Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if you think this salary is reasonable or am I being greedy?

437 replies

bkyegres · 06/05/2023 16:47

I qualified as a solicitor in 2016, so I’m around 7 years pqe. I’m paid 62k in Bham, commercial rather than private client work. I’ve only just paid off my student loan last year and honestly I feel like the firm are taking the piss… all the studying and expense feels ridiculous to be seven years on and barely over 50k. Obviously I know what some other firms pay and I can look into it further with recruiters but I am starting to wonder if you have to join a new company for any decent pay these days?! I could have skipped uni and worked my way up to this salary by now so it all seems a bit pointless.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 17:06

ggtown37 · 08/05/2023 17:02

Hecate01
No need to be so rude and disrespectful.

You can't blame people for getting a bit exasperated with the 100th person to come on this thread and tell the OP she's greedy for wanting to be paid market rate for her actual job as a solicitor because you are a nurse/teacher/all round good egg and you get paid less.

If you don't have anything relevant to say, this thread is not for you.

And how much you get paid as a nurse is not relevant.

ggtown37 · 08/05/2023 17:02

Hecate01
No need to be so rude and disrespectful.

Hecate01 · 08/05/2023 16:51

ggtown37 · 08/05/2023 16:29

I qualified 40 years ago as a nurse, have a BSc, MSc and post grad dip and earn £45000 and work in an Emergency Department. Yes you are greedy

Well you should have gone to law school not med school.

Gingerstars · 08/05/2023 16:51

Hi silly. So you are basically saying someone who earns more than a teacher shouldn’t be supported and that all workers no matter what job should receive equal pay?

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 16:50

Namechanger355 · 08/05/2023 12:49

so you don’t know the numbers but think less should be spent… ok

and you clearly have no reason why we make overseas aid payments (for global stability where instability which could impact everything for one thing- rather than just being kind), asylum (because they are people and we have legal obligations) and defence (well in this day and age doesn’t that make sense)

I'm not sure I appreciate your condescending tone.
Please do not presume what I do or do not know.
I summarise on here as I'm extremely busy, and don't really have spare time to talk to someone who seems hell bent on trying to argue.
I'm fully aware of the need to spend in certain areas.
I, along with many people, believe the amounts we spend far exceed what is necessary.
Especially with the cost of lining crisis here.
I've no interest in talking to someone who seems to think they know I know nothing 🙄
Good bye👋

TiredOfCleaning · 08/05/2023 16:49

ggtown37 · 08/05/2023 16:29

I qualified 40 years ago as a nurse, have a BSc, MSc and post grad dip and earn £45000 and work in an Emergency Department. Yes you are greedy

But the Op is not a nurse. In fact she works in a completely different sector in a completely different role. Where the base rates and comparable rates are .... different.

Your salary, with respect... and despite the fact you are undoubtedly doing a very good and important and massively valuable job....is irrelevant. If you are not happy with your salary then that is another matter and one to consider for yourself related to your circumstances.

ggtown37 · 08/05/2023 16:29

I qualified 40 years ago as a nurse, have a BSc, MSc and post grad dip and earn £45000 and work in an Emergency Department. Yes you are greedy

MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 14:49

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 12:35

If you're trying to win a debate, I'm not really interested in getting in to that. Happy to give that one too you to be fair.
I honestly do not know exactly how much we spend abroad, but it is in the billions.
Military, asylum, overseas aid, etc. - you know exactly what we spend and what on, else you wouldn't be questioning me on that.
I also think those on benefits who are able to work should do some form of community service to 'earn' the money they're given.
I know way too many who work the system and sit on their lazy backsides, living on the hard earned cash of everyone who contributes to this country.
Of course, if someone is physically unable to work, then they need help. But way too many are able to work, they just don't want to.
What we give out to benefit cheats is astounding, and what we spend catching them is more so.
A huge could be saved there if the Govt did something about this. It is easy too easy to claim when you're not actually entitled to anything.
Anyway, I went off on another tangent there, and we could do this all day, but I'm happy to leave it here.
Have a great bank holiday Monday.

Herein lies the problem.

The people who want us to magically find the money for a pay rise for doctors and nurses and teachers without raising taxes tend to believe that there are massive sums of money being spent on entirely optional and unnecessary things and that all we have to do to raise extra cash is stop spending money on these things.

That isn't the case.

Each year you should receive a statement of the tax you paid in the last tax year. When you receive your next one, look at the back of it. There's a pie chart detailing what your taxes get spent on. The biggest categories, if I remember correctly, are pensions and benefits, followed by health. Foreign aid spending is so minimal that it barely features. Even contributions to the EU budget - famously hundreds of millions per week - were such a small amount that it was barely worth worrying about, regardless of whether you believed we were getting value for money from our membership. And since Brexit the UK's credit rating has been downgraded, meaning that the amount we spend on national debt interest (a much bigger category) has increased.

There is no magic money tree. If you want to pay nurses more, you need to pay more taxes.

Namechanger355 · 08/05/2023 12:49

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 12:35

If you're trying to win a debate, I'm not really interested in getting in to that. Happy to give that one too you to be fair.
I honestly do not know exactly how much we spend abroad, but it is in the billions.
Military, asylum, overseas aid, etc. - you know exactly what we spend and what on, else you wouldn't be questioning me on that.
I also think those on benefits who are able to work should do some form of community service to 'earn' the money they're given.
I know way too many who work the system and sit on their lazy backsides, living on the hard earned cash of everyone who contributes to this country.
Of course, if someone is physically unable to work, then they need help. But way too many are able to work, they just don't want to.
What we give out to benefit cheats is astounding, and what we spend catching them is more so.
A huge could be saved there if the Govt did something about this. It is easy too easy to claim when you're not actually entitled to anything.
Anyway, I went off on another tangent there, and we could do this all day, but I'm happy to leave it here.
Have a great bank holiday Monday.

so you don’t know the numbers but think less should be spent… ok

and you clearly have no reason why we make overseas aid payments (for global stability where instability which could impact everything for one thing- rather than just being kind), asylum (because they are people and we have legal obligations) and defence (well in this day and age doesn’t that make sense)

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 12:35

MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 12:04

How much do you think we "spend abroad", out of interest, and on what?

If you're trying to win a debate, I'm not really interested in getting in to that. Happy to give that one too you to be fair.
I honestly do not know exactly how much we spend abroad, but it is in the billions.
Military, asylum, overseas aid, etc. - you know exactly what we spend and what on, else you wouldn't be questioning me on that.
I also think those on benefits who are able to work should do some form of community service to 'earn' the money they're given.
I know way too many who work the system and sit on their lazy backsides, living on the hard earned cash of everyone who contributes to this country.
Of course, if someone is physically unable to work, then they need help. But way too many are able to work, they just don't want to.
What we give out to benefit cheats is astounding, and what we spend catching them is more so.
A huge could be saved there if the Govt did something about this. It is easy too easy to claim when you're not actually entitled to anything.
Anyway, I went off on another tangent there, and we could do this all day, but I'm happy to leave it here.
Have a great bank holiday Monday.

Insideallday · 08/05/2023 12:19

Posters are comparing apples and oranges.

whether posters would love 62k salary is irrelevant.

As another poster said, check the industry standard.

MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 12:04

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 11:39

No, I did not say that.
Can you see anywhere where I've said that?
Given I'm self employed, I can only ask myself for a pay increase 😅
I said if I wasn't happy with my salary, I would move to another company.
Which I did, I decided to work for myself.
However, I do not believe that taxes or NI should be increased either.
As I'm self employed, as is my husband, we are crippled by these as it is, and I'd be deeply unhappy if they were increased.
OP is in a position where she can and most probably will be able to find much better pay, whereas emergency services cannot if they want higher pay.
But from another angle, they do know wages before they decide to enter their chosen field, so it is hard to justify all the strikes.
When there is no money in the pot so to speak, where do they think the extra is coming from.
Without raising taxes / NI, there is no money for these pay increases being demanded without raising the cost of living even further, making any pay increase minimal.
I do think we should stop spending so much abroad, and concentrate on the cost of living crisis here.
We need to look after our own first and foremost, and that isn't happening.
Unless you're extremely high up in Govt, don't even get me started on their wages and perks!

How much do you think we "spend abroad", out of interest, and on what?

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 11:39

MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 10:47

So do you think that people like the OP should be happy to be paid less than other people doing the same job as her because there is no money to increase your salary?

No, I did not say that.
Can you see anywhere where I've said that?
Given I'm self employed, I can only ask myself for a pay increase 😅
I said if I wasn't happy with my salary, I would move to another company.
Which I did, I decided to work for myself.
However, I do not believe that taxes or NI should be increased either.
As I'm self employed, as is my husband, we are crippled by these as it is, and I'd be deeply unhappy if they were increased.
OP is in a position where she can and most probably will be able to find much better pay, whereas emergency services cannot if they want higher pay.
But from another angle, they do know wages before they decide to enter their chosen field, so it is hard to justify all the strikes.
When there is no money in the pot so to speak, where do they think the extra is coming from.
Without raising taxes / NI, there is no money for these pay increases being demanded without raising the cost of living even further, making any pay increase minimal.
I do think we should stop spending so much abroad, and concentrate on the cost of living crisis here.
We need to look after our own first and foremost, and that isn't happening.
Unless you're extremely high up in Govt, don't even get me started on their wages and perks!

MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 10:47

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 10:38

I know.
There is no money.
I'd rather they didn't put taxes up either.

So do you think that people like the OP should be happy to be paid less than other people doing the same job as her because there is no money to increase your salary?

NatM70 · 08/05/2023 10:38

MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 07:32

I'm not denying that they do valuable work and should be fairly paid for it. Like many other people working in the public sector.

But where is the money going to come from?

People like the OP are already taxed to the hilt.

I know.
There is no money.
I'd rather they didn't put taxes up either.

JenWillsiam · 08/05/2023 09:14

Fluff3 · 07/05/2023 18:21

62k, I can only wish for that sort of wage as nurse with a bety stressful job. You dont know how lucky you are.

Why didn’t you train as a lawyer then?

or how about this, when you’re striking if the cleaner turned up and said you can’t earn more because I don’t would that be ok?

JenWillsiam · 08/05/2023 09:12

Stealthfart · 07/05/2023 21:04

It’s a shame the op has vanished. I’m more interested to know if she realises the dismissive ‘barely over £50k’ £12,000 can actually be a full salary for a lot of people? Made me feel uncomfortable anyway.

No it cannot. 12000 would be less than minimum wage if full time.

Coffeetree · 08/05/2023 08:41

Stripedbag101 · 07/05/2023 21:44

OP made this comment about a world where her peers probably earn £80-100k. In that context her salary is close to £50k and clearly not what she expected to be earning.

£12k would be a part time salary - even at minimum wage.

this thread demonstrates why women don’t negotiate bigger salaries - they are shamed and made to think about people earning less. The relevance of salaries earning by people in completely different industries with completely difference qualifications, skill sets and experience is zero.

Amen!

kasho5 · 08/05/2023 07:38

I’ve always found that you need to leave to get a decent pay rise - employers will give you inflation rises but not one that keeps up with the job market

MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 07:32

NatM70 · 07/05/2023 22:32

Just because they do the grunt work, doesn't mean they're not highly qualified?

I didn't say they should be paid the same?
But given they are the backbone, and with the hours they put in, I think they deserve more than they're paid.

And no, I'm not a nurse.

I'm not denying that they do valuable work and should be fairly paid for it. Like many other people working in the public sector.

But where is the money going to come from?

People like the OP are already taxed to the hilt.

Mumofsons87 · 08/05/2023 06:40

I qualified in science 7 years ago and started off on a rubbish €28k (as I got the job before my exams finished!) and now after 2 promotions I am earning 67k as a senior Engineer . Have you had any promotions in that time? It's hard to work up on yearly increases alone of say 2% you will never get anywhere different as inflation will always out pace the increase. You need to move roles or companies to negotiate. I've also once rejected a 4% pay increase before with the tag line 4% of nothing is nothing and I wanted to be brought up to the rest of the team, so rejection went in and I got a 15% increase up to the benchmark. You can do it!!!!

Also for all the teachers, I don't think it's fair to compare like for like. Look at the hourly rate of the hours worked and you will get a good comparison of rates.
I work 44hours a week 45.6 weeks of the year so 2006 hours a year so that works out at €33 per actual hour worked. Her in ROI primary teachers only work about 900 hours (thats including plenty of extra time) a year and earn about €49k after 7 years which works out at €54 per hour worked. So 40% more than me per hour worked. It's really not like for like.

Dibbydoos · 08/05/2023 05:53

So that's c£3620 take home? It's only reasonable if it's in the benchmark for your job and experience. Obviously, many other professions pay less to people with better qualifications than you and some pay more to people with no quals but talent in their field eg IT sales.

So go benchmark don't come here asking questions cos you'll get roasted!!!

Toomuchtrouble4me · 07/05/2023 23:34

Yes, terrible salary. Move companies.

pteradactyl · 07/05/2023 23:06

Can anyone else smell something? I think I might have caught a whiff of a humble brag

Stripedbag101 · 07/05/2023 22:50

HuffPuffBosomHoik · 07/05/2023 22:37

I think there may be a few little typos in your post, so I'm not 100% sure what it is you're saying.... However, I'm perfectly happy thanks 😊

But the op isn't, despite earning a lot more than I do. She was asking our opinions about this - I categorically didn't ask for yours or for your advice. Hope that clarifies.

Sorry yes on my phone. What I was saying was you earn close to minimum wage. You aren’t typical for a graduate - certainly not
one from I assume Oxford or Cambridge.

your personal experience is therefore unlikely to be relevant to OP as he/she is clearly driven by money (like many of us) and you are not.

yes there will be a lot of people who earn a lot less than OP who have degrees - but there will also be people who earn significantly more. You have chosen one path in thousands and therefore your experience doesn’t not mean OP couldn’t have earned more i a different profession - which she clealry could have.

Swipe left for the next trending thread