Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell clients to just leave

385 replies

selfemployedwwyd · 05/05/2023 22:43

I"m self employed with clients who pay monthly. I work 12 months of the year and take 4 weeks a year holiday which are unpaid - this is all explained upfront.

This year I've had an unprecedented number of clients who've informed me that they're not prepared to pay for my services over the summer as they're 'going on fancy holidays' and won't get the use of my services.

But they want me to take them back on in September once the summer holidays are over and the children are back in school.

AIBU to tell them they're free to go in June but I won't be giving them their space back in September?

I simply cannot afford to not be paid for 2 months. When I go on holiday (unpaid and only UK) I still pay all of my monthly bills (swimming, nursery etc)

I realise the cost of living affects even the wealthy, but it's the wealthiest clients who are doing this to me! For context, last year I earned £15k if that matters. I can't afford to take my children abroad (not that that's their fault I might add, but it does irk!)

AIBU to feel really pissed off and a little bit used/undervalued?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kazzyhoward · 23/05/2023 18:34

FinallyHere · 23/05/2023 18:03

And it's really not great to say 'Pay me for all the holidays or I won't keep your place in September.'

Whyever not?

It's not a public service, as teaching arguably is. OP offers a service at commercial rates. People are free to take up that offer as suits them.

Anyone who does not recognise this I would encourage to give their head a wobble.

Not to mention that the OP is willing to continue tuition through the holidays but it's the parents who don't want to. It's not as if she wants to be paid for weeks when she is on holiday herself and not available for lessons. It's the parents who don't want tuition during the holidays.

FinallyHere · 23/05/2023 18:03

And it's really not great to say 'Pay me for all the holidays or I won't keep your place in September.'

Whyever not?

It's not a public service, as teaching arguably is. OP offers a service at commercial rates. People are free to take up that offer as suits them.

Anyone who does not recognise this I would encourage to give their head a wobble.

Stewball01 · 23/05/2023 13:35

Quite right. It's a business not a charity.

selfemployedwwyd · 13/05/2023 20:28

PhyllisFogg · 12/05/2023 07:32

I thought it was understood that tutoring is never the same as earning a salary where an employee gets 'holiday pay' and benefits like sick pay @selfemployedwwyd ?

The school year is approx 38 weeks (depending on whether state or independent schools.)

What's your position on all the other school holidays? Christmas, Easter, half terms? Are you charging for those weeks too?

Are you relatively newly qualified as a teacher and in working as a tutor? You mention your child at nursery so I'm assuming you are a younger tutor (rather than an older tutor who's tutoring post-retirement.)

I'm only asking as I tutored for many years, after years as a teacher in schools.

I never knew any tutor who worked 12 months of the year and neither did they expect parents to pay for those weeks. All 'extras' in schools- both state and independent - are charged by the term. Those teachers are not being paid for holidays when they don't give lessons.

The fact parents are complaining about your 'contract' shows you've got it wrong.

If you are desperate to earn more, your choices are -

  • Get a teaching job in a school maybe a 0.4 post and do tutoring as extra.
  • Be innovative and create some group classes over the summer for children who need some intensive tutoring but who are not your usual students.

You can't expect parents to fund what is your lifestyle choice (tutoring rather than a salaried teaching post in a school.) And it's really not great to say 'Pay me for all the holidays or I won't keep your place in September.'

What you can do is make your contract a half-term commitment (I asked for that payment upfront every term.) You could ask for payment for September at the end of the summer term, to secure their place.

it doesn't help earn you more money but if you want that, why not get a job in a school?

I've left this thread for a while.

Really appreciate all the replies.

However, it just shows that threads do run like Chinese whispers!!!

Just to clear up a few points that someone seems to have whispered and everyone has run along with :

I do not charge for holidays. No one pays me for my own holidays. They're unpaid. I do not ask for 8 x£40 over the summer holidays and not tutor (saying this for about the third time!)

The vast majority of my clients have been with me for years - I've taught siblings, cousins, neighbours you name it. I build very strong relationships with my pupils and their families.

No. I'm not newly qualified. I"m an highly experienced classroom teacher and I still do the odd day of supply in school. I also pay for my own self development courses to ensure I'm trained and up to date. I'm not the type of tutor who simply hands out a worksheet. I make a life changing difference to my pupils.

I moved to monthly payment after consulting my parents. It wasn't something that I did on a whim and it's worked very well over the years as it reduces my admin massively (one invoice for the month to send over to the client instead of four) Also, given that a lot of my pupils are children struggling academically, it makes much more sense to continue teaching over the holidays to avoid the learning loss.

I'm incredibly flexible with accommodating holidays (even though technically the contract says that holidays aren't covered, in reality I absolutely do where I can) it's never been an issue before now.

Every job in reality is a lifestyle choice.

With relation to the comment about my income and how many hours I work - It's not that simple. I've already explained due to fault of my own that I have people on different rates. It will all be streamlined this September.

Yes - I have all of the relevant public liability and professional indemnity insurances

I absolutely do pay for all of my own children's swimming lessons etc. They are not term time only. They go through the entire 52 weeks in 10 week blocks. If you don't miss, that's your space gone. My older child is an elite swimmer. I can just imagine her club's reaction if I informed them I was going on holiday that I didn't intend paying for squad swimming whilst I was away! I mentioned nursery from when mine were in nursery - one year I went abroad for 3 weeks. My payment to the nursery continued as normal. The following year he'd moved to a childminder. Same thing except I also paid for her holidays and received no service.

The tutor I use for one of my own children works all year round too.

Anyway. Amazing input all round.

I'm going to go to term time only tutoring but offer holidays to the dedicated who still want it (I'm guessing the majority will but it gives the option) In the longer holidays I will run intensive booster camps. During the summer I will actively focus on 11+ booster sessions. Costs will go up for all in September and I will explain to those on a lower initial cost that I'm simply bringing them in line with everyone else. If I lose them, I will move to my waiting list.

Thank you all for helping me take the emotion out of all this.

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 12/05/2023 16:23

@PhyllisFogg

I never knew any tutor who worked 12 months of the year and neither did they expect parents to pay for those weeks.

Our son's tutor didn't work on termly basis at all - he continued through school holidays as normal, but then he wasn't an active teacher, he'd taken early retirement so didn't work to school terms/holidays at all.

Ellyess · 12/05/2023 15:39

PhyllisFogg · 11/05/2023 09:17

@selfemployedwwyd You have had masses of replies but I wanted to add mine in case you are reading.

I tutored full time for almost 20 years. I offered dyslexia tutoring, as well as dyslexia assessments. I always had a waiting list as dyslexia tutors are thin on the ground. (I also tutored non-dyslexics in English to A level.) I tutored for around 15+ hours week including some daytime for children home educated, and also adults.

I never ever charged for holidays. I am absolutely surprised you think this is okay. It isn't IMO.

As a parent who was also shelling out for tutoring for my own children, I'd not have accepted those terms.

I worked on the basis of a half-term's notice (not including holidays.) So if someone was not coming back in Sept, I had to know by the end of May ( lessons finishing early July.)

I didn't refund for missed lessons by them, but would rearrange at my own convenience. (I came to this decision after many cancellations for things like parties and school trips.) I would refund for lessons I needed to cancel.

I also needed a break from tutoring and didn't want to carry on all over the summer. I did offer some catch-up lessons for a couple of weeks if needed.

I think the best you can do it either increase your fees to cover the times you don't work, or ask for a low retainer fee.

I really feel it is not ethical to ask for 8 x £40 over the summer when you are not tutoring.

This. It makes sense and has been tried and tested. By an Expert I think.

Ellyess · 12/05/2023 15:29

PhyllisFogg · 12/05/2023 07:35

I still pay all of my monthly bills (swimming,nursery...)

Really? If you are holidaying in normal school holidays, why are swimming lessons a) still running and b) not charged by the lesson?

My DCs had swimming lessons and they were like school terms- 10 lessons and no fees over the holidays when lessons stopped.

My children did swimming courses and you booked them in to the whole course, paying in full in advance before it began. Most courses were 1 hour a week, led to a qualification and lasted 10 to 12 weeks. They were so popular you had to book in on opening of booking or you would miss out.

Ellyess · 12/05/2023 15:23

Surely people book for a session of Tuition on the basis of a number of sessions on specified dates? If you keep to term times this is easy, you can say that pupils may be booked in per term or per year. That payment is for a term's worth of tuition, each term the cost would depend on the number of tuition sessions that term, and full payment in advance would be due by the second week. Late payment means the Pupil is dropped from the Tuition list unless there is a special arrangement, [which would be a rare exception]. Once dropped, a Pupil will go to the end of the Waiting list if they ask to return.

In School holidays you can offer set days for different types of tuition. E.g. revision course with up to say 3 Tutees together for five mornings of 2 hours each over one week to be paid in advance. Or single child tuition for an hour twice a week on specified dates arranged with the Parent and paid in advance. It would mean you could arrange to teach when you were free and plan according to what your Pupils need while being able to earn during the school holidays. The parents can book their child's tuition with you around their holiday if they are going away. But I advise you treat the school holiday tuition on a 'booking in advance' basis with, if not full payment on booking, then a deposit and full payment before commencement of the tuition.

As far as fees are concerned, I only know two examples. One, not a qualified Teacher but has a degree, giving individual tuition in London 6 years ago, charged £80 per hour for a 10 year old and came to the child's own home. The other is a qualified Teacher but been out of the classroom for over 30 years, charging £90 to £100 per hour for children between 8 and 16 in Oxford recently - probably still doing so. Imho this is extortionate but the parents would pay (and do?) just about anything to get their child in to the prestigious schools in Oxford.

I assume that, as you are using your home for your work and seeing clients there, you have all the appropriate insurances in place, e.g. Public liability insurance and Professional indemnity insurance.

PhyllisFogg · 12/05/2023 07:35

I still pay all of my monthly bills (swimming,nursery...)

Really? If you are holidaying in normal school holidays, why are swimming lessons a) still running and b) not charged by the lesson?

My DCs had swimming lessons and they were like school terms- 10 lessons and no fees over the holidays when lessons stopped.

PhyllisFogg · 12/05/2023 07:32

I thought it was understood that tutoring is never the same as earning a salary where an employee gets 'holiday pay' and benefits like sick pay @selfemployedwwyd ?

The school year is approx 38 weeks (depending on whether state or independent schools.)

What's your position on all the other school holidays? Christmas, Easter, half terms? Are you charging for those weeks too?

Are you relatively newly qualified as a teacher and in working as a tutor? You mention your child at nursery so I'm assuming you are a younger tutor (rather than an older tutor who's tutoring post-retirement.)

I'm only asking as I tutored for many years, after years as a teacher in schools.

I never knew any tutor who worked 12 months of the year and neither did they expect parents to pay for those weeks. All 'extras' in schools- both state and independent - are charged by the term. Those teachers are not being paid for holidays when they don't give lessons.

The fact parents are complaining about your 'contract' shows you've got it wrong.

If you are desperate to earn more, your choices are -

  • Get a teaching job in a school maybe a 0.4 post and do tutoring as extra.
  • Be innovative and create some group classes over the summer for children who need some intensive tutoring but who are not your usual students.

You can't expect parents to fund what is your lifestyle choice (tutoring rather than a salaried teaching post in a school.) And it's really not great to say 'Pay me for all the holidays or I won't keep your place in September.'

What you can do is make your contract a half-term commitment (I asked for that payment upfront every term.) You could ask for payment for September at the end of the summer term, to secure their place.

it doesn't help earn you more money but if you want that, why not get a job in a school?

Kaylagiampaolo87 · 12/05/2023 00:22

Based on what you said your contract states the 4 weeks notice only gets them out of the obligation to pay during their vacation it doesn't guarantee their spot is held. Simply explain that to them

FinallyHere · 11/05/2023 17:59

Oh, and I expect your rates will have gone up for new clients, factoring in the income list over the break.

Or you could offer two rates, one for those who continue paying and a higher ad hoc rate if they don't want to commit.

FinallyHere · 11/05/2023 17:55

we will give you a call in September when we need you back'

As long as you are clear that you cannot guarantee their slot back in September, then I would leave it there.

If you have managed to fill the slot, all well and good, if not I'd take 'em back but perhaps offer their preferred time slot to your clients you stay on.

I have a 121 slot which I pay for all year round exactly to secure it for myself. I'm happy to do so because I value it soooo much.

PhyllisFogg · 11/05/2023 17:01

but it's kind of normal for someone not to be able to take months of the year with no pay

This isn't really true. People who are self-employed usually only get paid for the hours they work or the service they provide.

If they want to charge a retainer such as 25 or 50% of the fee that is one possible way forward.

However, it does suggest that @selfemployedwwyd doesn't actually really care about her pupils and is happy to ditch them if some other parent can pay her for not teaching!

I had close working relationships with my pupils and their families. I really cared about them. It would have been hard to say I couldn't have them back in Sept if they didn't pay for 8 weeks of no lessons.

I actually think that the OP will struggle if she tries to implement this. Her current parents are already not happy with the idea.

A lot of tutors get work through recommendation and contacts. I never had to advertise and always had a waiting list. Some pupils were with me for 5 years.

It's possible parents will vote with their feet and seek other tutors.

Nordicrain · 11/05/2023 16:58

Also I wouldn't expect to pay for YOUR holidays. You are a service provider, not an employee.

Nordicrain · 11/05/2023 16:57

Tutors around my way work term time only, unless otherwise agree. That is my experience with all children's activities actually, other than swimming/

that said, if you have plenty of clients you can set your terms and do it as you wish. Supply and demand.

stichguru · 11/05/2023 16:51

Your other option is to charge more per session and have school holidays off. I mean I can see why parents don't want the tutoring over summer, but it's kind of normal for someone not to be able to take months of the year with no pay. If you can't respect that people need to be paid, then don't use their services.

PhyllisFogg · 11/05/2023 13:13

Typo- I meant independent schools don't charge on that basis for extra tutoring.

@selfemployedwwyd Isn't your answer being given already by the parents?
If they don't want to pay for 48 weeks, then you will lose them anyway, presumably?

If you fill their place with a new student, their parents may not want to pay for lessons they don't have, either.
Are you going to set out the 48 weeks of payment right at the start?

I used to take payment for a half term, in advance.
If they gave notice right at the end of a term, they would have to pay for another half term unless I could fill the place.

There are numerous tutoring agencies around and you risk your parents simply finding another tutor, who doesn't want to charge for 'non-taught lessons' if you carry on like this.

PhyllisFogg · 11/05/2023 10:25

AIBU to tell them they're free to go in June but I won't be giving them their space back in September?

Yes you are unreasonable.

I don't know anyone who charges on the basis you want.

Part of the downside of tutoring is the fact that the school year is not 52 weeks or even 48 as you want .

I'm with the parents here.

Independent schools charge like this for extra lessons (ie music etc).
The parents pay for the lessons their child has. That's not 52 or 48 weeks.

If you need the money, think about creating holiday classes, where other pupils can have intensive tutoring for a few weeks.

PhyllisFogg · 11/05/2023 09:17

@selfemployedwwyd You have had masses of replies but I wanted to add mine in case you are reading.

I tutored full time for almost 20 years. I offered dyslexia tutoring, as well as dyslexia assessments. I always had a waiting list as dyslexia tutors are thin on the ground. (I also tutored non-dyslexics in English to A level.) I tutored for around 15+ hours week including some daytime for children home educated, and also adults.

I never ever charged for holidays. I am absolutely surprised you think this is okay. It isn't IMO.

As a parent who was also shelling out for tutoring for my own children, I'd not have accepted those terms.

I worked on the basis of a half-term's notice (not including holidays.) So if someone was not coming back in Sept, I had to know by the end of May ( lessons finishing early July.)

I didn't refund for missed lessons by them, but would rearrange at my own convenience. (I came to this decision after many cancellations for things like parties and school trips.) I would refund for lessons I needed to cancel.

I also needed a break from tutoring and didn't want to carry on all over the summer. I did offer some catch-up lessons for a couple of weeks if needed.

I think the best you can do it either increase your fees to cover the times you don't work, or ask for a low retainer fee.

I really feel it is not ethical to ask for 8 x £40 over the summer when you are not tutoring.

LT1982 · 11/05/2023 08:41

They have the right to give the 4 weeks notice now but don't have the right to expect to automatically get their place back.

Could you start offering the choice of 48 weeks or term time only (higher fees for term time only to cover the gap?)

Aldo unsure why it is relevant to compare your holiday destination to theirs?

Nikkidannih · 11/05/2023 06:33

knobheeeed · 10/05/2023 12:32

Why are people still "assuming" the OP is a childminder or a nanny when it has been said several times, including by the OP herself, that she is a tutor?
At least read the OP's posts if you can't be bothered to read the whole thread - or maybe twig on to the fact that it is tutoring because the majority of posters are talking about tutoring, therefore we can assume that at some point the OP has confirmed it is tutoring.

Calm down lovely. Not everyone has time to read through 20 posts of comments. Not a big deal. People are just trying to be helpful and the original post was vague.

slithytoveisascientist · 10/05/2023 23:32

its disrespectful @Clementinesucks because they are trying to avoid giving notice and are just expecting OP to keep their place.

longestlurkerever · 10/05/2023 23:10

I think you're taking this far too personally. You have a termination clause. Your clients want to make use of it to avoid paying over the Summer. They think you'll have space in September for them to re-register. You may not. That's their look out but perfectly open to them to take the risk. All this business about supporting you and missing out on income and how much their holidays cost is wholly irrelevant and would piss me off tbh. They don't owe you a living

admc · 10/05/2023 23:08

When I went self employed, I worked out my day rates like this:

  • what are the running costs of your business including taxes, registrations, professional fees, consumables, equipment etc.
  • what do you need to earn for it to be worth doing this as your job?
  • what's the minimum number of days/hours you are likely to be billing for? (in your case it looks like this should assume just 10 months of the year, for example). Make sure you get fair holidays.
Add the first two and divide by the third, remembering that we all have lots of work to do that we can't charge for. It's worth working this through and comparing to what you're currently charging - you might be surprised.

If you're worried about competitiveness at the rates you need to charge, I'll say this: it's far better to compete on quality and track down the clients that'll pay a good rate than try to compete on price and get stuck in a race to the bottom.

If clients start behaving like yours, then you can just let them do it but the calculation above changes and your rates will go up.

On the other hand, you can keep the calculation the same but be clear with them that if they take a break you'll fill their space and they likely won't get it back.
If you otherwise like them as a client you can be upfront and say that if they only need you 10 months of the year then you'll be happy to hold their place on that basis, but your rates will have to go up to reflect the time you won't be earning but also won't be able to take on another client. You're the one taking the risk, so you should have the benefit of either bonus free time or extra income if you do manage to fill the gap for a few weeks.

If they're wealthy they probably didn't get that way by spending money they didn't have to. You may find they're content to pay a higher rate but only for the hours they use, rather than a lower rate but feel that some of it's wasted. They're effectively the same, I know, but they don't feel the same from the customer side and the aim here is probably to leave them feeling like they're getting everything they pay for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread