Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if you think this salary is reasonable or am I being greedy?

437 replies

bkyegres · 06/05/2023 16:47

I qualified as a solicitor in 2016, so I’m around 7 years pqe. I’m paid 62k in Bham, commercial rather than private client work. I’ve only just paid off my student loan last year and honestly I feel like the firm are taking the piss… all the studying and expense feels ridiculous to be seven years on and barely over 50k. Obviously I know what some other firms pay and I can look into it further with recruiters but I am starting to wonder if you have to join a new company for any decent pay these days?! I could have skipped uni and worked my way up to this salary by now so it all seems a bit pointless.

OP posts:
Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:36

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 21:32

I think there's a perception that teachers are bitter because they never ever stop moaning about the pay and conditions in the profession that they willingly chose.

If the fact that teaching is stressful and not particularly well paid (although, as you say, still better paid than many other jobs) has come as a surprise to you, you clearly didn't do much research.

Erm I did my research thanks love, and where did I say i was surprised at what it’s like? I didn’t fyi.

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 21:35

Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:28

I understand that, however when people are telling teachers to be grateful but actively support others who aren’t teachers in getting extra pay then to me it’s hypocritical.

Which specific posters do you believe are doing this?

Are you sure it's not just the same people on £25k telling teachers they should be grateful for their whopping great salaries and pensions and telling the OP she should be grateful to earn the dizzying heights of £62k, only now the teachers are joining the £25k people in sticking a boot in to the OP and doing exactly the same thing they find so irritating when they're on the receiving end of it?

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 21:32

Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:26

I’m glad it’s not you and hopefully not the OP, however a lot of the comments on here are that teachers are bitter etc by the same people who say teachers should be grateful for what they earn etc

I think there's a perception that teachers are bitter because they never ever stop moaning about the pay and conditions in the profession that they willingly chose.

If the fact that teaching is stressful and not particularly well paid (although, as you say, still better paid than many other jobs) has come as a surprise to you, you clearly didn't do much research.

Twillow · 07/05/2023 21:29

You need to post this in legal if you want to know how it compares with other solicitors. Otherwise you're being pretty tone deaf to not understand it's a whopping great salary for most people.

Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:28

TheThinkingGoblin · 07/05/2023 21:16

The wages of public sector folks are limited by the underlying strength of the UK economy (national income) as they are paid directly from tax revenues.

Thats why teachers and nurses complaining about a solicitors salary (who is not in the public sector) is just so utterly pointless, and generally points to envy and bitterness.

The solicitor will be paid what the market can afford to pay him with a few caveats (ability to negotiate).

Public sector folks will always be limited by how strong the UK economy is in the long-run, as their wages are correlated to national income.

I understand that, however when people are telling teachers to be grateful but actively support others who aren’t teachers in getting extra pay then to me it’s hypocritical.

Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:26

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 21:15

Well, not me. And probably not the OP either.

The OP's taxes pay for teachers' salaries and pensions though, whereas the reverse is not true.

I’m glad it’s not you and hopefully not the OP, however a lot of the comments on here are that teachers are bitter etc by the same people who say teachers should be grateful for what they earn etc

TheThinkingGoblin · 07/05/2023 21:16

Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:10

Just like the bloody non teachers pile on teachers who are asking for more pay

The wages of public sector folks are limited by the underlying strength of the UK economy (national income) as they are paid directly from tax revenues.

Thats why teachers and nurses complaining about a solicitors salary (who is not in the public sector) is just so utterly pointless, and generally points to envy and bitterness.

The solicitor will be paid what the market can afford to pay him with a few caveats (ability to negotiate).

Public sector folks will always be limited by how strong the UK economy is in the long-run, as their wages are correlated to national income.

Stripedbag101 · 07/05/2023 21:15

UsingChangeofName · 07/05/2023 20:05

Why do you think a nurses salary is relevant to this question?

Because the question is "do you think this salary is reasonable or am I being greedy", which makes this poster's reply perfectly reasonable and relevant.

(and I'm not a nurse)

Your clealry not a recruitment consultant either 😂

OPs whole post about her work, years of experience.

all this nonsense people are spouting on this thread really does make me question basic intelligence.

OP was asking if she should earn more - a nurses salary isn’t at all relevant. She wasn’t asking everyone to debate whether we should live in a socialist/communist economy. She isn’t going to go into a salary negotiation where her boss says well you earn more than a nurse so count yourself lucky😂😂😂😂

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 21:15

Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:10

Just like the bloody non teachers pile on teachers who are asking for more pay

Well, not me. And probably not the OP either.

The OP's taxes pay for teachers' salaries and pensions though, whereas the reverse is not true.

Skyblue92 · 07/05/2023 21:10

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 19:04

The bloody teachers would still have piled on anyway.

Just like the bloody non teachers pile on teachers who are asking for more pay

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 21:06

Stealthfart · 07/05/2023 21:04

It’s a shame the op has vanished. I’m more interested to know if she realises the dismissive ‘barely over £50k’ £12,000 can actually be a full salary for a lot of people? Made me feel uncomfortable anyway.

No it isn't, don't be daft.

Stealthfart · 07/05/2023 21:04

It’s a shame the op has vanished. I’m more interested to know if she realises the dismissive ‘barely over £50k’ £12,000 can actually be a full salary for a lot of people? Made me feel uncomfortable anyway.

Okthenhun · 07/05/2023 21:00

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 20:38

A few reasons.

First thing you need to know is that they'll advertise roles with a particular salary band, e.g. £48,000 - £58,000 for a Grade 7 role. What they don't tell you is that they'll automatically start you on the bottom of that salary range, and you won't move off the bottom of it due to the pay freeze. The only Grade 7s earning £58,000 are the ones who have been Grade 7s for a really long time and got automatic salary increases to move up the pay band before the pay freeze, which has been in place for over a decade now. This means that the most talented Grade 7s who are ready to be promoted to Grade 6 are still at the bottom of the pay band, and the people at the top of the pay band are the ones who have been bumbling along at the same level of seniority for 20 years because they either aren't very ambitious or aren't very good. It also means that when those talented Grade 7s get promoted to Grade 6 and have management responsibilities, they'll be earning about the same as those long term Grade 7s who never got promoted.

The process for getting promoted is incredibly slow. Although they don't tend to promote rubbish people in my experience, they will make talented people who are ready for promotion do two roles at Grade 7 before they'll consider them for a Grade 6 role. So that means it'll take you at least 6 years to get promoted from Grade 7 at £48,000 to Grade 6 on £60,000.

Another reason I wouldn't recommend it is that once you're in, it can be very difficult to get out. This is partly because you might end up doing something niche like bona vacantia which has no real equivalent in the private sector. But it's also due to a perception that the Government Legal Department is where legal careers go to die, and that the people who work there are no good and would never be able to hack it in private practice. For what it's worth I think this perception is very unfair. There are lots of very hardworking, talented lawyers there, many of whom trained and worked in top law firms beforehand. Again, this will depend massively on what job you are doing. So for example, when I worked there I was doing a general commercial role with a specialism in EU law issues, which was actually pretty valuable to private sector employers. I didn't have any problems getting out again when I wanted to. And my former boss is now head of public sector law at one of the Big 4. So it is possible. But it can be very hard.

I also hear that morale has taken a real nose dive in the last few years.

Correct and a good description of legal roles in other gov depts too.

Heygal · 07/05/2023 20:41

I am coming up to 2 years PQ in private client in the south east. I am earning £45k. My starting wage was £35k. I thought I’d be on a lot more. No maternity pay. Won’t be clearing my student loan any time soon.

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 20:38

Coffeetree · 07/05/2023 19:56

Why don't you recommend GDL?

A few reasons.

First thing you need to know is that they'll advertise roles with a particular salary band, e.g. £48,000 - £58,000 for a Grade 7 role. What they don't tell you is that they'll automatically start you on the bottom of that salary range, and you won't move off the bottom of it due to the pay freeze. The only Grade 7s earning £58,000 are the ones who have been Grade 7s for a really long time and got automatic salary increases to move up the pay band before the pay freeze, which has been in place for over a decade now. This means that the most talented Grade 7s who are ready to be promoted to Grade 6 are still at the bottom of the pay band, and the people at the top of the pay band are the ones who have been bumbling along at the same level of seniority for 20 years because they either aren't very ambitious or aren't very good. It also means that when those talented Grade 7s get promoted to Grade 6 and have management responsibilities, they'll be earning about the same as those long term Grade 7s who never got promoted.

The process for getting promoted is incredibly slow. Although they don't tend to promote rubbish people in my experience, they will make talented people who are ready for promotion do two roles at Grade 7 before they'll consider them for a Grade 6 role. So that means it'll take you at least 6 years to get promoted from Grade 7 at £48,000 to Grade 6 on £60,000.

Another reason I wouldn't recommend it is that once you're in, it can be very difficult to get out. This is partly because you might end up doing something niche like bona vacantia which has no real equivalent in the private sector. But it's also due to a perception that the Government Legal Department is where legal careers go to die, and that the people who work there are no good and would never be able to hack it in private practice. For what it's worth I think this perception is very unfair. There are lots of very hardworking, talented lawyers there, many of whom trained and worked in top law firms beforehand. Again, this will depend massively on what job you are doing. So for example, when I worked there I was doing a general commercial role with a specialism in EU law issues, which was actually pretty valuable to private sector employers. I didn't have any problems getting out again when I wanted to. And my former boss is now head of public sector law at one of the Big 4. So it is possible. But it can be very hard.

I also hear that morale has taken a real nose dive in the last few years.

Theluggage15 · 07/05/2023 20:08

UsingChangeofName · 07/05/2023 20:05

Why do you think a nurses salary is relevant to this question?

Because the question is "do you think this salary is reasonable or am I being greedy", which makes this poster's reply perfectly reasonable and relevant.

(and I'm not a nurse)

Reasonable for law not totally unrelated jobs. Bloody hell.

Catslave67 · 07/05/2023 20:05

Speak to a head hunter/recruiter and take their advice as they know the market. Having previously worked for two big Birmingham firms I would say this is low but as has been said before on this you need to move to make a big jump in salary or at least get an offer and tell your firm you’re going to leave but could be persuaded if they match it. All those saying I am a teacher or watcher and can only dream of earning that, it’s irrelevant- she wants like for like comparisons. And no, you’re not greedy, you want what you’re worth!

UsingChangeofName · 07/05/2023 20:05

Why do you think a nurses salary is relevant to this question?

Because the question is "do you think this salary is reasonable or am I being greedy", which makes this poster's reply perfectly reasonable and relevant.

(and I'm not a nurse)

BounceyB · 07/05/2023 20:04

I was surprised when I went into law that not everyone was paid a lot and had time to mess around with just one case (how it always seems when I watched LA Law). By the time I left, 15 years ago, I was working at a mid-sized law firm in London suburbs, clinical negligence law, the pay was £50k. But it was also close to where I lived and although I worked hard I also had time for hobbies. I think you have to be careful as some places have a really brutal work culture.

Stripedbag101 · 07/05/2023 20:01

Fluff3 · 07/05/2023 18:21

62k, I can only wish for that sort of wage as nurse with a bety stressful job. You dont know how lucky you are.

Why do you think a nurses salary is relevant to this question?

Coffeetree · 07/05/2023 19:56

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 19:02

Yep, at her level and specialising in commercial law she could easily go in house and earn more than she is currently getting paid, for a job which will probably be 9-6 most days. Or if she got a Grade 6 role in the Government Legal Department she could earn the same but get a much more valuable pension. (I don't particularly recommend this though.)

Why don't you recommend GDL?

Messenger123 · 07/05/2023 19:50

£62k and you live in Birmingham. Fuck me you’re rich!

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 19:45

UsingChangeofName · 07/05/2023 19:35

This is my thinking, too.

62k is barely over 50k?

Were you away when they did maths ?

The irony of people making irrelevant comparisons to completely unrelated careers implying that the OP is thick...

blondieminx · 07/05/2023 19:43

YANBU to want to be paid market rate for your skills and experience. Best way of working out what that is, is to chat to a couple of recruiters and then make a plan to like up some interviews if the conclusion is your current salary is below current market rates. Good luck!

your question was about whether that figure is reasonable for your level of PQE in that area of the U.K… so people coming on to offer whataboutery in relation to salaries for other jobs are just irrelevant.

UsingChangeofName · 07/05/2023 19:35

Bovrilla · 06/05/2023 16:49

Well you get paid more than any standard teacher, nurse or Doctor with degrees and postgraduates for teachers and doctors at the same age so maybe yes YABU

This is my thinking, too.

62k is barely over 50k?

Were you away when they did maths ?