Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable in this situation?

89 replies

WotATwot · 05/05/2023 07:17

Husband and wife, they share two children and husband has two older children from a previous relationship that wife has known since they were 5&7 and they are now teens. The two shared children are young still.

Wife gets a large payout for an accident she was in (no lasting issues but pretty horrible at the time) and says she wants to keep it aside for help toward a house deposit or uni each for their two children so puts it in their bank accounts.

Husband thinks this is unfair because they are very unlikely to be able to do the same for his older children and neither is their mother. He thinks even if it's not a similar amount, DSC should be given some help if the younger DC are going to receive so much.

Husband thinks there is a theme ongoing in the relationship where his wife shows little care for his older children since hers were born and wishes she would want to include them more with things and thinks it's upsetting that she's never seemed to care or shown an interest in DSCs going to uni or having any savings for their futures.

YANBU - wife is right. She should prioritise her own children and is entitled to give what she likes to them without having to even it up.

YABU - husband is right. Wife should give DSC something even if not the same amount to make it fairer.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Daleksatemyshed · 06/05/2023 09:21

Just read your update Op, I didn't think you were in the wrong before and now I'm sure you're not. He was happy to blow £15000 on a car, no thought to his DC future then, but now you've shown him up by saving your payout for your DC. I'd make sure your money is tied up in higher interest accounts with no access until your DC need it.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 06/05/2023 09:11

And DH seemed pretty happy for this when he got a £15k inheritance and put it down on a nice car for himself

And there it is. He had the opportunity to do something for kids . He chose not to and to put himself first and now he's expecting you to pick up the slack.

WotATwot · 06/05/2023 07:15

Remember that DH’s older DC have been effectively disadvantaged by their DF’s choice to have 2 further DC, splitting his resources x4 instead of by x2. He’s allowed to recognise the unfairness, and be sad he can’t do much about it

Could you not say this about any sibling though? DSC1 therefore has been disadvantaged by DH and ex having DSC2, my first child was disadvantaged by having my second and so on.

I don't think the disadvantage here comes solely from the fact they have 2 extra siblings, it's probably moreso because those siblings have a different mother than they do and may therefore be given different opportunities or experiences just as they may be by their mother.

In regards to finances, these have always been separate apart from bills which are paid from a joint account and the rest then in separate accounts. I prefer it this way and yes having DSC is one of the main reasons for it, I wouldn't want to be getting involved in maintenance payments etc..

And DH seemed pretty happy for this when he got a £15k inheritance and put it down on a nice car for himself (which I didn't mind). I think he'd actually have been fine if I'd spent it on myself, it's moreso because it now means the DC might have different opportunities in the future that he's objecting to it. But he got to choose what he spent his on, this is what I want to spend mine on.

OP posts:
Everydayimhuffling · 05/05/2023 17:41

Mumsnet never fails to make me extraordinarily grateful for my actually nice stepparents who loved the small children who came into their lives. It boggles my mind that you could not care about them when you have known them since they were so small.

The issue isn't this money, the issue is that your DH sees that lack of care

Flamingogirl08 · 05/05/2023 16:32

I suppose neither are unreasonable really, you get to decide what to donwith your money but I can see where ges coming from.

From my personal point of view, I have a DSD who I have known since she was 5. I also have DD. If I came into money I would definitely give some to DSD and she is included in our life as a family.

Shinyandnew1 · 05/05/2023 16:29

I would do exactly what the mum has done here and prioritise my own children. DH can feel sad about it that he/his first wife can’t do the same for their joint children, but that’s life.

If the first wife won the lottery, she would prioritise her own children.

tailinthejam · 05/05/2023 16:26

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 07:37

OP what would your reaction be if your DH now directed his monthly savings only to the older children? Or if he did that in the first place?

It’s important to consider how you would feel in the reverse. Ultimately I don’t think it’s fair to treat step children differently if you would be upset if your own children were treated differently.

It's not the same. All of the children are biologically his.

WotATwot · 05/05/2023 16:13

No I'm not DSCs mum, I'm the wife. Thanks for the replies!

OP posts:
DemelzaandRoss · 05/05/2023 11:20

And yes, our Will splits our assets equally between all the children.

DemelzaandRoss · 05/05/2023 11:18

YABU. Don’t your SC mean anything at all to you?Such selfishness.

Eggseggseverywhere · 05/05/2023 11:14

Both women are not responsible for the other's dc..
Quite simple imo.

trisfreya · 05/05/2023 10:57

But they are not OPs DC, they already have a mother, it would be different if there was no mother in the picture

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 10:50

trisfreya · 05/05/2023 10:23

I think @extramaturecheddarcheese
If his ex came into money would she give some to your kids? Think about that and you have your answer. says it all

I don’t see how that’s at all the same though. OP’s biological children don’t live with the DH’s ex. They have no relationship with her whatsoever. Considering OP has been in the lives of her DH’s children since they were young and lives with them part of the time the relationship is obviously entirely different.

Catspyjamas17 · 05/05/2023 10:36

I wouldn't give my own DDs any money from compensation for personal injury, I would spend it on what care/support/bills from not being able to work or having to change jobs. They would benefit directly from anything left over but I would not be making any gift of the money.

mainsfed · 05/05/2023 10:36

I’d also make sure H doesn’t have access to your payout.

mainsfed · 05/05/2023 10:35

You need to prioritise your own kids. Step-kids will never be yours.

I would also look at your will. Make sure your dc get your full half of any property/savings.

ididntknowthat11 · 05/05/2023 10:31

Wife is under no obligation to provide for the step kids.

BUT. They have been on the scene since she met the husband. She has always known they were a part of his (their) family and I would find it very unfeeling and cruel if she didn't include them.

As the husband said, it doesn't have to be equal.

Very arbitrary numbers, but, if it were me and the money was £100k.

I'd maybe give my own kids £40k each and the step kids £10k each. Maybe a bit more for the stepkids depending on other factors, but I think that would be the minimum.

trisfreya · 05/05/2023 10:23

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 10:12

This isn’t a given. I would try to give all my children equal opportunities in life.
If I was the DH and the older children’s mother wouldn’t be able to give them the big chunk of money the younger ones have I think it’s more appropriate to give my children an even footing rather than making it so some had more advantages.
So if the younger ones had 20k each from their mother I wouldn’t be splitting a further 40k in 4 I would be making sure all children benefited equally at the end of the day and bringing them all up to 20 rather than the two younger ones ended up with 30k and the older only getting 10k.

I think @extramaturecheddarcheese
If his ex came into money would she give some to your kids? Think about that and you have your answer. says it all

extramaturecheddarcheese · 05/05/2023 10:20

If his ex came into money would she give some to your kids? Think about that and you have your answer.

Gymtastic · 05/05/2023 10:15

The mum and dad need to take responsibility for their own kids, it’s not the step mums job to support them, cheeky fuckers trying to make it so.

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 10:12

trisfreya · 05/05/2023 10:03

Dh has 4 dc, and should provide equally for them

Dw has 2 dc and should provide for them

This isn’t a given. I would try to give all my children equal opportunities in life.
If I was the DH and the older children’s mother wouldn’t be able to give them the big chunk of money the younger ones have I think it’s more appropriate to give my children an even footing rather than making it so some had more advantages.
So if the younger ones had 20k each from their mother I wouldn’t be splitting a further 40k in 4 I would be making sure all children benefited equally at the end of the day and bringing them all up to 20 rather than the two younger ones ended up with 30k and the older only getting 10k.

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 05/05/2023 10:12

It's up to the DC's parents to provide for their own DC.

The DH has four children to provide for; if he wants his DC to go to Uni and is struggling to pay for that, surely he shouldn't have had more kids? The solution to pay for your first 2 DCs Uni fees is not to marry someone new and get their new stepmom to pay for them, that's gold digger territory.

trisfreya · 05/05/2023 10:03

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 07:37

OP what would your reaction be if your DH now directed his monthly savings only to the older children? Or if he did that in the first place?

It’s important to consider how you would feel in the reverse. Ultimately I don’t think it’s fair to treat step children differently if you would be upset if your own children were treated differently.

Dh has 4 dc, and should provide equally for them

Dw has 2 dc and should provide for them

user1492757084 · 05/05/2023 09:55

There are two issues.
The money is the woman's to invest as she wishes.
Her injury could come up to bite her on the bum in future and she might not even be able to leave it in her kid's uni fund.
The money could indirectly improve the finances of the older two because their father will need to contribute less to their younger siblings' educaion.

Then there is the issue of the treating all kids with equal attention. The wife should improve and include her stepchildren in her plans and family activities on the days when they are all together.

The husband needs to plan for how his older two will afford to be educated. He should plan with their mother. Who knows? Maybe a grandparent will leave an inheritance to the kids or they might earn a scholarship or the whole family could move to a better location for education...

Eggseggseverywhere · 05/05/2023 09:52

If his exw won the Lotto would she see op's dc alright? Doubtful