Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread gallery
66
HoldingTheDoor · 06/05/2023 10:43

Imagine, a 'peaceful' protestor throws something, either at someone or deliberately at one of the horses. The horse spooks and throws his rider off, who is seriously injured upon landing. Other horses panic. One careers towards the barrier, behind which is a large crowd of members of the public. Because the police officers standing guard and the barrier can do fuck all against that much horse flesh, the public panic and run. People get trampled in all the chaos, possibly to death. All because the police trusted protestors to be peaceful. It could happen. With so many people present, a lot of people could get harmed if the protestors aren't as peaceful as they make out to be, or drunken idiots join in for the crack, or people pretend to be peaceful protestors but are actually there to just cause a much harm to other people are possible turn up. But hey, who cares if dozens of people get injured, possibly even killed as long as we are able to exercise our human right to protest, eh?

Alright, Chicken Little. Enough with the hyperbole.

And now I'm going to have Imagine stuck in my head for the rest of the day.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 06/05/2023 10:41

polkadotdalmation · 06/05/2023 09:40

@cakeorwine So you don't think a megaphone blaring in your ears or a sign blocking the view, is disruptive.?

If you went to a paid concert and people behaved like this, would you feel that's fine.

Peaceful protest is not an issue for anyone. Megaphones are not peaceful.

You are missing the point - even peaceful protests are meant to be disruptive. A protest that isn't is just a mild objection.

Were you also one of the people complaining that the strikes were inconvenient?

Againstmachine · 06/05/2023 10:41

cocoloco117 · 06/05/2023 10:39

Absolutely right and proper, it’s times like these that remind us of the police’s important role in maintaining law and order, which is, as always, first and foremost to protect the interests of the rich and powerful.

I'd expect nothing less from the MET.

Roussette · 06/05/2023 10:40

Prescottdanni123 · 06/05/2023 10:37

Imagine, a 'peaceful' protestor throws something, either at someone or deliberately at one of the horses. The horse spooks and throws his rider off, who is seriously injured upon landing. Other horses panic. One careers towards the barrier, behind which is a large crowd of members of the public. Because the police officers standing guard and the barrier can do fuck all against that much horse flesh, the public panic and run. People get trampled in all the chaos, possibly to death. All because the police trusted protestors to be peaceful. It could happen. With so many people present, a lot of people could get harmed if the protestors aren't as peaceful as they make out to be, or drunken idiots join in for the crack, or people pretend to be peaceful protestors but are actually there to just cause a much harm to other people are possible turn up. But hey, who cares if dozens of people get injured, possibly even killed as long as we are able to exercise our human right to protest, eh?

Their designated area agreed with the Police would not allow that to happen.

It's not about trusting the Protestors. It's about the Police agreeing where they could stand in advance then ambushing them.

Are you saying no one should protest about anything any more?

cocoloco117 · 06/05/2023 10:40

Prescottdanni123 · 06/05/2023 10:37

Imagine, a 'peaceful' protestor throws something, either at someone or deliberately at one of the horses. The horse spooks and throws his rider off, who is seriously injured upon landing. Other horses panic. One careers towards the barrier, behind which is a large crowd of members of the public. Because the police officers standing guard and the barrier can do fuck all against that much horse flesh, the public panic and run. People get trampled in all the chaos, possibly to death. All because the police trusted protestors to be peaceful. It could happen. With so many people present, a lot of people could get harmed if the protestors aren't as peaceful as they make out to be, or drunken idiots join in for the crack, or people pretend to be peaceful protestors but are actually there to just cause a much harm to other people are possible turn up. But hey, who cares if dozens of people get injured, possibly even killed as long as we are able to exercise our human right to protest, eh?

Imagine, if the sky falls on our heads

Againstmachine · 06/05/2023 10:40

Prescottdanni123 · 06/05/2023 10:37

Imagine, a 'peaceful' protestor throws something, either at someone or deliberately at one of the horses. The horse spooks and throws his rider off, who is seriously injured upon landing. Other horses panic. One careers towards the barrier, behind which is a large crowd of members of the public. Because the police officers standing guard and the barrier can do fuck all against that much horse flesh, the public panic and run. People get trampled in all the chaos, possibly to death. All because the police trusted protestors to be peaceful. It could happen. With so many people present, a lot of people could get harmed if the protestors aren't as peaceful as they make out to be, or drunken idiots join in for the crack, or people pretend to be peaceful protestors but are actually there to just cause a much harm to other people are possible turn up. But hey, who cares if dozens of people get injured, possibly even killed as long as we are able to exercise our human right to protest, eh?

All these what ifs, if a horse is that prone it shouldn't be there, but you are just chucking silly scenarios out there.

cocoloco117 · 06/05/2023 10:39

Absolutely right and proper, it’s times like these that remind us of the police’s important role in maintaining law and order, which is, as always, first and foremost to protect the interests of the rich and powerful.

Roussette · 06/05/2023 10:38

thanksamillion · 06/05/2023 10:36

As far as I can tell the narrative that they weren't where they'd agreed to be is false. They were unloading the van and it's entirely possible that was a little way from the agreed point. I imagine it's fairly hard to get a vehicle anywhere in central London today.

Their Twitter is saying that they are on the other side of the monument that they were expecting to be but that is hardly a long way away! If they'd wholeheartedly moved it would be tricky for the many supporters to find them - it wouldn't be in their interest. They have been very open all week about where they'd be and have had multiple meetings with authorities to agree it!

Thank you

I am correct then. They were arrested for getting out of a van and opening the back. There are photos to prove this.

Prescottdanni123 · 06/05/2023 10:37

Imagine, a 'peaceful' protestor throws something, either at someone or deliberately at one of the horses. The horse spooks and throws his rider off, who is seriously injured upon landing. Other horses panic. One careers towards the barrier, behind which is a large crowd of members of the public. Because the police officers standing guard and the barrier can do fuck all against that much horse flesh, the public panic and run. People get trampled in all the chaos, possibly to death. All because the police trusted protestors to be peaceful. It could happen. With so many people present, a lot of people could get harmed if the protestors aren't as peaceful as they make out to be, or drunken idiots join in for the crack, or people pretend to be peaceful protestors but are actually there to just cause a much harm to other people are possible turn up. But hey, who cares if dozens of people get injured, possibly even killed as long as we are able to exercise our human right to protest, eh?

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/05/2023 10:37

pointythings · 06/05/2023 09:45

These arrests are extremely Minority Report. No crime has been committed. No law has been broken. And yet people have been arrested, and the comments on here are terrifying in their sheep-like obedience.

This 100%.

Mind you, as an Irish person who remembers internment, it's not exactly without precedence in the UK.

Erex · 06/05/2023 10:36

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 10:31

Lol, there’s a lot more to the story than “arrested for getting out of a van”
😅

Apparently they and the van were not where they agreed if the reports on here are anything to go by.

I’ll take my chances on the “no protest day” after all this day is 1 in 25,550 days. The odds are in my favour.

I don’t find child safety ridiculous at all. Children have been trampled to death in peaceful protests.

"Apparently"... "if the reports are anything to go by"...

Well, no. If you're this happy to go along with arrests for protesting, you have to deal with facts, not a MNer posting what happened.

Apparently @HadalyEve is planning to disrupt the coronation as a protest against the monarchy! - See, easy as that.

But it sounds like as long as you aren't affected, it's okay in your eyes.

Tarantullah · 06/05/2023 10:36

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 10:35

Fuck off with the hyperbole, it's offensive

People get arrested for protesting in those countries.

Granted we don't get long jail sentences. I think it's 6 months now but it can be more if it's disruptive.

Oh - and unlimited fines as well.

And yet it's nothing like the reality in those countries.

thanksamillion · 06/05/2023 10:36

As far as I can tell the narrative that they weren't where they'd agreed to be is false. They were unloading the van and it's entirely possible that was a little way from the agreed point. I imagine it's fairly hard to get a vehicle anywhere in central London today.

Their Twitter is saying that they are on the other side of the monument that they were expecting to be but that is hardly a long way away! If they'd wholeheartedly moved it would be tricky for the many supporters to find them - it wouldn't be in their interest. They have been very open all week about where they'd be and have had multiple meetings with authorities to agree it!

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 10:35

Fuck off with the hyperbole, it's offensive

People get arrested for protesting in those countries.

Granted we don't get long jail sentences. I think it's 6 months now but it can be more if it's disruptive.

Oh - and unlimited fines as well.

OP posts:
pointythings · 06/05/2023 10:35

themessygarden · 06/05/2023 10:34

Honestly, all the main newspapers in Europe (at least), appear to not be giving the arrests any profile, maybe that will change after the coronation is over. But is is incorrect to say the arrests are being 'widely reported' abroad.

As evidenced by the links posted by myself and others, this is quite simply not true.

Roussette · 06/05/2023 10:35

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 10:31

Lol, there’s a lot more to the story than “arrested for getting out of a van”
😅

Apparently they and the van were not where they agreed if the reports on here are anything to go by.

I’ll take my chances on the “no protest day” after all this day is 1 in 25,550 days. The odds are in my favour.

I don’t find child safety ridiculous at all. Children have been trampled to death in peaceful protests.

No there isn't. Have you seen the footage? I have. You haven't. It was 5 people very early this morning from Republic. Please link to the report that says they were where they shouldn't be. I'm all over this and have not seen it. I follow Republic and they have put out statements about what happened.

I would worry more about the fervent Royalists trampling children to death as they try to get a glimpse of a gold carriage. Than the 0.1% of protesters.

Anyway, you don't believe in free speech, that much is obvious.

North Korea here we come. We'll all be obliged to hang a portrait of Charles soon.... oh hang on... that's happened...

2ManyPjs · 06/05/2023 10:35

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 10:22

Good. They should be arrested. The Coronation isn’t a pro-monarchy protest with the Republican “not my king” people as counter protesters being unlawfully suppressed.

There is no right for them to be there at the coronation and to disrupt it. There is no such right to protest in a way that causes a public order offence.

And it should be applauded that this is being kept as a protest free day especially since the Coronation is a family event with children present. It’s a safeguarding issue if you allow pop up protests around children.

Lady Victoria Hervey has entered the chat.

I find this kind of anti-democracy argument utterly terrifying.

pointythings · 06/05/2023 10:35

As for it not being reported in the UK national press, that's just laughable. It's on every front page.

themessygarden · 06/05/2023 10:34

Honestly, all the main newspapers in Europe (at least), appear to not be giving the arrests any profile, maybe that will change after the coronation is over. But is is incorrect to say the arrests are being 'widely reported' abroad.

Tarantullah · 06/05/2023 10:34

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 10:32

Apparently they and the van were not where they agreed if the reports on here are anything to go by

Can you hear yourself?

Do we live in North Korea or Russia?

Fuck off with the hyperbole, it's offensive. I agree there are many problematic things being pushed through parliament and the police are highly questionable, but people who flippantly use these 2 countries of which are highly repressive is ridiculous.

Againstmachine · 06/05/2023 10:34

Good old Met police, heavy handed yet again, wonder when these lessons that have been learnt, are going to actually learn from their mistakes.

The met police are a vile bunch these days.

Whaeanui · 06/05/2023 10:33

@HadalyEve I don’t find child safety ridiculous at all. Children have been trampled to death in peaceful protests. Where? Here in the uk?

fundhermental · 06/05/2023 10:33

The local elections were a couple of days ago too tories losing hundreds of seats but the focus is on the coronation where no one will benefit, only Charles playing King with his untaxed wealth. Local elections are not a big thing but it clearly shows a huge sign where the general election will be heading but of course there shouldn't be any time to process all of this.