Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Voting ID is a nonsense

217 replies

Cranmer · 04/05/2023 21:01

They asked to see my ID at the polling station door, but I went to the desk and could have said I was anyone. Should they not check it against your name and address, not just randomly look at the picture at the door?

All this does is put people off voting as they can't be bothered to get their passport out the drawer. Grrrrr

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
cakeorwine · 05/05/2023 18:23

Burningdownthehouse · 05/05/2023 10:16

Older people only have a hard copy of the bus pass but younger people can have hard copy or digital. The Gov thought it'd be confusing to say young person travel card but only if a hard copy.

It's all new and polling staff are working out the best way to go about it.
I worked at a polling station yesterday & we checked ID, then asked the name / address then handed ballot paper, all at the main table. It worked pretty well.

I presume where people were on the door checking, was to prevent someone wasting their time going in if they didnt have sufficient ID?? It's all trial & error and working out the best process.

You should be able to use the digital copy as well.

LlynTegid · 05/05/2023 18:14

It is a law to try to suppress non-Tory voting. Acceptable ID is not even consistent across the country.

I hope all the opposition parties pledge to repeal the law concerned, which also ended second preference voting for Mayoral elections and those for Police and Crime Commissioners.

pointythings · 05/05/2023 18:01

@USPollWorker the problem is that in the UK, introducing voter ID was a solution to a problem that did not exist. Add to that the fact that the accepted forms of existing ID (i.e. not the new one you could apply for) were heavily skewed towards a demographic that was more likely to vote Conservative and you get optics that are ugly.

What should have happened was that the UK should have introduced a universal ID card, as exists in many countries, and only then gone about introducing voter ID.

USPollWorker · 05/05/2023 17:23

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:28

But the process to register can be done much faster, can be done remotely and is led in many cases by community campaigners - the voter ID requirement has hampered voter registrations drives in poorer communities as the threshold to get ID is so much higher, more time consuming and more expensive.

I'm sorry, but I really don't believe that the threshold to get ID is that high.

However, if there is a registered voter who just wasn't in a position to procure one of the many types of picture ID that are accepted, they still have options. They can request a vote by mail ballot which they can either mail back (for free) or drop off at an early voting site - no ID required. Or if they want to vote in person but don't have ID they can vote a provisional ballot, which will be counted once the supervisor of elections office determines that they are indeed a registered voter.

MaisieMay23 · 05/05/2023 15:07

Khara · 05/05/2023 13:32

@SorePaw

The list would appear to be on an ipad now so only the woman looking you up could see it. She didn't seem to be that comfortable using it either. Ds1 did say that when he went they took ages to find him on the system.

@Khara

oh right, the two I had wouldn't have coped with that, they were struggling with the pencil & ruler! And there was only me there, no pressure of a long queue!

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:40

Thekirit · 05/05/2023 14:35

I was commenting on your previous one liner.
Which is incorrect.

For clarity then:

You think we need these new rules to prevent crimes that it is accepted (by the Electoral Commission and the Police) are not going to happen, and I think we do not need to take action to prevent things that are not going to happen.

I don't understand why you think we need to take action to prevent things that are not going to happen, that feels quite a waste of human endeavour, but I think I understand your POV.

Thekirit · 05/05/2023 14:35

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:16

You're stretching your point but it does not compare at all. Of course the police have a preventative role, but it is to prevent crimes we think might happen. We do not have a police force to prevent crimes we don't think are ever going to happen.

Voter fraud is not going to happen. It therefore does not need to be prevented. It only exists in the mind of the deluded!

I was commenting on your previous one liner.
Which is incorrect.

Caramelsmadfuzzytail · 05/05/2023 14:32

I was more miffed that I had to limp to the other side of my town when I can see a building they use as a polling station, from my frontroom window,

LizzieW1969 · 05/05/2023 14:30

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:12

No it is all electoral fraud.

If you need ID to cast a vote in person you should need it to register for and cast a postal vote.

That’s true enough. My DH and I voted by post and I really wondered why there was no requirement for voter ID.

I do wonder why more wasn’t made of the fact that ID isn’t required for postal voting? It means that no one needs to be disenfranchised at all by lack of photo ID.

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:28

USPollWorker · 05/05/2023 14:21

In case it's of any interest, here is my experience as a poll worker in the US. (It may be different in different states.)

We do require unexpired picture ID with a signature in order to vote in person. While this may be a barrier for a small minority of people, I truly believe that if someone is engaged enough to register to vote, they have the wherewithal to obtain a picture ID in the very unlikely event they don't have one. The vast vast majority of people use their drivers licenses as their ID, which makes our lives easier because we can scan them to automatically bring up the voter's information when checking them in. But we also accept passports, state IDs, student IDs, military IDs, state employee IDs, and several others, including a debit or credit card with photo.

We have a poll worker stationed on the door. While he or she won't be checking IDs, they may ask the incoming voter if they have it with them and to have it ready. This is just to save time.

A key point is that no one is ever turned away! If we can't find a voter in our records (maybe they didn't register to vote), or they don't have ID with them, or if the ID is expired, for example, they can vote a provisional ballot. This doesn't get counted with all of the rest of the ballots, but goes to the supervisor of elections office where they can investigate more thoroughly, and if it turns out that this really is an eligible voter their ballot will be scanned and their votes counted.

But the process to register can be done much faster, can be done remotely and is led in many cases by community campaigners - the voter ID requirement has hampered voter registrations drives in poorer communities as the threshold to get ID is so much higher, more time consuming and more expensive.

USPollWorker · 05/05/2023 14:21

In case it's of any interest, here is my experience as a poll worker in the US. (It may be different in different states.)

We do require unexpired picture ID with a signature in order to vote in person. While this may be a barrier for a small minority of people, I truly believe that if someone is engaged enough to register to vote, they have the wherewithal to obtain a picture ID in the very unlikely event they don't have one. The vast vast majority of people use their drivers licenses as their ID, which makes our lives easier because we can scan them to automatically bring up the voter's information when checking them in. But we also accept passports, state IDs, student IDs, military IDs, state employee IDs, and several others, including a debit or credit card with photo.

We have a poll worker stationed on the door. While he or she won't be checking IDs, they may ask the incoming voter if they have it with them and to have it ready. This is just to save time.

A key point is that no one is ever turned away! If we can't find a voter in our records (maybe they didn't register to vote), or they don't have ID with them, or if the ID is expired, for example, they can vote a provisional ballot. This doesn't get counted with all of the rest of the ballots, but goes to the supervisor of elections office where they can investigate more thoroughly, and if it turns out that this really is an eligible voter their ballot will be scanned and their votes counted.

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:16

Thekirit · 05/05/2023 14:11

The police are preventative aswell
Its not just about tackling crime !

You're stretching your point but it does not compare at all. Of course the police have a preventative role, but it is to prevent crimes we think might happen. We do not have a police force to prevent crimes we don't think are ever going to happen.

Voter fraud is not going to happen. It therefore does not need to be prevented. It only exists in the mind of the deluded!

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 14:12

Reugny · 05/05/2023 13:49

I presume because fraud involved with post is covered by it's own act?

There as fraud - which is basically non-existent - and mistakes at the ballot box is not properly covered.

No it is all electoral fraud.

If you need ID to cast a vote in person you should need it to register for and cast a postal vote.

Thekirit · 05/05/2023 14:11

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 13:39

ConfusedWe have police to tackle the crimes that we know are happening. If we were not aware of any crimes happening we would start to make police cuts, obviously.

The police are preventative aswell
Its not just about tackling crime !

Reugny · 05/05/2023 13:49

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 13:41

This is one of the key contradictions in this nonsense ID requirement. Postal votes are the most vulnerable to fraud and pressure. There have been instances of postal vote interference. But we leave that vulnerable.

I presume because fraud involved with post is covered by it's own act?

There as fraud - which is basically non-existent - and mistakes at the ballot box is not properly covered.

TheGoogleMum · 05/05/2023 13:43

YANBU surely the whole point of this is to make sure voters are who they say they are? Just proves its all about discouraging some people from voting :(

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 13:41

Kpo58 · 05/05/2023 11:40

I didn't vote yesterday as I don't have any form of photographic ID. It's weird that I could have a postal vote and vote, but not if I turned up in person, yet it's much easier if you had an abusive member of the household to get everyone's postal ballots than it would be at the polling station.

This is one of the key contradictions in this nonsense ID requirement. Postal votes are the most vulnerable to fraud and pressure. There have been instances of postal vote interference. But we leave that vulnerable.

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 13:39

Thekirit · 05/05/2023 13:13

For the same reason we have police….

ConfusedWe have police to tackle the crimes that we know are happening. If we were not aware of any crimes happening we would start to make police cuts, obviously.

Florenz · 05/05/2023 13:37

It's funny how people go on about "every other country has PR", "every other country doesn't have a monarchy" etc etc, and yet pretty much every other country requires voter ID, including one of the four parts of the UK, but it is "evil" for us now to require it.

Khara · 05/05/2023 13:32

@SorePaw

The list would appear to be on an ipad now so only the woman looking you up could see it. She didn't seem to be that comfortable using it either. Ds1 did say that when he went they took ages to find him on the system.

Sartre · 05/05/2023 13:15

The person checking my name off checked my ID so different set up to yours. You could have ‘said you were anyone’ but you’d have to know the name and address of someone else in your area in order to do this.

I don’t agree with ID to vote though, felt like I was going through passport control yesterday.

Thekirit · 05/05/2023 13:13

wildfirewonder · 05/05/2023 11:29

If a crime is not happening, why do we need to take action to prevent it happening @Deadpalm ?

For the same reason we have police….

Dixiechickonhols · 05/05/2023 12:23

Kpo58 · 05/05/2023 11:40

I didn't vote yesterday as I don't have any form of photographic ID. It's weird that I could have a postal vote and vote, but not if I turned up in person, yet it's much easier if you had an abusive member of the household to get everyone's postal ballots than it would be at the polling station.

Out of curiosity were you aware you could have applied to council for voter ID?

Kpo58 · 05/05/2023 11:40

I didn't vote yesterday as I don't have any form of photographic ID. It's weird that I could have a postal vote and vote, but not if I turned up in person, yet it's much easier if you had an abusive member of the household to get everyone's postal ballots than it would be at the polling station.

Reugny · 05/05/2023 11:35

One of the main proposals that people will need to re-apply every few years (2-4?) for a postal vote. Currently, if you apply for a postal vote, you effectively have one for life.

@jcyclops every couple of years I when I have to register to vote I have to apply for a postal vote again.

I am aware that my council, like lots of others cross checks, the people in my household against the council tax register.