Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school have to make adjustments?

144 replies

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 12:01

Hi, DD11 has her SATs next week.

She is autistic. Diagnosed last year.

She's been in contact with the SENDCO over the past few weeks after advocating for a space where she can be alone as she finds it hard to understand questions unless she reads them out loud. Obviously she will disrupt other kids if she does this.

Admittedly I haven't been involved (my mistake) as she was updating me every step of the way.

Last night the class teacher emailed me that they would be unable to meet her request because (paraphrasing) they had run out of teachers/assistants/rooms to accommodate everyone who requested or needs adjustments.

I've checked the gov.uk site and it simply says 'children are entitled to adjustments' blah blah, not 'entitled to adjustments if the school can accommodate'.

DD usually scores very well on exams but is so stressed out over the SATs. It doesn't matter that we've told her that they are a measurement for the school there's a lot of self pressure. I think the schoo think 'she's doing fine, doesn't need the adjustment'

Can I push this? I have emailed the teacher to express my disagreement over this approach and suggested that we can provide an independent (my friend does exam invigilation and will sit with her).

Advice needed. Please.

OP posts:
SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 20:14

That argument goes both ways: the SENCO and year 6 teacher have had months to sort it out too, and communicate with Mum. Am amazed those conversations haven't happened if she had her diagnosis last year - it does reek of the OP's DD masking well enough to be under the radar and being allowed to fall through the cracks.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/05/2023 20:10

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 18:52

ASD have sensory issues. This is why they are offered a separate room.

It was an automatic adjustment at the school l worked at, and automatic at my daughter’s school. So it is related to the diagnosis.

then it is being done wrong, and if the exam board finds out the schools will be in trouble - ASD diagnosis absolutely does not automatically entitle anyone to special consideration in exams, and nor should it

cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 19:59

Batalax · 05/05/2023 19:45

Make a fuss. He who shouts loudest, gets heard.

The thing is, the OP has had all of Y6 to discuss this and sort out arrangements with the school, but has delegated the task to her DD.

SATs start on Tuesday at 9 am, and if the school is typical, the exact rooms, staffing and timetables have been created and refined over weeks, along with evidence in case they are inspected.

It’s hard to make a fuss and shout now.

IceCreamWithSprinkles · 05/05/2023 19:46

My DS has some SEN and will be doing SATs next week in small groups of 3-4 children in a separate room with a teacher, who can read the questions out loud to them if they need it (other than on the Reading paper), and who can and will bring his mind back to the room if his mind is clearly wandering. I’m sure your DD’s school must have other children needing to branch out in small groups for the tests, Is there any chance your DD could join a smaller group of children to make it a bit less of a daunting environment for her, even if she can’t be alone?

The teacher also said to us today that during mock papers she has been sending DS out to the toilet during exams just to give him a chance to have a breather if it looks like he’s struggling, and that any time he misses during a toilet trip is added on to the end of the exam (in addition to the extra time he gets), so it seems wrong that you have been told differently….maybe it’s specific to toilet trips?! You could suggest this to them/her as a strategy?

Batalax · 05/05/2023 19:45

Make a fuss. He who shouts loudest, gets heard.

AnImmenseDislikeOfPeople · 05/05/2023 19:35

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/05/2023 18:51

Just as an FYI, at college level the rules on seperate rooms have changed significantly, and significant medical evidence is now needed. Things have been tightened up a lot over the last few years. So at A-level/GCSE, a parent "fighting" without the correct evidence unfortunately gets nowhere.

Oh yes, absolutely. I wasn't in college that long ago and had to show medical evidence. But the school need to communicate what they need, not just dismiss her.

cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 19:34

The choice is: move the school administrator, who also mans reception, the school business manager and the head (only 3 non-contact staff in school in the mornings) to join the Y6 1:1 TAs to provide specific access arrangements for the children who need them.

Or not provide access arrangements, because there are no other staff who are not either teaching classes or legally tied to a child with SEN working 1:1 .

Those are the options available. Parcels and phone calls can be dealt with later.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 19:31

She has had to leave the class a couple of times in mock exams, although has never started the exam in a quiet space.
I suspect this is why they are fobbing you off with the separate room but saying they can accommodate a sensory break.

Even yesterday she took her mock grammar paper and completed it in the SENDCO's room as she was feeling overwhelmed.
That's what you go back to them with - as Febb said - they have used that as a reasonable adjustment once before after the deadline, having ascertained she needed it.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/05/2023 19:27

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/05/2023 19:22

Who's answering the phone, dealing with emails, ParentPay, first aid, filing, photocopying, trips, visitors, early collections, deliveries and everything else if the 'receptionist' is taken away to supervise a child doing their SATs?

Potentially, it's not. Often, to run exams in schools, a lot of people are taken away from their "normal" jobs and these are put on hold whilst the exams are running.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/05/2023 19:25

Tamuchly · 05/05/2023 19:16

Yes, the pay is rubbish and the hours are very family friendly but TA’s do lots more now than they used to and are also expected to teach. In our area this means you need at least a level 2 qualification in Teaching & Learning in schools but they favour candidates with level 3 or even ex-teachers. The TA interviews involve an observation teaching a small group, an interview with the school council (children) and finally a meeting with senior leadership…all for a job paying little more than minimum wage!

I think the rise in flexible working from home jobs has had a significant impact- less people need the child friendly hours.

But agreed, it's very hard to recruit TAs. As you say, they are either expected to teach, or alternatively working with very high needs pupils, often taking on a lot of significant responsibility including medical, for very low pay.

So many TAs I know get hurt regularly by students at work.

Febb · 05/05/2023 19:23

PoorMegHopkins · 05/05/2023 19:14

@SequinsandStilettos that’s why we do the mocks with the same arrangements. It’s not hard to prove.

I'd argue that the fact she has previously had to be taken out due to getting upset and that she has then completed her work in a room by herself, then this is her usual way of working a SATS paper.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/05/2023 19:22

cantkeepawayforever · 05/05/2023 13:35

Space, supervision and normal ways of working all come into play here.

Increasingly, schools only have legally-required 1:1 support TAs for budget reasons. Those cannot be removed from the children who require them in order . to supervise SATs. So the additional adults to supervise children with additional arrangements will be eg the Head, the SENCo if not a full time teacher (increasingly rare to afford a non-teaching SENCo), receptionist / administrator - a very limited number.

Similarly, space - the school business manager, head and receptionist might supervise children in their offices, the SENCo if available may supervise a group with additional time. 1:1 TAs will work with their charges in any other spaces (stationery cupboard, library if not a corridor, music lesson room if any).

Any arrangements need to be evidenced as ‘normal ways of working’ - usually, evidence collection for this will start in Y5 and will continue through any SATs practice in Y6. If that’s not in place, it is hard for the school to argue that these arrangements are justified if their administration of SATs is inspected, as some are each year.

If this was January, then there would be time to work this through with parents, SENCo, Y6 staff and the Head. Friday before the SATs start? Unfortunately it’s a bit late.

Who's answering the phone, dealing with emails, ParentPay, first aid, filing, photocopying, trips, visitors, early collections, deliveries and everything else if the 'receptionist' is taken away to supervise a child doing their SATs?

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 19:22

STA will only consider applications after the deadlines in very exceptional circumstances. Examples of these include, but are not limited to, where a pupil’s needs have significantly changed
That's for extra time OP. (If you ask for the sensory breaks but wanted the extra time. Looks bad on the school but you could say anxiety/panic attacks from the 25th?)
If it's section 4 for alternate room only, and they have no evidence of that being needed in class or mocks, then I'd ask them to flag her needs as having changed due to new noticeable increased anxiety the week preceding.

CurlewKate · 05/05/2023 19:21

On the subject of TAs -many of my son's friends are working as agency TAs-and they can work as many days as they want to. The agencies are crying out for more. It's hard work, not brilliantly paid, and they are chucked in at the deep end. They don't know the kids, and can't really provide the quality of provision that a fully trained and experienced TA can provide. But better than nothing, I suppose.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/05/2023 19:19

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 19:08

At GCSE/A-level, the rules around separate rooms have been tightened up a lot in the last couple of years, and now significant evidence is needed, a diagnosis is not enough

Except my dd 16 was diagnosed in November and offered a separate room in March. We didn’t ask, we just received a letter based on the diagnosis.

Does your DD have any other access arrangements? Or does this reflect a normal way of working?

Did the school receive an Ed psych report that might have talked about access arrangements?

According to the rules, separate invigilation meant to be awarded when a candidate has a disability which has a substantial and adverse impact on their ability to sit exams in the main hall- or when their disability means that they would distract other candidates (e.g. tics).

Sometimes using a laptop etc means you end up in a small room as in the main hall there is nowhere to plug it in. Or reader/scribe etc.

Even a few years ago it was much easier to get a separate room, but the rules have been tightened up, and the school I work for have become very strict, as they have been checked by JCQ in the past. I think other schools are more lax, but if JCQ checked how access arrangements are being applied, then giving people small rooms on the basis of diagnosis alone would likely be queried.

The relevant guidance from JCQ is:

The SENCo must make their decision based on:
• whether the candidate has a substantial and long-term impairment which has
an adverse effect; and
• the candidate’s normal way of working within the centre.

https://www.jcq.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/AA_regs_22-23_May23_revision_FINAL.pdf

Febb · 05/05/2023 19:19

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 18:07

Have caught up with school: unfortunately there is nothing they can do regarding a private space and the ability to read the questions out loud.

They did say that if she was becoming overwhelmed or frozen (this is what happened in the mock exam yesterday, she couldn't move on from a question she couldn't answer and missed a whole page of questions because 'her brain wouldn't let her move on' then panicked and cried after the mock) that she can put her hand up and take a breather outside the room. I said 'but she will have the same time as everyone else and he said 'yes' so I said 'any breather time is included in the exam time?' And he said yes... so that doesn't work.

He hadn't even noticed she was upset yesterday and so I don't think he's going to be softly softly about this.

I challenged on this and he said he's going to raise it with the head.

On another note, is it normal on here to ask for advice (of which I am very grateful) and to be called stroppy? I feel like I've been scolded 😂

This is wrong. If she needs a break, it doesn't count towards her exam time-her exam clock should stop. I have had children stop mid exam, sleep for 3 hours and then finish their paper. As long as they don't see the other children who have completed the paper it's fine.

The school and teacher have been really really poor with this and are clearly not up with the guidelines. Children can have a break during the exam, they can put their hand up and ask an adult to read a question if they want-except in the reading paper.

You could play the school at their own game here - don't take your daughter in in the mornings, but take her in in the afternoon. There should be plenty of free space and staff by then Wink Your daughter could start the paper and then ask for a rest break and not be ready to start again until she has a safe space to complete... Neither option is great and your daughter absolutely should not have been put in this position by the school. I'm sorry some schools are so shit at accommodating individual needs.

Her grades will affect her predicted scores for GCSEs using the new progress 8 scores. But again, this and progress 8 is completely irrelevant for your daughter, it's just a stupid data point designed to beat teachers with.

CurlewKate · 05/05/2023 19:17

I know it's water under the bridge-but for anyone else-this really isn't something for an 11 year old to deal with.

Tamuchly · 05/05/2023 19:16

angstridden2 · 05/05/2023 13:16

Slightly off topic, but why are schools struggling to get support staff these days? Until fairly recently if schools advertised for TAs and support they were inundated because although the pay is appalling, the hours do fit if you have young children.

Yes, the pay is rubbish and the hours are very family friendly but TA’s do lots more now than they used to and are also expected to teach. In our area this means you need at least a level 2 qualification in Teaching & Learning in schools but they favour candidates with level 3 or even ex-teachers. The TA interviews involve an observation teaching a small group, an interview with the school council (children) and finally a meeting with senior leadership…all for a job paying little more than minimum wage!

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 19:16

No, it's not.
But you said
You do not have to prove it’s a “usual way of working” for separate rooms or breaks.
You do.

PoorMegHopkins · 05/05/2023 19:14

@SequinsandStilettos that’s why we do the mocks with the same arrangements. It’s not hard to prove.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 19:13

SATS 2023
Schools must make an application to the Standards and Testing Agency (STA) to request permission in advance for some arrangements (section 2). Some arrangements do not require permission, but schools must notify STA of their use once all tests have been administered (section 3). Other arrangements may be used without prior approval, or the need to notify STA, provided they reflect normal classroom practice (section 4).

During a monitoring visit3, local authorities (LAs) may ask to see evidence that any support given to pupils in the tests is regularly provided as part of normal classroom practice. Schools must ensure they have documentation to show that a pupil is eligible for access arrangements. Evidence will vary according to the type of support and may include:
• notes recorded in teaching plans
• individual pupil support plans
• a pupil’s classwork

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/05/2023 19:08

The ignorance on this thread is appalling. In my 25 years teaching secondary, no ASD chikd was put in the main exam room.

The rules on small rooms for secondary exams have significantly tightened up in recent years. I have students with ASD who now do sit exams in the main hall, as there is not sufficient evidence to do otherwise.

We explain the requirements to parents clearly, but obviously we cannot contact medical professionals about this, so they have to source the evidence.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/05/2023 19:08

At GCSE/A-level, the rules around separate rooms have been tightened up a lot in the last couple of years, and now significant evidence is needed, a diagnosis is not enough

Except my dd 16 was diagnosed in November and offered a separate room in March. We didn’t ask, we just received a letter based on the diagnosis.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 19:07

Separate rooms is in alternative accommodation in section 4 of the link above.

AngelinaFibres · 05/05/2023 19:06

bingbangbongding · 05/05/2023 12:39

No she's never say tests like this before. With her SATs in year 2 she didn't have a diagnosis. So no evidence that she's sat one on one.

She doesn't have an ECHP, I see how that is a problem. I will try to get one in place as she is approaching high school.

I have advised that I can provide an independent person. A person with a DBS and who is an exam invigilator.

I have already mentioned that they emailed me last night to say they couldn't accommodate her. I haven't raised this on the last day, I thought this was in place prior to this. They came to me to say no can do.

She will have done many, many old papers on the lead up to the real thing. Presumably those went okay

Swipe left for the next trending thread