Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people sail through life ?

260 replies

Cuberubick · 05/05/2023 11:54

Please don't think that this comes from a place of envy . It's something that puzzles me . The vast majority of us me included have ups and downs and life is not always fair.

But it strikes me that some people live truly wonderful lives, with no great trauma , no health issues or money woes , great kids etc. Think Richard Brandon for example . I'm not knocking him just using him as an example .

Then there are others who seems to go from one crisis to the next , and have tragedy befall them .

Like I have said for the vast majority of us it's bitter sweet .

Is it a case of mindset ? what you think is what you get ? Who knows .

OP posts:
SpringleDingle · 05/05/2023 14:41

I think many people have more of a dismissive attitude to their own issues. If you asked me I'd say I've had a pretty charmed life. Nothing too awful has ever happened and I have had some really supportive family and great breaks. I have a nice house, lovely kid and I am very happy. I've never gone hungry, always managed to achieve what I wanted, have found lots of love and great friends. My life is pretty fab!

Then I thought about it really hard.
I have some SEN, I was bullied in school, I have a chronic illness that contributed to my dropping out of college (later went back and finished my degree), one of my parents had a massive health issue 10 years or so ago (but is now a lot better), I had multiple miscarriages and later a divorce, my daughter has a disability.... So maybe not entirely smooth sailing but those things weren't my first thought. My first thought was all the great stuff I have now, |I has rather forgotten all the back-story crap!

Usernamen · 05/05/2023 14:40

Porkandbeans1 · 05/05/2023 14:32

What are you basing this on OP, what you see or what people say?

I have an amazing life, I would describe myself as incredibly lucky. My DH is my best friend, I have a good relationship with my DC, I have done well financially and we have lovely things and are able to go to nice places.

But I had a rubbish childhood and then got in a relationship with a man who was violent and vile. He could have killed me and left me in a lot of debt which took me years to pay off. So maybe that changed my outlook on life. I don't want to ever take the little things for granted. Me 20 years ago could never have gone for a walk, worn what they wanted or read a book in peace. Everyday is a blessing.

God this is such a lovely post. I love hearing about people turning their life around. Congratulations 💜

BeverlyHa · 05/05/2023 14:39

No social media with my whole life on there, no moany moany at so called friends, deal with my life as it comes and being focused on my own. My home, life, family, job, hobbies, church.

MammaTo · 05/05/2023 14:39

Heroicallyfound · 05/05/2023 12:14

I think it’s two fold-

  1. luck of the draw as to how much external trauma you experience (death/loss, health, traumatic stuff that’s not in anyone’s control
  2. childhood programming - mindset.

If 2 goes well, you tend to cope with type 1 events much better.

If 2 goes badly, you end up with poor mental health or lack of resilience, so you might not cope with type 1 events so well.

Experiencing lots of type 1 events will knock anyone off course though.

I think there’s also a capacity element too - if you live your life with enough rest/play/slack time, whatever your mindset, you’ll cope with type 1 events better as you’ll have the spare capacity to work through them.

This explains what I was trying to write so well.

BeverlyHa · 05/05/2023 14:38

No, everyone has to live the same life. Some are luckier in managing their money, emotions and kids with wisdom, love and patience. This is how I do it and noone has to know how i feel or what problems i resolve along the way.

ScribblingPixie · 05/05/2023 14:38

Even in his early life, Richard Branson really strategised to make his business work. Money didn't just float past him while he grabbed it. He was actually quite ruthless in some ways, I think, which made him money, but sometimes he failed and sometimes people took advantage of him. He's been working at his businesses for 50 years!

user1497207191 · 05/05/2023 14:36

@wildfirewonder

This 'resilience' bullshit is very similar to the rubbish that you can 'beat cancer' if you just fight hard enough.

Yes, but a positive mindset, attitude, may not "cure" cancer, but may improve your life whilst undergoing treatment, etc., i.e. healthy living, staying fit, healthy eating, etc all help your body cope with the treatments (chemotherapy, radiotherapy), helps your body tolerate the drugs you have to take to combat the side effects, etc. Your treatments may have a better impact if you can tolerate them better and, yes, may "cure" your cancer at that time and put you into remission.

No one sane would say that you can "cure" cancer by wishing it away, it's more that a positive attitude will help you get through the treatment better, encourage you to eat healthily rather than say "sod it I'll have another cake", encourage you to exercise when you really don't feel it rather than say "sod it, I'll blob on the sofa rather than going for a walk", etc.

Realistically, your prognosis is likely to be better if you don't retreat into yourself, get depressed, which in itself makes you less inclined to eat healthily, exercise, etc. Of course, that's not to say that people who have a positive attitude don't die of cancer. It's just saying that by being positive, your chances of survival are almost certainly higher than someone who gets morbidly depressed about the diagnosis, so much so, that the body can't tolerate the treatment or isn't as responsive to treatment being it's run down.

One of my closest friends was diagnosed with cancer and it caused her mental health issues, so much so, that she refused to start treatment (in fact she was close to being sectioned at one stage), and by the time that she'd got her head around it, the cancer has spread too far, and the treatment couldn't go ahead. If she'd started treatment on time, the prognosis had been quite good.

someoneisalwaysintheloo · 05/05/2023 14:33

Maybe Branson has had a charmed life from being from a wealthy family and he seemingly does what he wants with little consequence.

He's a bit of of a grifter, tax cheat, ladish, which because of his public image, wealth, and what used to be good looks gets away with.

Porkandbeans1 · 05/05/2023 14:32

What are you basing this on OP, what you see or what people say?

I have an amazing life, I would describe myself as incredibly lucky. My DH is my best friend, I have a good relationship with my DC, I have done well financially and we have lovely things and are able to go to nice places.

But I had a rubbish childhood and then got in a relationship with a man who was violent and vile. He could have killed me and left me in a lot of debt which took me years to pay off. So maybe that changed my outlook on life. I don't want to ever take the little things for granted. Me 20 years ago could never have gone for a walk, worn what they wanted or read a book in peace. Everyday is a blessing.

Usernamen · 05/05/2023 14:32

I haven’t RTFT but have we got to the bottom of who Richard Brandon is?

willWillSmithsmith · 05/05/2023 14:29

I have a friend who, generally speaking, has sailed through life. That’s not to say she has never had a bump in the road but it’s just been a small bump here and there rather than big, traumatic events. She married in her twenties and they’ve had a long happy marriage, her husband is as devoted to her now thirty odd years later as he was back in the early days. They live in a big house and have a holiday home. Their adult children all get on really well with each other and have achieved well. She has a good stable job and he is a white collar professional earning good money. I’ve known her all my life, in contrast my life has been nothing but ups and downs, some really distressing.

SisterAgatha · 05/05/2023 14:27

I think you can only know a person in that moment and see how they present and not how they feel.

I’ve had massive life changing events happen to me as a child. Adults currently facing things I did as a child might say “oh you’re so lucky” and I think no, you just assume I’m lucky because you only see the Sisteragatha who bounced back. You did not see me on the floor for several years.

on social media etc I might look healthy, but I have a disability.

I am often told oh I wish I was as resilient and as independent as you are. Great but realise that people fight to be those things in the face of their hardship. I know so many people who face such terrible things but they carry them so well. We can’t ever know what someone else has been through. My brother faced the same hardship as I did and our lives took very different paths so how you react to challenge and let it shape you is a factor.

I don’t think people are born more resilient than others. Some people just refuse to be beaten down. Easy lives are all relative.

Maryslargelamb · 05/05/2023 14:24

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:15

There is a big difference between ordinary stuff that is inevitable. Old people get ill and die for example. And people who have a hard life. If all you have is ordinary stuff you do have an easy life.

I absolutely agree with this.

This is the distinction I would make on this subject.

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:23

These are some examples of things (this is not an exhaustive list) that cause trauma but have FUCK ALL to do with personality:
Violent/accidental death of a loved one
Death of a child
Extreme illness/health change/disability
Violent assault/sexual assault
Abusive relationship
Loss of home
Stalking/harassment
Being wrongly accused of something - e.g. all those post office cases

These are not things it is possible/realistic to just 'be positive' about.
These are in a different category to ordinary/expected life events.

Many people (sadly) experience one or more of these things, but many people experience none of them.

amoobaa · 05/05/2023 14:22

@Cuberubick I think you’re right about it being related to mindset.

You could give the exact same things (I dunno, love, possessions, time, money etc) to ten different people and each of those people could have entirely different experiences of what you give them. It’s not about the things they have, but how they experience those things.

How we experience stuff is influenced by our values, circumstances and intellect but predominantly it is shaped by our perspectives, our mindset and our emotional resilience. And these things evolve from our experiences, especially our formative experiences.

One person might be incredibly grateful, another may resent you, another might feel it’s not enough, someone else may feel patronised, another might feel indifferent or awkward, another might feel blessed, another may feel under pressure to return the favour, another might take it completely for granted etc etc.

Apparently gratitude and noticing the good in your life really helps you feel more content, even during hardship.

I don’t think anyone should ever be pressured to find something to be grateful for in certain situations though. Like someone mentioned- the death of a child.

There are times when the only thing we can do is acknowledge how abhorrent and awful something is.

I’m a good example of someone who has had a really shit time but, for the most part, I genuinely feel like one of the luckiest people alive.

Sometimes it borders on unhealthy. I have to watch carefully to make sure I’m not pulling the wool over my own eyes. I have to remember to be a bit more critical and to assert healthy boundaries.

Maryslargelamb · 05/05/2023 14:21

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:10

Honestly you do not know what you are talking about. What you say works for ordinary stuff like redundancy. But what about a close relative being murdered? Should you be sunny and optimistic about that? Or having a child with a limited life expectancy? So you should be optimistic that the diagnosis is wrong?

I mean I do not walk around looking miserable and I have learned to make the most out of every day that is good because life has thrown me so many shit days. But some things are just shit.

Actually I have a friend who has had multiple major traumas. I am not gong to name them in case she reads this, but its the stuff that makes your jaw drop open. Really, gut wrenchingly awful. Its stuff that would destroy a lot of people. Other people would have committed suicide and everyone would understand why.

She openly acknowledges she has been able to cope and move forward as she was born with an optimistic personality. She just always believed, not matter how life shatteringly awful what she was going through was, that she would get through and get back to a good life. Many people who were not born with the good luck of that inherent optimism would not have coped.

Barnbrack · 05/05/2023 14:19

Maryslargelamb · 05/05/2023 14:15

I completely agree. I had two good friends who were ' their own worst enemy'. I also knew their backgrounds and childhoods. And that absolutely helped to explain their personalities. They were unable to see themselves as the common denominator as they needed to psychological protect themselves from acknowledging that. Their experiences meant their sense of self and esteem was so fragile they had nothing in them to cope with the knowledge that they were the factor in these bad interactions.

Your born with personality is also a huge factor. Quite a large proportion of personality is inherited. If you are lucky enough to be born with a resilient and optimistic personality life will always be easier. Someone born with an anxious and neurotic personality will obviously find life tougher. Even if they do try to change their mindset, they will constantly have to be consciously working at that, which is exhausting. Whereas the born resilient optimist doesn't have to work at it at all.

Resilience is not really inborn I don't think, I read a great book on the subject and largely resilience is formed in childhood by a complex mix of adverse events and protective factors and very difficult to predict. Trauma hitting at certain times and in certain ways is more likely to cause long term problems. It's all very interesting but yes, hard to increase resilience in adulthood apparently.

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:15

There is a big difference between ordinary stuff that is inevitable. Old people get ill and die for example. And people who have a hard life. If all you have is ordinary stuff you do have an easy life.

Maryslargelamb · 05/05/2023 14:15

Barnbrack · 05/05/2023 14:08

See I still don't think that's a choice, it's a complicated mix of mental health, lack of resilience, probably childhood stuff that's complicated. Even just having a certain personality type. All these things are not deliberate

I completely agree. I had two good friends who were ' their own worst enemy'. I also knew their backgrounds and childhoods. And that absolutely helped to explain their personalities. They were unable to see themselves as the common denominator as they needed to psychological protect themselves from acknowledging that. Their experiences meant their sense of self and esteem was so fragile they had nothing in them to cope with the knowledge that they were the factor in these bad interactions.

Your born with personality is also a huge factor. Quite a large proportion of personality is inherited. If you are lucky enough to be born with a resilient and optimistic personality life will always be easier. Someone born with an anxious and neurotic personality will obviously find life tougher. Even if they do try to change their mindset, they will constantly have to be consciously working at that, which is exhausting. Whereas the born resilient optimist doesn't have to work at it at all.

Tubs11 · 05/05/2023 14:13

No one sails through life, it's just not possible. Everyone will experience grief and illness at some point in their life.

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:10

midsomermurderess · 05/05/2023 14:04

I think that to an extent, character is destiny. If you are optimistic, confident, open, fairly sunny, not given to overthinking and neurosis, life will be an easier ride than otherwise, you will approach challenges and setbacks in a more positive way than an anxious, fearful person. But character is also informed by ones upbringing, early experiences etc. So some of it is just plain luck where you land.

Honestly you do not know what you are talking about. What you say works for ordinary stuff like redundancy. But what about a close relative being murdered? Should you be sunny and optimistic about that? Or having a child with a limited life expectancy? So you should be optimistic that the diagnosis is wrong?

I mean I do not walk around looking miserable and I have learned to make the most out of every day that is good because life has thrown me so many shit days. But some things are just shit.

Barnbrack · 05/05/2023 14:08

W0tnow · 05/05/2023 14:05

And there are others who are their own worst enemy. Losing friendships, jobs, alienating people, drama followed by drama and more drama. Blissfully oblivious that they are the common denominator. I knew someone like that once. She COULD have sailed through life, but chose not to.

See I still don't think that's a choice, it's a complicated mix of mental health, lack of resilience, probably childhood stuff that's complicated. Even just having a certain personality type. All these things are not deliberate

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:07

@frangipandas Most people who say things like that have had an easy life.
I do not dwell on things that have happened, but they have had an impact on my life. And I have had too many things that are not my fault.

Maryslargelamb · 05/05/2023 14:06

Beginningless · 05/05/2023 14:01

I used to think that too until I studied karma. Like I said in a previous post, I think this reaction is due to living in Christian societies focused on sin, blame, punishment etc. In the Buddhist view there is no god doling out punishments, karma is just a natural law like gravity and says that the negative experiences we all have arise from our own actions. It’s not stigmatising anyone because it suggests that we all experience the results of actions in previous lives, and as many agree here, everyone suffers, so we could say everyone is ‘stigmatised’ by their suffering in this case. It’s just how it is, no judgement (for those who believe in karma).

No, I am not talking about your reaction to it as someone from a Christian background. I am not talking about your understanding as a westerner who likes to think they have studied the texts. I am not talking about how it actually operates in the communities where karma is a core belief..

W0tnow · 05/05/2023 14:05

And there are others who are their own worst enemy. Losing friendships, jobs, alienating people, drama followed by drama and more drama. Blissfully oblivious that they are the common denominator. I knew someone like that once. She COULD have sailed through life, but chose not to.