Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the screwed up NHS is partly the gps doing...

166 replies

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 09:02

Please read before you roast me, sorry it's long and possibly complicated…

Brief timeline
Well before covid hit - gp surgery brilliant
Couple of years before covid, gp merged with large GP group which now covers 3 cities and many many surgeries. - appointments much, much harder to get.
Covid hit- GPs formed a private limited company making themselves directors and running all the vaccinations in the city. Appointments at all surgery’s like hens teeth- scarce- understandable.

Covid, now “over” and the surgery’s haven’t gone back to normal, they have closed smaller practices and outsourcing their work to the Private limited company where all the GPs are still directors and appear to be working. Patients have to wait 3-8 weeks (usually the latter) to get a phone call from their practice GP.

Excuse for closing down smaller surgeries "no receptionists to deal with abusive patients" in reality, all the receptionists moved to the private company, and they advertised for new positions at below national living wage (£9.50ph).

They have outsourced their online and telephone triage system to another company about 200 miles away, so some outsourced GP(?) decides whether you get an appointment or not.

In our city, patients are finding no alternative but to use A&E, Urgent care, Out of hours, Minor injuries (all based at the hospital) after getting frustrated at the lack of service and phoning 111. The hospital are all aware that the increase in patients through their door are from this one GP group, yet they aren’t able to do anything.

So in effect, the gps get paid by the NHS for the (lack of ) service they provide at the nhs surgery, the NHS pay the private company(plc) to run, the GPs then get paid as GPs of the plc and as directors of the plc, they are also shareholders so get dividends all whilst the patients aren’t being physically seen and costing the NHS hospital to see the patients and treat them.
Looked on companies house website and this company has nearly £1.5M in the shareholder (GPs) fund, their creditors and assets equal out and they have £3M in cash in the bank. All whilst putting more pressure and using more resources at the hospitals. Now this amount of money is small compared to the overall cost of the NHS but if you multiply it over the whole country, it would add up especially for one patient the nhs can end up paying 3 times as much than if same patient had just managed to see GP in own surgery.
So am I being unreasonable to think that GPs are partially to blame?

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 06/05/2023 19:32

The NHS is "screwed up" because:
1 - It is a model designed in the 1940s, which just doesn't work in the 21st century, especially with all the advances in medical science.
2 - The British public abuse and misuse it, because they think it is "free".
3 - Politicians of all parties are too scared to tell the truth and say that we need to move to some kind of insurance system, in which the public take at least some responsibility.

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 19:25

@cptartapp the smears are already outsourced. Not everyone can afford a home bp machine.

OP posts:
ApplePiePie · 06/05/2023 16:09

They are now asking patients to buy their own blood pressure machine and tell them the readings instead of running a clinic.

Because it’s more accurate to get an average home blood pressure reading. And BP machines are now more widely available an relative inexpensive

Also there has been changes made to the way pharmacists are trained, the idea being that from 2026 all newly registered pharmacists will also be independent prescribers.

Walkingtheplank · 06/05/2023 16:08

My little GP surgery was great. I'd see the same GP and could usually get an appointment within 48 hours.

During COVID it was merged/bought out by a huge practice down the road. It's now impossible to get an appointment within 2 weeks, never with the same GP twice and have recently had such gems as "Yes you can tell me, but only if you're quick', "How should I know", "Well it's hard to say".

No idea what to do other than go private.

holaholiday · 06/05/2023 15:43

WhatonEarthcan · 06/05/2023 14:10

More prescribing power for pharmacists then. They would help massively . A little training and a consultation area in pharmacies and I’m sure that would make a difference

Nurse led out of hours clinics too

Seeing as pharmacists are consistently over worked and under staffed just doing their basic bread and butter work(and medicines management is a crucial part of healthcare in itself ) this isn’t going to work either. Putting other professions forward to try and paper over deficits in gp provision isn’t an effective solution.

thecatsthecats · 06/05/2023 15:29

Ours has done this.

Luckily for us the nearest practice is still a short walk away, but the service is just not what it was.

Back in 2007, I was at university. There was a huge, single GP centre that served all students. You could book and manage appointments online and everything synchronised back with your home GP for the holidays. Other appointments all showed on my central record.

What the hell went wrong?

I'm pregnant. I have the badger notes app. I can view but not manage practice appointments. Midwife appointments are in my NHS app. The hospital scans are managed by letter and phonecall. One of the appointments in the app doesn't have a location in it. My first scan had three nurses - the sonographer, one who took my blood and one who made the appointments.

Got six months more of this bullshit before I give birth at one of the three poorly rated hospitals.

cptartapp · 06/05/2023 15:29

WhatonEarthcan · 06/05/2023 13:05

GP surgeries need to be open 7 days a week and on bank holidays. Even if the weekend / holiday opening hours are shorter then Mon-Fri hours this would immediately help with the situation where an and e units get overwhelmed .

I could work all today, but then will need my time off in the week in lieu when it's busier.
Statistically there are far more patient no shows at weekends. Plus no supportive services available such as child health, specimen transport.

cptartapp · 06/05/2023 15:26

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 13:02

I'm aware not all GP surgeries are like mine. I'm also aware that GP surgeries have had to be run as businesses for a long time but it's a bit galling when you can't see/speak to a GP, knowing they are being paid as you are their patient, but they won't see you. The nhs then gives a contract to the GP owned company to see the patients because the GP surgeries are "overwhelmed", and the GP makes a tidy profit without actually face to face seeing a patient, all while closing the smaller surgeries and blaming the patients who get frustrated because they can't get appointments.

Also, let's face it, not everything can be diagnosed over the phone, some things need to be done face to face!
They are now asking patients to buy their own blood pressure machine and tell them the readings instead of running a clinic.

Because home BP readings are more accurate. We can sit doing BP checks all day long, but then you'll wait much longer for your smear or your child to be vaccinated.

MrsCarson · 06/05/2023 15:17

It sounds awful seriouslygardening.
We have one GP but he covers 3 surgeries and it's not too bad getting in. He does have a couple of Advanced Nurse practitioners, and a few practise nurses and specialty nurses making things run smoothly. I think you are right about your GP service trying for most money for least amount of effort there. I'd look to see if there is another practise to move to that isn't covered by them.

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 15:09

WhatonEarthcan · 06/05/2023 14:10

More prescribing power for pharmacists then. They would help massively . A little training and a consultation area in pharmacies and I’m sure that would make a difference

Nurse led out of hours clinics too

I think this is a great idea. Also, how about having prescribing nurse but with actual prescribing power or a person between a nurse and GP who can see the majority of people, and can refer to GP if needed, but basically prescribe antibiotics, antivirals, and other lotions and potions.

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 06/05/2023 15:09

The outsourcing to private companies is happening in pretty much all areas of the NHS now. It’s certainly happening in our hospitals /mental health/learning disabilities. My dh is a consultant and it seriously angers him the money that the hospital spends on private companies to do work that costs far more than the NHS staff would do it for. They also make mistakes and employ companies that can’t actually do the work that needs doing! Oh and even mention quality assurance or safeguarding! And never any consultation with the clinical staff who might be able advise, or even do the extra work themselves for a bit of overtime money (no let’s pay 2 or 3 times that to randoms who might be spectacularly useless instead!)

Dh has been a victim of this himself when his brain MRI scan showed an important change, but the private company reporting on the scan didn’t pick up on the change, and therefore didn’t communicate it to anyone. 😡

Pyui · 06/05/2023 14:56

SweetSakura · 06/05/2023 14:50

Yanbu.

I have been involved in some negotiations with GP practices and NHS through work and am frankly dumbfounded at the profiteering

Recently went on a medical leadership day and they were talking about being visionaries and compassionate etc…
Sadly in the break out rooms we agreed that actually the people who get promoted and into management in the NHS seem to be those who are the most ruthless and domineering

SweetSakura · 06/05/2023 14:54

Another factor, they are often very dismissive of people. And women in particular. I think I had about 10 appointments because I knew something was wrong and they wouldn't listen. Then an optician spotted my (very visible) ptosis and wrote to the GP to tell them to refer me to neurology. That was 9 appointments that shouldn't have had to happen if they had listened to me, and looked at me!

I have heard similar stories from other friends who have later been diagnosed with similarly serious conditions

SweetSakura · 06/05/2023 14:50

Yanbu.

I have been involved in some negotiations with GP practices and NHS through work and am frankly dumbfounded at the profiteering

Pyui · 06/05/2023 14:48

I am not a GP but a doctor. 10 years ago when I was a junior trainee rotating I did GP and A&E.
Back then I thought GP was hard work- the days are really long- but at least then there was a lull or an end point. My colleagues now are just firefighting for 12 hours a day- they don’t work ‘part-time’ in terms of hours but there is no way to do a 9-5 day. It is intense and everywhere are haemorrhaging doctors because of burnout.
A&E similarly there was a lull at 3-5am so the 12 hours was more bearable- now you start and know there are more people in the waiting room who will still be waiting at the end of the shift.
It is multifactorial- increasingly complicated illness, higher demand, fund squeezing, mismanagement.
10 years ago there would be more managers than doctors in the handover room…

To address some previous points-

  • spreading GPs 24/7 would mean even fewer GPS because you would be spreading them even thinner- not the solution at all.
  • the limits on training doctors have been campaigned for because training needs to be adequate- there are only so many resources and time to enable clinical training
  • I agree some GP’s will be looking to monetise but also a I can empathise a little with them really about trying to create something that is sustainable- the old cliche of the family doctor for the village has been chased out
Kazzyhoward · 06/05/2023 14:26

IR35 has also stopped a lot of newly "retired" GPs from working as locums to cover sickness, holidays, etc. My own doctor "retired" but was a regular at our surgery for a couple of years after working through his own limited company. He stopped doing it when IR35 came in, and was open in telling me that was the reason - i.e. very high tax/nic which meant is wasn't worth his while doing it.

TurquoiseDress · 06/05/2023 14:24

I'm addressing my questions to the OP!

TurquoiseDress · 06/05/2023 14:23

@Parker231

I can't quote your reply but it's spot on

Ok if they force GPs to cover practices 24/7 at weekends etc

So then where are they going to find the GPs to cover during the 'normal' working week?

You do realise there is a shortage of GPs nationally?

So make GPs cover 24/7 but watch the numbers plummet further as those choose to go and work overseas or quit altogether due to poor working conditions

Kazzyhoward · 06/05/2023 14:22

Napmum · 06/05/2023 13:24

There's a shortage of GPs and nurses. Also, a lot of GP surgeries don't have space for more doctors despite an increase in the number of patients.

GP surgeries get paid for the number of appointments they give, so its hard to lay for more receptionists.

There are restrictions on how many GPs can be trained, and the NHS pays a set amount for an appointment, etc. If more and more go private, then the NHS are not competitive enough, so surely it's the NHS at fault as much as the individual GPs?

The BMA blocked increases in the number of medical school places and a ban on the opening of new medical schools about 10-15 years ago. That's now coming home to roost as we've not got enough coming through training now.

WhatonEarthcan · 06/05/2023 14:10

More prescribing power for pharmacists then. They would help massively . A little training and a consultation area in pharmacies and I’m sure that would make a difference

Nurse led out of hours clinics too

Fizbosshoes · 06/05/2023 13:32

The NHS was first set up when
a) the population was smaller
b) life expectancy was shorter
c) people died of (now) treatable conditions...(so now might have 20 years of appointments and treatment instead of dying prematurely from it)

All of those, as well as providing medical procedures that would not have been invented then, mean its a completely different service from when it was invented.

Fizbosshoes · 06/05/2023 13:26

LakeTiticaca · 06/05/2023 10:54

Something drastic needs to be done. The NHS has been "on its knees" so to speak, for decades, one of the problems is that many GPs now work part time which doesn't help with the backlog of patients needing appointments.
It's not shortage of money that is the problem, it's bad management and waste.
My SIL works in an NHS setting and she and others never fail to be flabbergasted at the amount of money that is wasted, when all it needs is decent management to cut it all out

I think there is money wasted and some of the issues are blamed on patients when its the NHS inefficiency causing the issue. (missed appointments that patients are unaware of, apt cancelled by patient but not logged so down as a missed apt etc)
However pay, retention and staff shortages cause an awful lot of the problems so its not all about bad management and wasting money. Brexit meant many NHS staff left and a lot of well qualified staff can earn better money or have better working conditions abroad.

Napmum · 06/05/2023 13:24

There's a shortage of GPs and nurses. Also, a lot of GP surgeries don't have space for more doctors despite an increase in the number of patients.

GP surgeries get paid for the number of appointments they give, so its hard to lay for more receptionists.

There are restrictions on how many GPs can be trained, and the NHS pays a set amount for an appointment, etc. If more and more go private, then the NHS are not competitive enough, so surely it's the NHS at fault as much as the individual GPs?

Parker231 · 06/05/2023 13:22

WhatonEarthcan · 06/05/2023 13:19

Existing gps need to realise they need to work weekends and bank holidays like everyone else is expected to

If you work evenings and weekends you get time off during the week. Where are you going to find enough GP’s to cover all the days/hours?
One in five GP’s under the age of 30 left the profession last year and the numbers overall are dropping each year.

AgnesX · 06/05/2023 13:22

guinnessguzzler · 06/05/2023 09:13

Thank Bevan for the NHS 😀

If it wasn't for Nye Bevan there wouldn't be an NHS. I don't think that today's NHS is quite what he had in mind though.