Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Animal testing for cosmetics restarted in UK

62 replies

Silverbook · 06/05/2023 09:14

Surely I’m not the only one horrified by this? To be clear- this is NOT for medical purposes but for make up? Surely if industries have managed to safely produce make up, without using animal experiments in the last 25 years (while under EU guidelines), they can continue to do so?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-65484552

Woman applying concealer under eyes in front of hand held mirror

Animal tests for makeup resume after 25-year ban

The High court dismisses case brought by animal activists against a government change in policy.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-65484552

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PollyPeptide · 17/05/2023 18:08

Good news. Braverman says no new licences to be granted.

RampantIvy · 07/05/2023 16:05

you will all be benefiting from past testing in any products and medication you use.

Yes. Dogs and pigs were used for insulin testing in the early days.

TempName247 · 07/05/2023 10:49

I hate the thought of animal testing but I don’t know what the alternative would be. Everyone saying they are against it, you will all be benefiting from past testing in any products and medication you use.

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 07/05/2023 10:24

@HollyGolightly4 There are two decent sites you can check. I'm having trouble getting links (phone is playing up). Ethical elephant is a good one and cruelty free kitty is also quite good.

Reachh · 07/05/2023 10:11

I do wonder how many of these ‘outraged’ companies will buy into the data Company X generates for snazzy new cosmetic substance, once they see snazzy new cosmetic substance has fantastic properties…

Reachh · 07/05/2023 10:05

GeeHDees · 07/05/2023 07:33

Thank you for bringing some sanity to this thread when most couldn't even be bothered to read the article.

You’re very welcome, I know it’s very long. 😂

The authorities want to move away from animal testing using ‘read across’ which is looking existing data for similar substances. Or similar scientific alternatives.

Reading animal reports testing has always made me very uncomfortable (I never commissioned animal testing or worked for companies doing it, I used to be a consultant managing client’s applications for chemical registrations).

The authorities aren’t evil - they want to make sure substances being put on the market aren’t harmful to an unacceptable level to humans. They minimise the amount of animals tested as much as possible. I hate that this is at the expense of animals though and I hope it becomes a thing of the past (I’d imagine in the next few decades).

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 07/05/2023 07:37

That’s annoying, but thank you for your reply.

GeeHDees · 07/05/2023 07:35

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 07/05/2023 07:22

Can someone clarify that leaping bunny products definitely are vegan?

Nope not necessarily, you need to check the ingredients. Leaping bunny just means no new tests have had to be carried out for the product, they will have been tested at some point.

GeeHDees · 07/05/2023 07:33

Reachh · 06/05/2023 23:42

I work in interpreting chemical regs and there’s a general misunderstanding in the public re animal testing of cosmetics.

Substances in ALL chemical products in the EU are tested on animals. These substances are in all kinds of things: window cleaner, cleaning spray, car engine oil, you name it.

Whatever substance is only tested on animals ONCE (not defending this just stating the process.) Then other companies buy into the data.

Products themselves are not tested on animals. When companies such as Lush say their products arenot tested on animals, this is meaningless marketing BS because no one tests their finished products on animals. Lush will either buy into or use for free, data on the substances they put into the products they make. So they’re still taking advantage of animal testing technically.

Until recently, substances tested on animals where substance was solely used in cosmetics was not allowed. But if the data was existing for other product types the cosmetic companies could buy into it. Now testing is allowed but you’ve got to have a strong case such as not being able to extrapolate from existing data/ data from similar substances / theoretical calculations.

So there’s a lot of outcry now about now allowing testing of cosmetic substances on animals. Which won’t be that many as a lot of the data already exists. But what people may be less aware of is that whilst this debate goes on, all the other types of chemical products (and that’s a lot) have substances that have been tested or will be tested on animals.

Also Uk law copied all the EU laws following Brexit.

I’m not saying animal testing is right, just outlining the process.

The EU and UK are trying to move away fromanimal testing but it’s moving slower than desired tbh.

Thank you for bringing some sanity to this thread when most couldn't even be bothered to read the article.

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 07/05/2023 07:22

daisydaisy11 · 07/05/2023 07:00

Shame on the uk. Moving backwards. Please only buy leaping bunny products.

Can someone clarify that leaping bunny products definitely are vegan?

YouveGotAFastCar · 07/05/2023 07:20

cocoloco117 · 06/05/2023 11:08

I presume it’s in order to sell into markets such as China that mandate animal testing.

No, there’s been separate agreements for this in place for years - I did some work with L’Oreal 12 years ago and this was sorted then. Essentially they can do the required testing for China while still claiming to be animal testing free here - which is why they don’t tend to make any decent list of brands that don’t test on animals.

There has been no regulatory changes in China, so this is a decision much closer to home.

RampantIvy · 07/05/2023 07:17

It has always been my stance that animal testing should be stopped, not just on chemicals (I find unilever quite hypocritical), but on medical research too

Yet the outcry from the many people who objected to bring "guinea pigs" when the first covid vaccines were produced shows that a lot of people wouldn't agree with you.

Thank you for your explanation @Reachh

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/05/2023 07:05

Nimbostratus100 · 06/05/2023 09:25

this is what we voted for. Brexit. we have the freedom to ignore humane laws now

Do you actually bother to read things before commenting?

daisydaisy11 · 07/05/2023 07:00

Shame on the uk. Moving backwards. Please only buy leaping bunny products.

sashh · 07/05/2023 06:31

PollyPeptide · 07/05/2023 03:32

First of all, you say the uk is responsible for introducing this testing. That's incorrect. It's the EU that introduced it before we'd left. They've already been taken to court to overturn the introduction of this testing and the plaintiff lost. At least lay blame equally where it should fall. Like the rest of the EU we were issuing licenses before Brexit had occurred. And if we'd stayed in the EU, we'd still be in the same position today.

It has always been my stance that animal testing should be stopped, not just on chemicals (I find unilever quite hypocritical), but on medical research too. It's true we don't know what's been tested but we know why it started and its intent was not to start testing on all makeup. It was for specific chemicals within spf products. Do I agree with that? No. But theres absolutely no reason to believe its going to lead to a free for all on makeup testing.

What makes it so difficult is the opaqueness of the language the govt uses. They are overruling Acts of 40 years ago to say if a foreign regulator requires a product to be tested, it must be. Clearly here it relates to the EU and the sunscreen ingredients. But what happens if other large economies like China demands things?

I'm always concerned when govts speak in waffle and talk of strategies. I see long grass. I feel so disappointed and let down by the UK and EU.

You will never stop animal testing for medicines, there are things you just cannot test with other methods eg zebrafish can regenerate heart muscle, knowing how and why has huge implications for humans.

The short lifespan of some animals lends them to research on Alzheimer's, fruit flies are often used as their natural life span is about 40 days rather than the 80 years of humans.

PollyPeptide · 07/05/2023 03:32

First of all, you say the uk is responsible for introducing this testing. That's incorrect. It's the EU that introduced it before we'd left. They've already been taken to court to overturn the introduction of this testing and the plaintiff lost. At least lay blame equally where it should fall. Like the rest of the EU we were issuing licenses before Brexit had occurred. And if we'd stayed in the EU, we'd still be in the same position today.

It has always been my stance that animal testing should be stopped, not just on chemicals (I find unilever quite hypocritical), but on medical research too. It's true we don't know what's been tested but we know why it started and its intent was not to start testing on all makeup. It was for specific chemicals within spf products. Do I agree with that? No. But theres absolutely no reason to believe its going to lead to a free for all on makeup testing.

What makes it so difficult is the opaqueness of the language the govt uses. They are overruling Acts of 40 years ago to say if a foreign regulator requires a product to be tested, it must be. Clearly here it relates to the EU and the sunscreen ingredients. But what happens if other large economies like China demands things?

I'm always concerned when govts speak in waffle and talk of strategies. I see long grass. I feel so disappointed and let down by the UK and EU.

Missingmyusername · 07/05/2023 03:24

AllAboutMargot · 06/05/2023 12:07

So disappointing. I genuinely thought we'd progress instead of regress when it comes to using and abusing animals for our own ends.

This ^

sashh · 07/05/2023 03:03

Suspific · 06/05/2023 22:20

I cannot understand the need for this. If we've managed for 25 years just because we can reintroduce it doesn't mean we should . Reinforces what an absolute bag of bollocks Brexit was. And how being part of Europe actually protected us from ourselves!!

We haven't managed for 25 years, any company that wells in China has tested its products on animals, not here, but in other countries.

The leaping bunny means that the product is not tested on animals.

Until 2009 ingredients could still be tested on animals and be labeled as not tested on animals, although I don't think you could use the bunny logo.

superstarglo · 07/05/2023 02:02

You do realise they just rear the animals in the uk before carting them off elsewhere anyway? It’s savage and I guess at least will eliminate a stressful transit before they’re tortured further. The industry is absolutely huge in the uk they’ve just never been able to directly do the testing here. These people walk among us in everyday life!!!

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/05/2023 01:49

Since 2019 the UK government have been issuing licences for animal testing of cosmetic ingredients. We don't know how many licences have been issued or who has received them @PollyPeptide. So how do you know who is testing what?

It's not as though our government has been open or transparent in any of this.Hmm

PollyPeptide · 07/05/2023 00:07

TooBigForMyBoots · 06/05/2023 23:28

This Tory government have ended the ban on animal testing for cosmetics in the UK @PollyPeptide. No one is to blame for that but the Conservatives.

Next thing you know we'll be breeding fur and exporting veal in crates again.

I don't think that's right. The EU said that certain chemicals have to be tested. I guess here it's for chemical sunscreens. Sunscreens are classified as cosmetics in the UK and spfs are found in foundation and concealers. That doesn't mean you're testing makeup. They're not testing the foundation or concealers. They're testing the chemical in the spf. And there does seem to be a constant chasing of new chemicals. The US FDA won't allow many, if any, EU chemical sunscreens to be sold in the US because they have doubts over these chemicals being used. There are tons of sunscreens still tested on animals.

As concerning as this is and I strongly support the cases brought in the EU and the UK to oppose these licences, it's not, as yet, any indication that animal testing will be resumed in this country - or indeed the EU.

Reachh · 06/05/2023 23:42

I work in interpreting chemical regs and there’s a general misunderstanding in the public re animal testing of cosmetics.

Substances in ALL chemical products in the EU are tested on animals. These substances are in all kinds of things: window cleaner, cleaning spray, car engine oil, you name it.

Whatever substance is only tested on animals ONCE (not defending this just stating the process.) Then other companies buy into the data.

Products themselves are not tested on animals. When companies such as Lush say their products arenot tested on animals, this is meaningless marketing BS because no one tests their finished products on animals. Lush will either buy into or use for free, data on the substances they put into the products they make. So they’re still taking advantage of animal testing technically.

Until recently, substances tested on animals where substance was solely used in cosmetics was not allowed. But if the data was existing for other product types the cosmetic companies could buy into it. Now testing is allowed but you’ve got to have a strong case such as not being able to extrapolate from existing data/ data from similar substances / theoretical calculations.

So there’s a lot of outcry now about now allowing testing of cosmetic substances on animals. Which won’t be that many as a lot of the data already exists. But what people may be less aware of is that whilst this debate goes on, all the other types of chemical products (and that’s a lot) have substances that have been tested or will be tested on animals.

Also Uk law copied all the EU laws following Brexit.

I’m not saying animal testing is right, just outlining the process.

The EU and UK are trying to move away fromanimal testing but it’s moving slower than desired tbh.

TooBigForMyBoots · 06/05/2023 23:28

This Tory government have ended the ban on animal testing for cosmetics in the UK @PollyPeptide. No one is to blame for that but the Conservatives.

Next thing you know we'll be breeding fur and exporting veal in crates again.