Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Camilla should not have been crowned Queen

612 replies

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:38

She should have been Princess Consort as we were told she would be. Instead the usual airbrushing of history to try and make her acceptable by clever spinning. And positive press. Bit sickening since Edward VIII had to abdicate over marrying a divorced woman.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Inkpotlover · 07/05/2023 09:37

Riverlee · 07/05/2023 09:12

I also think that in the months leading up to her death, people were loosing favour with Diana. She was beginning to live a celebrity lifestyle, lots of holidays, glitz and glamour, and people were getting fed up of it. Her untimely death catapulted her into a Saint. Yes, she did do good stuff - AIDS sufferer, landmines come to mind, but had she lived, I think we may have a different image of her. Her halo was beginning to slip.

I agree, people do have short memories. People were really sympathetic towards Diana after the Martin Bashir interview but it waned after the divorce came through and by the time of her death, when she flitting around the globe on holiday, the mood was far less supportive. It was almost as if the public resented her flourishing, stoked by the racist tabloids who hated the fact she was dating Dodi F.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 09:37

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

Are you always so very literal?

Yes.

This makes no sense.

With power you can do what you want. With no power and reliant on public good will, their perception of you matters more in relation to the survival of monarchy.

Look at the PR machine they have going. It matters.

Who's he competing with?

Those who would wish to abolish the monarchy, have republic/no figurehead/commonwealth.

And like I said before, punishing people for sexual indiscretion (where consensual and between adults) is never a liberal step.

So we all have to be liberal now?

Don’t think they should be punished. Just think they ought to have stepped aside.

I don’t fancy celebrating and revering people whose behaviour is totally out of line with my beliefs/morality, I find it abhorrent. I’m sorry, but that is my opinion.

IcedPurple · 07/05/2023 09:30

Robinni · 07/05/2023 09:20

Obviously it’s voluntary, but no less important.

I disagree, Australia and many others wanting to go and not wanting a Royal as figurehead.

NZ, Australia and other overseas realms may wellsoon choose to become republics and no longer have the British monarch as HoS.

However, I doubt they would leave the Commonwealth. Of course, if they do, they can leave any time they want. It's a voluntary organisation.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 07/05/2023 09:28

@MargotBamborough

Absolutely. People fell in love with her beauty, mainly.

Was I the only heterosexual man of about her age who didn't think Diana was that fanciable? I felt sorry for her from the moment she appeared on the scene, but to me she appeared a bland, milk-faced posh girl that you wouldn't particularly notice in a wine bar along the King's Road.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 09:23

Robinni · 07/05/2023 09:13

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

You’re saying “you have to let it go”, “you have to accept it”… says who? You’re trying to domineer and force me to agree and I don’t.

I’m not disputing the actions of Henry VIII.

But I think it’s Poppycock to compare his role as a Monarch with Charles in the modern day.

Henry VIII had absolute power, he established and expanded Empire.

Charles is a figurehead for the country internationally, has no power and has to grapple with the remnants of the Commonwealth and keeping it all together.

In short it did not matter a shit what Henry VIII did personally because he still had power, popularity wasn’t in it.

Charles’ sway over the commonwealth is a popularity contest. If people don’t believe in or like the monarchy, they are more inclined to get rid of them.

Getting rid of Henry VIII wasn’t happening now was it?

The context is entirely different.

You’re saying “you have to let it go”, “you have to accept it”… says who?

No, I said you didn't have to accept it but that didn't make it any less true. "You have to let it go" is just a turn of phrase meaning there's no point hanging on to a 40 year old affair that's now come as good as possible and has nothing to do with you. Are you always so very literal?

In short it did not matter a shit what Henry VIII did personally because he still had power, popularity wasn’t in it.

This makes no sense. If Henry VIII had power then it mattered very much what he did personally. He changed the state religion and government to suit what he did personally. If Charles has none then he's the one whose personal life doesn't matter.

Charles’ sway over the commonwealth is a popularity contest.

Who's he competing with?

The context is entirely different.

The rules of the church are the same regarding whether a man who was once unfaithful to his wife can head it up. And like I said before, punishing people for sexual indiscretion (where consensual and between adults) is never a liberal step.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 09:20

MrsFinkelstein · 07/05/2023 09:12

"There was no internet/global media and the Empire/Commonwealth wasn’t falling apart…."

Again, this is a fundamental misunderstanding. The Commonwealth is nothing like the Empire. Its a voluntary association of nations. 14 of them are Commonwealth Realms - so have the King as Head of State. The other 40 are independent nations, many ofnthem have no colonial links to the UK. Commonwealth Realms are able to choose to become Republics, they can still remain Commonwealth States. Charles has said he agrees with their choice to become Republics.

The Commonwealth is growing, not falling apart.

Obviously it’s voluntary, but no less important.

I disagree, Australia and many others wanting to go and not wanting a Royal as figurehead.

Enko · 07/05/2023 09:15

Riverlee · 07/05/2023 09:12

I also think that in the months leading up to her death, people were loosing favour with Diana. She was beginning to live a celebrity lifestyle, lots of holidays, glitz and glamour, and people were getting fed up of it. Her untimely death catapulted her into a Saint. Yes, she did do good stuff - AIDS sufferer, landmines come to mind, but had she lived, I think we may have a different image of her. Her halo was beginning to slip.

I agree with this.

She also had very.good PR advisers where as Charles at the time didn't. That changed though imo and he has become.more aware on this area

Robinni · 07/05/2023 09:13

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 08:38

Why do you think that a disagreement amounts to trying to force you into anything? Are you trying to force me to agree with you?

You have your opinion, and it's based on a complete misunderstanding of what monarchy, marriage and the CoE are. You aren't obliged to change your opinion, but you can't expect people not to correct you on the facts about it. It's not, for example, "poppycock" that the CoE was founded by a blatant, serial adulterer and there's therefore no reason an adulterer can't head it.

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

You’re saying “you have to let it go”, “you have to accept it”… says who? You’re trying to domineer and force me to agree and I don’t.

I’m not disputing the actions of Henry VIII.

But I think it’s Poppycock to compare his role as a Monarch with Charles in the modern day.

Henry VIII had absolute power, he established and expanded Empire.

Charles is a figurehead for the country internationally, has no power and has to grapple with the remnants of the Commonwealth and keeping it all together.

In short it did not matter a shit what Henry VIII did personally because he still had power, popularity wasn’t in it.

Charles’ sway over the commonwealth is a popularity contest. If people don’t believe in or like the monarchy, they are more inclined to get rid of them.

Getting rid of Henry VIII wasn’t happening now was it?

The context is entirely different.

Riverlee · 07/05/2023 09:12

I also think that in the months leading up to her death, people were loosing favour with Diana. She was beginning to live a celebrity lifestyle, lots of holidays, glitz and glamour, and people were getting fed up of it. Her untimely death catapulted her into a Saint. Yes, she did do good stuff - AIDS sufferer, landmines come to mind, but had she lived, I think we may have a different image of her. Her halo was beginning to slip.

IcedPurple · 07/05/2023 09:12

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 09:10

Absolutely. People fell in love with her beauty, mainly.

I too have sometimes wondered what attitudes might be like if Diana and Sarah Ferguson's looks were 'reversed'.

Enko · 07/05/2023 09:12

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 20:07

Henry VIii had his marriages annulled.AFAIK.pope wouldn't allow him too annul or divorce Katherine so he started his own church.

Eleanor of Aquitaine annulled marriage (fiasco I agree)
George iv not sure.

So nothing has changed. Same old hypocrisy and rule bending.

Both Anne Boelyn and Jane Seymour were Henry's mistresses in an emotional (Jane at least) and Physical (Anne) form prior to their marriage to him. Jane was with him whilst Anne was executed. They got engaged 3 days after.

Many also miss

In 1532, Anne Boleyn became pregnant with the king's child. She was married to Henry on 25 January 1533 so that the baby could be a legitimate heir. Henry's marriage to Catherine of Aragon was finally annulled in the following May by Archbishop Cranmer, thus ending the first of Henry's 6 marriages (Wikipedia entry re Catherine of Aragon)

The Church of England became independent under King Henry VIII in 1534(Wikipedia entry re Church of England)

With Wallis she wasn't just divorced she was twice divorced. Earl Winfield Spencer Jr. (m. 1916; div. 1927)
Ernest Aldrich Simpson (m. 1928; div. 1937)
Prince Edward, Duke of Windsor
(m. 1937; died 1972)

She was also not well.liked and was not.felt.she would make a good queen.
Edward consulted with Stanley Baldwin (the PM) on a way to both marry Wallis and keep the throne. Edward suggested a morgannatic marriage in which he would remain king but Wallis would not be queen, and their children could not become the monarch. This was rejected.

Charles and Camilla however were not rejected my parlement or cofE they were permitted to marry in a register office and have a church blessing.

Hence yes she should be crowned and was crowned Queen. Personally I am happy they have moved forward.

MrsFinkelstein · 07/05/2023 09:12

"There was no internet/global media and the Empire/Commonwealth wasn’t falling apart…."

Again, this is a fundamental misunderstanding. The Commonwealth is nothing like the Empire. Its a voluntary association of nations. 14 of them are Commonwealth Realms - so have the King as Head of State. The other 40 are independent nations, many ofnthem have no colonial links to the UK. Commonwealth Realms are able to choose to become Republics, they can still remain Commonwealth States. Charles has said he agrees with their choice to become Republics.

The Commonwealth is growing, not falling apart.

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 09:10

JoanThursday1972 · 07/05/2023 09:07

I'm interested if there's be all this anger if Diana had looked like Princess Fiona? I do think that has a lot to do with it.

Absolutely. People fell in love with her beauty, mainly.

JoanThursday1972 · 07/05/2023 09:07

I'm interested if there's be all this anger if Diana had looked like Princess Fiona? I do think that has a lot to do with it.

JoanThursday1972 · 07/05/2023 09:03

@Panteranoir Was Kanga Charles's mistress or would girlfriend be the better description as wasn't this before he got married?

Panteranoir · 07/05/2023 09:00

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 08:12

You aren't required to like it. I suppose you can refuse to accept it but that won't make it any less true.

It's not "poppycock" - what exactly is your rebuttal? It's historical fact and it's literally the reason the CoE exists. If it was founded by an adulterer so he could place himself at the head of it, there's clearly no reason an adulterer can't be head of it.*

You say they're unpopular but the streets were thronged, the viewing rates were high and I couldn't get any coronation tat in the shops on Friday when the kids asked for it; it was all sold out. Besides, if you have a monarchy then the whole point is that it's not a popularity contest. You get who you're given. That's literally how it works.

  • And I think we would all agree that out of Henry VIII and Charles III, Charles is the "better" adulterer. He should have married Camilla from the start, she was his only mistress and now they've been married longer than Charles and Diana were. There comes a point where, while you might not ever like or approve of it, you just have to let it go.

The RF seem to have done a lot of media work on portraying the Charles and Camilla relationship as the love that could not be but eventually won through. Well Charles could have married Camilla early on but she at the point wasn't important enough to him to do that, the throne was. The greatest of all things to Charles was obviously not love.

There's also a documentary about his other mistress , an Australian lady, called Kanga.

The RF chose to drag a naive 19 year old into a life she was unprepared and ultimately unsuited for because she was a virgin. She was essentially a walking womb. It showed poor judgement on the part of the entire RF including the then queen.

It might sound like I'm a republican, I'm not. I don't think there's much real benefit to getting rid of the RF. And who would fill the void? Some awful celebrity?

It might sound like I'm a massive Diana fan, again I'm not. I did feel immensely sorry for her, she was just a tool to the RF and often seemed adrift in her own life.

Charles for me personally lacks gravitas, comes across as spoiled and cantankerous. In my opinion he massively lacks moral fibre if he could not fight for the woman he 'loved'. Also who can forget the tampon phone calls or the time he was caught on camera slagging Nicholas witchell off (a man just doing his job).

There's so much water under the bridge with this particular generation of the RF, and I think that is the crux of the matter. Charles being divorced is a complete red herring. if Anne was being crowned (herself divorced). I think she would enjoy much more universal respect. Whereas I don't think Charles will be a popular king.

JoanThursday1972 · 07/05/2023 08:52

However I also think the main reason Edward VIII had to abdicate was probably the fact he was a Nazi, and the divorcee bit was rather convenient.

Agree totally, I tried to say that earlier but not very well! They were both Nazi apologists but the fact that Wallis was divorced was a more palatable reason I suppose.

Inkpotlover · 07/05/2023 08:45

Robinni · 07/05/2023 08:22

@Inkpotlover can people not respect others opinions.

At a time of overpopulation and climate change causing issues with resources, and Europe having war… I do think cohesion - like the Commonwealth is important.

Anything that undermines that isn’t in everyone’s best interests.

You can respect an opinion while still questioning it!

I agree cohesion is important in world events but the Commonwealth is not ruled by the Monarchy beyond a figurehead sense and therefore it has no tangible impact on the governance that's needed to keep it together. So the King undermining it (which I don't agree with anyway) is a moot point in the overall scheme of things.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 08:42

Robinni · 07/05/2023 08:22

@Inkpotlover can people not respect others opinions.

At a time of overpopulation and climate change causing issues with resources, and Europe having war… I do think cohesion - like the Commonwealth is important.

Anything that undermines that isn’t in everyone’s best interests.

You're the one not respecting other's opinions! You described the historical fact of the CoE as "poppycock" (though you never explained why) and you think someone sharing a view you don't like is somehow disrespecting your view.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 08:38

Robinni · 07/05/2023 08:17

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

You cannot force me to come around to your way of thinking.

I have my opinion, you have yours.

Why do you think that a disagreement amounts to trying to force you into anything? Are you trying to force me to agree with you?

You have your opinion, and it's based on a complete misunderstanding of what monarchy, marriage and the CoE are. You aren't obliged to change your opinion, but you can't expect people not to correct you on the facts about it. It's not, for example, "poppycock" that the CoE was founded by a blatant, serial adulterer and there's therefore no reason an adulterer can't head it.

IcedPurple · 07/05/2023 08:30

Helpisneeded100 · 07/05/2023 00:08

She should not be crowned queen as she gaslight a very young women, ie Diana, trying to convince Diana she was not having an affair with her husband. It was beyond awful what Charles and Camilla did to Diana, they completely messed with her mental health but because he is a prince we are meant to go oh that ok then. If it happened to your daughter or your friend you would outraged!!! Anyone with any ethics would not expect Camilla to be crowned queen.

The only qualification for being Queen is being married to the King.

Camilla is the King's wife, therefore she is Queen.

katemulberrybush · 07/05/2023 08:26

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:54

Charles is a widower so is free to marry in the eyes of the church. Camilla isn't.

He is not a widower

katemulberrybush · 07/05/2023 08:24

Almost 90 years ago

The world has changed. A lot

Robinni · 07/05/2023 08:22

@Inkpotlover can people not respect others opinions.

At a time of overpopulation and climate change causing issues with resources, and Europe having war… I do think cohesion - like the Commonwealth is important.

Anything that undermines that isn’t in everyone’s best interests.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 08:17

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

You cannot force me to come around to your way of thinking.

I have my opinion, you have yours.