Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Camilla should not have been crowned Queen

612 replies

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:38

She should have been Princess Consort as we were told she would be. Instead the usual airbrushing of history to try and make her acceptable by clever spinning. And positive press. Bit sickening since Edward VIII had to abdicate over marrying a divorced woman.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 12:01

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:54

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

You win.

Charles and Camilla are wonderful.

We should all bow down and not question their being in the position they are in whatsoever. Because there are rules and it’s nothing personal.

Afterall, Henry VIII was adulterous so Charles should be too, he should carry on in this vein and apply everything done to Royal wives in the 1500s as standard practice. But that wouldn’t be right now would it.

I thought you wanted to stop engaging?

Afterall, Henry VIII was adulterous so Charles should be too

No dear, the founder of the CoE was adulterous so adultery isn't an impediment to heading it.

Can't even make sense of the rest of the stuff here. Doesn't correspond to anything anyone has said. You keep saying you don't want to engage so why are you engaging?

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 11:59

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:50

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

…… he is not becoming an investment banker……. It is not a job.

He is becoming Monarch which is a state of being, with constitutional and representational duties.

It’s massively important and he should have had this at the forefront of his mind all along.

His first wife did not have the same birthright or responsibility and only started having affairs following appalling treatment.

Anyway I do not wish to engage with this further or have my opinion talked down or dismissed.

It is how I personally feel, everyone else is entitled to their own opinion.

I thought you had decided there was no point in continuing this exchange?

He is becoming Monarch which is a state of being, with constitutional and representational duties.

Yes. That's why abdication isn't this easy, apolitical solution that you think it is. It's highly destabilising and would be seen as a huge rejection of the country. Given that no other king has ever had to abdicate over his former adultery (and I'm not sure if any other king ever made good with it as much as he has), there's no reason to do it. His affair was not honourable but it had context, it does not define his entire character and it's got nothing to do with his constitutional and representational duties.

Anyway I do not wish to engage with this further

So stop engaging.

*or have my opinion talked down or dismissed.

You're the one telling me my opinion is poppycock, bickering, babbling and ordering me to stop. Stop being so hypocritical.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:54

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 11:45

So don't engage. Stop responding.

You keep demanding that I must respect your opinion. Bur the only person accusing anyone of poppycock, babbling and bickering, and demanding silence, is you.

If you're tired of the exchange, just don't reply. It'll mean I get the last word, but surely that doesn't bother you?

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

You win.

Charles and Camilla are wonderful.

We should all bow down and not question their being in the position they are in whatsoever. Because there are rules and it’s nothing personal.

Afterall, Henry VIII was adulterous so Charles should be too, he should carry on in this vein and apply everything done to Royal wives in the 1500s as standard practice. But that wouldn’t be right now would it.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:50

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 11:28

I in no way prefer sexual oppression.

You literally want a man to lose his job and are judging his entire character in everything because he had an affair 40 years ago. His wife also had affairs because the marriage was miserable. He has since married his mistress, who was his first and real love, and they've lasted longer than the first marriage.

That's an oppressive attitude.

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

…… he is not becoming an investment banker……. It is not a job.

He is becoming Monarch which is a state of being, with constitutional and representational duties.

It’s massively important and he should have had this at the forefront of his mind all along.

His first wife did not have the same birthright or responsibility and only started having affairs following appalling treatment.

Anyway I do not wish to engage with this further or have my opinion talked down or dismissed.

It is how I personally feel, everyone else is entitled to their own opinion.

zingally · 07/05/2023 11:50

I'm not the biggest fan of her, but did laugh at how abrupt her crowning was.
He came at her with the crown, sideways, really quickly. She had this really funny "What?!? NOW?!" expression on her face.

I think she anticipated this slow, stately crowning - like Charles' - but hers was "oh, ere ya go." And it messed up her hair. ;)

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 11:45

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:40

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

What I’m saying is our opinions have been trotted out over countless posts.

Your position is very clear.

My position is very clear.

They are not going to change.

So I do not see the point in engaging in this back and forth contradicting and arguing. It’s going around in circles.

So don't engage. Stop responding.

You keep demanding that I must respect your opinion. Bur the only person accusing anyone of poppycock, babbling and bickering, and demanding silence, is you.

If you're tired of the exchange, just don't reply. It'll mean I get the last word, but surely that doesn't bother you?

DappledThings · 07/05/2023 11:41

AnnesObstructiveFeather · 07/05/2023 11:39

No Queen in British history has ever been officially referred to as 'Queen Consort'. They've always just been Her Majesty The Queen.

Except for Camilla, who was referred to as Camilla, Queen Consort ever since QEII’s death. Her title was Camilla, Queen Consort on the Royal website. Up until the coronation.

As were other Queens Consort in printed media prior to their coronations.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:40

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 11:25

Could you leave off and go and bicker with somebody else.

I could. Could you? Is it only bickering when others do it but you're just fine?

I took it literally because I am autistic and your babbling on is a bit incessant.

I was starting to think you might be, so thank you for confirming. Again, why are your lengthy responses just fine but mine are babbling?

The decent thing to do considering what is at stake and their colourful history would have been to step aside themselves to allow a more palatable couple next in line to take over.

Their history has nothing to do with the system in which they have a certain place. There's no inconsistency with an adulterous king and his former mistress, now wife, being crowned. Your view that they should be punished forever for it is not really relevant since the system isn't personal. As republicans often point out, it's literally hereditary so personal indiscretions don't come into it. And abdication isn't the easy and uncontroversial solution that you think it is.

But they’ve decided to press on with their own agenda shamelessly throughout because they are selfish people.

They've adhered completely to law, tradition and convention. If they were that self serving, they'd have married in the 1970s.

We differ in our opinion. I can respect yours, please respect mine.

You do not respect my opinion at all. You've called it bickering, babbling, and ordered that I stop. You simply want to speak and not be countered or contradicted. That is not what respecting opinions looks like.

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

What I’m saying is our opinions have been trotted out over countless posts.

Your position is very clear.

My position is very clear.

They are not going to change.

So I do not see the point in engaging in this back and forth contradicting and arguing. It’s going around in circles.

AnnesObstructiveFeather · 07/05/2023 11:39

No Queen in British history has ever been officially referred to as 'Queen Consort'. They've always just been Her Majesty The Queen.

Except for Camilla, who was referred to as Camilla, Queen Consort ever since QEII’s death. Her title was Camilla, Queen Consort on the Royal website. Up until the coronation.

DappledThings · 07/05/2023 11:34

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 11:24

The key phrase here being 'known as' - just like princess Kate. The Windsors obviously see a big difference.

If you really think that the late Queen's statement using the words "known as" meant that she wanted to over turn centuries of tradition and have Queen Consort used as the style 100% of the time rather than it being just the formal title used in the particular instance that's very silly. Queens Consort are known as that and as Queen Name. I'm pretty sure the Palace knew that

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 11:28

I in no way prefer sexual oppression.

You literally want a man to lose his job and are judging his entire character in everything because he had an affair 40 years ago. His wife also had affairs because the marriage was miserable. He has since married his mistress, who was his first and real love, and they've lasted longer than the first marriage.

That's an oppressive attitude.

DappledThings · 07/05/2023 11:28

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 11:24

The key phrase here being 'known as' - just like princess Kate. The Windsors obviously see a big difference.

What do you mean Princess Kate? There isn't a Princess Kate

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 11:25

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:09

Oh crikey @DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

Could you leave off and go and bicker with somebody else.

I took it literally because I am autistic and your babbling on is a bit incessant.

The survival of the monarchy long term is very much based on public opinion. We pay for them.

I prefer that people who are representing the country have strength of character and decency towards others. What Charles and Camilla did showed poor character and indecency.

The decent thing to do considering what is at stake and their colourful history would have been to step aside themselves to allow a more palatable couple next in line to take over.

That’s not the state punishing them. That’s them taking ownership of their transgressions and prioritising the U.K. and commonwealth. A voluntary decision.

But they’ve decided to press on with their own agenda shamelessly throughout because they are selfish people. Which was apparent when they conducted the affair in the first place. They want to be king and queen and all the money and status that comes with.

We differ in our opinion. I can respect yours, please respect mine.

Could you leave off and go and bicker with somebody else.

I could. Could you? Is it only bickering when others do it but you're just fine?

I took it literally because I am autistic and your babbling on is a bit incessant.

I was starting to think you might be, so thank you for confirming. Again, why are your lengthy responses just fine but mine are babbling?

The decent thing to do considering what is at stake and their colourful history would have been to step aside themselves to allow a more palatable couple next in line to take over.

Their history has nothing to do with the system in which they have a certain place. There's no inconsistency with an adulterous king and his former mistress, now wife, being crowned. Your view that they should be punished forever for it is not really relevant since the system isn't personal. As republicans often point out, it's literally hereditary so personal indiscretions don't come into it. And abdication isn't the easy and uncontroversial solution that you think it is.

But they’ve decided to press on with their own agenda shamelessly throughout because they are selfish people.

They've adhered completely to law, tradition and convention. If they were that self serving, they'd have married in the 1970s.

We differ in our opinion. I can respect yours, please respect mine.

You do not respect my opinion at all. You've called it bickering, babbling, and ordered that I stop. You simply want to speak and not be countered or contradicted. That is not what respecting opinions looks like.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 11:24

DappledThings · 07/05/2023 11:00

The wives of the last three kings, the Queeens Consort Alexandra, Mary and Elizabeth were known just as Queen Alexandra, Queen Mary and Queen Elizabeth. And were crowned. This just isn't a change or contradiction no matter how many try to argue it is

The key phrase here being 'known as' - just like princess Kate. The Windsors obviously see a big difference.

JenWillsiam · 07/05/2023 11:24

MargotBamborough · 07/05/2023 09:10

Absolutely. People fell in love with her beauty, mainly.

Only after she died.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 11:22

IcedPurple · 07/05/2023 10:47

Where does one find 'royal protocol' in order to check it? What is the written source for 'royal protocol'?

No Queen in British history has ever been officially referred to as 'Queen Consort'. They've always just been Her Majesty The Queen.

Ask the posters who say royal protocol means queen consort is the same as Queen. They know where to find it too. I noticed no one challenged them.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:19

And @DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

I in no way prefer sexual oppression.

By all means people can go out and shag whomever they want, provided all over 18 and consenting.

But there is a difference in being sexually liberated, and being an absolute bastard of a person who cheats on their spouse, traumatises their children, fails in their obligations and tears people’s lives apart in order to get their end away.

There is a more dignified way of handling problems in a marriage - you work on it, or you leave.

That is my personal opinion. I don’t think we should be lowering standards and saying adultery is ok, it isn’t.

They’ve tried to turn it into a love story but it’s just so sordid the lot of it.

Now please, enough let some other people discuss.

No matter what you say it’s really not going to change my point of view or invalidate it, anymore than I could change/invalidate yours.

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:09

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 10:53

Yes.

Well, at least you admit not understanding common turns of phrase. It means we don't have to argue about the fact that you missed the point.

With power you can do what you want. With no power and reliant on public good will, their perception of you matters more in relation to the survival of monarchy.

As long as the monarchy is in place, it's got rules. They're not dependent on you approving of the monarch and his wife on a personal level.

So we all have to be liberal now?

Yes, you did say you take everything completely literally... But do you prefer regression and sexual oppression? Because that's what it is when one demands thar the state punish people one way or another for indiscretions, which basically is what you're calling for. Incidentally, who do you think will get the shitty end of that stick - men or women?

Oh crikey @DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

Could you leave off and go and bicker with somebody else.

I took it literally because I am autistic and your babbling on is a bit incessant.

The survival of the monarchy long term is very much based on public opinion. We pay for them.

I prefer that people who are representing the country have strength of character and decency towards others. What Charles and Camilla did showed poor character and indecency.

The decent thing to do considering what is at stake and their colourful history would have been to step aside themselves to allow a more palatable couple next in line to take over.

That’s not the state punishing them. That’s them taking ownership of their transgressions and prioritising the U.K. and commonwealth. A voluntary decision.

But they’ve decided to press on with their own agenda shamelessly throughout because they are selfish people. Which was apparent when they conducted the affair in the first place. They want to be king and queen and all the money and status that comes with.

We differ in our opinion. I can respect yours, please respect mine.

DappledThings · 07/05/2023 11:00

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 10:44

Ive double checked royal protocol. Queen consort = married to a king. Queen on its own up to now is interchangeable only with queen regnant. Public shorthand is different eg princess Kate/Meghan, neither of whom hold those titles or queen consort Elizabeth being referred to just as queen.

It's really funny seeing all these random anonymous posters arguing about something that Elizabeth II and Charles are openly contradicted them on in their public acknowledgement of a clear difference between the two and the decision to change them. Who to believe, let me think 😆

The wives of the last three kings, the Queeens Consort Alexandra, Mary and Elizabeth were known just as Queen Alexandra, Queen Mary and Queen Elizabeth. And were crowned. This just isn't a change or contradiction no matter how many try to argue it is

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 10:59

I suppose a lot of this comes down to whether you think everyone who ever had an affair, no matter what the circumstances or the outcome, is such an irredeemably Bad Person that they should be punished forever, or whether you have a slightly more nuanced view of it.

If it's the former, well, you're allowed to think that and nobody will convince you otherwise, but that's a lot of people you're attempting to condemn to permanent misery...and there comes a point where the motivations start looking questionable because it's hard to see it as anything other than displaced vengeance.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 10:53

Robinni · 07/05/2023 09:37

@DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

Are you always so very literal?

Yes.

This makes no sense.

With power you can do what you want. With no power and reliant on public good will, their perception of you matters more in relation to the survival of monarchy.

Look at the PR machine they have going. It matters.

Who's he competing with?

Those who would wish to abolish the monarchy, have republic/no figurehead/commonwealth.

And like I said before, punishing people for sexual indiscretion (where consensual and between adults) is never a liberal step.

So we all have to be liberal now?

Don’t think they should be punished. Just think they ought to have stepped aside.

I don’t fancy celebrating and revering people whose behaviour is totally out of line with my beliefs/morality, I find it abhorrent. I’m sorry, but that is my opinion.

Yes.

Well, at least you admit not understanding common turns of phrase. It means we don't have to argue about the fact that you missed the point.

With power you can do what you want. With no power and reliant on public good will, their perception of you matters more in relation to the survival of monarchy.

As long as the monarchy is in place, it's got rules. They're not dependent on you approving of the monarch and his wife on a personal level.

So we all have to be liberal now?

Yes, you did say you take everything completely literally... But do you prefer regression and sexual oppression? Because that's what it is when one demands thar the state punish people one way or another for indiscretions, which basically is what you're calling for. Incidentally, who do you think will get the shitty end of that stick - men or women?

IcedPurple · 07/05/2023 10:47

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 10:44

Ive double checked royal protocol. Queen consort = married to a king. Queen on its own up to now is interchangeable only with queen regnant. Public shorthand is different eg princess Kate/Meghan, neither of whom hold those titles or queen consort Elizabeth being referred to just as queen.

It's really funny seeing all these random anonymous posters arguing about something that Elizabeth II and Charles are openly contradicted them on in their public acknowledgement of a clear difference between the two and the decision to change them. Who to believe, let me think 😆

Where does one find 'royal protocol' in order to check it? What is the written source for 'royal protocol'?

No Queen in British history has ever been officially referred to as 'Queen Consort'. They've always just been Her Majesty The Queen.

Inkpotlover · 07/05/2023 10:46

Robinni · 07/05/2023 10:14

@Inkpotlover

You’ve missed what I said earlier re respect for the marriage and yourself.

miserable marriage -> divorce -> meet new partner and remarry FINE

If you enter into an affair while you are still married and not separated you are clearly not focused on your marriage or children and are a person of poor character.

If my DC ever behaved like that I would be disgusted, I would hope I’d brought them up better.

Fair enough! I respect your consistency on the subject.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 10:45

Excuse grammatical errors. Autocorrect is a nuisance.

Inkpotlover · 07/05/2023 10:45

aSofaNearYou · 07/05/2023 10:10

I think more likely Mumsnet is full of feminists who recognise there is no moral justification for condemning Camilla whilst accepting Charles, and as a mindset it's actually quite dangerous.

This ^. I am neither a Clarence House PR or someone who has cheated - it would actually a deal breaker for me in my own relationship – but I cannot stand the very un-feminist pile on of a woman who has been happily married now for 18 years.