Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My parents are really pissed with DH- what would you do ?

237 replies

babysofmummys · 05/05/2023 20:36

Parents came to visit a couple of months ago for a few days and it's transpired that they found my DH very rude.

Apparently they felt he was ordering them about to help and clean / make food while they were here.

They stayed for a week, during which we had my DD's birthday party. My parents are people who like to make themselves useful when they visit. If they see something needs doing, they just get on with it. My mum is an obsessively clean person and cannot stand mess and insists on tidying up/ gets frustrated if things are left out and takes over the cooking when she visits.

Apparently during this visit they felt like my DH ordered them around, on top of the stuff they were doing to help. He told my mum to make a salad or something and told my dad to carry some stuff outside..

He then didn't offer to make them drinks, while he was making drinks for other people. He also kept saying ' someone needs to clean up XXX or whatever is was and my mum felt he was implying she should do it. I have noticed him doing this before to her. He'll just keep repeating to her and to me that XXX needs cleaning or sorting or whatever, but he won't do it himself because he's ' never home ' and ' doesn't have time... it's quite annoying and rude

My parents felt disrespected and now I'm unsure whether to tell DH. I think he needs to know on some level, so he doesn't do it again.

OP posts:
Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 05/05/2023 22:59

Mirabai · 05/05/2023 22:35

Her dad is clearly old school and bit extra - but that’s no excuse for DH behaving badly - two wrongs don’t make a right.

DH asking her mum to clean something specific is rude. I wouldn’t never ask my mum that when she was staying with me.

It's rude to ask someone who wants to help to clean something specific? I have never experienced that. I am happy if someone tells me what I can do to help them.

PatchworkElmer · 05/05/2023 22:58

I think you clearly have underlying DH issues here, but I’m not sure he did much wrong? Certainly his delivery could be improved, politeness costs nothing. But your parents wanted to help and we’re directed to where they’d be most useful. This is fine (with the addition of please and thank you!)

Flipping it the other way around- your Mum likes helping. She took over the cooking and prepared almost all of the party food. If your husband had gone into the kitchen and started making a salad, would that have offended her too? Would you have been dealing with conversations about how he took her cooking and she felt he was saying hers wasn’t good enough?

… Do you think that maybe your parents are more upset about this issue than they would otherwise be because they know there are issues in your marriage?

I wouldn’t put up with my husband dropping hints for me or my parents to do something and would address that with him at the time, privately. Personally I think it’s been left too long now to be brought up in its own right. I would mention it in the lead up to their next visit, in the context of ‘this is something I’d like to do differently next time’. BUT as I say, I think there are underlying issues here and if you feel this needs to be brought up due to the wider context then fair enough.

Appleandoranges · 05/05/2023 22:56

It's perfectly possible for your husband to be rude, and also your father and maybe your mother to be rude as well. It doesn't have to be one or the other. I think it's tricky for you. Your parents say your husband is bullying you and in control of you. But it is a possibility they are used to bossing you about as well. I don't know. I think rather than be swayed by your husband's view and your parent's view, you take the time to see what you think about things. It may take a bit of time but you need to work on your own confidence and self esteem so you can take a considered view on whether your husband or your parents are being rude. It sometimes easier said than done though.

Toomanylatenightprogs · 05/05/2023 22:55

But there’s ways of your DH to speak to your DPs, and ways not to:
MIL, do you mind cleaning the worktop ? Thanks. Vs Someone needs to clean that worktop.
FIL, are you ok taking those chairs into the garden ? Thanks Vs FIL, take those chairs outside.

You say he doesn’t respect everything you do for the family so the problem is your husband and his attitudes. He has family, not servants.

maidmarianne · 05/05/2023 22:54

Gymtastic · 05/05/2023 22:44

I’m really shocked at some of these answers, irs like folks have no idea how to handle guests. I can’t believe they’d take the husbands side.

op. Your mother is right, remember you are a person and important, he can’t bully you and boss you round. And irs unbelievably rude to do it to guests.

you need to tell him you’ve been mulling it over and feel he behaved poorly . Explain why, do not say your parents complained, he will isolate you more.

my question is when you saw him doing it, why didn’t you say something. I’d be furious if my husband did that to any guest, and I’d be heard and immediately, with , yeah it does need cleaned crack on and get it done.

he’s a dick. Trying to exert his dominance. Tell him and put a stop to this.

Surely parents/in laws staying for an entire week would be expected to help out with organising a family party? They can't expect to be waited on hand and foot all that time, I certainly wouldn't expect that when staying at my in laws.

If someone is going to get pissed off about simply being asked to carry something outside, it's hard not to think that maybe they're the ones being unreasonable? It sounds like both were at fault to be honest, but it's weird that you're completely defending your parents and can't see that maybe you could be having a chat with them about being unreasonable too. Did you tell your dad he was out of order when you were pregnant and he didn't want to help?

magma32 · 05/05/2023 22:47

So his parents live locally but he treats them with respect as they’re guests when they come around, but your parents live far and seem to be a nuisance for him when they stay and treats them like the help. I wouldn’t put up with that but I think you already know he’s a twat. Would your parents be supportive if you left him? Maybe your mum is telling you in case your Dh shit stirs about them. Maybe they think he’s trying to cut you off from them so they’re getting in there first, I dunno.

I agree your dad sounds abit old fashioned whereas your Dh seems like he knows what he’s doing.

Gymtastic · 05/05/2023 22:45

Wexone · 05/05/2023 22:35

I dunno here now. did you see your partner being rude to your parents? ate they really helpful or just doing things they think is helpful ? have they ever said anything before about your partner being rude or is just since you were telling your mother about your marital problems? I am a big believer that your mother us not your best friend she is your parent. have you close friends you can lean on instead ? If it's a serous matter I would also try therapy

Could you just not be arsed even reading her posts then?

thecatsmeows · 05/05/2023 22:45

@FortofPud I'd agree with that. Her parents are now at 'bitch eating crackers' stage with her husband. I think involving her parents in her marital problems has caused this situation, nothing the husband does now will be right in their eyes.

I feel for you OP, you are in a lose/lose situation with both parties now. I think I would tell your husband what your parents have said, you might as well, if you are already having problems his reaction may help inform you what to do next.

If there is a next time your parents come to stay, it would be better if it is in a hotel. I've had two sets of inlaws, I liked the second set but no way on Earth would I have had them to stay for a week - it's far too long.

JudgeRudy · 05/05/2023 22:44

Your husband might have been a bit bossy but why did no-one address this as it occurred? Now no-one will remember for sure exactly what was done or said now.
If you've noticed he has a habit of giving out orders you need to challenge this.
I'm unsure how others operate but I'd find a week an awful long time, way passed guest status.

Gymtastic · 05/05/2023 22:44

I’m really shocked at some of these answers, irs like folks have no idea how to handle guests. I can’t believe they’d take the husbands side.

op. Your mother is right, remember you are a person and important, he can’t bully you and boss you round. And irs unbelievably rude to do it to guests.

you need to tell him you’ve been mulling it over and feel he behaved poorly . Explain why, do not say your parents complained, he will isolate you more.

my question is when you saw him doing it, why didn’t you say something. I’d be furious if my husband did that to any guest, and I’d be heard and immediately, with , yeah it does need cleaned crack on and get it done.

he’s a dick. Trying to exert his dominance. Tell him and put a stop to this.

WhiteBloatus · 05/05/2023 22:44

Mirabai · 05/05/2023 22:06

Bottom line - when people are guests on your house, particularly the older generation there should be no expectation of help. Most people like to help out nonetheless, just as your parents like to help, and that’s great. But ordering them around and expecting graft is not ok.

Agree, and OP is clear that they have been genuinely helpful. Not abnormal that parents would be miffed to get ordered about by husband (who is also disrespectful to their daughter)

FortofPud · 05/05/2023 22:39

I think this is an unfortunate clash between the slightly dysfunctional peculiarities of your family and the slightly dysfunctional peculiarities of DHs family. There are bits of wrong and right on both sides and you stuck in the middle. You've also accidentally made it worse with the complaining about DH as that has tainted your parents view of him so that every small issue is exaggerated.

Cornishclio · 05/05/2023 22:39

Putting the issue of your parents aside it sounds like you should be talking to your DH about the way he talks to you. That sounds like the crux of the matter if you have been complaining to your parents about him and the way he treats you. As to whether your parents or your DH are to blame for the fall out none of them sound like they covered themselves in glory. I think you should talk to him instead of your parents.

RunningRunningRunningRunningRunning · 05/05/2023 22:38

A week long stay with them in his house and personal space when he's still working, I can see why he'd get pissed off with them. Them deciding what to do to help out could also annoy him, id hate someone coming round and clearing stuff up i didnt ask or want them to. Can they not stay in a hotel and have a bit of space if they stay a week? I couldn't put up with my in laws for a week.

WhiteBloatus · 05/05/2023 22:37

Your husband sounds disrespectful/inconsiderate to you and your parents, and your parents sound over sensitive about being treated ‘with respect’.
They have now put you in the middle of a loss lose situation. I feel for you. However, you do need to address with your husband the way he treats you and your parents, it’s wrong.

Mirabai · 05/05/2023 22:37

RedToothBrush · 05/05/2023 22:32

I did read the thread and I'm still willing to bet they were faffing around getting in the way swearing blind they were helpful but in reality were just slow and not really doing what needed to be done and were more of a hindrance than help to your DH.

He's got snappy when the pair of them haven't actually done what they have been supposed to.

They then create a narrative of how wonderful their help was.

Why are you willing to bet on people you’ve never met when the OP was there and has explained what happened? Why would you think you know better than OP?

Mirabai · 05/05/2023 22:35

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 05/05/2023 22:29

She later says her Dad resented being asked to help her when she was pregnant and told her she was ordering him around like a slave.
As well that her mom would be angry if she was asked to clean something specific. That's not healthy or helpful.

Her dad is clearly old school and bit extra - but that’s no excuse for DH behaving badly - two wrongs don’t make a right.

DH asking her mum to clean something specific is rude. I wouldn’t never ask my mum that when she was staying with me.

Wexone · 05/05/2023 22:35

I dunno here now. did you see your partner being rude to your parents? ate they really helpful or just doing things they think is helpful ? have they ever said anything before about your partner being rude or is just since you were telling your mother about your marital problems? I am a big believer that your mother us not your best friend she is your parent. have you close friends you can lean on instead ? If it's a serous matter I would also try therapy

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/05/2023 22:34

Your husband is incredibly rude. Are you scared of him?

Vivi0 · 05/05/2023 22:33

babysofmummys · 05/05/2023 22:15

They were absolutely being helpful. Everyone was doing different tasks to prepare food for the party and tidy up the garden. This idea that they weren't helpful is completely wrong. They single handedly prepared all the food with him and tidied up the garden.

I did as much as I could whilst also looking after the children. He then just asked my dad to carry something in addition to what he was doing. The idea that they were running around like headless chickens being useless is completely not true. Sorry if I made it seem that way, but it didn't happen this way at all. We all decided what we were going to do with the food and garden and they got stuck in. Later on, he then asked my mum to also prepare a salad, which she didn't like. The decisions about the food prior to the salad was all a joint decision and then he unilaterally decided we needed a salad and that she should make it. This was later on when other guests arrived.

I just wanted to clear that up.

That paints a much clearer picture, actually.

So he asked your mum to prepare a salad. Then he asked your dad to carry something.

It would make sense to ask the person who was responsible for preparing the food if they could also prepare a salad. It might not have been something that was agreed upon beforehand, but it is easy to forget things when organising a party. He thought a salad was needed and asked your mum to prepare one. Your mum could have said, “Sorry, I’m a little busy. Could you do it?”

Asking your dad to carry something is a complete non issue.

I asked if your parents have form for taking offence, because I can’t see what there is to take offense over.

RedToothBrush · 05/05/2023 22:32

Mirabai · 05/05/2023 22:26

It would be great if people would read the thread and not invent their own narrative.

I did read the thread and I'm still willing to bet they were faffing around getting in the way swearing blind they were helpful but in reality were just slow and not really doing what needed to be done and were more of a hindrance than help to your DH.

He's got snappy when the pair of them haven't actually done what they have been supposed to.

They then create a narrative of how wonderful their help was.

Whyisitsosohard · 05/05/2023 22:32

Dh sounds super rude which you've acknowledged to your mum. I also feel for your dad. If you're already doing something I wouldn't appreciate being told to also do something else. Sounds like you require a lot of help for 2 adults.

I wouldn't dream of asking my in laws to prep food or clear the garden. I'm heavily pregnant now and still say no if my in laws offer to get me a chair although I'll accept a drink. Not making them one when you're doing it for others is unbelievably rude as well.

Noicant · 05/05/2023 22:30

Yeah I think it’s mainly your husband. If I had just made all the party food and DD’s DH then told me (TOLD) that I’m to make a salad I’d be pretty fucked off too. It’s an extension of the lack of respect he has for you. I’m not saying your parents are perfect but it sounds like they do a lot for you guys already and now your DH sees them as staff rather than appreciating the help.

Mirabai · 05/05/2023 22:30

If OP and DH organise a party it’s up to them to prepare it. Her parents aren’t staff. It was very nice of them to prepare most of the food.

Tbh if I had a party when my parents were staying I wouldn’t allow them to do anything but the most minor of preparations.

junebirthdaygirl · 05/05/2023 22:29

Does your dh work in a situation where, under pressure, he orders people around and then continues this at home. When everyone is rushing around it might happen that he would tell someone to do something but if he generally orders you around that is not on. Maybe some therapy would help you.