Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Camilla should not have been crowned Queen

612 replies

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:38

She should have been Princess Consort as we were told she would be. Instead the usual airbrushing of history to try and make her acceptable by clever spinning. And positive press. Bit sickening since Edward VIII had to abdicate over marrying a divorced woman.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
JenWillsiam · 06/05/2023 23:26

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:54

Charles is a widower so is free to marry in the eyes of the church. Camilla isn't.

What are you talking about? He divorced Diana.

SnackSizeRaisin · 06/05/2023 23:26

Robinni · 06/05/2023 23:14

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

We can agree to disagree. I’m not in favour of punishing anyone or standing lording over morality. As I said I wish them well as a couple.

But what is clear is that when faced with putting himself first or the U.K. and commonwealth first Charles made his decision.

not really sure what you are implying but it's obvious to me that charles thinks he is serving the uk and commonwealth by being king. Abdicating without good grounds, such as a limiting health condition, would be an extremely selfish move

Robinni · 06/05/2023 23:23

Ha yes @Ponoka7 I saw pics of the well placed hat in the news and thought the same.

Differences aside, enjoy the weekend and bank hol.

Goodnight all.

AskMeMore · 06/05/2023 23:21

There is zero acceptance of mistakes from Camilla and Charles. They lie and pretend they did not start their affair until the marriage between Charles and Diana had fallen apart.
Being rich and famous buys you a lot of get out clauses.

Ponoka7 · 06/05/2023 23:20

I think people need to stop looking at William and Kate through rose coloured glasses. They did very little until H&M marriage etc. They can't talk off script. William's facial expressions go from boredom to inappropriate. Camilla was very natural today. She was often trying to stifle nervous laughter. It was nice to see the genuine affection and love between them. They chatted normally. Camilla's grandsons were like any other children. The only issue for me was Andrew in regal robes. I did wonder if the feather on Anne's hat was carefully placed to cover Harry's face at all times.

mixedrecycling · 06/05/2023 23:19

Serenster · 06/05/2023 23:04

James I&VI's wife, Anne of Denmark, always refused to confirm whether she was or wasn't catholic, but I think sat out the coronation

She was crowned as Queen of England, having already been crowned as Queen of Scotland, but refused to take the communion at the (Protestant) service. I guess we’d call that playing her cards close to her chest? 😀

She certainly did 😂brought up Calvinist, apparently, then never appeared at a Protestant communion after a certain point... James was pretty good at playing the sides against the middle as well, implying to English Catholics that he would be sympathetic to them if he got the English crown after QE1, but also allowing the English Protestants he was a good, clean living Protestant...

mixedrecycling · 06/05/2023 23:17

Robinni · 06/05/2023 22:38

I wonder what precipitated the change in Church of England law at the particular point 🤔 Very convenient.

I think an acceptance that, out of pastoral concern for people, it needed to accept that people make mistakes and should not be punished for them life long. That staying in an unhappy marriage is not healthy, and God wants people to be healthy.

That it is better for someone whose marriage has failed not to be faced with the choice of lifelong celibacy or adultery, with no possibility of learning from their mistakes and go on to a more positive married relationship. That any sins and moral failings are between the individual and God, and will be forgiven by God if sincerely repented.

Just a few ideas why the CofE might have changed its stance. I don't think clergy respond to requests for a marriage service (whether first of second) without asking the couple a few questions about their relationship, and encouraging them to think through the meaning of a Church wedding. Although maybe more of an expectation of permitting a first marriage between people in their own parish, as they are the Established Church (which places certain requirements on them, such as having to allow any parishonner to attend for the purpose of worship).

Robinni · 06/05/2023 23:14

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 23:08

I think abdication would have been a bit more dignified and better for the monarchy.

That's absolutely crazy. Abdication is a very very big deal, extremely destabilising and often seen as an enormous snub to the country. Abdicating because he had a single affair with a woman who's now been married to him longer than his first wife, when the first marriage was miserable and the wife had affairs too? And has now been dead for over 20 years?

Affairs are wrong but you can't start twisting every part of life to punish people for them. Like I said, punishing people for affairs isn't actually a forward step or a moral act itself.

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

We can agree to disagree. I’m not in favour of punishing anyone or standing lording over morality. As I said I wish them well as a couple.

But what is clear is that when faced with putting himself first or the U.K. and commonwealth first Charles made his decision.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 23:08

Robinni · 06/05/2023 22:59

I understand they are King and Queen. I’m not arguing per se that they shouldn’t be. Just that I don’t like the situation and I think abdication would have been a bit more dignified and better for the monarchy.

I can’t see Camilla and not think of all the headlines that were written… it’s too closely associated with her for me.

They are very unapologetic and a bit shameless. But then they have money and power so can do what they want.

I think abdication would have been a bit more dignified and better for the monarchy.

That's absolutely crazy. Abdication is a very very big deal, extremely destabilising and often seen as an enormous snub to the country. Abdicating because he had a single affair with a woman who's now been married to him longer than his first wife, when the first marriage was miserable and the wife had affairs too? And has now been dead for over 20 years?

Affairs are wrong but you can't start twisting every part of life to punish people for them. Like I said, punishing people for affairs isn't actually a forward step or a moral act itself.

Bovrilla · 06/05/2023 23:07

Some people are way, way too overinvested in this.

No matter what the past held, it needs putting to bed. QE2 was happy with them. They are happy and clearly a far, far better match and relationship.

They have managed to blend their families pretty well. It's far more representative or modern day Britain than the holier than thou expectations of the past.

Maybe it marks a turning point, where the royal family actually are just a bit more.....normal. I can't see this is a bad thing? I'm not a strident royalist but everyone I know who has met and worked with them raves about Charles as a really genuine, affable man and Camilla as down to earth, funny and relatable.

I'd far rather that for our future.

Serenster · 06/05/2023 23:04

James I&VI's wife, Anne of Denmark, always refused to confirm whether she was or wasn't catholic, but I think sat out the coronation

She was crowned as Queen of England, having already been crowned as Queen of Scotland, but refused to take the communion at the (Protestant) service. I guess we’d call that playing her cards close to her chest? 😀

Robinni · 06/05/2023 22:59

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 22:52

So we should all do it and say affairs are wonderful and getting divorced tremendous.

And this is why you can't have an intelligent conversation about this with some people.

Nobody has said affairs are wonderful and getting divorced is tremendous. We are saying that having an affair isn't an impediment to being head of the C of E, as evidenced by the fact that a serial and open adulterer founded it. Most of us would also say it's better to get divorced if you're both absolutely miserable, as C & D were.

And while ideally C & C would not have had an affair, the fact remains that Charles and Diana were a terrible match, both unfaithful, both unhappy, and Camilla has now been married to him longer than Diana was. It's clearly the better relationship.

It's not condoning the affair to say that there's nothing to gain by attempting to rewrite the laws of marriage and monarchy in an attempt to punish them for it 40 years later. They were free to marry, they married, the rule is that a king's wife is queen. It's not personal, it's not a comment on their private lives, it's just the law.

I understand they are King and Queen. I’m not arguing per se that they shouldn’t be. Just that I don’t like the situation and I think abdication would have been a bit more dignified and better for the monarchy.

I can’t see Camilla and not think of all the headlines that were written… it’s too closely associated with her for me.

They are very unapologetic and a bit shameless. But then they have money and power so can do what they want.

mixedrecycling · 06/05/2023 22:58

IcedPurple · 06/05/2023 18:43

Who are these Catholic queens?

Being married to a Catholic automatically excludes someone from becoming King or Queen.

That was from the Act of Settlement in 1701.

Prior to that Charles I, Charles II and James II all had catholic wives.

James I&VI's wife, Anne of Denmark, always refused to confirm whether she was or wasn't catholic, but I think sat out the coronation.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 22:52

Robinni · 06/05/2023 22:45

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

So we should all do it and say affairs are wonderful and getting divorced tremendous.

Like saying to kids don’t worry when you get married you don’t need to try to work at it, you can totally disrespect your spouse, and in fact go around shagging other people. Then you can put your marriage in the bin because let’s face it, you couldn’t be bothered anyway!

Sorry but that’s the example sitting on the throne right there.

More positively you could look at it like love finds a way, and you can totally cock up your life and be redeemed.

I do think people need to have more accountability for poor behaviour.

So we should all do it and say affairs are wonderful and getting divorced tremendous.

And this is why you can't have an intelligent conversation about this with some people.

Nobody has said affairs are wonderful and getting divorced is tremendous. We are saying that having an affair isn't an impediment to being head of the C of E, as evidenced by the fact that a serial and open adulterer founded it. Most of us would also say it's better to get divorced if you're both absolutely miserable, as C & D were.

And while ideally C & C would not have had an affair, the fact remains that Charles and Diana were a terrible match, both unfaithful, both unhappy, and Camilla has now been married to him longer than Diana was. It's clearly the better relationship.

It's not condoning the affair to say that there's nothing to gain by attempting to rewrite the laws of marriage and monarchy in an attempt to punish them for it 40 years later. They were free to marry, they married, the rule is that a king's wife is queen. It's not personal, it's not a comment on their private lives, it's just the law.

Rosula · 06/05/2023 22:48

BlueAndGreen89 · 06/05/2023 22:25

Camilla fans are out in force 😂
The whole thing is bullshit to be fair.

Or maybe just people who are baffled by the unconstitutional notion that the king's wife should not be queen.

Macaroni46 · 06/05/2023 22:48

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:45

Its not only the fact she is divorced. She was Charles's mistress for many years. Never gave his marriage a chance. Lets whotewash all that.

Oh get over yourself. Neither were allowed to marry who they really wanted to. Affairs happen. They clearly love each other.

CabernetSauvignon · 06/05/2023 22:46

SnackSizeRaisin · 06/05/2023 22:29

To be fair, seatbelts were not as widely worn in the 90s. It was normal to put 6 kids loose in the back seat etc. It wouldn't be seen as reckless like nowadays. Guessing you're too young to remember the 90s

It really wasn't. We were using seatbelts for our children in the back of the car in the 1980s. The law requiring adults to wear seatbelts in the back of cars came in in 1991. In France, where Diana died, seatbelts had been compulsory since 1979.

Robinni · 06/05/2023 22:45

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 22:36

We’ve been over this in another thread that Henry VIII set up the COE in order that he could divorce Catherine of Aragon to pursue marriage with Anne Boleyn and to stop money being diverted to Rome.

Yes, I know. And he was a blatant serial adulterer whose mistresses included married women, judicial murderer and all-round arsehole. The point is: being an adulterer, even a blatant one, is no impediment to being head of the COE and remarrying. It was literally invented so an adulterer could head it and remarry while his first wife still lived.

Besides, surely we can have better standards in 2023 than the 1500s.

What, in marriages and sexual and romantic relationships? We're not going to have that one ironed out even if we wait another 500 years. Besides, it wouldn't actually be a forward step to start punishing divorced people and those who have had affairs.

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

So we should all do it and say affairs are wonderful and getting divorced tremendous.

Like saying to kids don’t worry when you get married you don’t need to try to work at it, you can totally disrespect your spouse, and in fact go around shagging other people. Then you can put your marriage in the bin because let’s face it, you couldn’t be bothered anyway!

Sorry but that’s the example sitting on the throne right there.

More positively you could look at it like love finds a way, and you can totally cock up your life and be redeemed.

I do think people need to have more accountability for poor behaviour.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 22:45

I thought she looked vv smug but that’s by the by

How do you ride in a state coach and be crowned Queen with a priceless crown and not look smug?

Inkpotlover · 06/05/2023 22:44

BlueAndGreen89 · 06/05/2023 22:25

Camilla fans are out in force 😂
The whole thing is bullshit to be fair.

I'm not a fan per se, I just don't understand the vitriol towards a couple who have now been lawfully and happily married for 18 years and some of the comments on MN today about her appearance are frankly disgusting.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 22:43

Robinni · 06/05/2023 22:38

I wonder what precipitated the change in Church of England law at the particular point 🤔 Very convenient.

But C&C didn't marry in a church? They just had a blessing, I thought?

Although if that was the catalyst for change, fine. It was an outdated concept and if it took a high profile, significant case to get it changed so everyone could benefit, great.

Serenster · 06/05/2023 22:43

I wonder what precipitated the change in Church of England law at the particular point 🤔 Very convenient.

Not for Charles. He and Camilla didn’t get married until a few years after the law change and they didn’t have a church wedding in any event. They got married in the Windsor Registry Office then had a blessing in St George’s Chapel at Windsor Castle.

Kickingupmerrybehaviour · 06/05/2023 22:42

I thought she looked vv smug but that’s by the by. Yes she should have been crowned. If we’re accepting him as king it’s only right.
I don’t think Harry should have been three rows back or whatever it was though.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 06/05/2023 22:40

BlueAndGreen89 · 06/05/2023 22:25

Camilla fans are out in force 😂
The whole thing is bullshit to be fair.

Er, the entire point is that it doesn't matter if you're a fan of hers or not; she's queen and she should be because we have a system in place and that's how it works.

A thread saying she shouldn't be queen is naturally going to draw people who understand why she should be (or rather, why she is) and can explain it.

Robinni · 06/05/2023 22:40

IcedPurple · 06/05/2023 22:35

He wasn't stopped from marrying Camilla. Their relationship just wasn't that serious at the time.

Didn’t she decide to marry TPB and that was the nail in the coffin?