Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school have to make adjustments?

144 replies

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 12:01

Hi, DD11 has her SATs next week.

She is autistic. Diagnosed last year.

She's been in contact with the SENDCO over the past few weeks after advocating for a space where she can be alone as she finds it hard to understand questions unless she reads them out loud. Obviously she will disrupt other kids if she does this.

Admittedly I haven't been involved (my mistake) as she was updating me every step of the way.

Last night the class teacher emailed me that they would be unable to meet her request because (paraphrasing) they had run out of teachers/assistants/rooms to accommodate everyone who requested or needs adjustments.

I've checked the gov.uk site and it simply says 'children are entitled to adjustments' blah blah, not 'entitled to adjustments if the school can accommodate'.

DD usually scores very well on exams but is so stressed out over the SATs. It doesn't matter that we've told her that they are a measurement for the school there's a lot of self pressure. I think the schoo think 'she's doing fine, doesn't need the adjustment'

Can I push this? I have emailed the teacher to express my disagreement over this approach and suggested that we can provide an independent (my friend does exam invigilation and will sit with her).

Advice needed. Please.

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/05/2023 19:06

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 18:38

Except she’s ASD and therefore has a disability which means she is entitled to adjustments to help her reach the same standard as her non disabled peers.

So, yeah, she’s not entitled 🙄

Shes got a recognised disability. How ‘entitled’ does she have to be?

When my dd was diagnosed we received a letter from her school saying she was entitled to all exams in separate room. We didn’t even have to request it.

At GCSE and A-level, you can have a disability, and not be entitled to specific access arrangements- for example, you have to prove slower processing, or need a letter from a professional saying specifically why the student needs a small/quiet room. Some students with ASD can do their exams in the hall, some need rest breaks, some qualify for extra time, and so on. Sometimes students can qualify for access arrangements without a specific diagnosis. It's about proving need, not diagnosis (which is good, given ASD diagnosis wait times locally!).

For SATs, none of the guidance I can find mentions separate rooms at all- which may mean it's not an allowable access arrangement as such, but would only be used to facilitate other arrangements, like a scribe.

So I don't think it's quite as clear cut as you think.

At GCSE/A-level, the rules around separate rooms have been tightened up a lot in the last couple of years, and now significant evidence is needed, a diagnosis is not enough.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 19:04

What exams officers need to show if monitored is that the reasonable adjustments they make are longstanding practice or that new needs have emerged - they had until 24th April for applications. A diagnosis of ADHD you'd be best off applying for extra time even if you don't end up using it but some kids with anxiety or ADHD won't benefit - they race through the paper then have the pain of sitting there with extra time they don't use and which can cause more distress...hence why it is imperative the teachers know what their kids need and do what their usual routine is.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 19:03

Girls are diagnosed much later than boys.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 19:01

viques · 05/05/2023 18:53

This, how does she cope in classroom settings, how has she managed with the interminable SATs practice under exam conditions? It is of course fair that children whose needs are identified are given fair conditions, but it does sound as though this is something that could have been addressed and dealt with long ago, well before next week. It begs the question if she has not previously been able to access written work in the curriculum - and in Y6 most of the content is presented in written form for most subjects - without reading it out loud then why hasn’t this been raised before?

Read the ‘Autistic Girls Network’ article entiltjed ‘Keeping it all inside’ One of the contributors is Head of Limpsfield School. An Ofsted outstanding school for ASD girls.

They mask until it bursts out. Or it bursts out under pressure (SATS).She ‘coped’ by holding it all together as long as she could. Girls are massively under diagnosed because they are quiet and fly under the radar. Just because she appeared to be coping doesn’t mean she doesn’t need further support.

The ignorance on this thread is appalling. In my 25 years teaching secondary, no ASD chikd was put in the main exam room.

She has ASD. A recognised disability within a wide ranging spectrum. She is entitled to adjustments, however we’ll she’s done before. She’s 10/11 years old. How much ‘before’ is there?

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 18:58

2023 key stage 2 access arrangements guidance (publishing.service.gov.uk)
I suggest you read it again,poormeg experienced or not.
You do not need to notify in advance if sensory breaks/alternative room is the normal way of working. (Section 4)
but you should have evidence that it is what usually happens with the student in question (classroom plans etc) in case you are monitored.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1143188/2023_key_stage_2_access_arrangements_guidance.pdf

viques · 05/05/2023 18:53

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 18:42

but that is not related to the diagnosis.

Being diagnosed with a disability or not has no bearing on this at all

it is related to normal way of working, and diagnosis is irrelevant

This, how does she cope in classroom settings, how has she managed with the interminable SATs practice under exam conditions? It is of course fair that children whose needs are identified are given fair conditions, but it does sound as though this is something that could have been addressed and dealt with long ago, well before next week. It begs the question if she has not previously been able to access written work in the curriculum - and in Y6 most of the content is presented in written form for most subjects - without reading it out loud then why hasn’t this been raised before?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 18:52

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 18:42

but that is not related to the diagnosis.

Being diagnosed with a disability or not has no bearing on this at all

it is related to normal way of working, and diagnosis is irrelevant

ASD have sensory issues. This is why they are offered a separate room.

It was an automatic adjustment at the school l worked at, and automatic at my daughter’s school. So it is related to the diagnosis.

Malkin48 · 05/05/2023 18:51

Would your daughter be alright about sitting them after the other children, which would mean that she has to keep away from them until they’ve done their tests? . The assessments don’t last all day, she could maybe do their after play in the heads office and get a space to herself that way. Plus the school has to be flexible about timetable variations if there are children off ill, so surely they can be flexible for your daughter.

The trouble maker part of me says that if she arrives late, then that’s what they’ll have to do anyway or risk her not getting any marks at all, which the school won’t do, so you could force their hand if they won’t compromise.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/05/2023 18:51

AnImmenseDislikeOfPeople · 05/05/2023 12:43

As someone who had 'reasonable adjustments' at school, they have to accommodate as long as they were given sufficient notice. You need to fight them on this. It is irrelevant whether they are out of staff or don't have enough room, they need to find it. When I sat exams at college, everyone else went to a completely different exam location. I stayed on campus in a computer room on my own with the invigilator. Do not let them fob off your daughter.

Just as an FYI, at college level the rules on seperate rooms have changed significantly, and significant medical evidence is now needed. Things have been tightened up a lot over the last few years. So at A-level/GCSE, a parent "fighting" without the correct evidence unfortunately gets nowhere.

lanthanum · 05/05/2023 18:50

cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 14:00

If seeking to avoid taking any of the tests, remember that:
a) there are, iirc, 5 tests (SPaG - in two parts, a spelling test and grammar / punctuation - Reading, and 3 Maths)

b) the child can be required to take the tests anything up to 5 days late following absence.

So if parents wished their child not to take any tests, they would need to be absent, unauthorised, for 2 weeks of school.

However, in this case, taking them late would probably mean taking them in a room on their own, which would solve the problem!

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 18:49

SeenAMillionFaces · 05/05/2023 18:47

Not OPs problem.

what do you realistically expect to happen if parents make impossible demands on the school? Realistically? come on.

GrettaGreen · 05/05/2023 18:47

I really do think you've dropped the ball here. To have left an 11 year old with additional needs to sort their own reasonable adjustments is beyond lax.

SeenAMillionFaces · 05/05/2023 18:47

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 12:34

what do you want them to do if they dont have the staff or the rooms? Build another functioning adult human in the workshop over the weekend? extend the school? Be reasonable

Not OPs problem.

PoorMegHopkins · 05/05/2023 18:46

School sound appalling though.
Why are they doing mocks the week before? That’s insane.

You do not have to prove it’s a “usual way of working” for separate rooms or breaks. You only have to apply in advance for extra time (need to evidence this) or early opening for colour photocopying.

We use every room and every available member of staff to ensure all the children can be comfortable. We have children using laptops, coloured copies, quiet rooms with less children, a room for those who need breaks and anything else they need within the rules. They need it- we find the room and staff. We do mocks in March using the same rooms so the children know what it’s like and we can adjust if needed. Why would they not want her to do well? It’s their results!

Re the EHCP suggestion- children who are cognitively YEARS behind are being turned down several times and most of them do not get any 1:1 hours specified. If she’s sitting the tests she’s very unlikely to get one.

Credentials: year 6 senior teacher of several years.

Nat6999 · 05/05/2023 18:44

Ds didn't have an ehcp but got extra time & to use a laptop for his Sats. You have to keep pushing, school won't want her to get a low mark as it will bring their average results mark down. Some of the pupils did their tests in the headmaster's office.

Pegsandsunshine · 05/05/2023 18:44

Does DD have actual access arrangements in place? Diagnosis itself may not mean anything for exams need to be done differently.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 18:42

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 18:38

Except she’s ASD and therefore has a disability which means she is entitled to adjustments to help her reach the same standard as her non disabled peers.

So, yeah, she’s not entitled 🙄

Shes got a recognised disability. How ‘entitled’ does she have to be?

When my dd was diagnosed we received a letter from her school saying she was entitled to all exams in separate room. We didn’t even have to request it.

but that is not related to the diagnosis.

Being diagnosed with a disability or not has no bearing on this at all

it is related to normal way of working, and diagnosis is irrelevant

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 18:38

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 18:34

there is nothing in the OP posts to suggest she is entitled to any of these adjustments

Except she’s ASD and therefore has a disability which means she is entitled to adjustments to help her reach the same standard as her non disabled peers.

So, yeah, she’s not entitled 🙄

Shes got a recognised disability. How ‘entitled’ does she have to be?

When my dd was diagnosed we received a letter from her school saying she was entitled to all exams in separate room. We didn’t even have to request it.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 18:34

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 18:16

Speaking as a teacher and parent of an ASD. You’re daughter is entitled by law to reasonable adjustments. It’s not your problem that they can’t meet it. They are breaking the law irrespective of space.

Woukd they let a child who couldn’t write due to ASD not have a scribe? Ocn.

Go back to the school. They have to comply. My dd is ASD, she has a separate room. If they won’t comply take it further.

Equalities Comission.

there is nothing in the OP posts to suggest she is entitled to any of these adjustments

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 18:33

Hadalifeonce · 05/05/2023 18:23

I was a school governor several years ago, during SATS one child needed to be in a separate room, as there were no teachers nor TAs available, I was asked if I would be prepared to supervise in the room. They gave me a 30 minute 'lesson' in how to be in the room, and obviously I was DBS checked. Perhaps you could suggest either one of their governors or an adult who volunteers to listen to readers?

were you paid? Or was this just another example of a school scraping around for a volunteer? You cant rely on volunteers, and not should you

Aaarrgg · 05/05/2023 18:30

The tests start on the next school day. It is too late to make further arrangements like getting a governor in or changing times of the tests.

Show her that you mean it - the tests don't matter so it's ok for you to be in the same room, because it doesn't matter if you can't answer everything.

Hadalifeonce · 05/05/2023 18:23

I was a school governor several years ago, during SATS one child needed to be in a separate room, as there were no teachers nor TAs available, I was asked if I would be prepared to supervise in the room. They gave me a 30 minute 'lesson' in how to be in the room, and obviously I was DBS checked. Perhaps you could suggest either one of their governors or an adult who volunteers to listen to readers?

neslop · 05/05/2023 18:22

SATS really aren't important (except for the school) so I would focus on calming and reassuring your DC and not make a big fuss about it. The important thing will be to get on it ASAP at secondary so you have things in place in good time for GCSEs.

Elisheva · 05/05/2023 18:17

One of the schools I work in has got five sittings of the SATS exams to accommodate all the different needs. They have nineteen children who need some sort of differentiation and/or TA support. They’ve even got one child sitting his exam after school so he has enough time and space to cope.
On another note, my son is just starting his GCSEs. He takes his exams in a smaller room, has a laptop, extra time and rest breaks. He doesn’t have a diagnosis or an EHCP.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 18:16

Speaking as a teacher and parent of an ASD. You’re daughter is entitled by law to reasonable adjustments. It’s not your problem that they can’t meet it. They are breaking the law irrespective of space.

Woukd they let a child who couldn’t write due to ASD not have a scribe? Ocn.

Go back to the school. They have to comply. My dd is ASD, she has a separate room. If they won’t comply take it further.

Equalities Comission.