Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the screwed up NHS is partly the gps doing...

166 replies

seriouslygardening · 06/05/2023 09:02

Please read before you roast me, sorry it's long and possibly complicated…

Brief timeline
Well before covid hit - gp surgery brilliant
Couple of years before covid, gp merged with large GP group which now covers 3 cities and many many surgeries. - appointments much, much harder to get.
Covid hit- GPs formed a private limited company making themselves directors and running all the vaccinations in the city. Appointments at all surgery’s like hens teeth- scarce- understandable.

Covid, now “over” and the surgery’s haven’t gone back to normal, they have closed smaller practices and outsourcing their work to the Private limited company where all the GPs are still directors and appear to be working. Patients have to wait 3-8 weeks (usually the latter) to get a phone call from their practice GP.

Excuse for closing down smaller surgeries "no receptionists to deal with abusive patients" in reality, all the receptionists moved to the private company, and they advertised for new positions at below national living wage (£9.50ph).

They have outsourced their online and telephone triage system to another company about 200 miles away, so some outsourced GP(?) decides whether you get an appointment or not.

In our city, patients are finding no alternative but to use A&E, Urgent care, Out of hours, Minor injuries (all based at the hospital) after getting frustrated at the lack of service and phoning 111. The hospital are all aware that the increase in patients through their door are from this one GP group, yet they aren’t able to do anything.

So in effect, the gps get paid by the NHS for the (lack of ) service they provide at the nhs surgery, the NHS pay the private company(plc) to run, the GPs then get paid as GPs of the plc and as directors of the plc, they are also shareholders so get dividends all whilst the patients aren’t being physically seen and costing the NHS hospital to see the patients and treat them.
Looked on companies house website and this company has nearly £1.5M in the shareholder (GPs) fund, their creditors and assets equal out and they have £3M in cash in the bank. All whilst putting more pressure and using more resources at the hospitals. Now this amount of money is small compared to the overall cost of the NHS but if you multiply it over the whole country, it would add up especially for one patient the nhs can end up paying 3 times as much than if same patient had just managed to see GP in own surgery.
So am I being unreasonable to think that GPs are partially to blame?

OP posts:
Parker231 · 07/05/2023 18:59

Florenz · 07/05/2023 18:50

No more letters, they are ridiculously inefficient. All communication to be by text or email.

A significant number of appointments are taken by the elderly who wouldn’t necessarily be able to access emails or texts

Againstmachine · 07/05/2023 18:59

Florenz · 07/05/2023 18:57

I think there'd be a lot less late appointments if people had to pay for them.

So no you aren't answering my question as every gp appointment I've had has been late

Florenz · 07/05/2023 18:57

Againstmachine · 07/05/2023 18:54

You didn't answer if they are going to pay me back for being late. Or is their time more important.

I think there'd be a lot less late appointments if people had to pay for them.

Againstmachine · 07/05/2023 18:54

Florenz · 07/05/2023 18:50

No more letters, they are ridiculously inefficient. All communication to be by text or email.

You didn't answer if they are going to pay me back for being late. Or is their time more important.

Florenz · 07/05/2023 18:50

Againstmachine · 07/05/2023 14:00

So are they going to pay me back when I have to wait past the time for my appointment.

You do realize a lot of hospital appointments are missed due to them being moved multiple times and the patient not informed or letters not reaching in time.

No more letters, they are ridiculously inefficient. All communication to be by text or email.

Florenz · 07/05/2023 18:48

cptartapp · 07/05/2023 08:01

Who would be charged? Everyone? Pensioners? (many of whom are very well off), Children? Those on benefits? Basically all those who get free prescriptions?
Or just the poor sods in the middle yet again.

No exceptions. Everyone pays.

TizerorFizz · 07/05/2023 18:22

My GPS run 3 practices but only 9 GPS are partners. The others are employed. There’s 9 partners and 17 salaried and registrar gps. Not a single one is available 5 days a week. Not one. Therefore you just see a GP. You have no relationship with any of them. That went out of the window decades ago. Its fair to say it’s not a bad practice.

My DM also has a partnership gp service. It’s atrocious. They are not willing to fund a new surgery. It’s still in an old house with stairs. It’s lit of the dark ages. It hasn’t changed since before the NHS was founded when the house belonged to a doctor. Continual complaints get residents nowhere. Poor care is standard and it upsets a lot of elderly patients who find it unfriendly and uncaring. Every other village and town has a more modern surgery. I find it incredible that they won’t invest when everyone else has.

LakieLady · 07/05/2023 16:44

I've just looked up my GP practice at Companies House. It was 4 separate practices, but they all merged into one big one approx 5 years ago.

The 3 directors applied to have the company struck off on 24 March, and haven't filed accounts since Feb 21. I suspect they may have sold the company to one of these big health providers.

Qazwsxefv · 07/05/2023 15:36

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:44

so yes then. GPs are making commercial decisions to merge.

Well if the options are merge or go under then merge is what happens. It’s not really a choice, the merged practice is maybe offering worse care but if the old practice folds then there is no care.

old style GPs are a partnership private business with a contract with the nhs to provide medical care to patients registered with them. The financial risk to the partners is unlimited. The medicolegal risk not just for the Gp partners own work but that of all staff in the practice (nurses/HCAs/receptionists) etcis only partly covered by the nhs (dvla stuff, benefits stuff, sick notes etc are not nhs covered).

if your local hospital owes money no one sends dept collectors round to the chief executives house trying to take his TV to cover the dept. If hospital goes into dept (and most are) it can still pay the wages of its nurses and receptionists as the government bails them out. The GP partner can well have debt collectors after their own stuff, they are responsible for the livelihoods of their staff, many I know when times get hard pay the staff out of their own money. If a nurse makes a mistake and it’s not nhs covered the GP partners are financially responsible for their mistakes.

the media will have you believe that GPs are all earning loads of money but infact recently small practices just keep on being non viable financially - it’s not a desire to sell out to make big money elsewhere it’s that the small practices can’t survive - they can’t pay the rent/wage bill/insurance anymore so they have to sell out or merge. If you can’t pay the staff or the rent you can’t continue.

Imagine an independent coffee shop near you. It’s run by a couple of friends who took out a loan secured on their own houses to set it up. They’ve been doing it for years and did have a loyal local support base, they tried to help out locally by doing free coffees for homeless people and letting groups meet in the shop but now costs have gone up, inflation is high and they want to be good employers so wages are going up, the sanitary inspectors demanding that they have some fancy ultra cleaning machine they can’t afford to keep their 5* hygiene rating and that everyone they employ needs to go on a fancy diversity course, and the customers are all complaining that they don’t have a fancy online ordering app like costa does. They try and innovate and appeal for help from government but are told they that they’re greedy and lazy. Customers seem upset all the time and get shouty with the barista becuase they haven’t heard of a double frozen extra hot no cream frapac-mocha-chino. The friends realise they can no longer break even and have mounting debt. They worry that their staff will all loose their jobs And they will loose their homes. They sadly decide costa to pay off their debts and to ensure their staff continue to have jobs and the people still get coffee.

would you blame the coffee shop owner for being a greedy fat cat who didn’t care about their staff or customers or would you realise that they have tried to make a business work and it has failed and they have made the only choice they have to survive?

General practice is in crisis. The sort of old style GP partnership people seem to want is not viable financially. Yes a GP can make loads of money setting up some sort of mega-corporation but that’s not what most are doing - these mega corporations only have a few CEOs after all. Most GPs are struggling in small practices or if/when that collapses they leave and go work abroad or for a mega-GP-corp not as a boss but as an employee making reasonable not eye watering money (60-80k per year full time) They actually earn less than when in partnership but don’t have to worry about running a business

Againstmachine · 07/05/2023 14:00

Florenz · 06/05/2023 22:28

There needs to be an excess payable for everything to deter people from missing appts or making unnecessary visits to the GP. £20 for a GP appt. £50 for a hospital appt. Nor refund under any circumstances. Reduce NI accordingly.

So are they going to pay me back when I have to wait past the time for my appointment.

You do realize a lot of hospital appointments are missed due to them being moved multiple times and the patient not informed or letters not reaching in time.

ForTheSakeOfThePenguin · 07/05/2023 13:57

Kazzyhoward · 07/05/2023 07:27

@ForTheSakeOfThePenguin

Having said that, I think it it was the Tories policies and massive budget cutting that forced surgeries to merge.

Nope, like a lot of current NHS problems it started under Blair. Our old GP surgery sold out back in 2003 and formed a "chain" of all the surgeries in our town. Service standards plummeted immediately. Our next nearest town followed a couple of years later. You can no longer go to your nearest surgery nor see the same GP. If you want an appointment you are allocated a random GP in a random surgery. That's been the case for the last 20 years around here.

I always find it quite “Trumpish” that we have had 5 Tory prime ministers since Labour was last in power but someway it is always Labour’s fault 😁

Pity that those 5 Tory PMs have not done anything for the economy apart of making it far far worse.

Againstmachine · 07/05/2023 13:56

I hate my local GPs with a passion, they withheld scans from my mum stating she couldn't have cancer again after having a hysterectomy when a quick google told me it is very possible. And it did happen. My mum got admitted to hospital eventually and was asked by them there why she hadn't had a scan depsite going to the GPs numerous times.

GPs withhold referrals like they are gods, there are story's every day of them ignoring patients illnesses

Would earlier intervention saved my mum I don't know but she shouldn't have had to wait so long.

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 13:14

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 12:44

I worked in the hospice in Wales and it did happen.

OH friend was part of the committee who reviewed the case and put forward the recommendations.

It would not have been based on two expected deaths in 24 hours. Something must have been specifically amiss or concerns raised so you cannot extrapolate that to usual practice and to do so is misleading and causes distress to families.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 12:51

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 11:22

Was replying to this load of rubbish

You're just unpleasant. Not one word is untrue I attended his funeral. The other a family member. Our family is awash with NHS staff. Nurses GPs and two consultants. I worked in a hospice.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 12:44

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 11:21

The police do not visit a hospice because two patients die in a 24 hour period. That is a ridiculous comment and totally untrue. Honestly why make up stuff like that?

Harold Shipman impacted regulation mainly in the form of appraisal.

Stories like those from Gosport thankfully made clinicians More aware of the issues of anticipatory prescribing and overall the medical examiner service has increased workload but will no doubt have benefits on better documentation and feedback of issues.

I worked in the hospice in Wales and it did happen.

OH friend was part of the committee who reviewed the case and put forward the recommendations.

RagzRebooted · 07/05/2023 12:25

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 00:07

I've just checked beta company my GP does have a limited company with four others. Interesting there was £467k in the bank

The company that runs our surgery group is over 2 million in debt, but they've only been running a few years and they tend to take over financially struggling practices.

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 11:22

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 10:20

Years ago my GP had a heart attack in his thirties. It was the workload, home visit, nighttime call outs plus normal surgery.

Another one who did this was burnt out early, retired died in his sixties.

The paperwork is horrendous Harold Shipman added an extra layer. If our hospice loses two patients in a 24 hour period the police visit.

The NHS with chronic conditions reaches a point where they can't do any more for a patient. My GP said it would save the NHS money if they block booked hotels for some patients in the winter in warmer climates

Was replying to this load of rubbish

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 11:21

The police do not visit a hospice because two patients die in a 24 hour period. That is a ridiculous comment and totally untrue. Honestly why make up stuff like that?

Harold Shipman impacted regulation mainly in the form of appraisal.

Stories like those from Gosport thankfully made clinicians More aware of the issues of anticipatory prescribing and overall the medical examiner service has increased workload but will no doubt have benefits on better documentation and feedback of issues.

MissyB1 · 07/05/2023 10:45

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:47

But GPs have always been private

Sorry I was referring more to the contracting out of other NHS services.

But actually I remember the “new” GP contract when it came into force and I foresaw a lot of problems then.

cptartapp · 07/05/2023 10:40

Menora agree with your pp.
And a large % of practice nurses will be retiring in the next few years. We had two go in February (early) and had two applicants in total who we've had to take on.
One a paramedic who is completely out his depth and an ex district nurse. Myself and my colleague will be well retired before she's fully trained up.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 10:36

To big fanfare an old primary school was transformed into a surgery minor operation unit. three surgeries merged. It all fell apart the GPs argued and left. It's now run by the health board using locums and isn't open some days. The principal idea was good was but GPs banging heads wasn't

RagzRebooted · 07/05/2023 10:23

Stinkymalinkyfromdownthelane · 06/05/2023 09:37

Lots of gps surgeries are now owned by private healthcare groups. They are running surgeries and dictating how and when you see a dr. These private healthcare companies are making a fortune out of the NHS. You are seeing profit over health.

This. I work for one that was a traditional partnership model when I started, but because they put patients first and didn't care about the money, they weren't really making any and couldn't get new partners. They sold the business to a fairly new Primary Care company that is apparently non-profit (but pays an awful lot of managers to sit around in virtual meetings working on 'transformation') and they have really changed the environment. Half our salaried GPs have left to join partnerships elsewhere. We can't get new GPs because no one wants to work for the company when they can work in a traditional practice and maybe be partner one day.

justasking111 · 07/05/2023 10:20

Years ago my GP had a heart attack in his thirties. It was the workload, home visit, nighttime call outs plus normal surgery.

Another one who did this was burnt out early, retired died in his sixties.

The paperwork is horrendous Harold Shipman added an extra layer. If our hospice loses two patients in a 24 hour period the police visit.

The NHS with chronic conditions reaches a point where they can't do any more for a patient. My GP said it would save the NHS money if they block booked hotels for some patients in the winter in warmer climates

BananaHam · 07/05/2023 10:17

Sympathies to you OP.

I feel fortunate my GP is on the whole very good, if you raise a request you will get a call back same day at the very least. Face to face appointments are hard to get but apart from things like smears, vaccinations etc I've always been fine with a phone consultation... never had an issue getting a script, referral etc from a phone consultation. Keeping the in person appointments for those who really need it is fine & my gp seems to get the balance right

Only complaint is they used to not let you book nurse appointments online (like vaccinations etc) but now they do let us!

Menora · 07/05/2023 10:01

Shelefttheweb · 07/05/2023 09:44

so yes then. GPs are making commercial decisions to merge.

Driven by contract changes, GP’s don’t set their own contract