Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable in this situation?

89 replies

WotATwot · 05/05/2023 07:17

Husband and wife, they share two children and husband has two older children from a previous relationship that wife has known since they were 5&7 and they are now teens. The two shared children are young still.

Wife gets a large payout for an accident she was in (no lasting issues but pretty horrible at the time) and says she wants to keep it aside for help toward a house deposit or uni each for their two children so puts it in their bank accounts.

Husband thinks this is unfair because they are very unlikely to be able to do the same for his older children and neither is their mother. He thinks even if it's not a similar amount, DSC should be given some help if the younger DC are going to receive so much.

Husband thinks there is a theme ongoing in the relationship where his wife shows little care for his older children since hers were born and wishes she would want to include them more with things and thinks it's upsetting that she's never seemed to care or shown an interest in DSCs going to uni or having any savings for their futures.

YANBU - wife is right. She should prioritise her own children and is entitled to give what she likes to them without having to even it up.

YABU - husband is right. Wife should give DSC something even if not the same amount to make it fairer.

OP posts:
Manichean · 05/05/2023 09:44

Of course she will prioritise her own children. DH is just another guilt ridden Dad trying to benefit his first family at his second wife's expense, tell him to jog on.

FloydPepper · 05/05/2023 09:32

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 05/05/2023 09:19

@FloydPepper I wouldn't blame him either. However he didn't do that did he? He didn't say I'll start saving for the older kids or get a new policy in place or sell my x,y,z or whatever to make sure my two other kids also get some money /are taken care of. Or he could've started a savings account for them when the were babies.Nope. He just demanded his wife pays and then brought out the emotional blackmail script when she didn't agree.

Here's the thing, a parent that actually cares sorts these things out themselves and make sure they're in place.

I meant that he may choose to do that now, based on 2 of his children benefitting (unfairly in his mind) from an unexpected windfall while 2 do not.

perhaps he’s always treated all 4 evenly, we don’t really know.

my point is, he may react in that way

foulksmills · 05/05/2023 09:26

@WotATwot Are you the mother of the two elder children?

Gistbury · 05/05/2023 09:20

Feelings seem natural and reasonable on both sides. It is one of many hurdles with blended families. Perhaps a small amount to older children would be the compromise?

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 05/05/2023 09:19

@FloydPepper I wouldn't blame him either. However he didn't do that did he? He didn't say I'll start saving for the older kids or get a new policy in place or sell my x,y,z or whatever to make sure my two other kids also get some money /are taken care of. Or he could've started a savings account for them when the were babies.Nope. He just demanded his wife pays and then brought out the emotional blackmail script when she didn't agree.

Here's the thing, a parent that actually cares sorts these things out themselves and make sure they're in place.

Sartre · 05/05/2023 09:17

I find these situations difficult because it’s hard not to project when I was a stepchild and had an awful stepdad/family who would go out of their way to exclude me. I always just think if you don’t want stepchildren, don’t marry someone who already has children.

In your situation though, I can fully understand why you want to reserve the money for your own children.

FloydPepper · 05/05/2023 09:11

OhmygodDont · 05/05/2023 08:18

She has two children he has four children.

She was in an accident and got a pay out she’s split that between her children. The people saying what if he only gives to the older two, then his an arse because he has four and would be favouring two of them where as the wife only has two children.

Fair does not necessarily mean equal

it may be fair to prioritise those that have less above those that have more in order to try and even things out a bit. I wouldn’t blame him for doing that

Deathbyfluffy · 05/05/2023 09:07

snitzelvoncrumb · 05/05/2023 07:41

Wife needs to put her money away for her kids immediately so dh can’t access it.

And yet when the reverse of this thread was posted a few weeks ago, everyone was saying the DH was a bastard for not giving his DSC a chunk!

Gotta love MN 😅

NoSquirrels · 05/05/2023 09:06

TillyTollyTully · 05/05/2023 07:34

I think you need to think about your approach to sharing money in general as a starting point.

With us, all money is shared totally equally. Over the years that's included an inheritance for me and a fairly large redundancy payment for DH. In both cases, the lump sum was thrown into our family pot and considered as ours, and jointly spent. We don't really have any concept of 'his' and 'mine' when it comes to money.

Therefore if this was us, there'd be no question of it being 'my' accident payout, it would just be 'our' money. Hypothetically, if DH had two dc and we had two together then I'd consider it fair that he provided for his 4 dc and I provided for our 2 with our equal shares. So if there was £100k then proportionally that would be £12500 for each of his two dc and £37500 each for our dc together.

If you don't share money as a starting point though, so this money is considered just as yours to do with as you like - then you should feel free to save only for your two dc. Any similar windfalls DH then gets in the coming years like bonus, redundancy, inheritance etc, he can choose himself, completely independently, what to spend it on.

This is also how I’d see it.

If a lump sum came into our household, DH and I would discuss how to allocate it or spend it.

In your scenario I’d expect my own DC to get all of my 50%, and a quarter each of DH’s 50%.

Looking at it as purely your compensation and your sole decision is always going to drive a wedge in a long-term relationship like a marriage, where you agreed ‘for richer for poorer’ because how we organise our finances does have effects - unintended or otherwise - on emotions.

Naranjas · 05/05/2023 09:06

Not her children, not her problem. The older kids have two parents, step-mum is not one of them.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 05/05/2023 09:05

@Dibbydoos so when you die are the SC in your will, splitting it all equally?

milkshakebringsallthebuoystotheyard · 05/05/2023 09:04

Dibbydoos · 05/05/2023 08:59

You marry someone with kids, you take those kids on, legally not just emotionally.
You divorce someone, and they have kids. You have no legal obligation to those kids, but are your children's siblings.

When my hubby died, his 2 kids from his first marriage and our kids were given the same amount of money. There was no will. I sorted that.

How are you managing to sound magnanimous about sharing your partners wealth between all his children. There is no question of that. If OH and I have a child, I absolutely expect his wealth to go between all of his children. Its mine that I have a right to give to just my child.

QuickGuide · 05/05/2023 09:00

I don't think the wife is unreasonable to want to prioritise her own DC with her money.

I think it's perfectly reasonable for husband to be sad that his DC won't get the same and that his wife who has been in their lives for so long and probably mostly appears to treat them equally doesn't want to in this case. That his apparently happy blended family has these undercurrents.

I also think this is the sort of thing that breaks a marriage.

Alleycat1 · 05/05/2023 08:59

@milkshakebringsallthebuoystotheyard .

Absolutely spot on!

Dibbydoos · 05/05/2023 08:59

PinkCast · 05/05/2023 08:45

If the 2 older DC's mother came into a large sum of money in a similar way, would she be expected to share it with the 2 younger DC? Very much not.
There seems to be an undercurrent of other feelings which are playing into this, in that the father doesn't think stepmum is always fair. I think it's ultimately the wife's decision, as she was awarded the money for her suffering.

You marry someone with kids, you take those kids on, legally not just emotionally.
You divorce someone, and they have kids. You have no legal obligation to those kids, but are your children's siblings.

When my hubby died, his 2 kids from his first marriage and our kids were given the same amount of money. There was no will. I sorted that.

NoSquirrels · 05/05/2023 08:58

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 05/05/2023 07:29

Wife is not unreasonable for choosing how to spend the money (on the face of it as there is no other info about how finances generally work).

Husband is not unreasonable for feeling sad his wife doesn't want to include step DC much/show more interest.

I agree.

The way you’ve set up the vote is too simplistic, OP.

Remember that DH’s older DC have been effectively disadvantaged by their DF’s choice to have 2 further DC, splitting his resources x4 instead of by x2. He’s allowed to recognise the unfairness, and be sad he can’t do much about it.

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 05/05/2023 08:57

Neither are unreasonable. The DH needs to accept he will never be able to make all his kids 'equal'. At the end of the day the wife can do with her money as she likes. The DH would not expect his ex to give his younger DC money if the same happened to her. Ultimately both women are responsible for 2 children and he is responsible for 4.

The older 2 could also get inheritance, gifts etc from his exs family - aunts, uncles, grandparents. Same with the younger from the wifes side. He can't expect all of wifes side to treat his older kids like the younger when his ex's will not be doing the same.

It's part and parcel of blended family. DH can he sad about that, but he decided to have 2 families. Each side of family will ultimately gift to their own side. All he can work towards is him and his side of the family treating all his children fairly.

milkshakebringsallthebuoystotheyard · 05/05/2023 08:56

Dibbydoos · 05/05/2023 08:54

You married him, you take his family.

YABU. Give the DSC some money too.

Seriously!

Absolute begging crap. You want your kids to have more money, give it to them, dont expect another woman to.

milkshakebringsallthebuoystotheyard · 05/05/2023 08:55

What is this constant handout expectation about from step mothers. Emotionally, financially, its appalling, especially considering how disgustingly we are talked about on here.

When the older children's mother dies, they will get her house between them. Younger siblings wont see a penny of that. I expect that dad thinks their current house should go four ways as well. When in fact SM's half should go to her children and dads half should go four ways to all of his. It is not the younger siblings burden to share everything with the older children when that doesnt work both ways. Its like older kids having a holiday with mum and a holiday with dad, but dad begrudging SM wanting a holiday with just her children. So that means that older kids get 2 holidays and younger kids only get one.

Same in this instance, if older kids mum got hurt, she wouldnt dream of splitting that money out with the younger two, so why should the step mother give her money away. Saying she "should want to" is just emotional manipulation. And those suggesting dad should redress the balance, that is just as bad. Why should he suddenly find 10k for the older two and neglect the younger, they are all his children and HE has a duty to treat them equally, not just running around after the older two trying to make it up to them.

Dibbydoos · 05/05/2023 08:54

You married him, you take his family.

YABU. Give the DSC some money too.

Seriously!

WotATwot · 05/05/2023 08:47

Wife and husband earn very similarly and finances are mainly separate (because of the blended family element).

OP posts:
AtChoService · 05/05/2023 08:46

Yanbu. Her money, goes to her kids. If he's so bothered he can go out and earn, beg, borrow or steal the same amount to give to his kids. What a wanker.

PinkCast · 05/05/2023 08:45

If the 2 older DC's mother came into a large sum of money in a similar way, would she be expected to share it with the 2 younger DC? Very much not.
There seems to be an undercurrent of other feelings which are playing into this, in that the father doesn't think stepmum is always fair. I think it's ultimately the wife's decision, as she was awarded the money for her suffering.

FeeFiFoFumble · 05/05/2023 08:41

Presumably your husband's life was also partially affected by the accident? Either by caring for you or helping to fund lawyer costs or whatever? If so I definitely take his point. If he has had literally nothing to do with it at all, then I guess it's up to you. I'd personally probably still give some to step kids but then not tell them how much I was giving their younger siblings

CatherinedeBourgh · 05/05/2023 08:38

I am a step child. All my step siblings, on both sides have received enough money from their other parent to not have to work for the rest of their lives.

I have not, and never expected to. What I have received I have been incredibly grateful for, as nothing was owed to me at all.

Such is life in blended families.