Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to help DS stop being so sensitive?

159 replies

Hoollaaahooops · 05/05/2023 16:12

Over the past couple of years my DS, 8, has grown more and more sensitive, currently it’s impacting friendships and even families interactions with him so I want to help develop resilience.

A recent example was my sister was chatting to DS and DD (5) and DD asked if my sister thought she would look nice when she is an old lady, my sister then jokes ‘didn’t you know, some babies when born look like little old people so I already know you’ll look nice when you’re old’ cue lots of laughter from DD. DD then asked if her brother also looked like an old man when born, my sister said of course, babies look a little wrinkly when they come out so DS also looked like a cute little old man. DS laughed for about a second then burst out crying, got really angry at my sister and started shouting that his aunt was being mean to him, he didn’t want to be an old man, and that he never looked like a little old man. He then stormed out the room after kicking his chair over. Obviously interactions like this are putting people off spending time with him, as even the most light hearted comment or joke is taken so seriously. It doesn’t help that DD is so confident and can really take and enjoys lighthearted conversations and practical jokes.

Im working with a play therapist (as he has gone through trauma in his childhood which is why he is so sensitive) who has suggested modelling gentle teasing to help show him that people can playfully tease each other and it’s not some form of attack. However I’ve had a few mean comments from other parents when discussing this with them, so wanted to see if I was being unreasonable for trying to (in their words) ‘change my sons nature’ as apparently sensitivity isn’t something to be ‘fixed’

Currently as it’s early days I’m modelling being teased myself and showing an appropriate response, but it will be worked up to gentle teasing for him to be able to identify when people are joking and when people are being mean.

If anyone else has super sensitive children and had other ways to help I’d also be grateful to hear other techniques to compliment what I’m already doing too, as it’s really impacting him socially.

OP posts:
HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 23:22

Nightlystroll · 05/05/2023 23:15

I don't understand what you mean about making mistakes. The aunt made a mild joke with the daughter. They all laughed. She made a similar joke with the son and he kicked off. The son had already assessed the interaction between his sister and his aunt and saw no offence. But he decided it was a big deal when it referred to him.

Of course parents can just say that no one should make any comment round my son. And that might work great when he's in the coddled atmosphere of home. And teachers might say no one is to laugh at anything in case someone is offended. And that might work great in a sterile classroom. But life is big and noisy and disrespectful and full of people who think and speak and act differently. And it can become very lonesome for a child that groups don't want to include in case they laugh wrong and he goes off crying to the teacher so they all get punished.

A parents job is to make sure their children are happy and functioning in society. If they are fragile and looking for offense, they will find it continually and they won't be happy. How does that benefit the child? And society does make a lot of allowances for people who are different. But in social situations, those that are fractious and don't learn to join in, will eventually be left out. The op can see this happening already and she wants to help her child have better opportunities than that.

I actually did not understand why the poster I was responding to brought up mistakes. They said There's no harm in laughing at mistakes you've made or other people joking about it.. The kid didn’t make any mistakes.

I don’t agree the child is “looking for offence”. He’s been through trauma, that makes you fragile and you absolutely do not heal someone from trauma by subjecting them to further hurt whether that is emotional or physical.

He will be happier and functioning if HOME is a space safe from being hurt. The rationale that the world is cruel so I must make home cruel too to toughen up my kid is absolutely wrong. It doesn’t work at all.

Coxspurplepippin · 05/05/2023 23:19

Oh, x-post, just 3 minutes late.........

Coxspurplepippin · 05/05/2023 23:18

It's not 'mocking his appearance'. It's not teasing. It's having a conversation about what babies look like. How do you think the OP and play therapist should be dealing with it? How do you think OP's son is going to navigate life if he gets so upset by this? It's not 'suppressing hurt' or even about 'toughening up' it's about learning how to react to something which isn't 100% what you want to hear, even though it's a perfectly nice thing to say, to not take offence or umbrage at something where there was nothing to be offended by.

Dealing with bullying or unwanted teasing is one thing. This is not it.

Nightlystroll · 05/05/2023 23:15

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 22:42

So, the 8yo made a mistake by being an ugly wrinkly old man looking baby? I don’t think you understand the difference between laughing at a funny mistake someone has done (and thinks was funny too when they told you about it) versus mocking someone for something they have no control over- like their looks.

I don't understand what you mean about making mistakes. The aunt made a mild joke with the daughter. They all laughed. She made a similar joke with the son and he kicked off. The son had already assessed the interaction between his sister and his aunt and saw no offence. But he decided it was a big deal when it referred to him.

Of course parents can just say that no one should make any comment round my son. And that might work great when he's in the coddled atmosphere of home. And teachers might say no one is to laugh at anything in case someone is offended. And that might work great in a sterile classroom. But life is big and noisy and disrespectful and full of people who think and speak and act differently. And it can become very lonesome for a child that groups don't want to include in case they laugh wrong and he goes off crying to the teacher so they all get punished.

A parents job is to make sure their children are happy and functioning in society. If they are fragile and looking for offense, they will find it continually and they won't be happy. How does that benefit the child? And society does make a lot of allowances for people who are different. But in social situations, those that are fractious and don't learn to join in, will eventually be left out. The op can see this happening already and she wants to help her child have better opportunities than that.

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 23:04

@Coxspurplepippin
DD then asked if her brother also looked like an old man when born, my sister said of course, babies look a little wrinkly when they come out so DS also looked like a cute little old man.

Thats mocking his appearance and he was old enough to be hurt by it:

DS laughed for about a second then burst out crying, got really angry at my sister and started shouting that his aunt was being mean to him, he didn’t want to be an old man, and that he never looked like a little old man.

You know if we recognised the damage such teasing does and people actually listened and stopped, then there’d be less misery in the world. Toughening up doesn’t make the hurt go away. You simply suppress it and when you’ve been subjected to past trauma like this boy has, your tolerance for this sort of thing has been ripped away from you. You can’t suppress the hurt and pretend to laugh along.

Coxspurplepippin · 05/05/2023 22:56

'So, the 8yo made a mistake by being an ugly wrinkly old man looking baby?'

Good grief. Suggest you read the OP again. No-one was mocking anyone.

'you need to meet your child where they’re at not try and change them because you’re embarrassed that they’re too sensitive.'

It's a big old world out there. Assuming everyone is going to meet your child where they're at is opening the child up to a world of pain. The best thing you can do, while understanding your child's sensitivities, is help them navigate the world so they don't meet everything as an insult or someone having a go at them.

The op's sister told her nephew he looked like a cute little old man as a baby, as most babies do, as his sister did (well, a cute little old lady). There is nothing malicious here, nothing to get upset about, no joke, or tease. If the op's son doesn't learn to navigate this kind of thing, he's going to have a miserable life.

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 22:55

Garethkeenansstapler · 05/05/2023 22:33

Yeah, smacking a kid is the same as gentle good natured teasing.

Good grief the extrapolation on here, I’m amazed some of you have made it this far in life with such dramatic attitudes.

It’s not the same, but funnily enough they’re both methods of bullying.

And you’re not being objective by adding in the “gentle, good natured” crap. Do you know how many school yard and workplace bullies gaslight their victims with the “just joking” and “why can’t you take a joke”?

How many times are children gaslit with the oh boys/girls are mean to boys/girls they like? And told to just shut up and be grateful for the attention or they’ll “lose friends.” It’s twisted.

Desensitising just teaches children that their feelings on anything said about them as a person are completely invalid. That what matters most is not upsetting whoever is saying shit about you while laughing in your face. It’s not a kindness. You’re teaching a child that their place in life is to be shit on.

humus · 05/05/2023 22:46

i’m confused and concerned as to why a play therapist would be working on your child being less sensitive, you need to meet your child where they’re at not try and change them because you’re embarrassed that they’re too sensitive. There is also the possibility your child is neurodiverse, my child is and they’re very similar.

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 22:42

Nightlystroll · 05/05/2023 22:29

Groups that tease are not the only social groups on the planet. 😕
Being excluded from “mean girl” groups isn’t the deterrence you think it is.

Teasing isn't about being mean. I said nastiness is something different. But do you never go out with friends and laugh over different things you've all done and said? Joked and pulled people's legs. There's no harm in laughing at mistakes you've made or other people joking about it. To not be able to laugh at yourself shows such fragility that I don't think can be healthy for your mental health and resilience.

So, the 8yo made a mistake by being an ugly wrinkly old man looking baby? I don’t think you understand the difference between laughing at a funny mistake someone has done (and thinks was funny too when they told you about it) versus mocking someone for something they have no control over- like their looks.

JazbayGrapes · 05/05/2023 22:38

Yeah, smacking a kid is the same as gentle good natured teasing.

It's only "good natured" if the other side finds it so. If you know it upsets them, and you keep on winding them up - then you're an arsehole.

Garethkeenansstapler · 05/05/2023 22:33

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 21:28

Should parents also hit their kids around a bit as well as say they looked like a wrinkly old man as a baby, as in one ugly baby while laughing at them? After all bullies are rampant in school. By your logic it would be a kindness to desensitise a kid by giving them a few good surprise wallops so they can toughen up for future bullying. Learn to accept that nowhere is safe for them.

Yeah, smacking a kid is the same as gentle good natured teasing.

Good grief the extrapolation on here, I’m amazed some of you have made it this far in life with such dramatic attitudes.

Nightlystroll · 05/05/2023 22:29

Groups that tease are not the only social groups on the planet. 😕
Being excluded from “mean girl” groups isn’t the deterrence you think it is.

Teasing isn't about being mean. I said nastiness is something different. But do you never go out with friends and laugh over different things you've all done and said? Joked and pulled people's legs. There's no harm in laughing at mistakes you've made or other people joking about it. To not be able to laugh at yourself shows such fragility that I don't think can be healthy for your mental health and resilience.

JazbayGrapes · 05/05/2023 21:39

Should parents also hit their kids around a bit as well as say they looked like a wrinkly old man as a baby, as in one ugly baby while laughing at them? After all bullies are rampant in school.

I've actually seen people suggest that a lot. Hit your kids "with love" so they don't murder their school bullies in the future.

Irritateandunreasonable · 05/05/2023 21:34

Tinkerbyebye · 05/05/2023 16:24

Teasing is bullying, it’s as simple as that. Some take it, some don’t. I hate being teased about anything, is a nasty activity and your sister owes your son an apology

Goodness. That’s ridiculous.

Isthatascratchonmygrandmother · 05/05/2023 21:31

My DD (8) is like this. She takes offence to everything. I could say 'DD can you close the door behind you please?' And she thinks it's a telling off. I can say 'you've got a right bedhead today lass' and she's in tears. Dh started saying 'what you laughing at?' everytime she cries and she immediately explodes into laughter. Every single time. So we believe its just a melting pot of emotions at this age. She also has ADHD so we know she can't help it at this stage and she's got considerably more sensitive since she turned 8. The 'what you laughing at' is really good at de-escalating her minor troubles because she often reflects afterwards and says she doesn't know why she cried at that and then we all chuckle and move on fairly quickly. We are mindful to support her if she has a genuine worry or anxiety about something but if she takes offence to something silly we quickly shut it down.

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 21:28

SchoolShenanigans · 05/05/2023 19:49

Aw, if only we could all just stop anyone being unkind to them ever.

The world isn't like that. They will be faced with sarcasm and challenges at every step of their childhood at school, and at work/social life when an adult.

Trying to desensitise your kid is a KIND thing to do. He obviously currently associate any criticism, however gentle or in jest it is, as a personal knock on his character which must feel awful. Much better to see if he can start to accept it.

Should parents also hit their kids around a bit as well as say they looked like a wrinkly old man as a baby, as in one ugly baby while laughing at them? After all bullies are rampant in school. By your logic it would be a kindness to desensitise a kid by giving them a few good surprise wallops so they can toughen up for future bullying. Learn to accept that nowhere is safe for them.

JazbayGrapes · 05/05/2023 21:27

You need to accept that this is his personality and treat him with more respect. Build his confidence up, Channel his sensitivity into something constructive (i.e. look after animals).

Banter is all about time and place. What would be a funny joke over a pint of beer, is completely inappropiate at work.

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 21:16

Nightlystroll · 05/05/2023 20:25

The whole world won't change to accommodate someone who is ultra sensitive. It will just bulldoze over them. The adage of it's only a joke if everyone is laughing sounds sensible in the sterile atmosphere of a classroom. But its logical conclusion is that no one can laugh unless everyone finds something funny, and that isn't realistic. Leaving aside nastiness, all groups tease each other, it's a sign of affection and acceptance. It's where you learn boundaries of how far to push and when to back off. If someone continually whines over things or kicks off, they'll just be omitted so the group can have a laugh without them.

Groups that tease are not the only social groups on the planet. 😕
Being excluded from “mean girl” groups isn’t the deterrence you think it is.

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 21:12

Garethkeenansstapler · 05/05/2023 19:48

You’re super sensitive. Saying babies look like little old men ‘yes even you Jimmy!’ is not fucking bullying. And people who cannot take a joke, laugh at themselves or even realise when something is intended as humour are utterly tiresome and usually friendless. Sure go ahead and teach kids that any attempt at humour from other people is ‘bullying’ and see how much fun they get out of life.

I did not say “fucking bullying” once in my post so you actually sound more sensitive than I as you’re OTT angry at my opinion so I must have touched a nerve.

I am sorry that you cannot enjoy life and have fun without making a “friend” the butt of your jokes. Are you sure you are not the tiresome and friendless one? I have tons of friends as do my children and larger family and these are friends who would not stop at anything to be there for us, or us for them.

Genevie82 · 05/05/2023 21:12

@DIYandEatCake

Lovely post - spot on x

Applequash · 05/05/2023 20:56

Garethkeenansstapler · 05/05/2023 20:44

So no jokes, ever?

Why is humour so demonised and dismissed on mumsnet? It’s all that keeps me going some days.

Many on here lack the ability to build friendships, most likely due to having no sense of humour at all. Sad really

Garethkeenansstapler · 05/05/2023 20:44

Greenfairydust · 05/05/2023 20:31

So your son has gone through trauma and you are asking why he is not coping with ''teasing''?

I really despair sometimes.

Also you need to accept people are different. Because you are a ''jokey'' family does not mean your son has to fan of silly jokes.

I am not sure your kid is really the problem here...

So no jokes, ever?

Why is humour so demonised and dismissed on mumsnet? It’s all that keeps me going some days.

Coxspurplepippin · 05/05/2023 20:39

There is nothing in the op's sister's comments that could be construed as bullying or even teasing. It does sound as if your DS is a bit oversensitive, and he does need to learn how to manage his feelings, so following the advice of the play therapist seems like a good idea.

cadburyegg · 05/05/2023 20:34

Interesting thread because my 8yo ds is the same. Super sensitive but also very clingy to me and will fly into rages if asked to do homework or practise times tables. He struggles to go into school or be away from me for any length of time. It's an exhausting combination.

I don't know how to handle it tbh but you're not alone.

I might consider some private play therapy or counselling for him.

Thing is I remember being similar as a child. I used to have a very short fuse. It has got better over time. I wonder if my parents tolerated it because I was a girl, and maybe (even subconsciously) we expect boys to be more emotionally robust?

Greenfairydust · 05/05/2023 20:31

So your son has gone through trauma and you are asking why he is not coping with ''teasing''?

I really despair sometimes.

Also you need to accept people are different. Because you are a ''jokey'' family does not mean your son has to fan of silly jokes.

I am not sure your kid is really the problem here...