Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know it’s been done before … but why do some posters have to reply when they don’t know the answer?

88 replies

Rosesandbee · 04/05/2023 19:44

A few weeks ago I had a fairly niche question relating to my line of work, clearly indicated in the post title. I had several replies loftily informing me I could not do what I was planning to do from posters who did not work in my job. Other posters were clearly correcting them and providing links showing this. But they were not perturbed by this and continued telling me and others how right they were and how wrong we were.

And you see it on threads relating to other countries - posters who live there will say ‘nope that’s not quite right’ and still they insist they are. Or benefits, or housing, or just about anything!

Do they just feel the need to say something, anything? Like annoying kids who raise their hands when they don’t know the answer just because they like hearing a voice? Or do they genuinely believe their knowledge encompasses everyone else’s?

OP posts:
PickledPurplePickle · 30/06/2023 08:10

This drives me mad, especially when people wade in with incorrect advice on things like tax and legal issues

FuckOffTom · 30/06/2023 08:10

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:03

I've had this twice.

One with my MILs pension- a couple of posters just kept on and on saying she wasn't entitled to her late husbands pension and would have to pay it all back. She was totally entitled to it.

The other was about degree funding. Totally wrong.

The sad thing was that both the posters insisted they were experts in the particular field. It's why I never believe anyone who weaponises their job to score points on here.

I’m on one thread atm where one poster keeps insisting she is a clinician even though it is blindingly obvious that she isn’t. She had never heard of the yellow card reporting scheme, for example. And her opinions completely contradict current advice given by HCP.

FuckOffTom · 30/06/2023 08:08

I know this is an old-ish thread but YANBU OP.
Ive been on several threads where posters have stated their opinion as an outright fact and,
even when confronted with actual evidence that they are wrong, they still continue.
They then get asked for evidence to back up their claims and say things like “why should I?” Or “there’s too much to type out”

It is infuriating and people who do this annoy the shit out of me.
Like, have an opinion - that’s cool - but say it’s your opinion… don’t act like you’re some superior being whose opinions are always right. It’s beyond arrogant!

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:03

I've had this twice.

One with my MILs pension- a couple of posters just kept on and on saying she wasn't entitled to her late husbands pension and would have to pay it all back. She was totally entitled to it.

The other was about degree funding. Totally wrong.

The sad thing was that both the posters insisted they were experts in the particular field. It's why I never believe anyone who weaponises their job to score points on here.

AussiUnHomme · 30/06/2023 08:00

I believe it's called the Dunning Kruger effect. I'm not an expert but understand that people with a little knowledge (having heard a snippet of something in a pub or seen a documentary or similar) will spout their views with the confidence of an expert.

The expert, meanwhile, knows their limitations so are a little less likely to comment, as they are more aware of what they don't know.

AmenAmin · 30/06/2023 07:45

Those kids you remember from school grew up. They didn’t disappear

CremeEggThief · 04/05/2023 21:07

YANBU. Drives me mad!

NotDavidTennant · 04/05/2023 20:56

Ego.

electricmoccasins · 04/05/2023 20:51

So many posters experts on schools because they went to one as a child.

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 04/05/2023 20:50

I don't know, but I didn't want to read and run, OP.

meditated · 04/05/2023 20:50

The ones that annoy me the most are 'I don't understand what you're asking....'

And especially those that will say something like 'your spelling/ grammar/ punctuation/ lack of paragraphs makes it ineligible...'

Iwantmyoldnameback · 04/05/2023 20:49

Dont forget the stealth boasters. Q What's the food like in Economy? A We only fly upper.

CherryCokeFanatic · 04/05/2023 20:48

I’m not sure tbh but didn’t want to read and run

OhwhyOY · 04/05/2023 20:47

I think it's that a lot of people sadly genuinely can't distinguish between fact and opinion as @BlueDinoRawr said. So they can't recognise that they are spouting nonsense.

SleazyLizzard · 04/05/2023 20:46

I’m afraid I can’t help you, but someone more knowledgeable will be along soon.

AnneElliott · 04/05/2023 20:46

This annoys me too op. I don't offer advice on an issue unless I know what I'm talking about, but am often stunned at the confidence of people who clearly don't have a problem with doing so!

I've seen posters tell me I'm wrong on my specialist subjects or comment on how Government works (I'm a civil servant) despite not having worked in the public sector! Can see why the lawyers get annoyed!

TooBigForMyBoots · 04/05/2023 20:41

I don't know but I've seen it on loads of threads. People who clearly don't know anything about the topic giving their uninformed opinion.🙄

Some will continue to argue even when they're presented with the facts.🤯

Bemyclementine · 04/05/2023 20:41

I work in housing and see this all the time on landlord/tenant posts. SUCH bad advice being given. Of course, the poster doesn't know that, otherwise wouldn't have asked in the first place.

BlueDinoRawr · 04/05/2023 20:41

AGailInMyPants · 04/05/2023 20:37

@BlueDinoRawr Oh goodness - I didn't mean you! I'm sorry if you thought I did. I meant that there are people on here who make preposterous claims to be lawyers, then spout a complete load of crap (quite often involving "custody" and "change the locks"). Those are just the ones I happen to be able to identify, but I'm absolutely sure the same would be true of all professions.

I’m not offended, better to treat anyone claiming those credentials on MN with suspicion anyway.

DoTrollsShitInTheThreads · 04/05/2023 20:39

Same with people who blithely confirm that they haven't read the thread and then impart their considered opinion in a long post. A post that they would realise is completely wrong or irrelevant if they had read the thread. Drives me insane.

AGailInMyPants · 04/05/2023 20:37

@BlueDinoRawr Oh goodness - I didn't mean you! I'm sorry if you thought I did. I meant that there are people on here who make preposterous claims to be lawyers, then spout a complete load of crap (quite often involving "custody" and "change the locks"). Those are just the ones I happen to be able to identify, but I'm absolutely sure the same would be true of all professions.

BlueDinoRawr · 04/05/2023 20:37

People also struggle to differentiate between facts and opinions, I.e they can’t accept a differing opinion is just that - an opinion and so can’t actually be wrong. But then dispute a proven fact, which can be backed up with their opinion. That’s so frustrating.

AdaColeman · 04/05/2023 20:34

One thing you can be certain of here on MN, is that whatever you say, someone will tell you that you are wrong.
You might be a world authority on some obscure branch of quantum physics, but if you post a comment including a fragment of your specialist knowledge, someone who failed Physics with Chemistry GCSE a lifetime ago, will immediately post to tell you that you are wrong!

But who knows why they do it? Maybe they get a buzz out of putting someone else down?

BlueDinoRawr · 04/05/2023 20:32

AGailInMyPants · 04/05/2023 20:17

I think it's the schoolchild thing you mentioned, OP - some people just like the sound of their own voices. I think there are also a fair few unhinged people on here who claim to be lawyers/"safeguarding leads"/doctors but are nothing of the sort.

That was sort of my point above, although I appreciate you perhaps don’t believe I’m a lawyer either - but that despite it being very unlikely I’d be identified I am still reluctant to give legal advice and say “I’m a lawyer” because we are so aware that you just can’t go around giving advice without a retainer between you and your client.

Arises from the case of Lejonvarn v Burgess [2017] EWCA Civ 254 which related to advice from an architect but the principle is relevant to other professions.

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/05/2023 20:29

It happens all the time. Someone will say if you are size 18, what do you weigh and the first answer will always be. I am size 10 and I weigh 9 stone. God knows how people like that communicate in real life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread