Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread gallery
66
Novella4 · 08/05/2023 19:48

What a climb down .
And quick too.
Symon Hill was arrested at a proclamation after Elizabeth died.
His crime ?
Saying 'who elected him?' aloud

He waited weeks to be told no charge

It is better to be part of an organisation. They pick off individuals too easily

Novella4 · 08/05/2023 19:44

The international reputational damage will be hard to repair

The image of two elderly people , tired and hobbling with the gaudy crowns full of stolen gems is just too perfect a metaphor for the monarchy itself in 2023

Combined with the outrageous treatment of peaceful ( but annoyingly informed and articulate ) protesters - so much for the 'soft power ' line

Oblomov23 · 08/05/2023 19:43

I can't believe this new law. Disgusting.

vera99 · 08/05/2023 19:40

Yup but they couldn't stop a couple of thousands of others coming along and the furore that arbitrarily arresting the leaders would cause. Had they left them to the screened off area in Trafalgar Square separated from the crowds effectively they would have been mostly ignored by the media, and it would be seen as an honourable example of the plurality of dissent in Britain and the sign of a healthy democracy.

The real danger for the monarchy now is that a broad coalition of the disaffected, which is growing all the time will see the institution as a lightning rod for their anger. A reverse Jeremy Corbyn for the young as it were facing protests wherever they go. Charles missed the perfect opportunity to have a truly slimmed down succession and try to pivot to the European model.

pointythings · 08/05/2023 19:27

@vera99 I reckon this was always the plan - stop them from demonstrating, put on a show of force and then quietly not charge anyone. Pour encourager les autres and all that.

vera99 · 08/05/2023 19:23

The Last King ? Led by Donkeys have joined the movement.

Charles the Last?

It's time for a national conversation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHmR5UPcaVo

JenniferBooth · 08/05/2023 19:20

They got them out of the way for the Coronation. So mission accomplished.

The litmus test will be whether they act in the same way the next time XR or Just Stop Oil block a road and stop people from going to work or medical appointments.

vera99 · 08/05/2023 19:03

Graham Smith and the other Republic leaders have been told there will be no further action. Looks like it was a misjudged operational decision that has backfired in terms of long term outcomes. I can't imagine the Met wishing to have increased support for Republic which is what has happened.

https://twitter.com/GrahamSmith_/status/1655627714395615243

We have just been told that the police will be taking no further action. This has been a disgraceful episode and we will be speaking to lawyers about taking legal action. I also expect a full inquiry into why they repeatedly lied to us and who authorised the arrests.

https://twitter.com/GrahamSmith_/status/1655627714395615243

cakeorwine · 08/05/2023 18:23

This is an interesting article on non-violent protest

Why Non-Violent Protests Work | Psychology Today

Lots of things that are relevant to the police actions.

"So, while the protesters might be rioting because they feel they have important needs that aren’t being met (seeking to achieve them via violence, or the threat of it), third parties might come to view the damage inflicted by the protest as being more important or harmful (as they generate a larger, or more legitimate need).
The net result of that violence is now that third parties side against the protesters, rather than with them.

By contrast, a nonviolent protest does not create as large a need on the part of those it targets; it doesn’t destroy property or harm people.

If the protesters have needs they want to see met and they aren’t inflicting costs on others, this can yield more support for the protester’s side.

However, as we have seen, violence against others, even disagreeable others, who are not themselves behaving violently can rally support from third parties, as they might begin to worry that threats to free speech (or other important issues) are more harmful than the opinions and words we find disagreeable (again, hitting someone creates more need than talking does).

Why Non-Violent Protests Work

Violence creates needs in others, reducing your side's social support.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/pop-psych/201702/why-non-violent-protests-work

OP posts:
LadyWithLapdog · 08/05/2023 18:14

Tienanmen square protest wasn’t great for traffic either.

cakeorwine · 08/05/2023 18:09

Gandhi used a lot of non violence in his protests. I wonder what would happen if the protestors didn't lock on but just allowed themselves to be dragged away?

I don't think holding up traffic helps anyone's cause. It can seek to alienate people from a cause and can cause very negative headlines.

I wonder what the current Tory party would have done with Gandhi if they were still ruling India?

OP posts:
IClaudine · 08/05/2023 18:00

pointythings · 08/05/2023 16:47

@GoldenRetriever4 it doesn't matter that one group gave the police 'an excuse'. The new law was drafted in the knowledge that it would be used exactly as it was on Saturday. And that would have happened anyway because we have a party in government who will not tolerate dissent. They brought in voter ID to suppress votes for the opposition, they brought in the new law on protests to suppress protests against their corruption and their policies. This government knows what it's doing and intends to do it. They need no excuses.

Yep.

Also, to accomplish change, some protests will be disruptive! The suffragettes did not win votes for women by protesting politely.

Roussette · 08/05/2023 17:22

@vera99 Thank you for the link. Graham Smith who has been completely reasonable with this for 2 decades, and has been interviewed on many of the main news channels over the years... he put it very well.

vera99 · 08/05/2023 16:59

Graham Smith as ever makes a wonderfully reasonable and articulate account of his arrest and the events that led up to it. Their membership and funding has increased by 10s of thousands, and they have spearheaded the debate of how we govern our country and who rules us. He is very brave as a huge amount of pressure will no doubt bear down on the leadership team from the forces of the state now. But rather than caving in he seems invigorated by the public;'s response to what happened. Camilla looked very tired last night at the concert I'm not sure that she has the energy and stamina for the role she had been catapulted into. We shall see. If the 'constitutional' monarchy can't take an unfolding landscape of ongoing persistent peaceful protest then it doesn't deserve to continue to exist in a democratic free society.

Anti-monarchy arrests are 'affront to democracy' - Graham Smith

"We've had four months of conversationswith the police... we were immediately surrounded by large numbers of police officers who detained us then arrested us...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Iz6OxRWrdM

pointythings · 08/05/2023 16:47

@GoldenRetriever4 it doesn't matter that one group gave the police 'an excuse'. The new law was drafted in the knowledge that it would be used exactly as it was on Saturday. And that would have happened anyway because we have a party in government who will not tolerate dissent. They brought in voter ID to suppress votes for the opposition, they brought in the new law on protests to suppress protests against their corruption and their policies. This government knows what it's doing and intends to do it. They need no excuses.

GoldenRetriever4 · 08/05/2023 16:17

@pointythings

Republic weren’t planning a disruptive protest, which is the key point here. There should be a distinction in my view between those who want to protest in a non-disruptive way and extremists like Extinction Rebellion, who are counter-productive.

These groups are giving the police and government an excuse to treat all protesters the same, which is of no benefit to anyone. Imo it is right that those who block traffic are arrested and dealt with, but the police should not be targeting those behaving peacefully.

pointythings · 08/05/2023 16:04

@GoldenRetriever4 you're still doing Minority Report. We do not arrest people for things they haven't done yet. We do not arrest people because a completely different group of people have done things that are unacceptable.

And protests are supposed to be disruptive, as are strikes. They'd be pointless otherwise.

Novella4 · 08/05/2023 16:01

Republic protest peacefully

They liaise with the police and had informed the police every step of the way .

This whole PR Charles party nonsense is paid for by the tax payer .

Royalists can cheer and wave
People who object can boo and chant
Except that isn't what happened . The police issues a statement saying 'tolerance ' would be low for any protest
The world must have a certain image of how we all support the monarchy when we do not

Meanwhile on this most precious of days , so precious that peaceful protestors must be stopped, Charles and Camilla appear on American Idol in a tacky awkward AF 'skit'

GoldenRetriever4 · 08/05/2023 15:17

Sorry, extremists like just stop oil blocking roads are not helping and are giving the media and right-wing politicians reason to crack down on protest.

I am all for the right to protest but in my view that cannot include to disrupt traffic and people trying to go about their business.

SofiaSoFar · 08/05/2023 13:31

IClaudine · 08/05/2023 12:05

Just Stop Oil now holding a protest
twitter.com/JustStop_Oil/status/1655526684790071299?s=20

What a delightful man in the Range Rover in that vid, shouting "cunts!" with a young child in the car next to him.

IClaudine · 08/05/2023 12:05

Just Stop Oil now holding a protest
twitter.com/JustStop_Oil/status/1655526684790071299?s=20

OP posts:
3dogsandarabbit · 08/05/2023 11:43

Novella4 - There's also republicans who have no idea about the Coronation. People thinking that the crowns were especially made for the day, that the robes and garments King Charles wore were all especially made for the day, that the coach is made of solid gold, etc. This is just some of the nonsense I have read over the last few weeks/days.

SofiaSoFar · 08/05/2023 11:37

I can't imagine for a moment what the Met police would have against rape alarms.

🤐

IClaudine · 08/05/2023 11:37

And the Met didn't even have the decency to appear on the programme to explain themselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread