Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Camilla should not have been crowned Queen

612 replies

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:38

She should have been Princess Consort as we were told she would be. Instead the usual airbrushing of history to try and make her acceptable by clever spinning. And positive press. Bit sickening since Edward VIII had to abdicate over marrying a divorced woman.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 08/05/2023 07:49

As someone who wasn't around at the time, I have to say that recollections may vary about why Charles and Camilla didn't marry initially. People say that it was because he didn't ask her, or he wasn't allowed because she wasn't considered posh, pure or pretty enough, or she didn't want to, or she did but then married Parker-Bowles on the rebound and so on.

Housewife2010 · 08/05/2023 07:37

@Effieswig I completely agree. Also for all those saying he should have been allowed to marry Camilla originally, did she not have any say in it? It is well known that she was in love with Andrew Parker Bowles who was a known philanderer. He cheated on her during their courtship (and during their marriage so I can't understand a previous poster feeling sorry for him). She went out with Charles originally to make Andrew jealousy She was in love with Andrew and had no desire to be the Princess of Wales. She wanted a quiet family life in the country rather than all the attention and pressure of Royal life. This is all well known yet people keep saying he should have married her originally as though Charles was Henry VIII at court who would choose a new bride and she would have no say in it.

Effieswig · 08/05/2023 06:13

There’s been threads here before where the Op was the OW, but been married to the man for 20 years. Much longer than the first marriage, but still vilified and treated as OW and they have got lots of support from posters. The general concerns us being that it was a shitty thing to do, but people really needed to move on. So it’s not something, that only the upper class get a pass for.

Cheating is shit. It’s really shit. But do people really deserve to be judged by it forever? I don’t think so. We all do shitty things, we all make mistakes. Imagine being judged, forever, because of something you did wrong 30 odd years ago.

Charles and Diana got married 40 odd years ago (is it 42 years) and separated 30 odd years ago. Yes what happened was shitty and all sides behaved poorly. But it’s really time to move on. If someone was still severally impacted by being cheated on 39 years ago I would be suggesting therapy because it’s not healthy to have not moved on. But to still be upset that 30 - 40 years ago someone you don’t know was the OW to a man you don’t know and hurt his wife, who you don’t know, and also cheated is really odd imo.

mixedrecycling · 08/05/2023 03:40

DeeCeeCherry · 07/05/2023 22:09

MN is a strange beast. An OW is villified on here. In Camilla's case MN mostly gives her a pass because she's rich, upper class, and shagged a King-to-be. That both she and Charles made their partners unhappy us nothing but a blip. Serfdom and starry eyed over the upper class is ingrained here. I'm not a Royalist but if I had to think on it I'd say the monarchy has had its day. It's like a badly written soap opera. I don't think monarchy will ever be abolished tho, because Britain - England, in the main - thinks it's special by way of having a monarchy. It's here to stay.

Or maybe because, after a period of time, she has gone from being an OW to being wife and long term partner?

Human beings aren't perfect. Marriages break down. Sadly. But there comes a point, surely, when the mistakes of the past (purely personal mistakes, we're not talking about genocide) are in the past?

TizerorFizz · 07/05/2023 22:22

Lots of countries have monarchies. It’s not special. Each monarchy is unique in its own way. Here it’s separate from government. It has a role as a constitutional monarchy but it doesn’t rule. If saves Uzbek trying to find a president. We would never agree on a suitable person!

The huge issue with Charles was that he should have stayed with Camilla when he first met her. At Cambridge I think. He was a wimp and was bullied into marrying Diana. At the time I remember thinking she was too young and inexperienced in life. She was starry eyes and what else could she do but marry him, At his age, he should have known better. You cannot make someone happy if they don’t want you!

DeeCeeCherry · 07/05/2023 22:09

MN is a strange beast. An OW is villified on here. In Camilla's case MN mostly gives her a pass because she's rich, upper class, and shagged a King-to-be. That both she and Charles made their partners unhappy us nothing but a blip. Serfdom and starry eyed over the upper class is ingrained here. I'm not a Royalist but if I had to think on it I'd say the monarchy has had its day. It's like a badly written soap opera. I don't think monarchy will ever be abolished tho, because Britain - England, in the main - thinks it's special by way of having a monarchy. It's here to stay.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 22:07

I think he did get his marriage to Anne Boleyn annulled, begging the question of how she could commit adultery if she'd never been married, but hey ho.

Guineasrule · 07/05/2023 21:52

FancyFanny · 07/05/2023 18:08

Since when has the behaviour of the Royals been something which is advocated as the moral compass for the lives of the nation? The monarchy has always been surrounded in scandal, corrupt and divisive.

Precisely-the royal family are not catholic but Church of England (Protestant Anglican)which was formed by Henry VIII to allow him divorce his first wife. This kicked it all off really. The Catholic Church would not allow him to divorce Catherine of Aragon without been excommunicated).

Once divorced he married his mistress Anne Boleyn to produce Elizabeth I, before moving into wife no 3 (not bothering with divorce but chopping Anne’s head off instead).

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 19:38

Sudeko · 07/05/2023 18:02

It doesn't necessarily make it true.
It may be what he told her and she was gullible enough to believe it and bask in the glory of being the one in control.
Or did she say it to win the battle of 'who dumped who' when it wasn't even true just because she had her voice back and was relishing having a captive audience and making him feel like the dumped one? She played these games with the media that would not look out of place in a casino.

Without medical checks, who is to know? The writing on the wall screamed differently

I don't think it matters who was unfaithful first. It was a miserable mismatch that should never have happened. They both made mistakes and they both deserved a chance of happiness after the inevitable divorce. If Diana were alive, she wouldn't deserve to be punished forever either.

mixedrecycling · 07/05/2023 18:28

Jonei · 07/05/2023 14:57

That's very weird. How would that work if Diana had remarried, and then died. Would that mean both Charles and Diana's (hypothetical) new husband would then both be widowers ? And erm, moving on from that, Charles could only remarry if his wife or ex wife, were dead?

IF you believe that once married you cannot divorce, Diana's hypothetical new 'husband' would not have been her husband as she was still married to Charles. Her 'marriage' to the hypothetical new husband would not have been a marriage, but an adulterous relationship. She was still married to Charles.

IF, on the other hand, you believe marriage can be ended by divorce, then as soon as Charles and Diana were divorced they were both single again, and free to marry again.

mixedrecycling · 07/05/2023 18:25

Jonei · 07/05/2023 13:57

How can he be a widower if he was divorced from her before she died. His wife didn't die, making him widowed. His ex wife died. He was a divorcee, not a widower.

Because if you do not recognise the validity of divorce, you do not recognise anyone as a divorcee. Once they are married they are married, until their spouse dies and they become a widow/er.

Of course, if you do recognise divorce as ending a marriage, then you recognise such a thing as a divorcee - who is free to remarry.

FancyFanny · 07/05/2023 18:08

Since when has the behaviour of the Royals been something which is advocated as the moral compass for the lives of the nation? The monarchy has always been surrounded in scandal, corrupt and divisive.

Sudeko · 07/05/2023 18:02

CwmYoy · 07/05/2023 17:53

Diana was the first to be unfaithful. She said so herself.

It doesn't necessarily make it true.
It may be what he told her and she was gullible enough to believe it and bask in the glory of being the one in control.
Or did she say it to win the battle of 'who dumped who' when it wasn't even true just because she had her voice back and was relishing having a captive audience and making him feel like the dumped one? She played these games with the media that would not look out of place in a casino.

Without medical checks, who is to know? The writing on the wall screamed differently

CwmYoy · 07/05/2023 17:53

Sudeko · 06/05/2023 19:43

Diana explained that she was only cheating to get back at Charles for doing it to her. She wanted him to feel the pain but of course, he didn't because he gave zero fucks about her.

Diana was the first to be unfaithful. She said so herself.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 17:49

CabernetSauvignon · 07/05/2023 16:28

No, they've decided to press on with normal constitutional practice. We really can't have some sort of morality election every time a monarch dies, it would be impossible. We'd end up with a load of useless monarchs with no life experience.

Exactly.

And to add: to demand a change to this practice out of a spiteful wish to punish Charles and Camilla would be to judge and insult every person who has ever had an affair themselves. Obviously some extremely blinkered people think this is a good thing, but I think most of us accept that it's a bad idea.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 07/05/2023 17:40

Dontworkmondays · 07/05/2023 15:27

Totally agree. I think it’s the start of the unravelling of the monarchy. A blended family in royalty?! step children, step grandmothers etc its all so tacky. They have shown they are not worthy of a pedestal they sit on.

Step families are tacky?

CabernetSauvignon · 07/05/2023 16:55

AnnesObstructiveFeather · 07/05/2023 11:39

No Queen in British history has ever been officially referred to as 'Queen Consort'. They've always just been Her Majesty The Queen.

Except for Camilla, who was referred to as Camilla, Queen Consort ever since QEII’s death. Her title was Camilla, Queen Consort on the Royal website. Up until the coronation.

And the Royal website also refers to the Queen Mother as Queen Consort. Because the titles of Queen and Queen Consort are interchangeable.

AllIeveknewonlyou · 07/05/2023 16:45

Viviennemary · 06/05/2023 16:54

Charles is a widower so is free to marry in the eyes of the church. Camilla isn't.

He's not a widower, his ex-wife died.

Maireas · 07/05/2023 16:38

Very true, @CabernetSauvignon and @LolaSmiles . Yesterday there were several anti Camilla threads started, plus ones attacking Charles and William. These were not about the issue of an hereditary Monarchy, or discussions about modernisation. No, they were deeply unpleasant personal attacks with strong whiffs of misogyny. Calling Camilla "the old bag on the throne" and basing any criticism on adultery. I think either there's a strong puritanical streak, or the Cult of St Diana the Martyr lives on. I don't particularly have strong feelings about Camilla, but the attacks were awful. All this adultery business as if she should be taken out and stoned to death. It was very strange.

LolaSmiles · 07/05/2023 16:31

No, they've decided to press on with normal constitutional practice. We really can't have some sort of morality election every time a monarch dies, it would be impossible. We'd end up with a load of useless monarchs with no life experience.
Agree with this.
Much as I'd be happy to remove the monarchy and they can be private citizens, possibly keeping their titles, monarchists can't have it both ways by wanting to keep an archaic institution based on hereditary titles and birthrights, whilst also thinking that the line of succession should be chosen by public opinion and whether the next in line is liked.

CabernetSauvignon · 07/05/2023 16:28

Robinni · 07/05/2023 11:09

Oh crikey @DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder

Could you leave off and go and bicker with somebody else.

I took it literally because I am autistic and your babbling on is a bit incessant.

The survival of the monarchy long term is very much based on public opinion. We pay for them.

I prefer that people who are representing the country have strength of character and decency towards others. What Charles and Camilla did showed poor character and indecency.

The decent thing to do considering what is at stake and their colourful history would have been to step aside themselves to allow a more palatable couple next in line to take over.

That’s not the state punishing them. That’s them taking ownership of their transgressions and prioritising the U.K. and commonwealth. A voluntary decision.

But they’ve decided to press on with their own agenda shamelessly throughout because they are selfish people. Which was apparent when they conducted the affair in the first place. They want to be king and queen and all the money and status that comes with.

We differ in our opinion. I can respect yours, please respect mine.

No, they've decided to press on with normal constitutional practice. We really can't have some sort of morality election every time a monarch dies, it would be impossible. We'd end up with a load of useless monarchs with no life experience.

CabernetSauvignon · 07/05/2023 16:20

Alltheprettyseahorses · 07/05/2023 10:44

Ive double checked royal protocol. Queen consort = married to a king. Queen on its own up to now is interchangeable only with queen regnant. Public shorthand is different eg princess Kate/Meghan, neither of whom hold those titles or queen consort Elizabeth being referred to just as queen.

It's really funny seeing all these random anonymous posters arguing about something that Elizabeth II and Charles are openly contradicted them on in their public acknowledgement of a clear difference between the two and the decision to change them. Who to believe, let me think 😆

This is just bizarre. When did you ever hear it disputed that the wives of Edward VII, George V and George VI were entitled to be described as Queen? When did either Elizabeth II or Charles III ever say that a Queen Consort could not be Queen? This is simply wishful thinking, no-one has managed to produce a shred of credible evidence that QEII didn't want Camilla to be known as Queen.

CabernetSauvignon · 07/05/2023 16:12

Sorry, the first para of my message at 16.11 was meant to be a quote.

DappledThings · 07/05/2023 16:11

AnnesObstructiveFeather · 07/05/2023 15:32

It would have been a more modest approach considering the rather chequered history.

Over-turning centuries of tradition would be a more modest approach? That doesn't make sense to me.

CabernetSauvignon · 07/05/2023 16:11

There are plenty of articles implying that QEII intended Camilla to be known as (and referred to as) Queen Consort rather than Queen.

You're seriously taking an amateur journo on Livemint as an authoritative source, @AnnesObstructiveFeather? It's obvious that the authors of those articles are woefully lacking in basic constitutional and historical knowledge. Somewhere a couple of history teachers are beating themselves up in utter frustration and shame.

Swipe left for the next trending thread