Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell clients to just leave

385 replies

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 22:43

I"m self employed with clients who pay monthly. I work 12 months of the year and take 4 weeks a year holiday which are unpaid - this is all explained upfront.

This year I've had an unprecedented number of clients who've informed me that they're not prepared to pay for my services over the summer as they're 'going on fancy holidays' and won't get the use of my services.

But they want me to take them back on in September once the summer holidays are over and the children are back in school.

AIBU to tell them they're free to go in June but I won't be giving them their space back in September?

I simply cannot afford to not be paid for 2 months. When I go on holiday (unpaid and only UK) I still pay all of my monthly bills (swimming, nursery etc)

I realise the cost of living affects even the wealthy, but it's the wealthiest clients who are doing this to me! For context, last year I earned £15k if that matters. I can't afford to take my children abroad (not that that's their fault I might add, but it does irk!)

AIBU to feel really pissed off and a little bit used/undervalued?

OP posts:
Clementinesucks · 10/05/2023 23:00

slithytoveisascientist · 05/05/2023 22:58

As PP have said you don't need to contract to this, just make it clear that they are terminating meantime that your future availability and rates are not guaranteed. And find yourself a more respectful client.

I don’t see anything disrespectful about a client giving four weeks notice.

Just pick up new clients.

Sjkeay75 · 10/05/2023 22:45

Here's a thought, say OK, that is your right to break contract, BUT on restart in September, they go onto a new rate which is 12 monthly divided by 10. That way they will know they are not "winning" and risk losing the slot. They can go onto the lower rate after a year, once you have recooperated the loss.
You could, if this is a common problem, charge this rate but offer the two months over summer "free", but in fact it is already paid for over the 10 months

CocoC · 10/05/2023 22:38

Tell them you can't guarantee them a place. If you can fill your spaces with people who don't do this, then great.
If however you can't, then you will have to take them back.... otherwise you will be turning down business and cutting off your nose to spite your face.
I do this with things like kids music teachers. Basically, I am not that fussed, and will take the risk of not getting a space. But where it's something I really value, I will pay for the peace of mind.

Crazydonkeylady · 10/05/2023 22:21

You’re being totally reasonable. Fair is fair - they have a contract, they’ve given you notice but they just need to know that you will only be able to offer them a place again in September if you have space at that time. You need to make it clear you can’t hold their place and forego income to do so.

NoThanksymm · 10/05/2023 21:31

Just politely say you will happily have them back in the fall if there is space in your schedule. Done.

they are entitled to have their budgets, and you yours.

you could offer a ‘holding fee’ - free money, less summer work.

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 20:48

I’m assuming you’re a childminder

I’m assuming you didn’t read past page one @Bob80 😂

456pickupsticks · 10/05/2023 20:30

It's fine for them to leave in June, but make clear that you won't hold a spot for them, so you'll only be able to take them back on as a client in September if there's space available.

Alternatively in future you could offer a term time only contract at a slightly higher rate, if you wanted, but if you're happy with how much you're working and you're fully booked, it's not really needed.

Suggested response:
Hi XXX,

Sorry to hear you won't require my services from June. Just to be clear, if you're not willing to pay over July and August, that will end our contract, as I can't hold spaces. You're welcome to get back in touch in September if you'd like to re-hire me on a new contract, but me taking you back on as a client is dependent upon me having the space available. I've been fully booked for the last seven years, so please be aware that I may not have room in September to take you back on.

Please let me know whether you'd like to keep me on past June by the end of this week, or I will take the last email as your four weeks notice to end the contract.

All the Best.

TheFifthTellytubby · 10/05/2023 19:58

If this is something that a lot of your clients are doing, could you consider altering your work model to continue with your usual arrangements until the end of June, and then (assuming your 4-week holiday is in August) run something akin to intensive "summer schools" in July? Obviously with adjustments for group teaching as opposed to 1-1. That way you could retain those students that are not dropping you during that month and also possibly attract new business (especially if you do 11+ tutoring, as the tests are often in September shortly after the return to school)?

masterblaster · 10/05/2023 19:57

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 22:48

Contract says that if I miss due to sickness, I will refund. If the client misses due to holiday, payment still needs to be made. Four weeks notice to be given.

So they're giving more than 4 weeks notice now to say they're finishing in June but 'Don't worry, we will give you a call in September when we need you back'

Tell them that you are happy with this type of contract, but your rates are increasing by 20 % to compensate.

Bob80 · 10/05/2023 19:28

I'm assuming you are a childminder. I would send them an email saying "I have a waiting list of people wanting your spaces. You are free not to pay me over the summer but I will have to give you your 4weeks notice immediately and take on clients that are willing to pay me through the summer. " Get them to sign to say the agree to it or hand them their 4wks notice and fill their spots immediately. They are being spoilt and entitled.

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 19:26

Themumlife · 10/05/2023 17:38

I would write it into the contract that they are signing up to a year, and payments are spread monthly for ease and affordability. I’d also put in place a cancellation policy, and that places cannot be reserved, and all placements for the following school year must be applied for and accepted by the end of June.

Op already asks clients to agree to a yearly contract paid monthly. She has a cancellation policy. You’re not suggesting anything different there?

The issue is, an unprecedented number of clients are following the cancellation policy to avoid making payments over the summer when they don’t require a tutor.
Thats not cheeky or taking the piss at all.

They can be reminded they aren’t guaranteed a slot in September or asked to pay a retainer to reserve a place.
You cannot rely on that happening and complain “I can’t afford 2 months with no income!”

I expect most would still prefer to cancel and save hundreds of pounds in the summer holidays. If the majority are doing it, it shouldn’t be a problem securing tuition in the new term.

This is to be expected, particularly in these tough economic times.

Applying for a tutor in June (and entering into a contract then ) is fraught with difficulties.
A level students for example aren’t accepted onto their courses until GCSE results day (around 23rd August) and many change subject choices.

The nature of private tutoring means there will always be busier times of the year- many requesting tuition before the 11 plus for example or enlisting a tutor in the last few months before GCSE exams or when issues with a subject become apparent.

There are many advantages to being self employed. A guaranteed steady income throughout the year is not one.

I think op upthread mentioned changing to charging termly (upfront and non refundable) a slight increase in hourly rate would cover the lull of school holidays.

That’s by far the simplest and fairest approach in my view, instead of the drama of feeling upset and resentful of clients cancelling, and would yield a more predictable annual turnover.

stichguru · 10/05/2023 19:23

I think this is pretty simple. You just write into the contract something along the lines of "My weekly rate is X. I will let you know my holiday weeks well in advance. With the exception of these weeks, you will need to pay for the place all year, unless I need to cancel." It is what most child carers do, and so I don't think it will be that strange for parents even if it is slightly annoying.

Countdown2023 · 10/05/2023 18:10

And standardise your hourly rate. No one should be on an old rate from previous years. Get a message out to all parents that your fee will be xx per hour from 1 September

Themumlife · 10/05/2023 17:38

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 22:51

So how do I write it into the contract that they can't just quit my services in June and expect to swan back in September?

I'm thinking along the line of nursery - I recall with nursery that you simply just paid even if you went on holiday. If you didn't, I"m fairly sure you'd lose your nursery place.

I would write it into the contract that they are signing up to a year, and payments are spread monthly for ease and affordability. I’d also put in place a cancellation policy, and that places cannot be reserved, and all placements for the following school year must be applied for and accepted by the end of June.

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 17:14

I can see why clients would cancel a tutor over say July and August if you didn’t need their services to save money.

For example : a tutor once a week on a Monday.
9 Mondays in July and August at £40ph is a total of £360.

Im surprised more parents aren’t asking to do this given the current economic climate.

Its reasonable to point out you can’t hold a slot open for them but unreasonable to be angry that a number of your clients don’t want to pay for a service they’re not using and are taking this approach.

Noodles1234 · 10/05/2023 17:13

Any further issues, raise your prices pro-rata and stipulate you do not work 4 week dates in the summer. So you always get paid.

Motherbear07 · 10/05/2023 16:32

You’re not being unreasonable and the 7% who have voted to say you are, are wrong.
they have given you four weeks notice. Therefore that means they want to terminate their contract with you. Which frees up a spot for you to get someone else.
I would simply say to them, that if they wish to terminate their contract then it’s not guaranteed that a spot will be available when September comes. As they have freed up their spot and someone permanent may come along.
you’re not being unreasonable but I would allow them to leave as they have given their notice. But I would fill in their spot with someone else. And tell them when a spot becomes available you will let them know :-)

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 16:12

A 20% increase in prices every year is quite a hike! That doesn’t sound realistic.

Be careful- you need to be completely transparent about any penalties clients are incurring by stopping and restarting your services.

What if there are other reasons for pausing your services (serious illness, injury, financial difficulties etc)? Will you still apply this 20% increase as penalty? Or will you levy on mitigating circumstances?

Like all self employed, you rely on word of mouth, recommendation and excellent references.
It might not sit well with parents comparing notes or seeing your services advertised to find out they’re paying varying rates, or have essentially been “priced out” for not giving you holiday money.

IGiveUpalready · 10/05/2023 16:10

@selfemployedwwyd Have a play on ChatGPT at making a contract and do your own tweaking - then source a contract lawyer to review (might be quicker than going in empty?)

This is what it just spat out for me

  1. FEES, PAYMENT, CANCELLATION POLICY, AND CONTRACT CANCELLATION:
The Student agrees to pay the Tutor a monthly fee of [amount] for a total of [number of lessons] lessons per month, to be conducted over a period of 48 weeks in a year. The monthly fee shall be paid in advance, with the first payment due prior to the commencement of the tutoring services. In the event of a cancellation or rescheduling of a tutoring session, the Student agrees to provide a minimum of [notice period] notice to the Tutor. If the required notice is not provided, the Student shall be responsible for the full payment of the missed session. In exceptional circumstances, such as illness or emergencies, the Tutor may, at their discretion, reschedule the missed session to a mutually agreed-upon alternative time. Either party may cancel this contract by providing written notice to the other party. In the event of contract cancellation, the Student will not be automatically re-enrolled for future tutoring sessions and will be placed on a waiting list. The Tutor will notify the Student if and when a spot becomes available, subject to the Tutor's availability and scheduling constraints. Payment shall be made by the Student to the Tutor through [specify preferred method of payment] on or before [due date], with subsequent monthly payments due on the same date each month.

Good luck, its disappointing that people take the mick out of something that benefits their child :(

Tellmeimcrazy · 10/05/2023 15:56

Soapyspuds · 05/05/2023 22:52

Contract says that if I miss due to sickness, I will refund. If the client misses due to holiday, payment still needs to be made. Four weeks notice to be given

So they're giving more than 4 weeks notice now to say they're finishing in June but 'Don't worry, we will give you a call in September when we need you back

Okay so you need to make it clear to them that they are not having a months break, as there are no rules for that in the contract. What they are doing is terminating the contract as per the terms.

If they ask for your services when they return from holiday then you advise them that the rate for new customers is 20% more than your previous rate. And they can take it or leave it.

Obviously the above is on the assumption you are able to pick up other clients if they decline.

I

I agree. Say you're happy to take them if you have space in September but prices will be going up and they will then need to be on the new rate. You should also add this into your terms and conditions/contract

SmileyClare · 10/05/2023 15:55

CombatBarbie · 10/05/2023 15:35

Why should be current students get priority??

Its really not much different to childcare. If you want your child's space kept then you pay when you go on holiday etc. This shouldn't be any different.

Op, can you charge a lower retainer fee for the holidays and only take on students who need you over the summer??

I agree a retainer fee for the holidays is a good way of covering a loss of income over the summer.

I don’t know why so many people are declaring private tutoring should follow the business model of childcare?

As a general rule it doesn’t. Just as most don’t pay their cleaner when they’re away if they don’t want their services..or a driving instructor, a personal trainer or your gardener or window cleaner or a music teacher, tennis coach or whatever.

Cosyblankets · 10/05/2023 15:54

This is an awful lot of fuss for someone who has been fully booked for 7 years. Spaces will be full again and you factor all that in when you go self employed. If you want the stability of a job with 12 months pay you need to get one. If you want the flexibility of self employment then this is what you have.
Fully booked can mean anything depending on circumstances. I choose not to do regular Fridays after school. i do the odd one if someone needs to move. Other days I teach 3 or 4 lessons after school and work. I'm fully booked. Once an evening or after school space becomes available, it's never available for very long. I teach adults in the daytime, not all day but a few each day. I don't insist that the youngsters come in the holidays, some do some don't. I cannot imagine doing zoom lessons from someone's holiday.
If you really are fully booked you will have no problem filling the spaces.

NotQuiteHere · 10/05/2023 15:53

CombatBarbie · 10/05/2023 15:35

Why should be current students get priority??

Its really not much different to childcare. If you want your child's space kept then you pay when you go on holiday etc. This shouldn't be any different.

Op, can you charge a lower retainer fee for the holidays and only take on students who need you over the summer??

The current students should have a priority because this is how the reputations are built, based on your loyal customers.

Luckydip1 · 10/05/2023 15:38

I would be inclined to say that if they terminate the contract, you cannot guarantee a space in September. I would also consider building into your contract an annual review in August/September each year. If the trend is that you are out of work for two months each year, perhaps increase your rate by 1/6th to reflect this.

CombatBarbie · 10/05/2023 15:35

NotQuiteHere · 10/05/2023 15:28

If you are a tutor with a good reputation, you keep a waiting list and in September you start filling your slots with 1. the students from the previous year who should have a priority if they want continue 2. students from the waiting list. Everything is clear, no drama involved.

Why should be current students get priority??

Its really not much different to childcare. If you want your child's space kept then you pay when you go on holiday etc. This shouldn't be any different.

Op, can you charge a lower retainer fee for the holidays and only take on students who need you over the summer??

Swipe left for the next trending thread