Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell clients to just leave

385 replies

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 22:43

I"m self employed with clients who pay monthly. I work 12 months of the year and take 4 weeks a year holiday which are unpaid - this is all explained upfront.

This year I've had an unprecedented number of clients who've informed me that they're not prepared to pay for my services over the summer as they're 'going on fancy holidays' and won't get the use of my services.

But they want me to take them back on in September once the summer holidays are over and the children are back in school.

AIBU to tell them they're free to go in June but I won't be giving them their space back in September?

I simply cannot afford to not be paid for 2 months. When I go on holiday (unpaid and only UK) I still pay all of my monthly bills (swimming, nursery etc)

I realise the cost of living affects even the wealthy, but it's the wealthiest clients who are doing this to me! For context, last year I earned £15k if that matters. I can't afford to take my children abroad (not that that's their fault I might add, but it does irk!)

AIBU to feel really pissed off and a little bit used/undervalued?

OP posts:
NotQuiteHere · 10/05/2023 15:28

If you are a tutor with a good reputation, you keep a waiting list and in September you start filling your slots with 1. the students from the previous year who should have a priority if they want continue 2. students from the waiting list. Everything is clear, no drama involved.

Lagranoui · 10/05/2023 15:24

I would charge a fee to keep their spots for sept. If I fill their spots i would set it up that they are only for the summer listing the start and end date. If the fee to hold spot is not paid then no spot will be held for september

NotQuiteHere · 10/05/2023 15:24

You have chosen a strange business model and if you don't change it you are bound to have more cases like that one which you describe as upsetting. In fact, it's strange that nobody have challenged it before. Tutors usually work term time only, with the chance for the current students to continue over the holidays. They can also arrange revision courses for those who can only do that during the holidays.

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 15:23

I agree @MargotBamborough

What I’m disagreeing with us op’s reaction to clients ending their contracts over the summer.

She’s pissed off saying “I simply cannot afford to have 2 months unpaid! These are wealthy people..I’m irked..I feel used and undervalued”

Unfortunately customers don’t owe op any loyalty and aren’t obliged to keep paying over the summer on a rolling contract.

Yes op can react by telling them not to return but it’s not productive or professional to do so.

It might be savvy to politely request a retainer payment to secure her services for the new academic year, rather than threaten unavailability.

It’s easy to feel a bit resentful or undervalued if clients want to pick you up and put you down as they see fit. I get it, I’m self employed but I think it’s wise to leave emotions out of business. It’s not personal.

Imisssleep2 · 10/05/2023 15:16

Do you not cover things like this in your contract with them?

Just say if your services arent required through the summer, you will be filling their slots with other clients on your waiting list amd their space will likely no longer be availablein September, they may soon change their tune unless they didnt plan to come back in September anyway.....

Geordie88 · 10/05/2023 15:13

Probably already been said, but I would accept their cancellation of services and advise that you can't guarantee you will have availability in September. If you refuse to work with them again, could be spiting yourself if you have space you can't fill. But if you can fill it, then you have zero obligation to hold a space for free.

MargotBamborough · 10/05/2023 14:53

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 14:49

I must admit I’d be hesitant to hire a private tutor under the condition that I was liable to paying a full 12 months tuition.

There are too many variables - serious illness, injury, holidays, changes in financial circumstances, or just simply not being satisfied with the service.

Op does not issue this sort of contract and it just doesn’t sound practical to attempt to enforce one.

I expect this is why most self employed tutors offering services don’t offer yearly subscriptions, or enforce penalties should clients wish to stop using them.

They can end their contract with four weeks' notice, which sounds sufficient for all the situations you have mentioned except holidays, where I think they really just need to consider it part of the cost of their holiday. Unless of course they want to terminate their contract in June, have their holiday, and take their chances that the slot will still be available in September.

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 14:49

I must admit I’d be hesitant to hire a private tutor under the condition that I was liable to paying a full 12 months tuition.

There are too many variables - serious illness, injury, holidays, changes in financial circumstances, or just simply not being satisfied with the service.

Op does not issue this sort of contract and it just doesn’t sound practical to attempt to enforce one.

I expect this is why most self employed tutors offering services don’t offer yearly subscriptions, or enforce penalties should clients wish to stop using them.

MargotBamborough · 10/05/2023 14:47

Can you easily replace these clients with other clients who will want your services from July and are happy to pay through the year?

Have you increased your rates at all due to the cost of living crisis? Does your contract allow you to do so?

I think I would point out that if they are giving you four weeks' notice then they are ending your contract, so if they want you back in September it will be subject to availability. If your current contract does not allow you to increase your rates due to the cost of living crisis, I would also mention that if they break their contract with you and then want your services again they will need to pay the rate for new clients rather than current clients, which is now higher due to the cost of living crisis.

AuntieJune · 10/05/2023 14:23

Charge slightly more for a 10-month year - then find something else to do in summer holidays. If I used a tutor, I wouldn't want them over the summer. You could work in summer camps or something, it might be useful experience?

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 14:14

HurryShadow · 10/05/2023 13:36

But if the OP's contract states they are providing a service at £30 per week for 48 weeks a year, it DOES make it comparable to a Sky contract.

Her contract doesn't say "only pay me when you use me".

If we’re comparing this to a Sky contract then op needs to have every legality covered before asking clients to sign up for a year.

With any service provider (e.g Sky ) there has to be a set “cooling off” period where the contract can be ended without money owing, the customer is also entitled to terminate a contract at anytime after that period where (in the case of Sky) a financial penalty is applied. No one is handcuffed!

As it stands, op’s clients are not in breach of contract to stop using op’s services, they are following the obligation to give 4 weeks notice of their intention.

They may or may not be able to secure op’s services in the future.That’s the penalty in ending their agreement.
Seems unprofessional for op to get huffy about that and threaten to refuse to let them return if she has space?

Dh and I are both self employed (not tutors!) but I don’t think op can offer private tutoring with all these caveats. What a minefield.

It’s fantastic money (around 18k for 6-8 hours teaching a week?) compared to her previous salary as a teacher!

I’d advise acknowledging the small pitfalls in private tutoring- income can fluctuate over the acedemic year and there’s less work in the summer holidays.

MegaManic · 10/05/2023 14:11

I think you are unreasonable to feel pissed off. Obviously you feel what you feel but ultimately you are providing a service with certain terms and they are abiding by those terms by giving you notice. Of course you can't guarantee they can have the same slots (or any) at the same price when they get back and they are unreasonable to expect that.
I use a tutor but during the summer she doesn't work normal hours so works certain days and if we can find slots that work for both of us we do them, if not we don't. If she had the same terms as you then I probably would cancel for the summer holidays and take my chances on getting new slots in September. I think she is really good and it's not that I don't value her but I wouldn't be willing to pay for a service I don't use. Having said that my kids are in primary so maybe of they were in secondary and I really depended on the tutor it might be different.

Users37 · 10/05/2023 14:05

I'd love to be in your position, OP. I teach English online. Have a good degree, a good qualification in teaching English and years of experience. Teaching English as a foreign language is extremely badly paid. I charge far less than you do and some people still complain that I'm too expensive. I include (on every invoice) the fairly standard term that a lesson can be cancelled by the student if they give 24 hours' notice. Students often cancel - including every time they go on holiday, of course. On the occasions when they don't bother to cancel and just don't turn up for the lesson, they are sometimes extremely aggrieved if I charge them for the missed lesson. I've lost students over that. I also often get contacted by random students wanting me to give them a free "trial lesson". It's obvious that many of these people just do the rounds of online teachers, and never pay anyone.
But seriously - for lots of people, paying for a lesson they don't receive is something they really, really resent. And in my experience the richer students are often those who resent it most.

BetterFuture1985 · 10/05/2023 14:05

Reading the thread gave me a thought. Could you guarantee a price only for those who stay on your books for the next 2 months and say people starting in September will need to pay the new price?

Catspyjamas17 · 10/05/2023 14:03

HurryShadow · 10/05/2023 13:36

But if the OP's contract states they are providing a service at £30 per week for 48 weeks a year, it DOES make it comparable to a Sky contract.

Her contract doesn't say "only pay me when you use me".

You can pause/cancel most contracts then start them again though. And Sky wouldn't say "Well, we might have space for you in September but we'll have to let you know."

Most tutors are term time only and offer summer schools etc in summer as an extra.

The only service I know of where there is some arrangement about payment over holidays when you are not using them is a childminder, or a nanny where you are actually their employer. Even with a childminder the parent would be allowed to end the contract with the appropriate notice but then they would have to take a chance about availability in September.

Gillbil · 10/05/2023 14:03

Be as professional as possible but basically tell em to go do one.

Your completely reasonable and right.
Say thank you for the notice unfortunately I can't save your place but you are more than welcome to reapply next year, unfortunately prices will be going up for August for new users, but all currently members will have a price promise to be kept the same for the next 12 month. Have a lovely holiday

Do a netflix! Everything is going up u should too

Tiredmama53 · 10/05/2023 13:50

I would just say that taking them on in September will be reliant on your availability and let them know that you won't be holding a space for them. So if you have space in September then they can come back because you'll want to fill up your gaps but if you find someone else tough luck for them

Whichnumbers · 10/05/2023 13:37

'Don't worry, we will give you a call in September when we need you back'

If I still have your space, you'll be welcome to it, I let you know at the time.

But you'll prices will have increased to them..... which will cover the 2 months break over the future 10 months

Thats if you have a space, you may have filled their slot and not be able to accommodate them any further and will let them know if a slot comes available in the future

BetterFuture1985 · 10/05/2023 13:36

@selfemployedwwyd I wouldn't let yourself get upset about it. Think about it with a hard headed business mindset. These people are negotiating with you and you have the right to say no. Your willingness to say no will depend on the industry norms and the ease with which you can pick up new clients (the fact they want to hold their places looks promising).

Also, if you decide based on industry norms that you must cave to their demands then you may be able to increase your fees for the other 10 months maybe?

HurryShadow · 10/05/2023 13:36

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 12:12

I'm sure these people that say they "don't want to pay for your services while they're not using them" still pay for their other costs like Sky TV, etc, while they're on holiday and not using them. They're trying it on with you because you're a sole trader that they see as a soft touch

Don’t agree!
I don’t think clients are “cheeky fuckers” to
give op notice that they don’t want to use or pay for her services for a few weeks over the summer.

A tutor is selling a service on a self employed basis. It’s not comparable with a Sky Tv subscription or household bill.

I’d say it was more on a par with a cleaner, a gardener or handyman who you are paying for the service they provide.

The self employed person does not have the same rights as an employee.

I actually think op’s taking this all far too personally; saying she feels “used”. Confused

Yes customers are using you when they need you ( if you are available) it’s just business. They don’t owe you a salary.

But if the OP's contract states they are providing a service at £30 per week for 48 weeks a year, it DOES make it comparable to a Sky contract.

Her contract doesn't say "only pay me when you use me".

MsProbably · 10/05/2023 13:35

Just raise your prices to them significantly in September and class them as 'new joiners' on a brand new rate

Changes17 · 10/05/2023 13:30

What about upping your monthly rate for those who want to have September to June only? Make it available as an option in your contract, but it costs more throughout the year?

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 13:29

I think the last few posts give excellent advice.

What you’re essentially describing is clients paying you a retainer over the summer to secure your services in the next academic term.
Some clients may be willing to pay that and some won’t.

You can be frank about the retainer in a professional way. You cannot expect it.
Perhaps face the fact that some clients don’t regard you as highly valuable as you might assume 😕

Theres no need for resentment, try to view this in a detached way. Your client’s wealth or how they prioritise their finances isn’t up for judgement.

Bluecirclesquare · 10/05/2023 13:21

I would advise caution, as PP have said, before telling them to leave. In the event that you don't get other students to fill the gap you might need them back as clients come September.

Be polite and explain you'll do your best to keep their place open for September, but you can't guarantee it because you may be booked with other students. That's just stating the case. I wouldn't flounce about it, you don't know how things might pan out.

Sage71 · 10/05/2023 13:19

Contract covers you, I would put in writing so you are covered along the lines of

Thank you for advising you will no longer be requiring my services as per contract your 4 weeks notice means DC last session will be on xx/xx/xxxx. If you wish to resume sessions at a future date I will be happy to re-contract space permitting. Wishing DC much success in the future.

Polite and professional but very clear. Then look for other students. Once they realise they cannot just pick you up and drop you as and when they will have to prioritise.