Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell clients to just leave

385 replies

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 22:43

I"m self employed with clients who pay monthly. I work 12 months of the year and take 4 weeks a year holiday which are unpaid - this is all explained upfront.

This year I've had an unprecedented number of clients who've informed me that they're not prepared to pay for my services over the summer as they're 'going on fancy holidays' and won't get the use of my services.

But they want me to take them back on in September once the summer holidays are over and the children are back in school.

AIBU to tell them they're free to go in June but I won't be giving them their space back in September?

I simply cannot afford to not be paid for 2 months. When I go on holiday (unpaid and only UK) I still pay all of my monthly bills (swimming, nursery etc)

I realise the cost of living affects even the wealthy, but it's the wealthiest clients who are doing this to me! For context, last year I earned £15k if that matters. I can't afford to take my children abroad (not that that's their fault I might add, but it does irk!)

AIBU to feel really pissed off and a little bit used/undervalued?

OP posts:
selfemployedwwyd · 07/05/2023 09:14

Deathmetal · 06/05/2023 22:54

Op, you don’t sound business savvy.

You should take legal advice from a solicitor and modify your contract and fees.

It’s bizarre that with some of your clients, fees haven’t risen in 5+ years. You should have implemented annual increases.

It’s more fair if all your clients are charged the same price. If word got out that you’re essentially cherry picking, it could damage your reputation as some clients may ask for the cheaper price and be put out if you refuse.

You need to improve your business plan and offer more value during the time you are off. We are going through a cost of living crisis and people don’t want to pointlessly spend money. It’s a business relationship - your bills are NOT going to be a priority compared to their own bills! You don’t work full time, could spend some time creating one hour of weekly content the students can access each week you’re away? Whether that’s tests or pre recorded lessons or something to add value to the 4 weeks you are away.

the truth is, what you’re experiencing are some of the downsides of self-employment. You don’t get holiday pay. If your business is becoming less feasible, you may need to consider employment instead.

Wy would I provide work for the 4 weeks I don't work - I don't charge them for those 4 weeks? One week at Christmas, one in the Summer holidays and 2 others at other half terms.

TBH I've decided I'm going to go term time only and offers services in the holidays to revision and groups.

I'm already said myself I'm not business savvy - why are people pointing out the obvious! That's why I came on here for advice.

OP posts:
Deathmetal · 06/05/2023 23:02

My website is frankly shit and my FB page well out of date

It’s 2023. That’s not something to be proud of. You will be putting other clients off. If you already have a decent interest, improving your marketing will only take you further and you might attract more high quality clients who pay on time and accept a higher price. Especially if you’re happy to have distance clients via Zoom, that opens your consumer base away from locals. I find arranging business through FB tends to be informal, which is why you’ve got some pisstakers on your books as they don’t really take it seriously. A robust website will attract different people.

Deathmetal · 06/05/2023 22:54

Op, you don’t sound business savvy.

You should take legal advice from a solicitor and modify your contract and fees.

It’s bizarre that with some of your clients, fees haven’t risen in 5+ years. You should have implemented annual increases.

It’s more fair if all your clients are charged the same price. If word got out that you’re essentially cherry picking, it could damage your reputation as some clients may ask for the cheaper price and be put out if you refuse.

You need to improve your business plan and offer more value during the time you are off. We are going through a cost of living crisis and people don’t want to pointlessly spend money. It’s a business relationship - your bills are NOT going to be a priority compared to their own bills! You don’t work full time, could spend some time creating one hour of weekly content the students can access each week you’re away? Whether that’s tests or pre recorded lessons or something to add value to the 4 weeks you are away.

the truth is, what you’re experiencing are some of the downsides of self-employment. You don’t get holiday pay. If your business is becoming less feasible, you may need to consider employment instead.

knobheeeed · 06/05/2023 22:54

I've had I've had some amazing advice off your all and I'm going to sit down Tuesday and get my backside into gear setting up new T_C's for Sept and sorting out my business arrangements in general

Good. I suggest going through every step of the process of booking, paying for, attending and quitting lessons and tighten up everything where there might be a loophole.
So start at the beginning and analyze everything. Where have people taken the piss or where is the potential for them to take the piss or is there anything in the T and C which could give rise to misunderstanding (rather than piss-taking).
What are you going to do about late payers? What are you going to do about the summer holiday issue? How many lessons can be missed before you boot someone out? etcetcetc.

selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 22:36

Ok. So just to address a few points.

I can only work after school hours in general (although I have picked up a 'daytime' person recently) . In order to accommodate my own childcare needs, I mostly have between 2 -3 pupils a night - mainly at my own home school classroom, some on Zoom, 2 or 3 I still drive out to their house (but trying to stop this as it cuts into my work time and I don't charge mileage)

It is my only income, but no, I'm not working 40 hours a week obviously!

I already charge £40 an hour. That's the going rate where we are. There are plenty of cheap tutors (in the main unqualified teachers or youngsters after some cash on the side) and I've had plenty of people message me asking me why I'm not £15 like so and so is.

I'm professional and I'm worth my £40 an hour. If I started charging £50 an hour, I'm not confident I would be fully booked around this area. But maybe I need to take a risk and find out.

Indeed. One of the reasons I've kept some of my older clients on lower rates is because I've feared that If I upped the cost by say £10 a month they would leave - and I would lose £120 a month!

Just submitted 2022/23 and I earned £18k approx after expenses. Yes i would earn more working on a till, but not for 12 hours a week (pupils come and go at times - sometimes I have less, sometimes I have more pupils) Those hours work around my partners and my children, one of whom has SEN. Honestly, I love what I do. I'm good at it and I love making a major difference in a child's life.

Everyone is making very good points. No, I'm not business savvy. I need to get a payment programme in place instead of just asking clients to set up a direct debit to me. I need to charge for late payments instead of chasing the same people month in month out. I need to stop accepting that they can't pay me this month because of a 'big birthday' or a 'holiday' they've just put a deposit on - leaving me in debt instead.

Finally, I haven't complained at all. I have smiled and simply explained that I can't hold their place. At no point would I risk my reputation as nearly 100% of my clients come word of mouth - neighbours, friends, cousins etc etc. My website is frankly shit and my FB page well out of date = but my reviews are fantastic and I never have to chase work.

I agree 100% its unfair that some are paying less than others. It also pains me that I'm working just as hard for those pupils and receiving £40 a month less!

I'm not blaming my clients. I'm just putting on here anonymously that it really winds me up that I can be working flat out for their child for not an obscene cost (as you've all pointed out) but that their fancy holiday still trumps paying me in their mind. Of course they're absolutely allowed to do what they want, and feel how they want - I'm just moaning on here about the way some clients (not all) treat self employed as some sort of skivvy servant at their beck and call.

I've had some amazing advice off your all and I'm going to sit down Tuesday and get my backside into gear setting up new T_C's for Sept and sorting out my business arrangements in general.

I'm far too nice and far too accommodating tbh.

OP posts:
selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 22:12

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 11:55

I think posters are missing that this is a new thing

the op says never happened before and now “unprecedented”

which indicates that this is due to cost of living crisis and a general concern about the economy. Many other sectors are experiencing the same.

If the Op take them “they’re cheeky”, word will get around.

If the OP changes her contract to mean this flexibility is no longer possible, she will put off new clients

Times are a-changing

Exactly that.

It's honestly the first year that's it's started to happen en masse.

OP posts:
selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 22:11

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 12:05

Op you say you pay termly for gymnastics and dancing

Presumably if you knew that you couldn’t make a term due to holidays… you would simply not pay that terms fee

and yet for your own clients…

No, I said I paid. I pay monthly. I pay every month. I consider those costs the same as my mortgage/water/gas/electric. Whether I'm on holiday or not is irrelevant. Anyway. There's no gymnastics club that would allow you to simply not pay and then take your child back to squad weeks later.

OP posts:
selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 22:09

LIZS · 06/05/2023 14:02

Even if they are abroad do you offer zoom style sessions? Their choice to lose continuity of learning and potentially tutor.

Yes I do. I have 2 international pupils who regularly have Zoom.

OP posts:
OhwhyOY · 06/05/2023 15:45

Could you just charge more in the months you are working to cover the summer where you're not? Otherwise just tell them the contract says X, you are very welcome to quit the contract with the appropriate notice but unfortunately I am oversubscribed and it is extremely unlikely I will have space available in September.

Kazzyhoward · 06/05/2023 14:30

To the OP, how about you change the name of your services and call it a retainer. Have it in your contract that you'll continue to provide service A/B/C for each month that the retainer continues to be paid? But that non payment ends the "retainer". By changing it's name to "retainer", it makes the payment being to "retain" you, so clients are paying to effectively "keep" you.

LIZS · 06/05/2023 14:02

Even if they are abroad do you offer zoom style sessions? Their choice to lose continuity of learning and potentially tutor.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/05/2023 13:55

Just make clear you can’t hold places and if the slot is filled then it’s filled.
Other way is to really push the need for continuous study so they don’t regress - if not September is catching them back up etc.
Or look for different clients for summer only.

Fourpeasinapodcast · 06/05/2023 13:49

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 13:37

With a brilliant tutor who arranges her sessions and finances as any other tutor on this thread seems to do with the op being the outlier

You are sitting with a tutor eating scones? Curiouser and curiouser... crack on!!!

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 13:37

Fourpeasinapodcast · 06/05/2023 13:27

Absolutely! One mad scone eating a scone eating with jam and cream while madly waving a flag at the telly!

With a brilliant tutor who arranges her sessions and finances as any other tutor on this thread seems to do with the op being the outlier

selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 13:29

Clarinet1 · 06/05/2023 09:37

I used to do some instrumental teaching. All I said was that I required 24 hours notice of a cancelled lesson on the pupils part (unless there were genuinely unforeseen circumstances such as severe weather, sudden illness of the pupil or parent who had to bring them) or I charged. Payment was in advance. I’m not saying that you should do this but just providing context and I’m sure you’ll agree that it was a fairly relaxed policy.
I still got parents who repeatedly failed to give give notice of absences. One was particularly bad - I would phone her about half way through the lesson time to be told “We’re having a party” “He’s on a school trip abroad for two weeks”. She then quibbled over payment and started calling into question my qualifications (I do hold one of the standard qualifications for instrumental teachers). She didn’t seem to appreciate that she was paying for my time as much as anything else. I don’t remember exactly how the relationship ended but, like you, I had a waiting list and was virtually never without as many pupils as I wanted,
The point is you must be clear about what your policy is and stick to in. You’re a person who only had 24 hours in the day just like anyone else, not a session vending machine that they can put money into when they fancy some tutoring!

This^ ! Precisely why I moved from weekly payment to monthly payment.

I particularly remember one client I drove to, half an hour journey (traffic rather than mileage), to find out the house was empty. Rang her and she was on holiday in the Bahamas and forgotten to tell me. Wasted an hour of travelling and the lesson planning time. Also numerous clients who would cancel with 5 mins notice - booked a hair cut, child is going to a party now, we've had tea late just don't fancy it etc etc.

To be fair the vast majority have been great with monthly upfront. It gives consistency and actually teaching over the holidays ensures that the child doesn't have summer slump!

OP posts:
Fourpeasinapodcast · 06/05/2023 13:27

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 13:17

Appropriate given today! With cream and jam 🤤

Absolutely! One mad scone eating a scone eating with jam and cream while madly waving a flag at the telly!

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 13:17

Fourpeasinapodcast · 06/05/2023 13:00

She has them in her clutches.....ahhh you are a mad scone.

Appropriate given today! With cream and jam 🤤

Fourpeasinapodcast · 06/05/2023 13:00

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 12:18

They don’t “keep a place” for me. At the end of each term, you are asked whether you want to sign up for the next term or not.

OP doesn’t give her client this opportunity. Once they are in her clutches… she wants them all year with no break.

The clients are simply reacting to the fact that rather than giving them any choice over the year - it’s stick with me or you’re out!

She has them in her clutches.....ahhh you are a mad scone.

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 12:56

Havanananana · 06/05/2023 12:51

"would you book your family holiday around an hour a week tutor?"

The OP is not asking people to do this, but since almost all families with children have the same six/seven weeks of summer holiday, if the question of paying for the service during the holidays is becoming an issue, then one way to resolve it is to tell everyone that for a period in the summer, they will be closed for holidays.

If she does this, the OP doesn't charge (because there are no sessions during that period) but of course makes sure that she increases the price during the rest of the year to cover her overall costs and to secure her income for the year. If she doesn't do this, then ultimately it becomes uneconomic for her to offer the service, she gets a job doing something else and nobody gets any sessions.

I was responding to a Pp suggestion 😐

Havanananana · 06/05/2023 12:51

"would you book your family holiday around an hour a week tutor?"

The OP is not asking people to do this, but since almost all families with children have the same six/seven weeks of summer holiday, if the question of paying for the service during the holidays is becoming an issue, then one way to resolve it is to tell everyone that for a period in the summer, they will be closed for holidays.

If she does this, the OP doesn't charge (because there are no sessions during that period) but of course makes sure that she increases the price during the rest of the year to cover her overall costs and to secure her income for the year. If she doesn't do this, then ultimately it becomes uneconomic for her to offer the service, she gets a job doing something else and nobody gets any sessions.

thecatsthecats · 06/05/2023 12:49

There's nothing wrong with your T&Cs as they are.

You can give notice of a cancellation of the current terms and reissue at new prices of you're on a rolling contract. You can reply to their messages thanking them for giving four week notice of termination, and that you will add them to your waiting list for September at the price for new customers.

It is entirely within their court to withdraw their termination (you might then still wish to reissue the contract at a higher fee).

You don't need a clause to define every situation. Don't panic about that. Your existing contract defines the situation perfectly well. You don't want to tie yourself in knots with an over-defined contract, so long as you don't grant them rights to the contrary in you existing contract.

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 12:32

Skybluepinky · 06/05/2023 12:27

Do u give yr holiday dates in advance so they can try to book the same as u?

Good grief.

would you book your family holiday around an hour a week tutor?

Skybluepinky · 06/05/2023 12:27

Do u give yr holiday dates in advance so they can try to book the same as u?

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 12:19

And when I don’t want to sign up for the summer term but do for the September term…. They don’t get pissed off with me and tell me I’m being cheeky and that I can’t even though they have space.

if they don’t have space, then I 🤷‍♀️, they don’t have space!

Whoknewiwouldlovethedog · 06/05/2023 12:18

Fourpeasinapodcast · 06/05/2023 12:14

Aren't you lucky they keep a place for you!

They don’t “keep a place” for me. At the end of each term, you are asked whether you want to sign up for the next term or not.

OP doesn’t give her client this opportunity. Once they are in her clutches… she wants them all year with no break.

The clients are simply reacting to the fact that rather than giving them any choice over the year - it’s stick with me or you’re out!