Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell clients to just leave

385 replies

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 22:43

I"m self employed with clients who pay monthly. I work 12 months of the year and take 4 weeks a year holiday which are unpaid - this is all explained upfront.

This year I've had an unprecedented number of clients who've informed me that they're not prepared to pay for my services over the summer as they're 'going on fancy holidays' and won't get the use of my services.

But they want me to take them back on in September once the summer holidays are over and the children are back in school.

AIBU to tell them they're free to go in June but I won't be giving them their space back in September?

I simply cannot afford to not be paid for 2 months. When I go on holiday (unpaid and only UK) I still pay all of my monthly bills (swimming, nursery etc)

I realise the cost of living affects even the wealthy, but it's the wealthiest clients who are doing this to me! For context, last year I earned £15k if that matters. I can't afford to take my children abroad (not that that's their fault I might add, but it does irk!)

AIBU to feel really pissed off and a little bit used/undervalued?

OP posts:
selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 00:24

stayathomer · 06/05/2023 00:10

In a way you’re not bu but in another way would you pay for a service you didn’t need because you weren’t there to use the service? But I don’t know how you fix it tbh.

I do. I pay for my kids swimming, gymnastics, tutor, nursery and tennis when I go on holiday. Granted, individually they cost less (aside from the tutor) but I simply inform them that my child won't be there.

I wouldn't dream of asking for a refund or telling them I"m not paying the full amount that month. Why should my holidays mean their income is affected?

If I go on holiday, I can't ring the bank to say I'm not paying my mortgage that month as I'm not living in my house !

OP posts:
KingofCats · 06/05/2023 00:23

tutors round here are £50-£100 (south east) if highly regarded

MaggieFS · 06/05/2023 00:23

This is your business and not a hobby. Sounds like you need to sort out all of your Ts and Cs (with proper advice) but broadly, you need to be clear how long people are signing up for, what the rate it, notify them of an increase each year, not permit 'breaks' and so on.

If you are in such demand, you can afford to reset the clock with everyone and they can take it or leave it.

selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 00:19

knobheeeed · 06/05/2023 00:10

I had one last year for piano who sent the child for the first week in September. Straight after the lesson she sent a message saying "X is transferring to the local music school so Y (sister of X) will be taking over the lessons instead".
Er no....... I'd already given Y a trial lesson in June and said she was too young and that they should wait for a couple of years as she wasn't ready to start piano.
So then the mother started kicking off wanting the money back for September because it was me cancelling the lessons and not her. Again, no.. because the agreement was to teach the other child - and he must have been registered with the music school before the summer to even get a place there - so I feel like she did it deliberately to try to force me to take on the younger child.
I didn't refund her the money and I suggested the younger child also went to the music school, whereupon the mum said "Yeah, we asked but they said they had no space".

Had to add clause to terms and conditions about lessons not being transferable to other children.

People really do try it on. Or I should say "some" people, because most of them are fine.

One who wants to finish shortly wants to send sibling for the last few lessons!

I don't have anything in my contract at the moment so what can I say other than sure. Suck it up - fume about it internally! But it has made me realise I've seriously got to cover for all scenarios.

I agree, most are fine. I've got some fabulous clients.

OP posts:
selfemployedwwyd · 06/05/2023 00:17

HanSB · 06/05/2023 00:12

Can your clients pre-pay you for a term? My children aren’t at the age for tutoring yet but I pre-pay a term for their gymnastics, drama school, swimming etc. I think they would be less likely to cancel on you then and you can re-word the contract. I don’t know what subject you tutor but your rate sounds low to me. I was looking into tuition for next year and £40-50 is the rate for virtual group learning. 1-1 in person is £80-120 in London.

I'm in the North.

I don't know any tutors locally that charge more than £45. I agree it seems low given my Mum used to pay £25 an hour 30 years ago! But I genuinely cannot see people paying as much as £80 an hour.

Pre payment of a term of gymnastics is only going to be £40/£50. Prepayment for a term of lessons at £40 a go is considerably more.

They pay monthly. I'm happy with that. It does mostly work.

OP posts:
HanSB · 06/05/2023 00:12

Can your clients pre-pay you for a term? My children aren’t at the age for tutoring yet but I pre-pay a term for their gymnastics, drama school, swimming etc. I think they would be less likely to cancel on you then and you can re-word the contract. I don’t know what subject you tutor but your rate sounds low to me. I was looking into tuition for next year and £40-50 is the rate for virtual group learning. 1-1 in person is £80-120 in London.

stayathomer · 06/05/2023 00:10

In a way you’re not bu but in another way would you pay for a service you didn’t need because you weren’t there to use the service? But I don’t know how you fix it tbh.

knobheeeed · 06/05/2023 00:10

I had one last year for piano who sent the child for the first week in September. Straight after the lesson she sent a message saying "X is transferring to the local music school so Y (sister of X) will be taking over the lessons instead".
Er no....... I'd already given Y a trial lesson in June and said she was too young and that they should wait for a couple of years as she wasn't ready to start piano.
So then the mother started kicking off wanting the money back for September because it was me cancelling the lessons and not her. Again, no.. because the agreement was to teach the other child - and he must have been registered with the music school before the summer to even get a place there - so I feel like she did it deliberately to try to force me to take on the younger child.
I didn't refund her the money and I suggested the younger child also went to the music school, whereupon the mum said "Yeah, we asked but they said they had no space".

Had to add clause to terms and conditions about lessons not being transferable to other children.

People really do try it on. Or I should say "some" people, because most of them are fine.

imnotsadyouresad · 06/05/2023 00:07

Honestly, I think you should allow customers to pause for their own holidays... but you should put your overall prices up to make this financially feasible for you.

That way your customers won't feel ripped off, and you won't feel vulnerable. Same result, but both parties think they've won.

I use a self-employed service (not tutoring) and I'm on old rates because I'm a good customer. I give plenty of notice when I can't use the service, and if I have to cancel at short notice because of an emergency or sickness, I pay anyway even though I'm under no obligation to do so. If I'm asked to move my appointments at short notice and I can accommodate that, I'm flexible. I also pay a Christmas bonus (again, this is not contractual - I just think it's a nice thing to do).

I think it's fine to have different rates depending on how long you've had a client relationship, but you should only keep older customers on lower rates where they're really good customers. If you can replace their slot and they're hard work, put their fees up and/or bin them off.

When you're self-employed and in demand, it's down to you to keep the clients you actually want. Don't keep bad clients where you can replace them with better ones.

porridgeisbae · 06/05/2023 00:03

THANBU for trying to cut their own costs really. But it does sound like some are being cheeky about it.

YANBU for doing as you see fit.

sladys · 05/05/2023 23:57

Scalessayeek · 05/05/2023 22:50

Just say, as a business I can’t afford to keep your spot open so you can either pay or lose the spot (if you can afford to maybe offer half price like some nurseries/childminders go for similar situations).

Or do this but word it as "I can't hold a spot open. Feel free to contact me in September and I'll let you know my availability"

That way if you're struggling in November as you haven't filled the slot you're not cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Hopefully you fill the spots tho and they regret being so tight

Dibbydoos · 05/05/2023 23:54

Do you have a contract in place? It should specify this exact situation and your own holiday entitlement so when/how you will advise them of your own holidays, how kuch notice etc. Honestly the rest of the year, they have to pay even if thry dont use the service - its exactly the same with nurseries etc.

How unreasonable are your clients?

Find better clients, OP.

Good luck x

Aweebitpainful · 05/05/2023 23:54

I need to tell myself this firmly because I'm
doing the same as you! Lol… you aren’t alone!

Aweebitpainful · 05/05/2023 23:51

Your time and knowledge is WORTH it!

Aweebitpainful · 05/05/2023 23:50

OP if you are fully booked you need to increase your price slightly.

Also consider giving old clients notice
that their lower payment is coming to an end and charge them the current / new rate going forward.

You are a business.

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 23:39

GCWorkNightmare · 05/05/2023 23:30

Can you work more than 8 hours a week?

I do. New clients (taken on in the last year) pay £40 an hour but I've got clients going back on various rates.

I do need to get everyone on the same rate of pay and will up my fees in September for all. Just need to get the wording right as it will be an increase of £40 a month for some, £30 a month for others.

I'm actually really bad at asking for money which is one of the reasons I went to monthly pay - although I regularly have 4 or 5 clients who don't pay on time (it's the 5th today and I'm short by 5!)

OP posts:
knobheeeed · 05/05/2023 23:38

I teach music - people pay for 10 months of the year and receive 38 lessons during the school terms. (I also tutor but they pay for blocks of 5 in advance, so a different system to yours).
The problem I had with the music students was people not beginning promptly again in September and then rocking back up in October. So I kept spaces open for them and they'd keep delaying their start. So I had to change terms and conditions to reflect that. They have to give notice at the end of the summer term if they don't want to come back in September (and one month's notice the rest of the year).
That still wouldn't solve the problem of people starting the term late so I added that people must reconfirm two weeks before the autumn term if they are continuing lessons and to arrange their time slot. I send a message out in good time. I won't keep slots open for anyone not confirming their return. Anyone confirming but wishing to start later has to pay from the beginning of the autumn term or lose the slot.
Also had one this year who really took the piss in a different way, so again, I've had to add yet another sentence to my terms and conditions for the coming academic year.

It's hard sometimes but you're running a business. Those clients are free to leave if they so wish, as long as they give adequate notice that they won't be continuing the lessons in the summer, but that means they won't be guaranteed a slot in September either.
Just tell them they can leave but you can't hold the slot for them, you have a waiting list and you can't afford to have free slots open not being used for an indeterminate length of time. There's no guarantee they'll start again promptly in September or even return at all.

Ellie56 · 05/05/2023 23:33

I would up your fees in September for all your clients in line with the new academic year, and in the meantime make it clear that you cannot hold spaces open for the CFs wanting to "take a break."

GCWorkNightmare · 05/05/2023 23:30

Can you work more than 8 hours a week?

VivX · 05/05/2023 23:23

Similar to pp suggesting you increase your fees, the alternative to attempting to enforce payment over the holiday period would be to build in the 2 months of unpaid holiday by increasing your fees for the other 10 months by 20%

TheHateIsNotGood · 05/05/2023 23:22

Well done OP - be firm, there are a lot of chancers out there. Value the services you provide - after 10 years you've proved your 'market' worth.

I say this to myself often. Not a tutor myself but one of my clients employs tutors as a large part of his business. I've respectfully told him to do one at least once, we are currently working under 'truce' arrangements (the job needs doing) and at least he's upgraded his T&Cs for his tutors as a by-product.

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 23:22

JagerbombsUnite · 05/05/2023 23:19

OP you can also add in your contract prices subject to annual review.

Yes I need to add that, thank you.

When do people think is a good time to increase? September in line with a new school year or April with a new tax year?

OP posts:
selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 23:21

Merangutan · 05/05/2023 23:09

Tell them that having tuition means they are having a weekly slot of your time allocated to them exclusively. This prevents you from offering it to other pupils on your waiting list. For that reason, if they choose to have more than two (or 3/4 - whatever you feel) consecutive weeks without lessons, you reserve the right to offer that slot to other pupils.

They can’t have it both ways - expect to not have the lessons for months but also expect to have the slot reserved and you turn away other clients who are willing to start now.

The other options you have are to charge more per hour so that it covers you for holiday pay OR to charge a holding deposit over summer to retain their place for September while still allowing other pupils to book in if they want to, on a temporary ad-hoc basis.

In addition to this, I've also had two clients decide they're finishing at the end of June instead of the end of August as they originally said. I'd turned down two replacement clients in March who could have filled these slots if I had known.

OP posts:
JagerbombsUnite · 05/05/2023 23:19

OP you can also add in your contract prices subject to annual review.

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 23:18

BeenThereTooo · 05/05/2023 23:07

Maybe you just need to up your rates and accept that you offer a 10 month service ( like a supply teacher).

I considered this, but I do think I'm at the top end as it is. I am a highly regarded tutor with verified reviews and my pupils achieve excellent results.

I charge £40 an hour for new clients. Some of these clients are still on the old rate of £30 an hour though (from 5 years ago) . I changed to monthly payments about 6 years ago as I was regularly getting people cancelling lessons to take their child for a hair cut or similar and I couldn't fill the space on a one off ad hoc basis.

I'm paying £40 an hour for the tutor I use for my child (different subject) so seems to be the going rate where we are.

OP posts: