Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the screwed up NHS is partly the gps doing...

166 replies

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 09:02

Please read before you roast me, sorry it's long and possibly complicated…

Brief timeline
Well before covid hit - gp surgery brilliant
Couple of years before covid, gp merged with large GP group which now covers 3 cities and many many surgeries. - appointments much, much harder to get.
Covid hit- GPs formed a private limited company making themselves directors and running all the vaccinations in the city. Appointments at all surgery’s like hens teeth- scarce- understandable.

Covid, now “over” and the surgery’s haven’t gone back to normal, they have closed smaller practices and outsourcing their work to the Private limited company where all the GPs are still directors and appear to be working. Patients have to wait 3-8 weeks (usually the latter) to get a phone call from their practice GP.

Excuse for closing down smaller surgeries "no receptionists to deal with abusive patients" in reality, all the receptionists moved to the private company, and they advertised for new positions at below national living wage (£9.50ph).

They have outsourced their online and telephone triage system to another company about 200 miles away, so some outsourced GP(?) decides whether you get an appointment or not.

In our city, patients are finding no alternative but to use A&E, Urgent care, Out of hours, Minor injuries (all based at the hospital) after getting frustrated at the lack of service and phoning 111. The hospital are all aware that the increase in patients through their door are from this one GP group, yet they aren’t able to do anything.

So in effect, the gps get paid by the NHS for the (lack of ) service they provide at the nhs surgery, the NHS pay the private company(plc) to run, the GPs then get paid as GPs of the plc and as directors of the plc, they are also shareholders so get dividends all whilst the patients aren’t being physically seen and costing the NHS hospital to see the patients and treat them.
Looked on companies house website and this company has nearly £1.5M in the shareholder (GPs) fund, their creditors and assets equal out and they have £3M in cash in the bank. All whilst putting more pressure and using more resources at the hospitals. Now this amount of money is small compared to the overall cost of the NHS but if you multiply it over the whole country, it would add up especially for one patient the nhs can end up paying 3 times as much than if same patient had just managed to see GP in own surgery.
So am I being unreasonable to think that GPs are partially to blame?

OP posts:
cptartapp · 07/05/2023 08:01

Florenz · 06/05/2023 22:28

There needs to be an excess payable for everything to deter people from missing appts or making unnecessary visits to the GP. £20 for a GP appt. £50 for a hospital appt. Nor refund under any circumstances. Reduce NI accordingly.

Who would be charged? Everyone? Pensioners? (many of whom are very well off), Children? Those on benefits? Basically all those who get free prescriptions?
Or just the poor sods in the middle yet again.

WellTidy · 07/05/2023 07:45

Three GPs I know are permanently only doing online appointments. One has moved far, far away from the surgery they work at. Ok, this is better than them leaving the professional altogether (though, as far as I know, this was never something any of them intended to do), but it’s not ideal from a patient’s perspective.

Kazzyhoward · 07/05/2023 07:32

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 00:31

GP practices were always private companies. The fact they are now an LLP is a red herring. That was the way the NHS was designed. As well as general medical practitioners (GPs), general ophthalmic practitioners, general dental practitioners and general pharmaceutical practitioners were all set up as private contractors.

The others are paid "per piece of work", GPs are paid "per patient". So dentists etc have to actually provide appointments and do things to get paid - the more they do, the more they are paid. Same with opticians, pharmacists. GPs are paid per patient, so there's no incentive for them to do anything more than basic standards required by the contract, hence they do the bare minimum needed to keep their contract.

Kazzyhoward · 07/05/2023 07:27

@ForTheSakeOfThePenguin

Having said that, I think it it was the Tories policies and massive budget cutting that forced surgeries to merge.

Nope, like a lot of current NHS problems it started under Blair. Our old GP surgery sold out back in 2003 and formed a "chain" of all the surgeries in our town. Service standards plummeted immediately. Our next nearest town followed a couple of years later. You can no longer go to your nearest surgery nor see the same GP. If you want an appointment you are allocated a random GP in a random surgery. That's been the case for the last 20 years around here.

HighHedges · 07/05/2023 02:38

GP surgeries - in my experience - are not fit for purpose. Our 4yo couldn't get an appointment for 4 weeks. Went to walk in who told us to go to the GP. I find it pretty scary as a parent.

Nat6999 · 07/05/2023 02:21

Are you in Sheffield? That sounds exactly like my surgery. They ran the vaccination programme for half the city. They shut down the branch surgery which is the only one with adequate disabled parking & access, cut everything else in the surgery to a minimum, even though Covid is over, nothing has restarted, You ring for an appointment & it's press button2, then 1, then *, spend an hour on the phone in a queue & you are still number 40 if you have been lucky enough to get through, the message says book online but they have removed online booking from the website. The whole place is a shitshow, I ordered my prescription 10 days before Easter, when it still hadn't arrived the day before Good Friday I rang the pharmacy who said they hadn't received it, I spent 90 minutes trying to get through to the surgery who hadn't got it signed & sent across, it took until 3.30pm to get it sorted which was too late for the pharmacy to deliver it. Because I'm housebound, I ended up going 4 days with no antidepressants over Easter, tried to complain & goy told we only accept complaints in writing, it's the 21st century, whycan'tI email a complaint.

Saschka · 07/05/2023 02:19

Kazzyhoward · 06/05/2023 14:22

The BMA blocked increases in the number of medical school places and a ban on the opening of new medical schools about 10-15 years ago. That's now coming home to roost as we've not got enough coming through training now.

I wish people would stop repeating this - the BMA have no influence whatsoever over training numbers. That is the GMC and Department of Heslth.

The BMA passing a resolution at its AGM doesn’t have any wider impact - they’ve also voted to ban boxing and fizzy drinks in the past.

crew2022 · 07/05/2023 01:18

My GP practice is generally awful.
They make you complete an e consult and don't get back to you. Say use the app but no appointments are ever uploaded. Prescribe medication over the phone, say it needs a review then never have an appointment to review it so just prescribe more when you are about to run out.
They expect you to take your own BP.
Never do any proactive health checks.
Have never called me for my smear which was due in January.
I know one of the admin team who says the main two GPS are lazy and avoid face to face consultations as they prefer working from home. They have so few face to face appointments that when you do get one and only use two minutes of your allotted time there's no one else waiting to be seen so they sit and read the paper. My friend has witnessed this.

Ammaouttahere · 07/05/2023 01:03

Not all GPs operate like the OP has described.

However as mentioned there is privatisation by stealth happening within the NHS. Services are contracted out to companies with the lowest bid. Unfortunately if it turns out it’s not exactly possible to deliver those services for that cost, said private company will adopt dubious practices.
Dh works as a locum and the company he works for treats all permanent staff appallingly. No break for 8 hours, appointment slots too short to assess the patient properly, double or triple bookings, no admin time given . The attitude from management is suck it up, don’t be nice to patients it takes up too much time, if you haven’t got time to write up notes it’s your problem, don’t criticise the company it reflects badly on us. That’s only the half of it.
No wonder staff leave.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:35

sylvandweller · 06/05/2023 10:55

No, it's been "on its knees" for about ten years.

Ten years.

Ten years ago my GP said she didn't expect the NHS to survive more than ten years. I went home and researched and paid for a private plan for myself and son. Husband scoffed and wouldn't join the plan.

I've needed it a couple of times in a decade. Now I need a scan GP wasn't optimistic until I said I had private cover. He actually smiled. I think he's fed up knowing patients referral is a waste of time.

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 00:31

GP practices were always private companies. The fact they are now an LLP is a red herring. That was the way the NHS was designed. As well as general medical practitioners (GPs), general ophthalmic practitioners, general dental practitioners and general pharmaceutical practitioners were all set up as private contractors.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:25

WhatonEarthcan · 06/05/2023 14:10

More prescribing power for pharmacists then. They would help massively . A little training and a consultation area in pharmacies and I’m sure that would make a difference

Nurse led out of hours clinics too

I feel really sorry for pharmacy. Ours are run off their feet since covid. The Welsh government promoting that we see them and phone them first. So the phone never stops, they're called away to look at a rash etc in what was a walk in cupboard. Many of the staff I've known for years have left. You have to wait minimum 7 days to pick up a repeat. I overheard patients being told that it wasn't in stock, so go back to GP ask for some else or wait and they will order it.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:17

Menora · 06/05/2023 22:25

Also for anyone who isn’t aware from 15th May the new contract dictates that no patient can be ‘told to phone back another day’. This means all patients need to be placed somewhere, for something. This doesn’t increase capacity it is dictating how they manage demand. So not enough GP’s and now we have the contract change. It will be interesting

That's going to be challenging for our surgery who have always done this

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:10

OH has a friend at the marina he said ghost patients were the best ones to have on the books. All the European patients who left after the Brexit stayed registered he said. I guess that helps to cover the cost of the patients who visit regularly

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:07

I've just checked beta company my GP does have a limited company with four others. Interesting there was £467k in the bank

Menora · 06/05/2023 22:32

Kazzyhoward · 06/05/2023 11:10

The biggest problem with GPs is the way it's funded, i.e. they get paid "per patient" rather than for what they actually do, so there's no incentive for them to actually see patients, they get paid whether they see you or not.

It needs to be changed so that they're paid for what they do, rather than how many patients they have on their books.

This is not true.

They receive a higher weighting depending on deprivation, but it very much involves ‘doing the work’ to get paid, ask any practice manager about their end of year QOF!

The thresholds are variable but this is the issue - the money isn’t in seeing you or your child for your cough/cold, a referral for a hip replacement or a manky toenail, its seeing you for your long term conditions. It’s seeing you to manage your medication. It’s visiting care homes. It’s reducing your opiates. So, how do you balance all the chronic long term condition management with all the acute requests too?

You get paid a flat rate (not always much either) for simply having patients on books but the £££ is in the work you do. I can honestly tell you that this is a false narrative, it’s just not structured the way you think. Seeing 1 patient 5 times about their bad back essentially is a financial loss to the practice, you have to rely that a lot of your patients do not contact you at all, so you can use that to mitigate the losses.

Florenz · 06/05/2023 22:28

There needs to be an excess payable for everything to deter people from missing appts or making unnecessary visits to the GP. £20 for a GP appt. £50 for a hospital appt. Nor refund under any circumstances. Reduce NI accordingly.

Menora · 06/05/2023 22:25

Also for anyone who isn’t aware from 15th May the new contract dictates that no patient can be ‘told to phone back another day’. This means all patients need to be placed somewhere, for something. This doesn’t increase capacity it is dictating how they manage demand. So not enough GP’s and now we have the contract change. It will be interesting

Menora · 06/05/2023 22:22

I’m a practice manager.

The main issue is, there are not enough GP’s. The reason they are outsourcing and using ARR staff is for this reason. You can’t recruit GP’s anymore. They are all locums, very expensive and don’t do any admin, so all your partner GP’s are doing the admin and not seeing as many patients.

I don’t know of any surgeries operating in this way, are you talking about a PCN (primary care network?) as yes that makes profit, but it has to go back into the business, or back to the practices in the PCN. The PCN’s are winning local contracts via their ICB in competition with other NHS Trusts. This system came into play many years ago when they (Tories) abolished PCT’s and separated all services into 2 categories - commissioning and providing. The commissioning has all the money and awards contracts to whoever is seen to deliver the best value.

The partners themselves do make profit via their GP partnership. They have always done this, they do this via QOF and other contracts. Some practices do not make profit, or a small one. This is not a big conspiracy, it’s not new, it is the structure. GP’s are independent contractors who hold a GMS contract which generates funding from the NHS.

SchoolShenanigans · 06/05/2023 22:15

This is far from normal, in my experience (within the NHS).

Mariposa6 · 06/05/2023 22:11

There are certainly problems with privatisation, but the key reason that services are now so poor, access so difficult and so on, is because there is a huge shortage of GPs. This has been an issue for over a decade but accelerated since covid. Government has known it’s a problem and failed to do anything about it.

Qazwsxefv · 06/05/2023 21:47

So old style Gp partnership is not limited meaning that if the practice went under (as small businesses can do) then the GP will loose their own money/house etc. Since as a GP partnership you have only one choice with whom to have your major client - the nhs - then there is considerable risk taking on a non limited partnership when the nhs can change the contact unilaterally whenever they want meaning that if the government changes the amount or way they pay and the partnership fails the GPs family looses their home. The government keeps on saying it’s going to reform general practice , no one knows what that means but I sure don’t want my family home as collateral in whatever reorganisation occurs. e.g labour wants to make everyone salaried employees - if your a current or potential GP partner with a mortgage on the surgery or other debts in the partnership and the government decides to scrap all that - your left with a load of debt and no business. This means that GPs are looking for non traditional models such as PLCs etc because no one wants to end up homeless because the government change the rules again. That’s not to say that some of the big conglomerates are not out for profit at the expense of care - these aren’t your run of the mill GPs though, these are businesspeople first and GPs second - this is the privatisation of primary care that everyone is warning about

the small old style family GP with one of two partners has already been priced out and stressed out. All the people posting about their little small surgery being taken over by a big one - that’s probably because the small one went bust. Single or two partner practices don’t work anymore as the funding is poor and the risk and workload huge. These big business setting up don’t represent individual GPs selling out patients for more money, they represent small GP practices collapsing and the big firm swooping in to make profit.

the traditional model of Gp is financially, practically and emotionally unsustainable. Yet patients blame the individual GP who has been forced out of the market rather than the system that drove them out.

ForTheSakeOfThePenguin · 06/05/2023 21:24

Ours merged into a group and everything went down the hill very fast, suddenly it was impossible to talk to someone on the phone or trying to get an appointment without having to call every single morning and staying in the queue for hours before the call finished with the message to try again tomorrow.

Having said that, I think it it was the Tories policies and massive budget cutting that forced surgeries to merge. They also cut funding for nursing and medical education with the result that there are less of these professionals around… then Brexit, if we cannot recruit health professionals from abroad and we are not subsidising the training of those in the country no wonder everything is going down the hill.

cptartapp · 06/05/2023 21:17

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 19:25

@cptartapp the smears are already outsourced. Not everyone can afford a home bp machine.

Not everyone.
But if 3/4 can and do, (like most patients I see), it saves hundreds of nursing hours over the year which means people get seen more timely for their cancer injection, their newborn's vaccinations or their recall smear.
I'd be quite happy to sit and BP's, but when there's not enough appointments and not enough nurses, it's prudent to follow national guidance and try and make the best use of our time.
No one wants repeated appointments to keep having a raised BP checked to confirm a diagnosis. The cost of petrol or bus fares back and forth over a few weeks would more than cover the cost of a basic sphygmomanometer. Not to mention the ongoing prescription costs to them of antihypertensives which may not even be necessary.

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 19:36

ApplePiePie · 06/05/2023 16:09

They are now asking patients to buy their own blood pressure machine and tell them the readings instead of running a clinic.

Because it’s more accurate to get an average home blood pressure reading. And BP machines are now more widely available an relative inexpensive

Also there has been changes made to the way pharmacists are trained, the idea being that from 2026 all newly registered pharmacists will also be independent prescribers.

Neighbour borrowed ours to check his BP against our machine because his was reading what he thought was too low. 2 different machines 2 concerningly different BP taken minutes apart. So are the both accurate?
Not everyone can afford them.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread