Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think British culture is 'fake' nice

155 replies

Wonderingmyhead · 05/05/2023 10:04

First time posting.

Just for background, I've been living in the UK for a long time so I'm a fully integrated resident.

Before anyone asks why am I living here. I've made it my home here and have a family here (DH & DD) but I struggle to understand the whole 'let me know if you need help' in EVERY situation of my life eg any time we'd be doing something be it decorating or, more recently, had a baby. My friends/DH's side of family would all say 'let me know if you need help/we're here to help if you need anything' BUT there's is real intention behind it - just words.

Another one where people say we should meet up/go for a coffee and when I suggest it takes weeks in advance to schedule it and ends up being cancelled in the end anyway.

We had tonnes of people offering help when we had a baby and after getting home from the hospital and realising we don't have any milk etc I told my DH 'well we've had all these help offers' and he told me it's best we order one of those whoosh Tesco deliveries as he'd feel awkward for someone to be dropping shopping off to us without seeing the baby in return (we weren't ready at that point). And any other time I'd attempt to call upon someone's promise it just doesn't go anywhere.

The culture I come from is less polite (which I dislike) and more direct, but if someone offers help they mean it and will turn up at your door to help.

So help out a gal.

So I'm wondering is it just me who thinks this way or AIBU/pessimistic?

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 05/05/2023 11:08

I'm on holiday at the moment and reading this book (see pic)

I'm English and it has everything pretty spot on I'd say - worthwhile reading for anyone who wants to understand English culture and behaviours

To think British culture is 'fake' nice
RedToothBrush · 05/05/2023 11:07

Yes it's a cultural thing.

My Dutch friend used to comment when she lived here that people would say things like

"Oh you are welcome to come around anytime".

It was a nice platitude but it wasn't a literal invitation. Brits would generally understand this and that it was just polite conversation rather than a real invitation.

It took her a long time to understand the difference between British platitudes and what the British actually mean.

The reverse is true in Dutch culture. If they said the same they would expect you turn up on their doorstep the next day if the mood took you and you'd be welcome. They are also more direct and blunt.

I find it hard, because I'm naturally more like the Dutch cultural expectation in many respects and find the whole British platitudes thing frustrating.

It's trying to avoid saying things like
"I don't really fancy going for a cuppa actually" because we are so desperate to not be rude. But the effect can ultimately be the same as being rude if not properly understood.

There is this whole unwritten rulebook that the British understand which we don't even see and aren't aware of which people who haven't grown up here just don't understand.

We don't mean to be fake nice but we just do these things because we think it's being polite to act like this. It comes from a place of being nice.

thefatpotato · 05/05/2023 11:06

That's not been my experience. I also was not born here but have made my life and family here- I have friends I could call on in the middle of the night in an emergency, we look after each others kids to give each other a break. I regularly drop baked good off to neighbours and they do similarly for us.

My street WhatsApp is brilliant; full of neighbours lending house stuff etc. It's so much more community minded than my home country.

dudsville · 05/05/2023 11:06

I agree totally! I think we like the concept of community but really don't wish to be involved in one another's lives.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/05/2023 11:05

Yanbu. There are loads of threads on here with people who have suffered something like a bereavement or an illness and find their 'friends' are nowhere to be found. And lots of people confirm that to be the case, and lots of others comment 'maybe death makes them uncomfortable'. But if you can't check in with a friend or drop them round something that they need in their worst times...then I dont think it's even a friendship personally.

And the people who always say 'yes we should do this' do my head in. One woman just ignored my invitation to pop in for a coffee and her child told mine she just didnt fancy it...which is actually much easier than saying yes and faffing about pretending to find a date.

Anyway I'm quite direct, I think I'm ND, and would only offer help if I could follow through...but find most people decline or say thanks and then dont take me up on it...maybe because they are worried it may be fake. However recently I've started saying 'yes' a bit more. We had a bereavement recently and a couple of people offered to take the kids for a while to get stuff sorted and it was really helpful. In the past I'd have said no. And I've made sure to return the favours since. We have no family near and it's nice to feel like you have some people to call on in an emergency.

So I'd say next time someone offers try saying 'oh yes that would be great, we are actually out of milk so would be amazing if you could drop some round' and see what happens...if it doesn't materialise you will be able to sort the fake from the real.

YourMommaWasASnowblower · 05/05/2023 11:04

I’m British and I do agree with you to an extent. I think some people do genuinely mean it, but those usually do an action to back it up quite quickly. Eg if you are out of hospital they bring you a meal and then say if you need anything let me know. There are also the ones that feel they are over-stepping if they go beyond saying let me know if you need something, so they mean it, but it doesn’t end up happening. But there are quite a lot who say ‘let me know if I can help’ in a fake nice way. Usually if you take them up on their offer their eyes pop out and they are all ‘ummm, oooh, I’d love to BUT. . . .’ or they completely disappear until the situation is over so that you don’t take them up on their fake offer.

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 11:04

whumpthereitis · 05/05/2023 10:34

It’s enough of a thing that it’s become a meme.

I’ve also noticed this. I come from a country where people communicate very directly, but in the UK this is often perceived as rude, and rudeness I’ve found seems to be considered the worst of all sins to be avoided at all costs.

It’s one thing I definitely still struggle with despite otherwise being fluent. There’s a lot of reading between the lines required. I’ve had to temper my own way of communicating, but I’m still considered blunt (just not as blunt).

I think there is a lot of truth in this list!

I am British but work with lots of people from all over the place, sometimes I have to help them decode, especially in meetings. A meeting can have gone really badly (with lots of these type of comments) and they think it was fine!

BeatriceLacey · 05/05/2023 11:03

I think you're right. I'm half British. However, there are some genuinely kind people who really do want to help and you can maybe spot them because they offer something specific rather than a vague offer of help.

Askil · 05/05/2023 11:03

@OP based on my 35yrs experience in this country. They do not mean it. It's something they say to round up conversation. Offering help here and there and acting like a community is not the norm, although they will argue about that but those of us who have lived in other countries and cultures know that the U.K does not embody these values.

shivawn · 05/05/2023 11:02

I don't find this to be honest. I haven't lived in UK for a long time and no longer even consider myself from there so I'm not biased.

If you want fake nice try going to USA, half the people you encounter day to day are being super nice and helpful just to get as many tips out of you as possible.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/05/2023 11:01

If I offered to fetch shopping for someone who had just had a baby and was taken up on it I wouldn’t expect to be shown the baby ‘in return’. Say I dropped the shopping off and it was asleep upstairs I would think nothing of it.
However I find your thing about not being ready to let people ‘see’ your baby very peculiar! Not wanting to receive guests is understandable but if you had been holding the baby when you answered the door to the person with the shopping would you have hidden its face?!

Okisenough · 05/05/2023 11:00

whumpthereitis · 05/05/2023 10:34

It’s enough of a thing that it’s become a meme.

I’ve also noticed this. I come from a country where people communicate very directly, but in the UK this is often perceived as rude, and rudeness I’ve found seems to be considered the worst of all sins to be avoided at all costs.

It’s one thing I definitely still struggle with despite otherwise being fluent. There’s a lot of reading between the lines required. I’ve had to temper my own way of communicating, but I’m still considered blunt (just not as blunt).

This meme is spot on especially the dinner thing! For probably each 100 times someone says you must come round for tea/dinner/coffee, I've actually been invited once but to be fair each time it's said I know it isn't genuine and in return they mostly know I don't want the invite! lol, I am British.

SequinsandStilettos · 05/05/2023 10:59

Obviously, a broad sweeping statement to follow caveat - England in particular has a "smiling tiger" culture with nuance, reading between the lines and politeness - the latter brings forth lots of "what is the done thing" responses but not necessarily sincerity, depending on who is offering what.
Whereas somewhere like Germany is very direct - bordering on brutal on occasion and you have to earn the informality of being per Du.

LightDrizzle · 05/05/2023 10:57

@whumpthereitis - I've seen this a few times and it's definitely based on the truth, - but with an important regional exception, if you are from where I am in the north, "Not bad" is high praise indeed.

Coffeeandbourbons · 05/05/2023 10:56

Gilmorehill · 05/05/2023 10:08

People have offered to help and you haven’t taken them up on their offer. What more can they do?

This. Don’t ask, don’t get. I learned to take people up on their offers ages ago. Some will see it through, some won’t, and it’s a good way of weeding out the time wasters (I always return offers by the way).

GretaGood · 05/05/2023 10:55

From my experience I would say that ‘We must meet up for coffee. Sometime’ means I don’t want to meet you for coffee.

But offers of help - I’m a bit surprised at offers from people who aren’t family - but I would take them up on it. Make sure it doesn’t mean them having to leave work early or something disrupting like that but I’m sure they’ll be happy to help.

readbooksdrinktea · 05/05/2023 10:55

I remember this. YANBU.

LightDrizzle · 05/05/2023 10:54

KimberleyClark · 05/05/2023 10:12

I think British people do genuinely want to help - but they are also respectful of people’s privacy and don’t want to push in where they may not be wanted.

This.

Obviously some people aren't helpful, but I think the desire not to intrude or be overbearing, particularly when there is a new baby, is who people give and open offer but don't just tip-up at the door.

whumpthereitis · 05/05/2023 10:54

briansgardenshed · 05/05/2023 10:49

Maybe you just:

  • don't understand as much as you think you do
  • are surrounded by people who don't really like you
  • haven't met ALL the Brits yet so saying they are "fake nice" and ultimately unhelpful is based on a sample of 25 or less
  • are not very helpful or friendly towards others so they see you as a CF and don't want to be taken advantage of

Could be anything. It might be that you are truly lovely and all the Brits really are awful people! Who knows.

Not very nice, however, to slag off someone else's culture and people - and saying, (without saying what your own culture is), that you find your own a bit direct does not make it ok to slag off someone else's.

If I knew you felt like that about me, my friends and my family I wouldn't be too keen to help you out either.

I hope you meet some nicer more helpful people soon OP, because there are lot of them about.

Or maybe it’s a genuine cultural difference, and enough of one to have become a trope.

There are plenty of stereotypes about my home country that have truth behind them. I don’t consider this to be inherently offensive 🤷🏻‍♀️

DogInATent · 05/05/2023 10:53

When people say, "We're here if you need help" it's up to you to ask. It's very easy to fall into the very British trap of keeping up appearances and saying "Everything's fine" when it's not.

And it's one of life's unwritten rules that the more notice you give for a meet-up the less likely it is to go ahead, and the more you invest in it emotionally so the worse you feel when it doesn't work. Decide that you are going out for a coffee the day after next, let people know and leave it up to them to join you. Don't turn it into a royal engagement with invites and RSVPs - that's what puts people off. Be spontaneous. Be happy to have a coffee with one friend without needing a crowd.

briansgardenshed · 05/05/2023 10:49

Maybe you just:

  • don't understand as much as you think you do
  • are surrounded by people who don't really like you
  • haven't met ALL the Brits yet so saying they are "fake nice" and ultimately unhelpful is based on a sample of 25 or less
  • are not very helpful or friendly towards others so they see you as a CF and don't want to be taken advantage of

Could be anything. It might be that you are truly lovely and all the Brits really are awful people! Who knows.

Not very nice, however, to slag off someone else's culture and people - and saying, (without saying what your own culture is), that you find your own a bit direct does not make it ok to slag off someone else's.

If I knew you felt like that about me, my friends and my family I wouldn't be too keen to help you out either.

I hope you meet some nicer more helpful people soon OP, because there are lot of them about.

IcedPurple · 05/05/2023 10:48

When you say you were offered help was it in the form of 'Let me know if you need anything'? And if so, did you in fact let them know, and did they then not help you out?

If so, then yes their offer to help was indeed fake. However, if you didn't let them know that you needed help, then I don't think it would be reasonable to expect them just to call you.

kethuphouse · 05/05/2023 10:47

I think it's just a lack of social intelligence. Generally, we are not taught to acknowledge our feelings or express them honestly. I think we tend to feel awkward about being open and honest in case we offend people. We stifle our feelings, then gossip and become bitter about it all because we have not been able to say out loud what is bothering us. Things are changing and I've noticed a focus on 'big feelings' etc in schools which is great to see.

whumpthereitis · 05/05/2023 10:34

It’s enough of a thing that it’s become a meme.

I’ve also noticed this. I come from a country where people communicate very directly, but in the UK this is often perceived as rude, and rudeness I’ve found seems to be considered the worst of all sins to be avoided at all costs.

It’s one thing I definitely still struggle with despite otherwise being fluent. There’s a lot of reading between the lines required. I’ve had to temper my own way of communicating, but I’m still considered blunt (just not as blunt).

To think British culture is 'fake' nice
TripleDaisySummer · 05/05/2023 10:16

My friends/DH's side of family would all say 'let me know if you need help/we're here to help if you need anything' BUT there's is real intention behind it - just words.

I'm British but it is very hard to know if people actually mean this when they say it.

We had a few hard times when kids were young lots of bad luck and when a few very persistent family members kept saying this we asked for help they'd offered - shock and horror and only occasionally begrudging help. It often felt more depressing than struggling to manage ourselves.

On other hand I've live in communities that really do mean it sometimes to point they just politely intercede and start helping.

I'm ND so maybe I'm missing some signals though DH isn't and he often can't tell either - and yes mostly we don't bother people and get on with things ourselves.