a much bigger bonus in-house than I did when I worked for a law firm. And better pay too!

Dibblydoodahdah · 07/05/2023 11:41

@hereiamagainn my brother is a teacher. He’s never worked through the night. I have as a lawyer. Both jobs are hard work but I have worked many more hours than him over the years. For that, I expect more pay. Nursing is a difficult one to compare with. I don’t dispute that nurses work hard and that they deserve more pay, but a more usual comparison would be between doctors and lawyers.

drinkeatsmile · 07/05/2023 11:30

samG76 · 07/05/2023 11:18

Exactly, TimesRwo - I though she's doing company/commercial at a law firm, hence my reference to billings. If in house, it's different, of course, but here are lots of in house benefits that you don't get at law firms, and it is an "eat what you kill" environment, as Curtain 1980 accurately sums up

I assumed it was in house - no mention of bonuses, structured progression through the grades to Partner

HauntedPencil · 07/05/2023 11:28

Completely irrelevant to my point anyway.

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 11:20

drinkeatsmile · 07/05/2023 11:08

She’s not working for a law firm - she’s commercial- big difference in salary.

Huh? She works in a law firm.

samG76 · 07/05/2023 11:18

Exactly, TimesRwo - I though she's doing company/commercial at a law firm, hence my reference to billings. If in house, it's different, of course, but here are lots of in house benefits that you don't get at law firms, and it is an "eat what you kill" environment, as Curtain 1980 accurately sums up

TimesRwo · 07/05/2023 11:12

drinkeatsmile · 07/05/2023 11:08

She’s not working for a law firm - she’s commercial- big difference in salary.

That’s not clear at all - she compares commercial to private client and in fact talks about other firms. She could very well be doing commercial in a law firm.

drinkeatsmile · 07/05/2023 11:08

HauntedPencil · 07/05/2023 09:46

Is it greedy if everyone doing the same job as you is being paid more to want to be equalised? Sorry this js a total doormat attitude she's working for a law firm not Jesus.

She’s not working for a law firm - she’s commercial- big difference in salary.

drinkeatsmile · 07/05/2023 11:04

hereiamagainn · 07/05/2023 10:45

Sigh. I guess there is a difference between “Am I REASONABLE to want more” and “Is it GREEDY to want more”. Most people have answered the former, and quite rightly so given this is AIBU. I think I have focused, possibly erroneously, on the question about greed.

If it helps, I think a great many people who choose boring and/or stressful jobs that command an extremely high salary, are greedy. It’s why they chose the job in the first place. The OP’s post suggested that this is likely the case for her. And if you want to make a comparison with nursing and teaching, which require similar levels of qualification and hard work, the main difference is that some choose the satisfaction of helping society whereas others choose the satisfaction of a large salary, to put it crudely.

No doubt many of you will bristle with indignation at this, but it is the way I see things and sharing different perspectives is what AIBU is all about.

So, YANBU to want to be paid on a par with your peers (male and female) however that does not mean that you (and they) are not greedy.

Even the caring professions need lawyers and accountants, and a lot of us would find nursing and teaching stressful and dull - you are sharing your views of these professions but thankfully not everyone feels the same way.

VivX · 07/05/2023 10:59

SeasonFinale · 06/05/2023 22:42

Perhaps the OP is her friend 😉

😂

VivX · 07/05/2023 10:54

Mortimercat · 07/05/2023 05:28

Sorry off topic, but there is no such thing as an “unqualified accountant”. If you do not have a professional qualification you are not an accountant.

"Accountant" is not a protected term. Anyone can call themselves an accountant regardless of their qualifications (or lack of). But if you are qualified, you'll generally earn more.
Job adverts for accountants will often specify if they want a CCAB-qualified accountant.
A 7yr post-qualified accountant in Birmingham would expect to be on more than £62k.

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 10:50

hereiamagainn · 07/05/2023 10:45

Sigh. I guess there is a difference between “Am I REASONABLE to want more” and “Is it GREEDY to want more”. Most people have answered the former, and quite rightly so given this is AIBU. I think I have focused, possibly erroneously, on the question about greed.

If it helps, I think a great many people who choose boring and/or stressful jobs that command an extremely high salary, are greedy. It’s why they chose the job in the first place. The OP’s post suggested that this is likely the case for her. And if you want to make a comparison with nursing and teaching, which require similar levels of qualification and hard work, the main difference is that some choose the satisfaction of helping society whereas others choose the satisfaction of a large salary, to put it crudely.

No doubt many of you will bristle with indignation at this, but it is the way I see things and sharing different perspectives is what AIBU is all about.

So, YANBU to want to be paid on a par with your peers (male and female) however that does not mean that you (and they) are not greedy.

But £62k isn't an "extremely high salary". Especially not when you take into account that almost half of the top slice of that will be deducted at source (40% on tax which pays for, among other things, teachers' and nurses' salaries, and 9% on student loan repayments), and that the OP will be getting a much less generous pension entitlement than teachers and nurses.

I also don't believe that everyone who goes into teaching in particular does so for altruistic reasons. In many cases I believe it's more like, "Oh, what can I do with an English degree?" and, "Well I want at least two children and so it makes sense to do a term time only job." There's a reason why most teachers are women until you get to senior management levels, when suddenly the women are mysteriously outnumbered by the men.

hereiamagainn · 07/05/2023 10:45

Sigh. I guess there is a difference between “Am I REASONABLE to want more” and “Is it GREEDY to want more”. Most people have answered the former, and quite rightly so given this is AIBU. I think I have focused, possibly erroneously, on the question about greed.

If it helps, I think a great many people who choose boring and/or stressful jobs that command an extremely high salary, are greedy. It’s why they chose the job in the first place. The OP’s post suggested that this is likely the case for her. And if you want to make a comparison with nursing and teaching, which require similar levels of qualification and hard work, the main difference is that some choose the satisfaction of helping society whereas others choose the satisfaction of a large salary, to put it crudely.

No doubt many of you will bristle with indignation at this, but it is the way I see things and sharing different perspectives is what AIBU is all about.

So, YANBU to want to be paid on a par with your peers (male and female) however that does not mean that you (and they) are not greedy.

Flavabobble · 07/05/2023 10:39

No idea what the going rate is, but yabu for thinking 62k is barely over 50k.

TimesRwo · 07/05/2023 10:23

Emotionalstorm · 07/05/2023 07:56

She said she is 7PQE. In law there is usually no concept of promotions apart from to council or partner. Your seniority is otherwise determined by however many years qualified you are and you get an automatic payrise each year.

Well no, that’s not quite right. You can have a 4PQE senior associate earning more than a 7PQE associate in the very same firm and therefore more senior with more responsibility. PQE does not reflect how good someone is as a lawyer. It is very much about the promotions and your job titles

Curtain1980 · 07/05/2023 10:17

I work in the law and in HR so know a lot about earnings. I’m happy to advise you OP if you DM me.

For others on this thread I’d think you’d be astonished at what lawyers earn at the top of their game but can I say it doesn’t come without a lot of sacrifice and sadly as I’ve seen with Partners often shorter lives. It’s a very stressful job, huge impact on health and family lives. Totally dog eat dog too.