Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school have to make adjustments?

144 replies

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 12:01

Hi, DD11 has her SATs next week.

She is autistic. Diagnosed last year.

She's been in contact with the SENDCO over the past few weeks after advocating for a space where she can be alone as she finds it hard to understand questions unless she reads them out loud. Obviously she will disrupt other kids if she does this.

Admittedly I haven't been involved (my mistake) as she was updating me every step of the way.

Last night the class teacher emailed me that they would be unable to meet her request because (paraphrasing) they had run out of teachers/assistants/rooms to accommodate everyone who requested or needs adjustments.

I've checked the gov.uk site and it simply says 'children are entitled to adjustments' blah blah, not 'entitled to adjustments if the school can accommodate'.

DD usually scores very well on exams but is so stressed out over the SATs. It doesn't matter that we've told her that they are a measurement for the school there's a lot of self pressure. I think the schoo think 'she's doing fine, doesn't need the adjustment'

Can I push this? I have emailed the teacher to express my disagreement over this approach and suggested that we can provide an independent (my friend does exam invigilation and will sit with her).

Advice needed. Please.

OP posts:
JetWashingIsMyHobby · 05/05/2023 12:59

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 12:55

It all depends on what has been done up to now.
Schools do continuous assessment all the time and SATS prep.
If your child has had
sensory breaks
extra time
different room
scribe
in the run-up to these exams then they'll make access arrangements.
Same with GCSE - it isn't the diagnosis, it's the precedent (what has always been done in class for internal exams) that counts.

The precedent has to start somewhere.

Funkyslippers · 05/05/2023 12:56

You would need to provide evidence of her exam concessions. Just because she has a diagnosis it doesn't mean she is entitled to a separate room

LittleOwl153 · 05/05/2023 12:55

Folks are correcting terms of time scales and staff/space. HOWEVER your daughter is entitled tonwork in whatever way is most accessible to her. If this means she reads out the questions to a room full of students then so be it. If that irritates others then the school will have to act to solve - and by this I do not mean by telling your daughter to shut up. They may not have a separate room/person but they could put up a screen to separate her into a corner for example so she is still visible to the teacher but sound carries less...

But do please talk to the SENDCO at her allocated secondary sooner either than later. It is likely if she has no 'paperwork' now she won't be handed over properly to them which won't help her start. Talk to them about EHCP and the best way of applying in your area.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 12:55

It all depends on what has been done up to now.
Schools do continuous assessment all the time and SATS prep.
If your child has had
sensory breaks
extra time
different room
scribe
in the run-up to these exams then they'll make access arrangements.
Same with GCSE - it isn't the diagnosis, it's the precedent (what has always been done in class for internal exams) that counts.

JetWashingIsMyHobby · 05/05/2023 12:48

Apply yourself to local authority for EHCP needs assessment. They might refuse to assess, but your daughter meets legal threshold so ignore any nonsense they use to refuse, don’t bother with mediation and just fill in appeal form. If they refused the first time they will concede when you appeal.

Then your daughter will be assessed by educational psychologist and this is the time to look at things like exam access arrangements. Secondary is going to be much more demanding than primary, get things moving asap and advocate for your daughter in future.

GiltEdges · 05/05/2023 12:46

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 12:34

what do you want them to do if they dont have the staff or the rooms? Build another functioning adult human in the workshop over the weekend? extend the school? Be reasonable

With respect, why should the OP's child not have her needs accommodated when other children will have? It puts her at a material disadvantage and it's illegal.

viques · 05/05/2023 12:46

What happens normally in the classroom when she has to read something, eg a maths question with several,parts, or a piece of text to use in history or geography. There will have been a number of practice SAT papers taken in school, what was the arrangement then? Either she has managed to do this previously in a classroom setting by reading out loud quietly to herself , or she doesn’t actually have to do it and what she is expressing is some anxiety about the SAT tests.

AnImmenseDislikeOfPeople · 05/05/2023 12:43

As someone who had 'reasonable adjustments' at school, they have to accommodate as long as they were given sufficient notice. You need to fight them on this. It is irrelevant whether they are out of staff or don't have enough room, they need to find it. When I sat exams at college, everyone else went to a completely different exam location. I stayed on campus in a computer room on my own with the invigilator. Do not let them fob off your daughter.

KinderCat · 05/05/2023 12:41

I work in a school so this is coming purely from my experience. Whilst I do understand the stress your DD and you just both feel, the school also have rules to follow and if they have students with EHCP who have been identified as needing exam arrangements as part of that they have to have priority. And like another poster mentioned, normal way of working will come into it. The school should have a record of this being a normal requirement for your child or past exams being completed in this way. Space and staff are valuable commodities in schools and it is horrid to say this but not everyone can have their own space necessarily. I'm sorry OP. Definitely push for it in future and chase it up as for GCSE all things like this need to be applied for months prior to the exam externally...

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 12:39

No she's never say tests like this before. With her SATs in year 2 she didn't have a diagnosis. So no evidence that she's sat one on one.

She doesn't have an ECHP, I see how that is a problem. I will try to get one in place as she is approaching high school.

I have advised that I can provide an independent person. A person with a DBS and who is an exam invigilator.

I have already mentioned that they emailed me last night to say they couldn't accommodate her. I haven't raised this on the last day, I thought this was in place prior to this. They came to me to say no can do.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 12:34

what do you want them to do if they dont have the staff or the rooms? Build another functioning adult human in the workshop over the weekend? extend the school? Be reasonable

MelchiorsMistress · 05/05/2023 12:32

Have you got evidence that she has sat other tests this way? They may want proof that it is necessary first

Semtee · 05/05/2023 12:28

I'd also argue thy noon on the Friday before they start on the next working day is really far too late to be having this conversation. If you were that worried, this should have been discussed a month ago.

CwmYoy · 05/05/2023 12:27

It's all very well to say it's unacceptable but if they don't have the staff they can't conjure them up from nowhere. Which other child should lose support to benefit another?

It's a horrible situation for you and the school but they can't work miracles. My friend who is a HT has been advertising for support staff since September and has only had 2 applicants. There is a child in desperate need of a 1 to 1 but no one is prepared to do it.

Semtee · 05/05/2023 12:27

You have to be realistic though. Not all schools physically have space. SATS can be an absolute logistical nightmare. Arrangements should mirror normal classroom practice so it might not actually be possible. I've taught year groups where 1 in 3 have had some sort do SEN and it's about trying to do the best by all children. The school hopefully isn't just being awkward for the sake of it.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 05/05/2023 12:19

They need to fix this. It's unacceptable. As above, I'd say that you will bring her in Tuesday and stay until they confirm they have a private space she can use. If one is not provided, you will take her home.

Realowlette · 05/05/2023 12:17

Under the Equality Act 2010 the school have a legal duty to make reasonable adjustments. They've had plenty of time to consider this and bring in an additional person / find a room. I'd be asking for an urgent meeting with the SENCO and head, before contacting the governor with responsibility for SEN. Good luck.

Saniflo · 05/05/2023 12:05

Tell them you won't send her in if they don't accommodate. Does she have an EHCP? My eldest 2 do and it states they must have certain accommodations in exams. Maybe you need to consider getting an EHCP?