Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people sail through life ?

260 replies

Cuberubick · 05/05/2023 11:54

Please don't think that this comes from a place of envy . It's something that puzzles me . The vast majority of us me included have ups and downs and life is not always fair.

But it strikes me that some people live truly wonderful lives, with no great trauma , no health issues or money woes , great kids etc. Think Richard Brandon for example . I'm not knocking him just using him as an example .

Then there are others who seems to go from one crisis to the next , and have tragedy befall them .

Like I have said for the vast majority of us it's bitter sweet .

Is it a case of mindset ? what you think is what you get ? Who knows .

OP posts:
Booklover40 · 05/05/2023 15:19

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 15:09

@Booklover40 Do you really have no close friends you have had for years?

I do have close friends and we do get together and have a moan sometimes but I am very conscious of not wanting to be a drain and get all heavy. I'm just not an oversharer I guess. Also we are wealthy and my friends are not and I don't want to I feel like if I'm moaning they will be thinking "what have you got to complain about compared to me?" Maybe they wouldn't think that, I don't know.

Bittersweetlife · 05/05/2023 15:17

No one knows their life but them.

Some do face more adversity than others, sometimes by their own hand and sometimes at the hands of others.

I was sexually abused for almost 4 years as a child, raped by my first husband and have also suffered a child dying.

Almost no one knows I was sexually abused and raped. I don’t tell everyone that my child died.

I live in a very nice house and come across as a very cheery not a care in the world type.

My life has been exceptionally hard but I do not take that out on anyone else.

HamptonCaught · 05/05/2023 15:10

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:10

Honestly you do not know what you are talking about. What you say works for ordinary stuff like redundancy. But what about a close relative being murdered? Should you be sunny and optimistic about that? Or having a child with a limited life expectancy? So you should be optimistic that the diagnosis is wrong?

I mean I do not walk around looking miserable and I have learned to make the most out of every day that is good because life has thrown me so many shit days. But some things are just shit.

Totally agree. Some people’s bad luck is a hell of a lot worse than others’. They try to make it relative but some people definitely have a rougher ride and anyone denying it is just one of those who are sailing through life. They don’t know any better (or should that be worse?), luckily for them.

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 15:09

@Booklover40 Do you really have no close friends you have had for years?

sweetdreamstenasee · 05/05/2023 15:06

..yes some peoples lives are easier than others, is that the point of this post? welcome… to life?

Booklover40 · 05/05/2023 15:05

I never feel like this about other people - I don't presume to have any clue what is going on in other peoples lives. Some people slap on a fake happy front but could be going through difficulties.

I once had a friend say to me that I was extremely lucky and nothing ever goes wrong for me. I do have a nice life but I also have had my share of problems - I just don't talk about them.

user1497207191 · 05/05/2023 15:04

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:50

@user1497207191 You attitude makes no difference to the prognosis of cancer. It has been researched. And this harmful myth puts a lot of additional pressure on people suffering from cancer.

No, eating healthily and exercise is proven to increase effectiveness of cancer treatments. A healthy mind is also proven to increase your likelihood of eating well and doing exercise. Of course just "thinking yourself fit" doesn't work directly, it's attitude and mindset that if you're in a "good place" mentally, you're more likely to have a healthy lifestyle, diet, etc., which in turn is more likely to make your treatments more tolerable and effective.

ClawedButler · 05/05/2023 15:04

Good looks, wealth, life partner - all these things matter a helluva lot more when you don't have them. So some people look at those who do have these things and think those people are 'lucky', and are envious. When actually none of those things guarantees happiness.

Also, everyone has a different idea of what a perfect life looks like. And you simply never know what someone has been through or what fate has in store for them.

Booklover40 · 05/05/2023 15:03

Inthesamesinkingboat · 05/05/2023 12:04

Richard Brandson who struggled at school, dropped out of secondary school and felt that as a dyslexic he didn’t fit in?

And had his private island set on fire resulting in Kate Winslet having to rescue his granny!😂

SallyWD · 05/05/2023 15:00

I don't know. I had a friend who I was envious of because her life seemed so blessed. So easy, so lucky. Then a series of unfortunate things happened and let's just say her life is very difficult now. Even if someone appears to be sailing through life you have no idea what's going on behind the scenes or what may be about to happen to them.

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:55

OP as usual lots of people who have had an easy life just ascribe their good luck to their own efforts and mental attitudes. Or they ignore your point and just say no one has an easy life quoting perfectly normal life events that affect everyone.
They do not understand.

FourTeaFallOut · 05/05/2023 14:55

Yes, some people have easy lives. Life's not fair. Some people would have easy lives but they court drama and misery. Some people have easy lives but they miss it because they think they are owed something better. As some people have god-awful difficult lives and it defies the normal distribution of bad luck how much misery finds them.

Most people live somewhere in-between.

Maryslargelamb · 05/05/2023 14:54

@user1497207191 Of course, that's not to say that people who have a positive attitude don't die of cancer. It's just saying that by being positive, your chances of survival are almost certainly higher than someone who gets morbidly depressed about the diagnosis, so much so, that the body can't tolerate the treatment or isn't as responsive to treatment being it's run down

Do you have links to the peer reviewed systematic evidence reviews which demonstrate this? If not it is an absolutely disgusting thing to say. This supernatural belief system that a 'positive mindset' means people are more likely to survive cancer has real world consequences when people feel guilt when they are dying or relatives think ' why didn't they love me enough to live?'

The thing that most dictates survival is the stage at which cancer is diagnosed. Treatments for cancer and serious and highly invasive and unless you have hard and comprehensive scientific meta- analysis that they are affected by ' sunny' attitudes you really should not be spouting this stuff.

MammaTo · 05/05/2023 14:53

I think a lot has to do with upbringing maybe, I’m also a believer of “idle hands make light work for the devil”. If you can keep yourself busy with work, hobbies, gym - what ever you’re physically capable of doing, do it.

I mean I can say this but at the same time I’ve had a pretty good life so far, had good parents who worked hard for me and my sister so it set us on the right path in life to get good jobs, nice friends and partners. Could be the hand were dealt in childhood sets us up for life maybe?

Usernamen · 05/05/2023 14:52

Moveoverdarlin · 05/05/2023 14:45

Sometimes you have no idea what goes on in people’s lives. I have a friend who has gone from one catastrophe to another. You name it. I’m sure she thinks I’m a lucky bastard who has everything handed to me on a plate. But the reality is I struggled with IVF and losses for years but I’ve never opened up to any of my friends. None of them. I prefer to be seen as the chirpy, happy go lucky one. When I meet with some friends they are just doom and gloom and I hate meeting up with them. So I never share any serious problems of mine, I can’t stand bringing everyone down. On the outside I’m pretty lucky but you just never ever know what is going on really.

Yes, some people are such doomers and positively thrive on being seen as a victim, such that those who have the decency to be outwardly positive and not drag people down are seen as ‘sailing through life’.

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:51

user1497207191 · 05/05/2023 14:36

@wildfirewonder

This 'resilience' bullshit is very similar to the rubbish that you can 'beat cancer' if you just fight hard enough.

Yes, but a positive mindset, attitude, may not "cure" cancer, but may improve your life whilst undergoing treatment, etc., i.e. healthy living, staying fit, healthy eating, etc all help your body cope with the treatments (chemotherapy, radiotherapy), helps your body tolerate the drugs you have to take to combat the side effects, etc. Your treatments may have a better impact if you can tolerate them better and, yes, may "cure" your cancer at that time and put you into remission.

No one sane would say that you can "cure" cancer by wishing it away, it's more that a positive attitude will help you get through the treatment better, encourage you to eat healthily rather than say "sod it I'll have another cake", encourage you to exercise when you really don't feel it rather than say "sod it, I'll blob on the sofa rather than going for a walk", etc.

Realistically, your prognosis is likely to be better if you don't retreat into yourself, get depressed, which in itself makes you less inclined to eat healthily, exercise, etc. Of course, that's not to say that people who have a positive attitude don't die of cancer. It's just saying that by being positive, your chances of survival are almost certainly higher than someone who gets morbidly depressed about the diagnosis, so much so, that the body can't tolerate the treatment or isn't as responsive to treatment being it's run down.

One of my closest friends was diagnosed with cancer and it caused her mental health issues, so much so, that she refused to start treatment (in fact she was close to being sectioned at one stage), and by the time that she'd got her head around it, the cancer has spread too far, and the treatment couldn't go ahead. If she'd started treatment on time, the prognosis had been quite good.

Sounds rather like you are equating mental illness/health with 'negative/positive mindset'.

They are really not the same thing at all.

Your friend did not choose either the cancer or the mental health impact. Flowers for her loss

PurpleWisteria1 · 05/05/2023 14:50

Beginningless · 05/05/2023 12:54

I think everyone suffers. Even the wealthiest people have plenty of worries, perhaps even more than people with less.

I do agree that some people have easier lives than others, and I believe that’s due to karma. It’s fascinating to study the subject beyond the usual ‘what goes around comes around’ idea. For me it explains so many unexplained things. Why bad things happen to good people and vice versa, why we get instant likes/dislikes to people and things, why babies are born with very specific personality traits etc. It’s also a framework to remove feelings of victimhood and passivity, by understanding our experiences all coming from our own past actions, and liberating us to choose a happier future based on current positive actions and how we respond to what is appearing for us moment to moment.

Humans will always look for something that explains the randomness and cruelty of life. To somehow make sense of it because believing it’s all totally random is very hard to accept for some people.

AlyssumandHelianthus · 05/05/2023 14:50

Some people are luckier than others, definitely. I don't think anyone lives a problem free life though. I'm pretty lucky, but I've still encountered difficulties. Probably Richard Branson has had lots of other issues but just hasn't shared them.

Skybluepinky · 05/05/2023 14:50

Some focus on negative and at every opportunity talk about it, others don’t.

AskMeMore · 05/05/2023 14:50

@user1497207191 You attitude makes no difference to the prognosis of cancer. It has been researched. And this harmful myth puts a lot of additional pressure on people suffering from cancer.

Rightnowstraightaway · 05/05/2023 14:48

Everyone has highs and lows in their life. Of course some people have lower lows and others have higher highs. Hugely depending on luck and where you are born. I don't believe in karma - some horrible people apparently sail through life while good people suffer.

However, some people are also better at dealing with difficulties. Or better at hiding it.

I think it's like miscarriage - once it happens to you, often you find loads of friends opening up that it's happened to them too. More than you realised. People often hide their problems, so to an outsider it all looks easy.

I know people who have been crushed by a miscarriage, and others who just thought "that's nature, it's common" and didn't seem that upset. Different mindsets, personalities, circumstances.

Moveoverdarlin · 05/05/2023 14:45

Sometimes you have no idea what goes on in people’s lives. I have a friend who has gone from one catastrophe to another. You name it. I’m sure she thinks I’m a lucky bastard who has everything handed to me on a plate. But the reality is I struggled with IVF and losses for years but I’ve never opened up to any of my friends. None of them. I prefer to be seen as the chirpy, happy go lucky one. When I meet with some friends they are just doom and gloom and I hate meeting up with them. So I never share any serious problems of mine, I can’t stand bringing everyone down. On the outside I’m pretty lucky but you just never ever know what is going on really.

museumum · 05/05/2023 14:45

Heroicallyfound · 05/05/2023 12:14

I think it’s two fold-

  1. luck of the draw as to how much external trauma you experience (death/loss, health, traumatic stuff that’s not in anyone’s control
  2. childhood programming - mindset.

If 2 goes well, you tend to cope with type 1 events much better.

If 2 goes badly, you end up with poor mental health or lack of resilience, so you might not cope with type 1 events so well.

Experiencing lots of type 1 events will knock anyone off course though.

I think there’s also a capacity element too - if you live your life with enough rest/play/slack time, whatever your mindset, you’ll cope with type 1 events better as you’ll have the spare capacity to work through them.

You need to add a third element to this - the class system / generational wealth.
Again rich people can have plenty personal trauma, they’re not immune. But money and connections make a far greater safety net than poor people have.

HazelBite · 05/05/2023 14:44

I am in my 70's and I can honestly say I know of no-one who has absolutely "sailed " through life. I have seen couples who seem to have had it all suddenly suffer with incurable life limiting conditions as they hit retirement, loose adult children, or their partner.
What I'm trying to say is even if everything looks rosy as people age we never know what life is going to chuck at us at any time.
Everyone has their own private hell, it is not always evident to those around us and sometimes the only way we can cope is to have a positive attitude.

Toasterjuggler · 05/05/2023 14:42

shammalammadingdong · 05/05/2023 12:08

Branson with ADHD and dyslexia? With multiple failures in business and jailed for tax evasion? Whose daughter died?

Yes, that sounds like a smooth and easy life that was sailed through. FFS

And let’s also add he came from an already wealthy family and started his business with a large loan from his grandmother.

obviously he worked hard, and overcame problems, but from a very wealthy base. And clearly a supportive family.