Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know it’s been done before … but why do some posters have to reply when they don’t know the answer?

88 replies

Rosesandbee · 04/05/2023 19:44

A few weeks ago I had a fairly niche question relating to my line of work, clearly indicated in the post title. I had several replies loftily informing me I could not do what I was planning to do from posters who did not work in my job. Other posters were clearly correcting them and providing links showing this. But they were not perturbed by this and continued telling me and others how right they were and how wrong we were.

And you see it on threads relating to other countries - posters who live there will say ‘nope that’s not quite right’ and still they insist they are. Or benefits, or housing, or just about anything!

Do they just feel the need to say something, anything? Like annoying kids who raise their hands when they don’t know the answer just because they like hearing a voice? Or do they genuinely believe their knowledge encompasses everyone else’s?

OP posts:
SouthCountryGirl · 30/06/2023 09:18

I have a Facebook friend who does this. She'll tell me she has no idea what I'm on about. Right. It wasn't aimed at her so why reply?

And then there's those who when I ask "is anyone free to guide me at parkrun on such a date please?" There's always someone replying with "I'm not there that week. Maybe the weekend after". Helpful.

DoormatBob · 30/06/2023 09:17

The thing that frustrates me with MN is a lot of posters writing the exact same response. That's not how you would have a discussion in real life. It's like ask the audience on who wants to be a millionaire!

Worse when the discussion has moved on but someone feels the need to write the same reply on page 6 that was already posted on page 1 three times.

I've wasted plenty of time reading what could have been an interesting thread only to find nothing was added after the initial comments.

marcopront · 30/06/2023 09:17

@FuckOffTom

They then get asked for evidence to back up their claims and say things like “why should I?” Or “there’s too much to type out”

Or they tell you the evidence is out there you can find it yourself.

x2boys · 30/06/2023 09:15

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:05

I think the most classic comment was on the student finance thread. One poster was insisting I'd get student finance when I didn't think I would. I started ignoring her. In the end she put something like "I don't know why you are wasting your time posting here when I've categorically told you that you will get student finance"

I rang SFE the next day, they confirmed I wasn't eligible. I added that to the thread and surprise surprise no comment from that poster 🫢

Yeah I have seen that on the legal.board ( I go on sometimes to.have a nosy even though I have no.lrgsl.knowledge whatsoever ) There are a couple of lawyers who.regularly post giving generic advise about child arrangements sometimes I see that their advice is ignored because its not what the Op.wants to.hear and the Op will instead listen to.the posters who are just giving their opinion .

FictionalCharacter · 30/06/2023 09:14

BlueDinoRawr · 04/05/2023 20:37

People also struggle to differentiate between facts and opinions, I.e they can’t accept a differing opinion is just that - an opinion and so can’t actually be wrong. But then dispute a proven fact, which can be backed up with their opinion. That’s so frustrating.

This is a big part of it.
Covid showed just how bad this phenomenon can be. Every man and his dog was suddenly entitled to argue with genuine experts on infectious disease, immunology, virology, vaccines, epidemiology, and PPE. A lot of people believed that their opinion was as valid as actual research findings and data.

x2boys · 30/06/2023 09:09

The most frustrating ones are " medical.advice"
I have seen so.much dangerous advice around things like constipation for example ,the only advice that should be given is see your GP,or get advice from.a pharmacist.
.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:06

ginslinger · 30/06/2023 09:03

I know but I'm not telling because my knowledge is so specialised that it would be so outing.

I actually do have some very specific knowledge about something that I agree would be very outing! I sometimes name change and try and give my perspective but usually get ignored anyway 🙃

Terryer · 30/06/2023 09:05

I think the most classic comment was on the student finance thread. One poster was insisting I'd get student finance when I didn't think I would. I started ignoring her. In the end she put something like "I don't know why you are wasting your time posting here when I've categorically told you that you will get student finance"

I rang SFE the next day, they confirmed I wasn't eligible. I added that to the thread and surprise surprise no comment from that poster 🫢

ginslinger · 30/06/2023 09:03

I know but I'm not telling because my knowledge is so specialised that it would be so outing.

ApocalypseNowt · 30/06/2023 09:01

I work in Debt Advice. The bollocks that get spouted on money worries/debt threads is astounding.

The only 'advice' I offer (other than correcting factually incorrect statements) is GO AND GET SOME DEBT ADVICE.

And, breathe.....

CountTo10 · 30/06/2023 08:41

I've often wondered the same. It puzzles me even more when a poster does start an answer with 'I have no legal knowledge whatsoever' and then goes on to give their opinion on some legal process or point of law. I wonder why they even bothered to open the thread in the first place when the title made it clear the poster was after specific legal advice. It's really bizarre.

x2boys · 30/06/2023 08:39

Yep.see also.children with disabilities and or special needs ,I.have seen posters ,post in quite desperate situations ,and other posters replying who.although they mean well clearly have no.clue how the system works and advise to.demand respite ( you can demand all.you want but its a slow process with limitations)
Or say things like have you thought about a residential.school.( I see this a lot ) ,its not as simple as asking for a residential school a child being given a place .

ThisWOMANWontWheesht · 30/06/2023 08:31

That's interesting what you said about not declaring being a lawyer on a thread @BlueDinoRawr and the very good reasons for it. It will make me far less believing of those who do, now!

I think some people just get gripped by the dilemma/problem/situation and want to make themselves part of it, so say whatever bollocks they think founds just about plausible to get right into the midst.

PonyPatter44 · 30/06/2023 08:29

I think its pathological. My exH used to HATE being involved in conversations that weren't all about him, and would steer any and all conversations back to himself, his hobbies, his interests....So there would be five of us sitting around the table chatting about gardening, for example, and he'd make some silly-ass comment about heavy metal music, to bring the chat round to something HE wanted to talk about. He did this because he felt invisible and if he wasn't being the centre of attention, he might just pop into non-existence.

It's the same with the people who post non-replies. They feel that every thread on Mumsnet needs to be all about them, and their opinion matters.

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 30/06/2023 08:25

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:11

It's so obvious.

Also there seems to be an amazing amount of university admissions people.

There's certainly one particular poster who knows everything there is to know about every single course at every single university in the UK and in Europe in terms of eligibility. Plus of course what the graduates go on to do and who they marry.

I have intimate knowledge of one of the uni systems in one of the countries she likes to go on about and guess what? A 3 day mini break in the relevant city, does not an expert make 🤣

HappiestSleeping · 30/06/2023 08:25

2023forme · 04/05/2023 19:46

@Rosesandbee - sorry, but I don’t know the answer to that 🤣🤣🤣

This 👆 🤣

giraffetrousers · 30/06/2023 08:24

Echoing what PP have said- they just like to express their opinions on stuff, and they dont care if theyre wrong because they like the sound of their own voice.

That said, I am a bit baffled when people ask medical or legal questions on here, like, I understand asking for advice about where to go to get the answers but if I had a serious medical/legal question there is no way I'd come to a forum like this for the answer. It could be very dangerous to take some random online stranger's advice about something that only a qualified professional should answer. Even if someone claims to be a doctor/lawyer, you have no idea if thats even true or what their motives are.

Canyousewcushions · 30/06/2023 08:22

To be fair, my MIL does this a lot n really life, it's not necessarily that they are just doing it in here.

She seemingly knows far more about my profession, which entailed 5 years of uni plus professional qualifications after, than I ever will. Actively moves the conversation towards my specialism and then spouts utter bollocks while I smile and nod.

I think online forums probably attract deluded nutters who think they know more than they do and just LOVE imposing their wisdom on unsuspecting others.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:20

If you ignore them...

"I see you've ignored my post OP"
"Have you done the (mad) thing I suggested??"
"Well clearly you only want posters to agree with you"

Etc etc

Frogmila · 30/06/2023 08:19

If they're getting the answers wrong then either they have misunderstood the question, are wrongly informed or think that their tangential info might be useful. Some say 'I don't know but good luck' or whatever to show support, boost the thread or place mark. Some people just like to offer an opinion. As a PP says, it's a discussion board not an advisory service so you have to accept an element of this.

happyfoot · 30/06/2023 08:18

It was the same during Covid- people suddenly became experts in virology despite having no more credentials than looking at a few facebook posts. I think its just plain old arrogance. Its very true that a little knowledge is a dangerous thing. I've posted about stuff before in my job and people have argued with me that its wrong despite me doing that thing literally daily when theyve never worked in that area before. I think the best thing to do is completely ignore. There is no point arguing with someone who clearly doesnt know what they are talking about, its a complete waste of time. Dont waste precious energy on people like that, just internally chuckle at their stupidity and only respond to the posters who make sense.

Caradonna · 30/06/2023 08:14

Also a myriad coming on to repeat what's been said 50 times.

Fightyouforthatpie · 30/06/2023 08:14

Is it potatoes?

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:13

PickledPurplePickle · 30/06/2023 08:10

This drives me mad, especially when people wade in with incorrect advice on things like tax and legal issues

Yes - see my post. It's actually quite damaging- I was really worried about my MIL. Even after posting that I'd spoken directly to the dwp and posted their advice, this poster kept insisting it must be wrong

Terryer · 30/06/2023 08:11

FuckOffTom · 30/06/2023 08:10

I’m on one thread atm where one poster keeps insisting she is a clinician even though it is blindingly obvious that she isn’t. She had never heard of the yellow card reporting scheme, for example. And her opinions completely contradict current advice given by HCP.

It's so obvious.

Also there seems to be an amazing amount of university admissions people.