Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable in this situation?

89 replies

WotATwot · 05/05/2023 07:17

Husband and wife, they share two children and husband has two older children from a previous relationship that wife has known since they were 5&7 and they are now teens. The two shared children are young still.

Wife gets a large payout for an accident she was in (no lasting issues but pretty horrible at the time) and says she wants to keep it aside for help toward a house deposit or uni each for their two children so puts it in their bank accounts.

Husband thinks this is unfair because they are very unlikely to be able to do the same for his older children and neither is their mother. He thinks even if it's not a similar amount, DSC should be given some help if the younger DC are going to receive so much.

Husband thinks there is a theme ongoing in the relationship where his wife shows little care for his older children since hers were born and wishes she would want to include them more with things and thinks it's upsetting that she's never seemed to care or shown an interest in DSCs going to uni or having any savings for their futures.

YANBU - wife is right. She should prioritise her own children and is entitled to give what she likes to them without having to even it up.

YABU - husband is right. Wife should give DSC something even if not the same amount to make it fairer.

OP posts:
DisneyMillie · 05/05/2023 08:37

I think it’s tricky - I wouldn’t expect my exdh’s wife to share with my eldest in that situation (and she wouldn’t) but I would expect my dh to (and he would)

I think maybe it depends on how much of a “family” they are - my dd doesn’t spend that much time with her dad and his wife so I wouldn’t expect her to treat dd as hers - but dd is part of mine and dh’s family and we both consider we have two children so she’d be treated equally here.

blended families are difficult!

CraftyIrishMamma · 05/05/2023 08:32

My little pot of money will only go to my child. Step children won’t see receive anything because they don’t need it. They already received inheritances from their maternal grandparents and their mother and they are substantially richer than me!

Annoyingwurringnoise · 05/05/2023 08:31

they aren’t her kids. Both kids have two parents to provide for them, she’s only obligated to provide for her own. I bet she does more than enough for the SC already.

I’d be mighty pissed off if somebody started demanding I give my money to children that aren’t mine.

Tinkerbyebye · 05/05/2023 08:28

This makes me so cross. His guilt showing. His children all have the same, two parents, two sets of grandparents. Just slightly different, and possibly with different advantages in life. What happens when his first wife passes, will she be expected to leave her inheritance to all 4- no, will all three sets of grandparents be expected to do the same-no, and any inheritance maybe different for all of them, would the kids be expected to divvy it up- no

if he wants all HIS kids to have the same he better get cracking on saving, for all 4

LovelaceBiggWither · 05/05/2023 08:24

I will probably inherit a reasonable sum from my parents. It will be ring fenced from our marital accounts and my stepdaughter will not inherit a cent from it. It's not my kids' fault that her mother is not good with money (she's run through 2 sizeable inheritances already). I feel no obligation to her whatsoever.

SpudsandGravy · 05/05/2023 08:24

Do DH's older children live together with him and DW? If so then I think it's unreasonable not to share with them. If not then I don't think it's unreasonable. It's just the way of the world for some people to be more financially lucky/unlucky than others.

Heidi1976 · 05/05/2023 08:22

Excluding any individual moral opinions that exist on here regarding blended families, she is their 'step' parent and has no legal obligations or rights to their upbringing. But is expected to give them a ton of money?

This shouldn't be on the wife to sort out the inequality. If her husband feels so strongly he should step up to level that out. It's not on her to do that.

There is still a very real prospect that they could divorce at some point, she will have then given a load of money to two children she won't see or be in their lives in any real way.

Daleksatemyshed · 05/05/2023 08:20

Generally money should be shared but an inheritence or compensation payout are a bit different. If it's a lot of money I'd give a smaller amount to the DSC but if the DH's expecting an equal split that's unreasonable.

OhmygodDont · 05/05/2023 08:18

She has two children he has four children.

She was in an accident and got a pay out she’s split that between her children. The people saying what if he only gives to the older two, then his an arse because he has four and would be favouring two of them where as the wife only has two children.

ZenNudist · 05/05/2023 08:18

Said yanbu but it depends on how money is shared in family. If H is supporting W then W needs to share windfall. If W earns own money then she can keep it.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 05/05/2023 08:16

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 07:37

OP what would your reaction be if your DH now directed his monthly savings only to the older children? Or if he did that in the first place?

It’s important to consider how you would feel in the reverse. Ultimately I don’t think it’s fair to treat step children differently if you would be upset if your own children were treated differently.

The difference is they are all his dc.

The step dc have two parents of their own. It’s not op’s fault that they can’t afford to help them in the same way, or get responsibility to compensate for that. Plus if the dsc’s mother had extra money she would categorically not be offering to share with op’s dc and no one would suggest for a moment that she should.

CheersForThatEh · 05/05/2023 08:14

How well does she know the older two? Did they live on the family home? Come over at weekends only? Spend time together like a family?

fantasyhomesbythesea · 05/05/2023 08:12

The step children have their own mother as well. DH says their mother wont be able to help them but it shouldn't mean that OP has to compensate for this. The Mother's situation may change, she may receive her own windfall. No one knows what is going to happen in the future.

Agree with previous poster , in a blended family where there are different parents and grandparents involved it's never going to work out equally.

Ponoka7 · 05/05/2023 08:08

On here it's said that all money is family money, so the money should be split between the two of them. Then the father gives his four children an amount and the mother gives to her two. When you marry a person who has children then there is an obligation towards those children, they aren't just shacked up together. The step children should get a small amount.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 05/05/2023 08:05

What's always interesting in these thread is that the actual parent of the children never does anything to the level that he expects their SM to do.

They never plan the parties,trips,buy the gifts, save hard, make wills or arrange life insurance etc. but get extremely pissy that their wives won't "put themselves out".

If they really cared that much they'd do it themselves, but nope. All words and showmanship and expecting someone else to actually put the work in.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 05/05/2023 08:03

OP what would your reaction be if your DH now directed his monthly savings only to the older children? Or if he did that in the first place?

It's not as easy as that though @Sissynova these children aren't the OPs, DH has 4 children and he'd be choosing 2 children over the other 2. The op isn't doing this as she only has 2 children.

I think I'd put an amount away for all dc but more for the two that are OPs. Enough for her sc to buy a cheap car and insure it for one year maybe (if the amount allows): it's likely they will get theirs sooner than younger children anyway so by the time the younger two are old enough to receive their amount they will understand

Lavenderflower · 05/05/2023 08:01

I can see both sides but the older children have their own mother and father who should have made arrangements.

nearlyemptynes · 05/05/2023 07:55

Neither are unreasonable. Dad should make plans for how he can do something similar for the other two.

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 07:51

Semm · 05/05/2023 07:45

And if the step DC’s mother came into some money, she should give some of it to the two children who aren’t hers? Yes?

Don’t be ridiculous!

That’s really not comparable though. The older children are OP’s step children, the younger child are not the ex wife’s step children.
The older children could spend half the week living with OP and the ex wife has probably only ever seen the young ones in passing.

0ddSock · 05/05/2023 07:51

I see where the DH is coming from, more interest in his kids lives and a little bit of the money would be a nice gesture

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 05/05/2023 07:46

I don’t think the husband is unreasonable to want more involvement/interest in the older children.

However your DC older children are his and his ex wife’s responsibility, what are they actively doing to further their children into higher education? There is a number of ways they could be doing this without money involvement.

His older children’s education is NOT your responsibility, he’s need to discuss this with her older children’s mother, unfortunately with blended families it’s never going to be equal.

Suprima · 05/05/2023 07:46

I think you are well within your rights to solely gift the bulk of it to your DC, if there is some money left over- it would be kind to set DSC up with a first car or a decorating fund.

Teens are old enough to know that any large cash gifts to their half siblings came from their mum. Your stepkids have two parents, and it’s on them to look after them in this way. I don’t think the concept of ‘family money’ applies with a blended family without great resentment.

I get that it doesn’t feel fair though. But I think men should think twice before having a new batch of kids if they can’t deal with the natural unfairness that will arise when having kids with two different women.

but on a separate note- I’d think twice about putting large sums of money into a bank account they will take control of when 18! It might not go on a house at all.

Overthebow · 05/05/2023 07:45

I do think it’s a bit unfair. You are married and therefore have accepted the kids as family, and they should be treated as part of the family. I wouldn’t give them equal amounts, as they have their mum too, but I would think giving them a smaller amount would be fair.

Semm · 05/05/2023 07:45

Ladysquamy · 05/05/2023 07:38

I think the wife is being unreasonable. It would be nice to give the DSC some of it, even if it was just a couple of thousand each. She's married to their father and they're children of the family. That would be my approach as a stepmother anyway. I don't blame the dad for being pissed off.

And if the step DC’s mother came into some money, she should give some of it to the two children who aren’t hers? Yes?

Don’t be ridiculous!

Choppyskop · 05/05/2023 07:44

OP what would your reaction be if your DH now directed his monthly savings only to the older children? Or if he did that in the first place?

It’s important to consider how you would feel in the reverse

That’s not the reverse though, because all 4 kids are his so he’s obligated to them all. His wife is only obligated to 2 of them.

A pp asked how the step kids mum was contributing to the younger kids but again not an analogy as they don’t live with her and she might feasibly never meet them.