Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know it’s been done before … but why do some posters have to reply when they don’t know the answer?

88 replies

Rosesandbee · 04/05/2023 19:44

A few weeks ago I had a fairly niche question relating to my line of work, clearly indicated in the post title. I had several replies loftily informing me I could not do what I was planning to do from posters who did not work in my job. Other posters were clearly correcting them and providing links showing this. But they were not perturbed by this and continued telling me and others how right they were and how wrong we were.

And you see it on threads relating to other countries - posters who live there will say ‘nope that’s not quite right’ and still they insist they are. Or benefits, or housing, or just about anything!

Do they just feel the need to say something, anything? Like annoying kids who raise their hands when they don’t know the answer just because they like hearing a voice? Or do they genuinely believe their knowledge encompasses everyone else’s?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PonyPatter44 · 30/06/2023 19:12

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 30/06/2023 10:42

I think it’s because people lead quite small, inconsequential lives, good portions of which are carried out online and on forums such as Mumsnet, so they create personas with all the traits they’d like to have, that make them feel important.

Some people take it too far and try to feel big and clever by being cunts to OPs having a shit time, and that’s when it takes a really dark turn.

I think you're spot on.

BertieBotts · 30/06/2023 14:48

Dunning–Kruger effect Grin

DrunkenKoala · 30/06/2023 14:44

During Covid we were prioritised for supermarket home delivery. My local supermarket then started doing click and collect and was thinking about changing to it but as we weren’t supposed to leave the house if anyone had covid symptoms I asked on here what others were doing if they found themselves in that situation. I had about three different poster telling me I COULDN’T leave the house if anyone has Covid symptoms. So I specifically told them that already knew that and could they suggest what I COULD do. Oddly enough never heard a peep out of them again on that thread. I think some people love the idea of berating others

x2boys · 30/06/2023 14:06

Megifer · 30/06/2023 13:33

The ones who don't know but them go on to say WHY they don't know are weird and I think sometimes done to be a bit mischievous E.g. question about bottle feeding "i can't help as I breastfed" (seen on here the other day).

The whole Breast versus Bottle thing gets out of hand,at the best of times!

Sweetashunni · 30/06/2023 13:36

To be fair your OP made me think, why do people start threads when they know the answers from previous ones?

Megifer · 30/06/2023 13:33

The ones who don't know but them go on to say WHY they don't know are weird and I think sometimes done to be a bit mischievous E.g. question about bottle feeding "i can't help as I breastfed" (seen on here the other day).

So1invictus · 30/06/2023 13:26

MendedDrum · 30/06/2023 12:59

Anyone else remember 'I AM CANADIAN'? Can't remember the poster's name but she was so polite and patient.

Someone linked to it again a few weeks ago. I think the poster might have been StewieGriffithsMum.

My facepalm ones are when posters disagree with me about recipes for Italian dishes. "Italians put X, Y and Z into tomato sauce, only ever make their own and handmake pasta every day".

I've only been in Italy since 1994 and DH is only one Italian chef but it does tickle him when I read the posts to him.

Ceraunophile · 30/06/2023 13:18

Oh I think I’ve been guilty of this at some point.

  1. answering to say I don’t know -I’ve done this to help keep the thread in active. Not often but if the op seems desperate
  2. answering with my similar situation and saying what happened with that if I think it might help. Again not often but if I think it’s relevant

I don’t claim to be an expert on anything though!

MendedDrum · 30/06/2023 12:59

Anyone else remember 'I AM CANADIAN'? Can't remember the poster's name but she was so polite and patient.

PercyPhelps · 30/06/2023 11:05

Some of the advice on medical threads is dangerous. I read one where someone had a burn and was told to put butter on it!

BrioNotBiro · 30/06/2023 10:56

"Don't want to read and run..."

Then follows a big paragraph of pointlessness.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 30/06/2023 10:42

I think it’s because people lead quite small, inconsequential lives, good portions of which are carried out online and on forums such as Mumsnet, so they create personas with all the traits they’d like to have, that make them feel important.

Some people take it too far and try to feel big and clever by being cunts to OPs having a shit time, and that’s when it takes a really dark turn.

Terryer · 30/06/2023 10:24

Spanielsarepainless · 30/06/2023 10:22

It happens in the product question section of Amazon too. You'll ask a question and out of five answers, three will be idiots saying they don't own this item.

A lot of the questions and answers are done by marketing agencies anyway.

Spanielsarepainless · 30/06/2023 10:22

It happens in the product question section of Amazon too. You'll ask a question and out of five answers, three will be idiots saying they don't own this item.

FuckOffTom · 30/06/2023 10:20

Usernamenotavailab · 30/06/2023 09:30

i have two bugbears:

”my dh says…”

and the anecdata brigade.

”well my aunt Ethel smoked til she was 93 and never got cancer so it’s not true that smoking means you will get cancer”

I hate this too! People genuinely cannot understand the difference between a sample size of one and actual, population level data. It infuriates me.

I just wish people entered debates in good spirit. Keep an open mind, respect those that disagree but put your points across - you might learn something! It’s all about ego, people would rather hold on to their views than grow and learn.

Poisoningpigeons · 30/06/2023 10:19

Hah, I've had that with the country thing.

Somebody started a thread asking about XYZ aspect of visiting my home country...
At first the replies were sensible advice from various posters who had holidayed there...
Then this one very insistent poster popped up who said they were especially qualified (because they had visited for work) and XYZ was completely impossible because she said so...
This poster kept coming back to the thread to tell the OP to ignore every other poster's comments because they didn't know the country as well as she did...
Strangely enough the poster disappeared without trace when I posted that not only was XYZ completely fine, but I was in my home country at the time and doing XYZ Grin

moonlitwalks · 30/06/2023 09:51

Usernamenotavailab · 30/06/2023 09:30

i have two bugbears:

”my dh says…”

and the anecdata brigade.

”well my aunt Ethel smoked til she was 93 and never got cancer so it’s not true that smoking means you will get cancer”

Urgh yes, this grinds my gears too. Someone always pipes up that they had an elderly relative who smoked 150 a day and lived on whiskey who lived until 100 or washed their face with bleach every night and had "no wrinkles whatsoever at age 99" or never wore sunscreen, covered themselves in lard and baked in the sun for 8 hours a day and never got skin cancer, doesnt mean its a good or sensible thing to do for the majority of people!

RudsyFarmer · 30/06/2023 09:46

Kristen Marie the comedians name is. I think she’s on Instagram.

RudsyFarmer · 30/06/2023 09:43

I watched a parody comedy skit on this come through TikTok about boomer parents. Was very well observed 🤣

TheProcrastinati · 30/06/2023 09:39

Fightyouforthatpie · 30/06/2023 08:14

Is it potatoes?

no! It’s a semi quaver

(forgot to quote previously)

Baabaagreysheep · 30/06/2023 09:39

This is so frustrating and exacerbated by the fact posters never concede graciously they might be wrong but get very angry at you ignoring helpful advice!

I had a pile on when I was paid my maternity pay in one lump sum. I had so many aggressive posts telling me it was my poor financial management that was at fault. Despite me and some other posters trying to explain over and over that there is a monthly threshold for national insurance of £520 so if you get paid in one lump everything above 520 has NI applied (in equal instalments your threshold will effectively be 4680 so i has lost 11% of 4160.) It basically meant I was down more than 2k when money was already tight, but I was apparently totally unreasonable and needed to manage money better.

TheProcrastinati · 30/06/2023 09:38

No! It’s a semi-quaver.

Usernamenotavailab · 30/06/2023 09:30

i have two bugbears:

”my dh says…”

and the anecdata brigade.

”well my aunt Ethel smoked til she was 93 and never got cancer so it’s not true that smoking means you will get cancer”

MrsGusset · 30/06/2023 09:25

People who don't read the the thread are infuriating but can also be unintentionally funny.

A recent poster wanted advice on where to buy a house convenient for his/her work in north London. This produced a shoal of impractical suggestions including Woodbridge in Suffolk & Morpeth in Northumberland.

countrygirl99 · 30/06/2023 09:24

They do it in real life too. FIL had mates like this who would tell him he was entitled to x or y help/benefit.
Every time we could show him government/council websites/charity that showed him otherwise but he would shout us down every time because his gobby mate had said so. Then he would go and have a flaming row with the social worker/benefit person who "clearly doesn't know their job/ just doesn't want to give whatever out to save money". Then phone us ranting about the "jobsworth".
Every Single Time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread