Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school have to make adjustments?

144 replies

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 12:01

Hi, DD11 has her SATs next week.

She is autistic. Diagnosed last year.

She's been in contact with the SENDCO over the past few weeks after advocating for a space where she can be alone as she finds it hard to understand questions unless she reads them out loud. Obviously she will disrupt other kids if she does this.

Admittedly I haven't been involved (my mistake) as she was updating me every step of the way.

Last night the class teacher emailed me that they would be unable to meet her request because (paraphrasing) they had run out of teachers/assistants/rooms to accommodate everyone who requested or needs adjustments.

I've checked the gov.uk site and it simply says 'children are entitled to adjustments' blah blah, not 'entitled to adjustments if the school can accommodate'.

DD usually scores very well on exams but is so stressed out over the SATs. It doesn't matter that we've told her that they are a measurement for the school there's a lot of self pressure. I think the schoo think 'she's doing fine, doesn't need the adjustment'

Can I push this? I have emailed the teacher to express my disagreement over this approach and suggested that we can provide an independent (my friend does exam invigilation and will sit with her).

Advice needed. Please.

OP posts:
cansu · 05/05/2023 18:10

You should have not left it to your daughter to sort this out.
It also depends on what is her normal practice. Does she normally need to read the questions aloud?
I would imagine it is easier to find her a smaller room to sit in with supervision than to sort out an individual room where she can read out the questions.

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 18:07

Have caught up with school: unfortunately there is nothing they can do regarding a private space and the ability to read the questions out loud.

They did say that if she was becoming overwhelmed or frozen (this is what happened in the mock exam yesterday, she couldn't move on from a question she couldn't answer and missed a whole page of questions because 'her brain wouldn't let her move on' then panicked and cried after the mock) that she can put her hand up and take a breather outside the room. I said 'but she will have the same time as everyone else and he said 'yes' so I said 'any breather time is included in the exam time?' And he said yes... so that doesn't work.

He hadn't even noticed she was upset yesterday and so I don't think he's going to be softly softly about this.

I challenged on this and he said he's going to raise it with the head.

On another note, is it normal on here to ask for advice (of which I am very grateful) and to be called stroppy? I feel like I've been scolded 😂

OP posts:
hereiamagainn · 05/05/2023 18:06

I think you need to show your daughter that you really mean it when they say “it doesn’t matter, it’s for the school”. And leave it be.

It would be very different if these were her GCSEs. In year 6, if she’s coping in a mainstream classroom every day and achieving well, it’s not unreasonable to have these dame conditions for SATs. She needs to think of them like any other classroom test. Because they are exactly that.

Butterflyflytoday · 05/05/2023 18:05

They probably don’t have the staff or space needed to accommodate your DD. They will prioritise the children whose reasonable adjustments are their normal way of working.

The SENCO shouldn’t have suggested it to your DD until plans were finalised.

ManyRiversToCross · 05/05/2023 17:57

HurryShadow · 05/05/2023 13:45

A couple of things:

  • as PP have said, push for ECHP statement for when your DD has important exams
  • SATs aren't important exams and are of no benefit to your DD whatsoever, so keep her home that day if they aren't able to help. They're a reflection on the school, so if a pupil isn't provided with the support to be able to take the exam I'd say that's a fair reflection on the school!

You really won't get an EHCP for the purpose of providing special exam arrangements. There is absolutely no need. Complete waste of time and effort. The diagnosis entitles her to reasonable adjustments anyway, via equality act.

She only needs an ehcp if she has needs that a school can't be expected to support from their own budget despite their best endeavours, and if she isn't making decent progress in her areas of need.

To think school have to make adjustments?
ManyRiversToCross · 05/05/2023 17:45

If she has a diagnosis you don't need a EP or EHCP to recommend special exam arrangements.
She can have them as reasonable adjustments to accommodate her autism, which is protected under equality act.

It is "reasonable" adjustments though. Not any adjustment. The school might argue that she could sit in the room with the TA who is reading aloud and "hear" the questions that way. Couldn't she whisper under her breath in the same room as others, or in a small room but not alone? Is there proof that she can't comprehend info taken in visually, and that she needs an aural pathway?

Semtee · 05/05/2023 17:36

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 12:39

No she's never say tests like this before. With her SATs in year 2 she didn't have a diagnosis. So no evidence that she's sat one on one.

She doesn't have an ECHP, I see how that is a problem. I will try to get one in place as she is approaching high school.

I have advised that I can provide an independent person. A person with a DBS and who is an exam invigilator.

I have already mentioned that they emailed me last night to say they couldn't accommodate her. I haven't raised this on the last day, I thought this was in place prior to this. They came to me to say no can do.

But you obviously hadn't had it confirmed beforehand. You could have pushed this weeks or months before. It's ridiculous that you're getting stroppy about it now, with little awareness of what it means for the school. There will already be children sitting in every cloakroom, office and spare piece of corridor. An ASD diagnosis does not necessitate the adjustment in its own right.

Tessabelle74 · 05/05/2023 17:24

cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 14:00

If seeking to avoid taking any of the tests, remember that:
a) there are, iirc, 5 tests (SPaG - in two parts, a spelling test and grammar / punctuation - Reading, and 3 Maths)

b) the child can be required to take the tests anything up to 5 days late following absence.

So if parents wished their child not to take any tests, they would need to be absent, unauthorised, for 2 weeks of school.

This is perfect then, if they have to sit the tests, them OP's daughter missing the big day means they'll have to find a quiet space on another day for her to do them

Georgeandzippyzoo · 05/05/2023 14:39

Schools, for obvious reasons, WANT the kids to do their best. Yes children with diagnosed issues will take precedent but schools will also make allowances for children who don't and may. struggle.
DH school has large y6 group with multiple behavioural/educational needs . ALL of their TAs and support staff are allocated roles next week, ALL other classes are 'thin on the ground' during the tests.
They don't have spare classrooms now but staff offices etc are utilised.
As soon as your DD mentioned this you needed to have jumped on it, however if she really struggles she could be moved as previously. Your friend wont be counted as independent and if she scored higher than expected there could be doubt.

Regarding gcse's. We foster and our fc struggles in tests. They are in y9 and school are already compiling evidence to show they need extra time/support. They do not have an ehcp and won't get one. The evidence is assessed by higher ip than the school and so you really need to get on top of that.

HaroldeVwilliam · 05/05/2023 14:11

Op you could call the council and query this as well.

Unfortunately teachers and often Senco do not understand the law around legal rights etc.
Ask the couch uk whats going on

Soapboxqueen · 05/05/2023 14:01

I think there are a couple of issues here.

  1. The school need to show this is a usual way of working. A diagnosis isn't enough because not all children with the same condition need the same adjustments also some children without a diagnosis will already be working with certain adjustments. Has your dd been working on this way for some time ?

  2. This really shouldn't have been left up to your dd to push for. I do know it's hard to keep all the balls in the air but this is the reality of having a child with additional needs.

  3. The school may just not have additional space or staff. They can't magic up a room. Often every square inch of space is used including office space.

However, I think you need to ask the school very specifically why this won't be accommodated.

If its purely space, can they keep her in isolation while the test happens and then get her to sit it immediately after with no contact with other children? Children used to be able to sit a test of they were ill up to a week later if the head was sure they hadn't interacted with other children and the test.

If its because they can't evidence her requirements because of the testing rules, then you might just have to suck it up and get plans put in place for the next stage of her education.

cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 14:00

HurryShadow · 05/05/2023 13:45

A couple of things:

  • as PP have said, push for ECHP statement for when your DD has important exams
  • SATs aren't important exams and are of no benefit to your DD whatsoever, so keep her home that day if they aren't able to help. They're a reflection on the school, so if a pupil isn't provided with the support to be able to take the exam I'd say that's a fair reflection on the school!

If seeking to avoid taking any of the tests, remember that:
a) there are, iirc, 5 tests (SPaG - in two parts, a spelling test and grammar / punctuation - Reading, and 3 Maths)

b) the child can be required to take the tests anything up to 5 days late following absence.

So if parents wished their child not to take any tests, they would need to be absent, unauthorised, for 2 weeks of school.

HurryShadow · 05/05/2023 13:45

A couple of things:

  • as PP have said, push for ECHP statement for when your DD has important exams
  • SATs aren't important exams and are of no benefit to your DD whatsoever, so keep her home that day if they aren't able to help. They're a reflection on the school, so if a pupil isn't provided with the support to be able to take the exam I'd say that's a fair reflection on the school!
cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 13:42

It is worth being aware that SATs are used by the Government to assess the progress that your child makes in secondary. This is a double-edged sword - a very low SATs score can lower a secondary’s ambitions for your child, while a very high one means they are always judged as ‘below target’. However, other than that, a child’s exact SATs score is irrelevant later in life.

Itsallovernow23 · 05/05/2023 13:40

We cant get TAs, teachers or supply teachers. Nor invigilators in secondary schools. It's just the way it is for many atm. My year 10 son doesn't even have an English teacher.
However, these are just SATs and dont really matter for your child. Seek an EHCP and write to your MP supporting teachers strikes

DRS1970 · 05/05/2023 13:37

SATs aren't to assess your child. They are to assess how well teachers have taught your child. I really wouldn't stress about them at all.

cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 13:35

Space, supervision and normal ways of working all come into play here.

Increasingly, schools only have legally-required 1:1 support TAs for budget reasons. Those cannot be removed from the children who require them in order . to supervise SATs. So the additional adults to supervise children with additional arrangements will be eg the Head, the SENCo if not a full time teacher (increasingly rare to afford a non-teaching SENCo), receptionist / administrator - a very limited number.

Similarly, space - the school business manager, head and receptionist might supervise children in their offices, the SENCo if available may supervise a group with additional time. 1:1 TAs will work with their charges in any other spaces (stationery cupboard, library if not a corridor, music lesson room if any).

Any arrangements need to be evidenced as ‘normal ways of working’ - usually, evidence collection for this will start in Y5 and will continue through any SATs practice in Y6. If that’s not in place, it is hard for the school to argue that these arrangements are justified if their administration of SATs is inspected, as some are each year.

If this was January, then there would be time to work this through with parents, SENCo, Y6 staff and the Head. Friday before the SATs start? Unfortunately it’s a bit late.

JetWashingIsMyHobby · 05/05/2023 13:20

It is hard work isn’t it @RainyReadingDay ? Feels never ending!

OP, I was just coming back on to say that you will have a free SENDIASS service locally. If you make the request yourself (and ignore school if they say she doesn’t need to be assessed) that will be the best thing as she is off to secondary soon so you can keep hold of it instead of waiting for new school, you can ask SENDIASS to check the wording first. I recommend doing this.

Tessabelle74 · 05/05/2023 13:18

angstridden2 · 05/05/2023 13:16

Slightly off topic, but why are schools struggling to get support staff these days? Until fairly recently if schools advertised for TAs and support they were inundated because although the pay is appalling, the hours do fit if you have young children.

Not desperate around my area, I've applied to 3 different schools, including my daughter's where in very active on the PTA do know a lot of the kids already and not even got an interview 😔

Tessabelle74 · 05/05/2023 13:17

Sorry you're struggling OP but without the EHCP in place I'd say they have no legal duty to accommodate your daughter. They have obviously used the resources they have for the children that have them in place. SATS are meaningless anyway so personally I'd be taking her out for a lovely day trip instead of her sitting them and sort the EHCP out in readiness for secondary school.

RainyReadingDay · 05/05/2023 13:16

JetWashingIsMyHobby · 05/05/2023 12:48

Apply yourself to local authority for EHCP needs assessment. They might refuse to assess, but your daughter meets legal threshold so ignore any nonsense they use to refuse, don’t bother with mediation and just fill in appeal form. If they refused the first time they will concede when you appeal.

Then your daughter will be assessed by educational psychologist and this is the time to look at things like exam access arrangements. Secondary is going to be much more demanding than primary, get things moving asap and advocate for your daughter in future.

This is very good advice.

We applied for an EHCP for DS ourselves. It's been hard work, and an uphill battle with the LA who have been resistant and tried to block our every step but we have appealed, complained, made a huge fuss in order to get them to listen to what DS needs.

angstridden2 · 05/05/2023 13:16

Slightly off topic, but why are schools struggling to get support staff these days? Until fairly recently if schools advertised for TAs and support they were inundated because although the pay is appalling, the hours do fit if you have young children.

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 13:14

Smartiepants79 · 05/05/2023 13:01

This should have already been worked out and decided weeks ago. All these kind of arrangements will have been planned in school sometime ago.
Why is your 11 yr old having to ask for this herself!? If you think she needs it you should have made a request months ago. If school thinks she needs it they’d have already done something about it. These kinds of arrangements are usually for children with recognised needs not given out on the kids say so. I am surprised that, with her diagnoses, school have not thought that she might need it.
This late in the day though they will be really struggling to change what they’ve arranged. Where do you suggest this other person magically appears from. The fact that she usually does fine in tests will be suggesting to school that she doesn’t need this adjustment, she’s never had it before and managed just fine.

She didn't ask for the adjustments herself, the SENDCO suggested that she would be able to have adjustments. She did say to DD that it would hinge on a discussion with the class teacher and the head and DD has badgered for that decision for a few weeks. They said they would email me when they had decided. Which was last night:

Yes she has had to leave the class a couple of times in mock exams, although has never started the exam in a quiet space. Even yesterday she took her mock grammar paper and completed it in the SENDCO's room as she was feeling overwhelmed.

Thank you to whoever posted the ehcp link above I will apply for one for her.

OP posts:
MrsR87 · 05/05/2023 13:03

KinderCat · 05/05/2023 12:41

I work in a school so this is coming purely from my experience. Whilst I do understand the stress your DD and you just both feel, the school also have rules to follow and if they have students with EHCP who have been identified as needing exam arrangements as part of that they have to have priority. And like another poster mentioned, normal way of working will come into it. The school should have a record of this being a normal requirement for your child or past exams being completed in this way. Space and staff are valuable commodities in schools and it is horrid to say this but not everyone can have their own space necessarily. I'm sorry OP. Definitely push for it in future and chase it up as for GCSE all things like this need to be applied for months prior to the exam externally...

Agree with this.

I work in a school and am also a parent and can totally see both sides. It’s so frustrating if something cannot be accommodated and without the correct paperwork etc there isn’t necessarily legal recourse for it to be provided and of course this is devastating if a child is expecting it and it is their normal way of working. If it is their normal way of working or they have documented special consideration then of course it needs pushing as the school should be providing it.
However, (and I’m not saying this is right…just the result of years of underfunding) the amount of pupils in my school that have special arrangements in place such as readers, separate rooms etc has increased by tenfold since I started teaching 13 years ago. This is at a time when there are less classrooms available due to increased cohorts having more classes running simultaneously and rooms having to be repurposed and also decreased staff available due to budgets and inability to recruit. None of this is helpful but in most cases of the school says they cannot accommodate they probably have exhausted every possibility.
Looking at the situation in schools in my local area, I am so worried about how even children with statements/EHCPS will continue to get their entitled provision as schools are haemorrhaging staff without being able to replace them. And whilst I know it’s the schools legal duty to provide it, we seriously are not far away from the point where this is going to become impossible. And honestly, we are also not far away from some schools not being able to provide enough teachers to teach. It is a shocking and disgusting state of affairs for our education system to be in and I feel so sorry for all the parents and children currently in the system!

Smartiepants79 · 05/05/2023 13:01

This should have already been worked out and decided weeks ago. All these kind of arrangements will have been planned in school sometime ago.
Why is your 11 yr old having to ask for this herself!? If you think she needs it you should have made a request months ago. If school thinks she needs it they’d have already done something about it. These kinds of arrangements are usually for children with recognised needs not given out on the kids say so. I am surprised that, with her diagnoses, school have not thought that she might need it.
This late in the day though they will be really struggling to change what they’ve arranged. Where do you suggest this other person magically appears from. The fact that she usually does fine in tests will be suggesting to school that she doesn’t need this adjustment, she’s never had it before and managed just fine.