Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the screwed up NHS is partly the gps doing...

166 replies

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 09:02

Please read before you roast me, sorry it's long and possibly complicated…

Brief timeline
Well before covid hit - gp surgery brilliant
Couple of years before covid, gp merged with large GP group which now covers 3 cities and many many surgeries. - appointments much, much harder to get.
Covid hit- GPs formed a private limited company making themselves directors and running all the vaccinations in the city. Appointments at all surgery’s like hens teeth- scarce- understandable.

Covid, now “over” and the surgery’s haven’t gone back to normal, they have closed smaller practices and outsourcing their work to the Private limited company where all the GPs are still directors and appear to be working. Patients have to wait 3-8 weeks (usually the latter) to get a phone call from their practice GP.

Excuse for closing down smaller surgeries "no receptionists to deal with abusive patients" in reality, all the receptionists moved to the private company, and they advertised for new positions at below national living wage (£9.50ph).

They have outsourced their online and telephone triage system to another company about 200 miles away, so some outsourced GP(?) decides whether you get an appointment or not.

In our city, patients are finding no alternative but to use A&E, Urgent care, Out of hours, Minor injuries (all based at the hospital) after getting frustrated at the lack of service and phoning 111. The hospital are all aware that the increase in patients through their door are from this one GP group, yet they aren’t able to do anything.

So in effect, the gps get paid by the NHS for the (lack of ) service they provide at the nhs surgery, the NHS pay the private company(plc) to run, the GPs then get paid as GPs of the plc and as directors of the plc, they are also shareholders so get dividends all whilst the patients aren’t being physically seen and costing the NHS hospital to see the patients and treat them.
Looked on companies house website and this company has nearly £1.5M in the shareholder (GPs) fund, their creditors and assets equal out and they have £3M in cash in the bank. All whilst putting more pressure and using more resources at the hospitals. Now this amount of money is small compared to the overall cost of the NHS but if you multiply it over the whole country, it would add up especially for one patient the nhs can end up paying 3 times as much than if same patient had just managed to see GP in own surgery.
So am I being unreasonable to think that GPs are partially to blame?

OP posts:
Menora · 07/05/2023 10:00

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 09:20

As an example- the often thrown about accusation that GPs take in money from hitting QOF targets.

those targets are set nationally from evidence of work that improves outcomes for patients eg checking the feet of people with diabetes. Basic annual funding per patient is so small that it cannot cover additional work. Such work costs money-running clinics with trained nurses, documenting contact, running search lists and sending letters or phone calls to book people in etc.
so there is a financial reward attached to achieving the target. If you don’t do the work (properly) you don’t get paid it. If the payment is made then the public are getting the evidence based service.

Yet then people slag off GPs for making QOF money like they are robbing banks! Would you rather the care isn’t offered or should they be doing it for free?

the main complainants of this issue are from two categories:

  1. those who rarely use or need healthcare but when they do, are frustrated by not being able to access it quickly enough
  2. Those who do use it regularly and feel frustrated that things have changed from how it used to be

what everyone seems to expect is fast reactive service to an immediate (acute) need, forgetting about the huge amount of work that has to go into everyone who has a long term condition that needs management all year round, as these are the national targets GP’s don’t choose to do but it’s their main source of income. You cannot survive as a practice without achieving these targets.

The narrative is that people pay their tax so they are entitled to care, but don’t forget, you are actually paying for everyone else’s care now who has more need than you. The young are paying for the elderly care now, not really for themselves, this is how society ends up working. I am also worried about the future, we can no longer view our tax as a long term investment into our own future needs.

When you are acutely unwell or in pain all you want is medical care, understandably, but the reason services aren’t as reactive as people would like is the burden of the elderly and LTC every day, almost hidden work and lack of qualified staff to carry it out.

The point of LTC work is to reduce the strain on hospitals (secondary care) by keeping people well at home for longer. If I could I would have our prescribing nurses seeing all the minor illness all day long and free up some time for GP’s, but I cannot as the nurses need to manage diabetes, asthma, family planning, wound care, injections etc. I also have limited space, so I cannot suddenly recruit more staff as there is nowhere for them to work.

Your GP (partner) will be spending many hours of their day not just seeing patients but they will be: signing prescriptions, writing referrals, talking to consultants, reporting investigation results, reading hospital documents (and adjusting records accordingly), training and supervising staff, managing the business finances, dealing with significant events, working on QOF and essentially dealing with anything complex. they are not hiding at home, they are productive but they are swamped with this hidden work.

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:47

MissyB1 · 07/05/2023 09:43

Part of the problem now is that the public often assume that private services will be better than public. They probably think outsourcing to private companies is going to give them a better service- ahem… I’m afraid it’s often worse. I know lot of the outsourcing is hidden from the public, but it’s amazing how many mumsnetters often seem in favour of privatisation.

But GPs have always been private

Frightenedbunny · 07/05/2023 09:44

@Menora has explained it perfectly as my friends described. Financially they couldn’t survive as stand alone practices.

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:44

Menora · 07/05/2023 09:39

No it’s driven by contract changes. They are merging to share risk, smaller practices cannot cope with some of the contract changes and GP’s are teaching retirement age. It’s meant to be for protective reasons not for ££ reasons. The only feasible way of working now is at scale, hence PCN’s. I work at a big practice so we are managing, but smaller ones are struggling and we are all in a PCN, and without it we would be much worse off

so yes then. GPs are making commercial decisions to merge.

MissyB1 · 07/05/2023 09:43

Part of the problem now is that the public often assume that private services will be better than public. They probably think outsourcing to private companies is going to give them a better service- ahem… I’m afraid it’s often worse. I know lot of the outsourcing is hidden from the public, but it’s amazing how many mumsnetters often seem in favour of privatisation.

Menora · 07/05/2023 09:39

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:35

Presumably it was ‘forced on them’ by the other GPs in the partnership?

No it’s driven by contract changes. They are merging to share risk, smaller practices cannot cope with some of the contract changes and GP’s are teaching retirement age. It’s meant to be for protective reasons not for ££ reasons. The only feasible way of working now is at scale, hence PCN’s. I work at a big practice so we are managing, but smaller ones are struggling and we are all in a PCN, and without it we would be much worse off

bakebeans · 07/05/2023 09:37

the fault here lies with the government. I work in the NHS. Newly qualified nurses start on a lower salary than most other public sector workers. Newly qualified doctors start on £14 an hour. Expected on average to work a 50 hour week.
GP surgeries are struggling to retain GP's. They are all either leaving the profession or going abroad for less abuse and more pay.

Many services have already been outsourced to private companies. Near where I live, the sexual health services and anticoagulant service are both run by private companies not an NHS trust.
Many mental heath services for years have been outsourced to tender to the private companies.

it is going to get worse!

Menora · 07/05/2023 09:36

the reason why they are merging is to share risks, the GP population is ageing out so they are worried about small practices being left with last partner standing. You can’t run a surgery on one partner easily. It circled back to the exact same issue, not enough GP’s and certainly not enough who want to be a partner and take on all the risk, liability and work.

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:35

Frightenedbunny · 07/05/2023 09:31

I have a number of friends who were GP’s. Within the space of 7 years they have all either emigrated to Oz or taken early retirement. Huge conglomerate super surgeries were forced on them as contracts predicted this was the only feasible ways of working. None of them wanted to work this way and it impacted in their mental well-being. There was a huge exodus from all their surgeries as they felt frustration at the restrictions placed upon them.

there is now a shortage of GP’s and surgeries are unable to staff.

Personally, I blame the years of underfunding from the Tory government, not the GP’s who studied many years to practice.

Presumably it was ‘forced on them’ by the other GPs in the partnership?

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:32

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 09:20

As an example- the often thrown about accusation that GPs take in money from hitting QOF targets.

those targets are set nationally from evidence of work that improves outcomes for patients eg checking the feet of people with diabetes. Basic annual funding per patient is so small that it cannot cover additional work. Such work costs money-running clinics with trained nurses, documenting contact, running search lists and sending letters or phone calls to book people in etc.
so there is a financial reward attached to achieving the target. If you don’t do the work (properly) you don’t get paid it. If the payment is made then the public are getting the evidence based service.

Yet then people slag off GPs for making QOF money like they are robbing banks! Would you rather the care isn’t offered or should they be doing it for free?

There might be evidence that if you pay people extra to do something then they are more likely to do it. But there is also evidence that targets distort service delivery negatively as well. The problem is the targets become the focus of care and the underlying contract/service gets neglected in favour of meeting targets. This isn’t just an issue in primary care, it is the same in the acute sector too, and in non-medical sectors.

Frightenedbunny · 07/05/2023 09:31

I have a number of friends who were GP’s. Within the space of 7 years they have all either emigrated to Oz or taken early retirement. Huge conglomerate super surgeries were forced on them as contracts predicted this was the only feasible ways of working. None of them wanted to work this way and it impacted in their mental well-being. There was a huge exodus from all their surgeries as they felt frustration at the restrictions placed upon them.

there is now a shortage of GP’s and surgeries are unable to staff.

Personally, I blame the years of underfunding from the Tory government, not the GP’s who studied many years to practice.

FixTheBone · 07/05/2023 09:28

VeggieSalsa · 06/05/2023 09:09

Do you know this is how all GPs work? They’re never employed by the NHS and always contracted?

I suspect this is driven by the NHS and not the GPs themselves though.

I’m more interested that it’s a plc though, that seems a peculiar choice for the GPs.

This.

This has been happening for well over a decade and is the direct result of making it increasingly financially risky to be a partner in a practice.

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:21

The Tory agenda is to dismantle primary care. Everyone is currently suffering both those within in and those using it. I can assure you that the private outcome that will be with us in a few years will be much much worse.

I get so fed up of these threads that spout ‘Tory Agenda is to make primary care private’ but ignore the fact it has always been private

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 09:20

As an example- the often thrown about accusation that GPs take in money from hitting QOF targets.

those targets are set nationally from evidence of work that improves outcomes for patients eg checking the feet of people with diabetes. Basic annual funding per patient is so small that it cannot cover additional work. Such work costs money-running clinics with trained nurses, documenting contact, running search lists and sending letters or phone calls to book people in etc.
so there is a financial reward attached to achieving the target. If you don’t do the work (properly) you don’t get paid it. If the payment is made then the public are getting the evidence based service.

Yet then people slag off GPs for making QOF money like they are robbing banks! Would you rather the care isn’t offered or should they be doing it for free?

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 09:16

I get so fed up by these threads.

Absolutely services in primary care are not great in many places- some however are brilliant and that if anything fuels the fire of the ones not getting a good service

BUT it’s all the comments from people who know absolutely nothing about how these things are funded and organised, the historical situations and the complex contracts that are in place.

Of course some GPs are maximising income ahead of other things and of course some are more service driven. They are human and as variable as we all are.

But it doesn’t help arguments to improve things when so much bollocks gets spouted by people who claim to know all about it and have clearly just informed themselves via the local FB page and the Daily Mail.

The Tory agenda is to dismantle primary care. Everyone is currently suffering both those within in and those using it. I can assure you that the private outcome that will be with us in a few years will be much much worse.

Anotherusernameagainitseems · 07/05/2023 09:15

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 00:31

GP practices were always private companies. The fact they are now an LLP is a red herring. That was the way the NHS was designed. As well as general medical practitioners (GPs), general ophthalmic practitioners, general dental practitioners and general pharmaceutical practitioners were all set up as private contractors.

The difference now is they are merging into large groups and being bought by private companies. The same is happening with vets. To make profits we are charged more for animal care. They can't do that with the NHS so instead are making profits via poorer service.

Anotherusernameagainitseems · 07/05/2023 09:09

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:25

I feel really sorry for pharmacy. Ours are run off their feet since covid. The Welsh government promoting that we see them and phone them first. So the phone never stops, they're called away to look at a rash etc in what was a walk in cupboard. Many of the staff I've known for years have left. You have to wait minimum 7 days to pick up a repeat. I overheard patients being told that it wasn't in stock, so go back to GP ask for some else or wait and they will order it.

Long queues at pharmacies and you have to say what's wrong on front of the rest of the queue and other shoppers

Riverlee · 07/05/2023 09:05

All gps have private companies and are contracted to run nhs services. They can also earn extra money by reaching QOF targets.

Gps also form groups with other local gps to provide extra services, known as PCNs (Primary care networks). The gps run independently from each other. However, the pcns can get extra funding to employ physiotherapists, pharmacists etc. which all the surgeries can use.

The main problem is there’s too much demand and not enough gps to go around. Many employ other disciplines, advanced nurse practitioners , pharmacists etc to ease the pressure.

I agree that some surgeries are badly run, but a lot are hard working, and trying to do their best.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 09:04

If you can afford it I recommend chiropractor for a bad back, osteopath when your hips are painful. They give you the right specific exercises which help so much to do at home daily. It's better than painkillers.

Menora · 07/05/2023 08:53

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:10

OH has a friend at the marina he said ghost patients were the best ones to have on the books. All the European patients who left after the Brexit stayed registered he said. I guess that helps to cover the cost of the patients who visit regularly

Yes, it does. So that you can cover everyone else. If you live in a fairly nice area, your surgeries will be getting a very low £ per patient. This is why they end up encouraging patient self management, as it’s more cost effective. If you live somewhere like an inner city, it will likely be more £ per patient

If it’s £100 per patient per year, then that is the cost of your visit. Each visit could cost £30-50 for instance (staffing, premises, equipment) so every patient could get 2-3 appts per year. But Mavis with a bad leg needs weekly appts for 3 months. Bob needs a hip replacement and is on a long waiting list so he keeps booking an appt cos he’s in pain. All of their tariff is used up quickly, so you need your young fit healthy population to never visit you. GP’s don’t get paid per contact they get paid per patient and then runs out. They then get paid to manage all the long term conditions and reduce the burden on secondary care. They are asking you to buy your own BP machine because it’s £20, and they assume that people will want to try to take some responsibility for their own health. I am sure you can still book in if you cannot afford a BP machine but those who can, probably should buy one.

We are all also responsible for managing our own health, it is not entirely your GP’s responsibility in the same way it’s not for your child’s school to teach your children absolutely everything about life, it's also you as a parent

Menora · 07/05/2023 08:43

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:07

I've just checked beta company my GP does have a limited company with four others. Interesting there was £467k in the bank

They still don’t pay this directly to themselves, look up how a PCN operates. Their LLC is funded by the work that GP’s do and the contracts they are awarded.

https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-support/gp-practices/primary-care-networks/primary-care-network-funding

A good PCN passes back some of the funding to practices, they also invest in other local initiatives to improve access, support GP practices, local population (services you wouldn’t usually get from a GP, like physiotherapy). They can’t sit on this money forever, they have to justify exactly how the £ is spent to the ICB by a deadline. So if they pass it back to the practice the practices have to justify what it was spent on, for what reason and it has to fit into one of the improvement categories

GP practice article illustration

Primary care network funding

Information on the amended DES (direct enhanced service), the additional roles reimbursement scheme, the investment and impact fund and financial entitlements for PCNs.

https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-support/gp-practices/primary-care-networks/primary-care-network-funding

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 07/05/2023 08:14

Our Gp used to be a great surgery but also became part of a larger group and now it's very difficult to get an appointment

Qazwsxefv · 07/05/2023 08:12

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:07

I've just checked beta company my GP does have a limited company with four others. Interesting there was £467k in the bank

Sorry my above was in reply to this post. Quote function glitchy

Qazwsxefv · 07/05/2023 08:11

so your GP practice is solvent…

how much do you think a medium sized company with a large premises to rent and maintain and probably about 60 employees (salaried doctors, receptionists, manager, typists, nurses, pharmacists, HCAs, physio, cleaners) to pay the wages of should have in the bank?

Kazzyhoward · 07/05/2023 08:09

cptartapp · 07/05/2023 08:01

Who would be charged? Everyone? Pensioners? (many of whom are very well off), Children? Those on benefits? Basically all those who get free prescriptions?
Or just the poor sods in the middle yet again.

Yep, like Poll tax in the 80s, there'll be so many exemptions that the poor sods in the middle end up paying more.