Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fancy a Chinese?

139 replies

Tinktravels · 04/05/2023 12:28

Now I know this is ridiculous but it might give you a laugh.

American people on tik tok have discovered that we call it ' a Chinese' rather than 'Chinese food'.
There has been so many stitches of videos from mainly English or Irish people saying things like 'I haven't had a Chinese in ages' or 'I really fancy a Chinese tonight'. There are many that are actually calling it racist which is we all know is rubbish!

They are also slating the food itself for not being authentic Chinese and having dishes like curry sauce and chips. Cant argue with that one we all know its not authentic but its bloody lovely.

Has it ever even crossed your mind that people would consider this racist?

(Search A Chinese British on tik-tok there are so many videos on this.)

OP posts:
Enko · 04/05/2023 14:49

Gtsr443 · 04/05/2023 12:39

See Goodness Gracious Me and "Going for an English".

For what it's worth chips and curry sauce is fusion food at its finest.

Love that

Ja. Mes 😂

whowantssmore · 04/05/2023 14:47

Oh how mumsnet loves an anti American pile on. Just try to remember a few tiktokers do not represent the whole population of the US. Imagine if the whole of the UK was judged on a handful of smart arse 'influencers'

Tinktravels · 04/05/2023 14:32

I read a comment from an English person saying how nice it tasted and that they should try it.
Then a comment from an American saying ' don't trust them they devour beans on toast' 😂
That one made me laugh.

OP posts:
Asthebellcurves · 04/05/2023 14:16

Having lived in the US, I think any critiques of authenticity of British-Chinese food are hypocritical to say the least. This also applies to racism.

userxx · 04/05/2023 14:13

Snowtrails · 04/05/2023 13:33

Not racist. But it's a bit odd.

But saying "a McDonald's" or "a Costa" is weirder!

Eh? How is it weird?

Tinkerbyebye · 04/05/2023 13:59

It’s absolute rubbish, we say a Chinese, a Indian, a McDonald’s a Burger King, a Italian, it’s just how we speak

the person in question is American, and whilst I agree this is a generalisation, most Americans seem to think there is only their way in this world and don’t understand every other country is different to them

ArrrMeHearties · 04/05/2023 13:56

Will we have a Chinese tonight or an Indian tonight I see no wrong with saying this. Is just a shortened version of said cuisine takeaway. Nobody I know says will we get Chinese or Indian takeaway when deciding for dinner that night

CurlewKate · 04/05/2023 13:49

In other news, nobody's banning Christmas and you can celebrate St George's Day any safe and legal way you want.

tabulahrasa · 04/05/2023 13:48

IMO the reasons Americans find the phrase a Chinese weird is that Chinese take out or Chinese food is a plural noun there and we use takeaway as a singular noun.

and... because the phrase a Chinese is only used in the context of food, if we were talking about people or anything else, we’d always use a noun or pronoun with it.

A Chinese. In the U.K. is the full phrase, they’re saying a Chinese, what? But to us it’s so obvious we mean food from a Chinese takeaway or restaurant that it literally doesn’t make sense in any other context, there’s no gap there for us.

SquidwardBound · 04/05/2023 13:47

CurlewKate · 04/05/2023 13:40

I couldn't be more sure that nobody ever thought "mad as a box of frogs" is offensive to French people.

That would probably be because you don’t make any automatic association of French people and ‘frogs’. You’d have to think about what the link might be.

oldwhyno · 04/05/2023 13:43

As others have said, it's an abbreviation. It's not racist. How American's feel about the way we use language doesn't make it racist.

How Chinese people feel about it doesn't really matter either.

Bargellobitch · 04/05/2023 13:42

I'm on tt a lot and haven't seen people saying its racist. I saw one person asking about the phrasing and seems fine with the fact its a short version of a sentence. Honestly feels a bit dramatic and looking for a reaction to say it's people sati g it's racist. Most of the videos are about the food being different.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 04/05/2023 13:41

Createausername1970 · 04/05/2023 13:07

I don't think "having a Chinese" is racist. Its descriptive of what it is.

But if we go for an Indian we say "going for a Ruby" - I think its rhyming slang, but not sure what for or why, we just do.

A big breakfast is a full English and I have seen menu's in Dublin serving a Full Irish for breakfast.

Going for a Ruby = Ruby Murray = curry.
It's cockney rhyming slang, the second word of the slang saying is usually the rhyming word and is then dropped. Obviously this particular slang phrase is not original Cockney rhyming slang but a newer one

CurlewKate · 04/05/2023 13:40

I couldn't be more sure that nobody ever thought "mad as a box of frogs" is offensive to French people.

SquidwardBound · 04/05/2023 13:40

The other bizarre thing is that the many things on a standard Chinese takeaway menu seem to have been reduced on tik tok to chips with curry sauce, possible salt and pepper chips, plain fried rice and chicken/pork balls with sweet and sour sauce.

Which, is fine, if that is what you get from
the takeaway. But loads of people are eating all sorts in theirs.

Then there’s the simple fact that you can actually order much more what people in
china eat versions of Chinese takeaway in most British cities, which seems to have been lost in all of this. If I want to order mixed pork congee with century egg, or smashed cucumbers with garlic sauce or chicken and pork tripe braised with white pepper or poached frog legs in chilli sauce I can get that on Deliveroo in the provincial city I live in.

or I can order chicken balls and chips and curry sauce (not from the same place admittedly) if I prefer.

Because there’s quite a lot of choice and differentiation on offer even within the Chinese takeaway offering in this country in the 21st century. There are actually loads of takeaways that have two menus - so it would be possible to phone through an order of red braised pork knuckle and chicken balls with curry sauce if I wanted to combine the two.

I assume that it’s possible to do the same in many American cities. Except that you would have hot and spicy pig intestines with your lo mein, general tso’s chicken and beef and broccoli.

(Full disclosure: I don’t think I will be ordering the frogs or the tripe any time soon - but the congee and the cucumber are nice! I think the properly Chinese students at the local university population may be more the target market for much of that menu).

WheelsUp · 04/05/2023 13:39

The person who originally posted it has backed down as she accepts it's shorthand for a Chinese takeaway/meal and that the UK uses it for all nationalities (including a full English ) and corporations (eg a McDonalds)

As for the authenticity angle, the US has plenty of American chains that sell inauthentic equivalents. Not everyone has access to a China Town with authentic cuisine.

I don't order chips from the Chinese but this reinforces how arrogant some Americans can be about the world and an insistence that everyone else must be wrong.

capitanaamerica · 04/05/2023 13:38

RE the variety of food - in the US, the most long-standing Chinese restaurants in places like San Francisco and Los Angeles where there’s a large, consistent, and very long-standing Chinese population are MORE likely to have a variety of food on the menu that is not Chinese in origin. They originally served local communities and had things for Chinese people with Americanised children (and increasingly Americanised tastes of their own) as well as to bring in new regular customers by catering to the tastes of non-Chinese people and specifically other immigrant groups that might have a significant concentration in the area.

A lot of these more casual, everyday neighborhood places have gone and been replaced with more upscale Chinese focused places where people go specifically to have Chinese food because they DON’T eat it every day. But the old places (if you can find one!) still often have at least a few choices of sandwiches, pasta, hamburgers, fried chicken, etc. on the menu. And it’s very common to see combo place - Cuban Chinese is classic in NYC, and there are loads of Chinese-Japanese, Chinese-Korean, Chinese-Thai, Chinese-Vietnamese etc. on the west coast. I’ve seen seen Chinese Mexican and Chinese Peruvian in Southern California.

Of course, the Chinese food in the diaspora is not the same Chinese food you'd typically have in China, unless someone has intentionally mirrored current tastes and trends from China, imports ingredients, etc.

alloalloallo · 04/05/2023 13:36

The response videos to this are all over my FYP at the moment, but I’ve yet to see the original version.

Some of these creators seem to be chronically online. A little while ago there was a fuss over Drew Barrymore dancing in the rain, and about the British slang word for cigarettes.

My daughter has a TikTok account for horse riding and she got a roasting from American TikTokers who clearly didn’t understand the differences between American and English riding. I just don’t think some of them realise there’s a whole world out there with a whole different way of doing things

Snowtrails · 04/05/2023 13:33

Not racist. But it's a bit odd.

But saying "a McDonald's" or "a Costa" is weirder!

erlangshen · 04/05/2023 13:32

Im chinese, no I dont find this offensive, but I do feel a bit sad that they call it "chinese food", I know its not their fault because people need to alter the dishes to suit the local peoples taste, just like Mcdonalds in China sells rice dishes too. However, if you have ever been to China you will you we eat nothing like those "American Chinese" food.

KimberleyClark · 04/05/2023 13:31

Reality · 04/05/2023 12:58

We had this on here once, years and years ago, a thread got completely derailed because someone took offence at the OP going out for a Chinese.

Also ‘mad as a box of frogs’ is offensive to the French.

surely frogs in this case is referring to amphibians not French people.

Reality · 04/05/2023 13:26

CurlewKate · 04/05/2023 13:02

"Also ‘mad as a box of frogs’ is offensive to the French."

No it isn't. And I suspect you know it isn't.

No, that’s what a mad poster claimed, sorry if I wasn’t clear.

Createausername1970 · 04/05/2023 13:25

littleripper · 04/05/2023 13:15

"a Ruby" is a Ruby Murray - a curry

Ah!

I have just googled Ruby Murray. Well, she wasn't what I was expecting. How odd - you have a lot of success in your own right, but you are forever known as rhyming slang.

Just like poor old Richard III.

userxx · 04/05/2023 13:24

I really fancy a Chinese now.