Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I contact landlord directly to negotiate rent increase?

34 replies

creamedcustard · 05/05/2023 11:23

The estate agent who acts for the landlord has informed me the landlord wishes to put up my rent in the next tenancy period.
I have some room for negotiation and am wondering if it's better to reach out to the landlord directly (I've never been given his contact details, but can find them online) and ask if he'd consider setting up as a private landlord without the agent acting on commission, as he could get more of the rent amount that way. I know agents sort out the daffy admin and legal stuff the landlord probably doesn't want to deal with, but I'm a long-standing tenant and it'd be a hopefully straightforward renewal of rental agreement. It seems win-win to me, and I wouldn't have to pay as much as the agent is proposing.
Is this bad tenant etiquette? Grateful to hear thoughts on my best approach.

OP posts:
Erex · 05/05/2023 11:54

EarthwormJane · 05/05/2023 11:51

Of course you can contact the LL, and discuss whatever you like. If you don't contact them, you definitely wont get a reduction. If you do contact them, you might get a reduction.

It's bizarre that PP are telling you not to contact your LL.

It's because OP mentioned she rents through an estate agent. They charge landlords fees to manage the properties, what's the point of paying for a fully managed service if the tenant just calls you and you end up doing it yourself anyway?

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 11:53

Too, the EA is legally required to pass on any message or request you have as a tenant for the LL. If you tell the EA you can’t afford a rent increase and would like to suggest a smaller increase, the EA has to pass that on to the LL.

EarthwormJane · 05/05/2023 11:51

Of course you can contact the LL, and discuss whatever you like. If you don't contact them, you definitely wont get a reduction. If you do contact them, you might get a reduction.

It's bizarre that PP are telling you not to contact your LL.

Erex · 05/05/2023 11:50

It will probably just annoy them. DP could technically manage our rentals alone but does it through an estate agent as they handle all admin and any maintenance issues. They are in both our names, although it's more DP's area, so I would just ask a tenant who contacted me directly to take it through the EA, and ask EA to remind the tenant to go to them directly with any queries.
Both of us would genuinely listen to any rent increase concerns, so the landlord may well negotiate, but please do it through the proper channels.

whirlyhead · 05/05/2023 11:47

I have an agent to deal with tenants purely because they have a database of repairs people and can sort out repairs to my property much faster than I can. They also chase up re rent etc, sort out gas safety certificates and so on. All things I don’t have the capacity to deal with. So no, I wouldn’t want to cut out the managing agent. There’s a lot of admin associated with a rental.

Persephoned · 05/05/2023 11:43

I wouldn’t. The landlord is presumably aware they could operate without an estate agent if they wanted to, and have chose not to - possibly partly in order to have no direct contact with tenants, in which case they won’t be very impressed by you digging out their details online.

HadalyEve · 05/05/2023 11:41

I would not contact the LL directly by bypassing the EA. The EA represent the LL. I certainly wouldn’t be suggesting they terminate their contract with the EA to save money so you can have lower rent. That would be tantamount to telling the LL they have bad judgement and is faintly insulting.

jc12689 · 05/05/2023 11:37

The landlord will be under contract from the EA so probably wouldn't be able to exclude the EA anyway .

If I were a landlord I wouldn't want tennants contacting me direct. That's what I pay the EA for.

ffsgiveitarest · 05/05/2023 11:33

Doubt the estate agent will want you contacting the LL directly, the LL will be paying them a fee to rent out the property.

I’ve had a similar situation, they don’t give a sweet FA if you’ve been a long standing tenant, as they know most people aren’t in a position to be able to move and there’s a shortage of rental properties.

I was told mine would be increasing, and wasn’t given the option of negotiating but told them I can’t afford the increase, so they’ve lowered it slightly but it’s still a massive increase, the only thing I can do now is either dispute it in court, suck it up or go into arrears and face eviction.