Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you have private healthcare would you recommend it?

63 replies

sparklins · 04/05/2023 11:47

I'll preface this by saying I am not looking to be bashed for this just hoping to get advice.
Unfortunately I've had some nasty NHS experiences in the past and whilst they are very good in an urgent life or death situations, on a day to day of getting referrals and/or exams and tests to actually get to the bottom of something is a nightmare and my relatives have paid the price with their health.

I've been reviewing our finances and worked out we could potentially afford to pay for a private policy, I like the idea of some who offer yearly health MOTs and similar.
We've had a quote from Vitality who were the first to pop up however the reviews seem less than great so I am back to the drawing board for now.

Does anyone on here have private health insurance and are you happy with it?
And if you are happy with it would you mind recommending the company you are with?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IDontWantToBeAPie · 12/05/2023 11:00

DP would. He got a surgery that has massively improved his chronic illness to the point it's almost gone.

The surgery is point blank no available at any NHS trust. He went from referral to surgery within 1 month private.

Orangesandlemons77 · 12/05/2023 10:40

I just started a policy with aviva and got one child free, other one only £7 a month but it is quite basic as I chose the option of it being only if 6 weeks wait with NHS and no outpatients (also have benenden)

CaveMum · 12/05/2023 09:27

@MsMargoLeadbetter yes you have to sync a tracking device of some kind to your Vitality account and download the Vitality app onto your phone. It then logs your activity each day and awards you points. They partner with a few different manufacturers including FitBit. I used to use a FitBit then upgraded to an Apple Watch which I got through Vitality!

Basic points are:

7,500-9,999 steps = 3 pts
10,000-12,499 = 5 pts
12,500+ steps = 8 pts

Or you can get 5pts for 30 mins moderate exercise (a brisk walk usually does it) or 8pts for 30 mins higher intensity exercise (a run or gym session). It’s all about getting your heart rate up for those points.

You can only earn a max of 8pts a day.

whumpthereitis · 12/05/2023 09:23

Dintananadinta · 05/05/2023 14:29

@whumpthereitis I thought there's no private a&e here?

There are a few. In London, and on certain military bases (granted, the latter are restricted).

MsMargoLeadbetter · 12/05/2023 09:00

@CaveMum sorry, I've just seen your message, thank you for the info!

That's really useful, thanks - this may be a dim question, but how do they know you've hit your 40 points?! I have an iPhone and an (old!) Fitbit, do they pull the info from those?

There's a lovely gym near us which is v expensive, more affordable with their discount, but probably not the best option for us yet as the DCs are still their 'creche' age rather than 'doing stuff' age - maybe in a few months when they turn 8 and can do the actual gym training/ classes offered!

CaveMum · 08/05/2023 13:15

MsMargoLeadbetter · 06/05/2023 11:01

This is really interesting, I'm considering either Axa or Vitality insurance as our local GP and NHS services are just swamped - luckily I haven't had to use them for a while but it's worrying hearing about the lack of appointments Confused

I'm being quoted about the same by each company - are the incentives the main selling point for Vitality? I know @sorrynotathome found them really good?

I can’t comment on Axa but I love the incentives from my work Vitality policy. Providing I hit the required activity levels each week (not too onerous, you need to earn 40 points across the week but can only earn a max of 8 points per day) I currently get:

Apple Watch paid for (worth £9.99 per month, I had to pay £39 of my own money to get it)
Amazon Prime (worth £8.99 per month)
Rakuten movie code (depends on movie, but worth about £3 and you get 1 every fortnight)
Cinema tickets (worth about £10, you get 1 every 2 weeks)
Cafe Nero free drink (worth about £4.25 each time, you get 1 every week)
Cashback at Waitrose (% depends on how many points you’ve earned and is only payable on “healthy” purchases)
12 month subscription to the Headspace App (worth £49.99 per year)

shivawn · 07/05/2023 19:13

ADHDGURL · 04/05/2023 19:13

Can anyone advise (sorry to jump on your thread OP🙏) if its worth it with pre existing chronic conditions (diabetes/fibroids) I've waited 7 months for a reply from NHS gynaecologist, could take a work benefit offer but worried it won't be eligible for treatment..

When you say a work benefit offer do you mean a company policy through work? Here in Ireland there are often additional benefits to company schemes including the waiving of all waiting periods and pre-existing condition exclusions. I don't know if it's the same in UK but it would be worth checking your companies policy to see if this is included in their scheme.

MsMargoLeadbetter · 06/05/2023 11:01

This is really interesting, I'm considering either Axa or Vitality insurance as our local GP and NHS services are just swamped - luckily I haven't had to use them for a while but it's worrying hearing about the lack of appointments Confused

I'm being quoted about the same by each company - are the incentives the main selling point for Vitality? I know @sorrynotathome found them really good?

mondaytosunday · 05/05/2023 14:37

I should say I don't have it anymore.

mondaytosunday · 05/05/2023 14:37

Nope. And my husband had one of those full body scans/checkups and died 18 months later with cardiovascular disease it never picked up!

Dintananadinta · 05/05/2023 14:29

@whumpthereitis I thought there's no private a&e here?

Peccary · 05/05/2023 14:22

I have vitality through work and had a problem looked at promptly. Husband has Axa, again impressive speed, went from reporting abdominal pains to having no gall bladder in a month (and could have been quicker)

Orangesandlemons77 · 05/05/2023 13:26

ADHDGURL · 04/05/2023 19:13

Can anyone advise (sorry to jump on your thread OP🙏) if its worth it with pre existing chronic conditions (diabetes/fibroids) I've waited 7 months for a reply from NHS gynaecologist, could take a work benefit offer but worried it won't be eligible for treatment..

You could try Benenden but you need to be with them 6 months before you access it.

ginghamstarfish · 04/05/2023 22:32

Depends where you live or how far you're prepared to travel. We have it through my husband's job, but have used it only a handful of times. Was in south of Scotland, had to go to Glasgow or Edinburgh, even just to see a consultant, then back for test, back for treatment etc. Now in Cumbria, again would have to go back to Scotland or Newcastle. Obviously that wouldn't be a big thing for something serious, but a long way to go if you're not near a city.

Moraxella · 04/05/2023 22:24

@whumpthereitis is the private A&E in London?

ADHDGURL · 04/05/2023 22:15

DeedlessIndeed · 04/05/2023 20:12

@ADHDGURL I think self-funded private treatment would be better for you.

Most PMI is either fully underwritten which will generally specifically exclude pre-existing conditions (or face eye-watering premiums), or alternatively you get a it on a moratorium basis, where anything pre-existing for the last 5 years isn't covered until x amount of time on the plan.

Thank you for your advice @DeedlessIndeed 🙏

Chipswithketchup · 04/05/2023 21:54

Very happy with Vitality. I’ve just had a major op fully paid for with my insurance (17 week wait on the NHS) and have had several other smaller ops/procedures over the years & no complains whatsoever. The online GP service is great & you can usually get a same or next day appointment plus a referral. Oh and our insurance covers pre-existing conditions (DH had cancer years ago so this was essential for us).

Orangesandlemons77 · 04/05/2023 21:21

We have Benenden and have used them for varicose vein surgery and also to investigate abdo pain (ultrasound, mri and consultant) last year. Found it very quick and helpful.

LisaD1 · 04/05/2023 20:52

I have Axa through work and they’ve been great. I had various pains, mainly hip and knee. Had a video call with one of their GP’s and was referred for X-rays, whilst there they wanted to do MRI and gor
approval in less than 10 mins, treated within a week. I’ve now added DH and my DD.

Effingmagicfairy · 04/05/2023 20:49

Have a look at Simply Health. It’s a Cash back plan, I have yearly MOTs on mine, consultant appts, you also get allowance towards Dental, Optician, chiropractic, osteo, chiro, hospital stays. So you can self refer and just check Simply Health accepts. I’ve spent way over what I’ve paid in this year. So you don’t get operations if needed but we would look to self fund. My work provide a private GP service which is great.

PolkaDotMankini · 04/05/2023 20:47

I'm have a Vitality scheme through work (the company pays for me, I pay for the DC). It's as good as you want it to be on the day-to-day wellness bits.

What I value is the peace of mind. I had a cancer scare when DS was tiny and before I had private cover. I had to wait 2 weeks from my GP' referral to see a specialist, then it was the wrong one so they referred me on, then that referral got lost and so it was 3 months before I actually saw the right specialist. Then waiting 6 weeks for surgery, when they thought it was probably a benign tumor but they weren't sure. Those 4.5 months of having to wait for answers were absolutely awful and the mental strain was immense. I really, really wished I'd had private cover so I didn't have to go through that.

rosiebl · 04/05/2023 20:41

Have an Axa policy through work. Pay the extra to extend to my family. Choose a GP time slot for a video call, same day. Once referred, have a list of consultants sent to us to choose from. Book directly, seen within a few days. Had to claim for my kids a few times. Always really quick and easy to deal with. Not needed it (other than the GP service) for me or DH so far. Highly recommend if you can afford.

Thriwit · 04/05/2023 20:36

I’m another who has BUPA through work. It’s been brilliant.
I’ve had physio & acupuncture covered - just call them, speak to one of their physios, they authorise the referral and I pick the physio I want.
DS had an appointment with a specialist paediatrician within a week - we had a phone appt with Babylon GP, & they referred. From experience, we’d have waited at least a year with NHS.
I had gynae scans and the operation that was medically best for me, one that wasn’t even an option with NHS.
All in all, I wouldn’t be without health insurance if I could possibly help it.

cptartapp · 04/05/2023 20:33

DH has it through work and added me to the policy for a £200 annual excess.
Twelve months ago he was referred on the NHS to MSK for a bad back. Became unbearable so went via BUPA, had trial of physio then surgery within a couple of months and and will probably be signed off next week. Still not heard from NHS.
I have been under cardiology, endocrinology and ENT last year via BUPA. I was almost cured of my ear problem by the time I saw NHS ENT. I'd had two private MRI scans whilst waiting for NHS endo and am having a cardiac procedure next month on BUPA with which if I'd waited for NHS would probably be dead.
Best money ever spent. And I've worked for the NHS for 33 years.

InconvenientPeg · 04/05/2023 20:24

Have Bupa through work and had an endometrial ablation and then a hysterectomy. Complete lifesaver, a week after the hysterectomy, I got a letter from the NHS referral that had been made a year previously letting me know I had an initial assessment in three months 🤦🏻‍♀️

There's an online GP which helps with some of the bottle necks and I found the process easy though had to keep an eye on whether I had the right codes and stuff.

It was such a good experience, I now pay for DH and the kids to be on it.