Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread gallery
66
Deathbyfluffy · 06/05/2023 16:22

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 09:17

Distrust in the police is low. This just serves to make it lower. And to make people angrier.

Surely you mean trust in the police is low?
Distrust being low is a good thing

pointythings · 06/05/2023 16:22

I think most people in the UK do not understand just how far the new bill goes. And they won't find out until they want to protest for something they believe in.

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:21

DuncinToffee · 06/05/2023 16:19

They weren't arrested for thinking 'not my king' aloud?

“Thinking out loud” is a type of speaking, not thinking. And no they were not arrested for either of them.

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:21

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:18

Then that is an issue of criminal speech or writing, ie like hate speech. You can think all day long the worst things but when you say it or write it, the crime isn’t thought crime, it’s speech/writing crimes like how we have for hate speech.

Criminal speech?

I don't agree with the Monarchy.
I might attend the protests about it.

That could be enough for the police to arrest me because they might have a reasonable belief that I could cause disruption. They don't need suspicion. Just a reasonable belief.

OP posts:
DuncinToffee · 06/05/2023 16:19

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:18

They were not arrested for their thoughts.

They weren't arrested for thinking 'not my king' aloud?

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:19

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:16

You wouldn’t be arrested unless you already had multiple arrests and it were a violation of the court order that suspended a custodial sentence.

Even if it were illegal to protest (it isnt), your comment is not thought crime. That’s confessing intent to commit a crime to the police.

Have you read the new protest laws?

How does the new Policing Act affect my protest rights? - Liberty (libertyhumanrights.org.uk)

You can be arrested and charged if you breach conditions on the protest, even if you didn't know about those conditions

How does the new Policing Act affect my protest rights? - Liberty

As the Government’s Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act comes into effect, we explain the main protest law changes and what they mean for protesters.

https://www.libertyhumanrights.org.uk/advice_information/pcsc-policing-act-protest-rights/

OP posts:
HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:18

DuncinToffee · 06/05/2023 16:17

The police had had in depth discussions with the protesters (Republic Staff) about the nature of their peaceful protest. They knew their 'thoughts'

And still they were arrested.

They were not arrested for their thoughts.

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:18

Whaeanui · 06/05/2023 16:12

If the police can now legally arrest people for thought crime, they would need to be able to know our thoughts

People often speak or write their thoughts down. Then other people know what they think. 😐

Then that is an issue of criminal speech or writing, ie like hate speech. You can think all day long the worst things but when you say it or write it, the crime isn’t thought crime, it’s speech/writing crimes like how we have for hate speech.

DuncinToffee · 06/05/2023 16:17

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:10

Thought crime means certain thoughts are a crime. It is a term coined by George Orwell.

The post alleged that the “policing bill really has been drafted to make arrest for thought crime legal”

If the police can now legally arrest people for thought crime, they would need to be able to know our thoughts.

The police had had in depth discussions with the protesters (Republic Staff) about the nature of their peaceful protest. They knew their 'thoughts'

And still they were arrested.

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:16

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:11

If the police can now legally arrest people for thought crime, they would need to be able to know our thoughts

If I said to to the police that I was thinking of going to a protest, they could arrest me.

You wouldn’t be arrested unless you already had multiple arrests and it were a violation of the court order that suspended a custodial sentence.

Even if it were illegal to protest (it isnt), your comment is not thought crime. That’s confessing intent to commit a crime to the police.

pointythings · 06/05/2023 16:15

@3dogsandarabbit not true. I'm not a UK national. I live in the UK, but Charles III is not my King. Willem Alexander of the Netherlands is.

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:13

UK security minister defends new anti-protest laws before coronation | UK news | The Guardian

The security minister, Tom Tugendhat, defended the new laws, which include a 12-month prison sentence for protesters who block roads and a six-month prison sentence or unlimited fine for anyone who locks on to others, objects or buildings. Police will also be able to stop and search protesters they suspect are setting out to cause “disruption”.

Official warning letters have been sent to anti-monarchists planning to stage peaceful protests at the coronation, but the cabinet minister insisted people would still have the “liberty to protest”.

UK security minister defends new anti-protest laws before coronation

Tom Tugendhat insists people will still have ‘liberty to protest’ after government fast-tracked legislation

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/03/uk-security-minister-defends-new-anti-protest-laws-coronation

OP posts:
Whaeanui · 06/05/2023 16:12

If the police can now legally arrest people for thought crime, they would need to be able to know our thoughts

People often speak or write their thoughts down. Then other people know what they think. 😐

3dogsandarabbit · 06/05/2023 16:11

Good, I don't want to watch stupid twatty people with placards saying "not my king". If you live in this country then he is your King so go and do something useful instead.

Whaeanui · 06/05/2023 16:11

No, I have faith in a lot of the independent journalists.
Which one’s? I have as much of a distrust of media as I do the police and politicians and I think it’s healthy that the public do. But perhaps you have a point and can highlight some good independent ones that are on the ground at events and provide unbiased reporting.

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:11

If the police can now legally arrest people for thought crime, they would need to be able to know our thoughts

If I said to to the police that I was thinking of going to a protest, they could arrest me.

OP posts:
HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:11

pointythings · 06/05/2023 16:06

This. So basically if you have ever been picked up by CCTV at a protest, the police can pick you up from the street even if you're just out buying new shoes. That is so far from acceptable it isn't real - and people on here think it's just fiiiiine.

You’re right that it isn’t real.

givemecoffeenow · 06/05/2023 16:10

Wait there’s a new law stopping people from protesting now??

How did I miss this😶…

Im not anti royal or particularly for them either. But I do think people should have the right to a peaceful protest. Kind of scary that laws are now taking away that right.

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:10

2ManyPjs · 06/05/2023 16:05

Talk about wilfully misconstruing a point.

Thought crime means certain thoughts are a crime. It is a term coined by George Orwell.

The post alleged that the “policing bill really has been drafted to make arrest for thought crime legal”

If the police can now legally arrest people for thought crime, they would need to be able to know our thoughts.

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:08

pointythings · 06/05/2023 16:06

This. So basically if you have ever been picked up by CCTV at a protest, the police can pick you up from the street even if you're just out buying new shoes. That is so far from acceptable it isn't real - and people on here think it's just fiiiiine.

Imagine if the police saw you on facial recognition going to buy a bike lock.

They would throw the book at you.

OP posts:
pointythings · 06/05/2023 16:06

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:03

If there is a protest being planned, the police can use their laws to detain you, even if you are not going to go.

They will be able to track you with their facial recognition.

You may be thinking of going to the protest. But you might not even have attended it.

This. So basically if you have ever been picked up by CCTV at a protest, the police can pick you up from the street even if you're just out buying new shoes. That is so far from acceptable it isn't real - and people on here think it's just fiiiiine.

2ManyPjs · 06/05/2023 16:05

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:01

Please tell me how can the police know our thoughts? Really would like to know.

Talk about wilfully misconstruing a point.

cakeorwine · 06/05/2023 16:03

HadalyEve · 06/05/2023 16:01

Please tell me how can the police know our thoughts? Really would like to know.

If there is a protest being planned, the police can use their laws to detain you, even if you are not going to go.

They will be able to track you with their facial recognition.

You may be thinking of going to the protest. But you might not even have attended it.

OP posts: