Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not what parental leave is for?

409 replies

Friendlybreadbin · 03/05/2023 21:07

I may well BU but interested in people’s opinions. My company offers a fairly standard 25 days plus bank holidays leave package. New colleague comes from a company where they had been for over 20 years and so had got up to 30 days, their old company also offered a ‘buy an additional 10 days leave’ package. Our company doesn’t. Having passed their 3 month probation period (where they also took a lot of leave) they are using leave days like they are going out of fashion, and have already had a skiing holiday and an all inclusive this year. As well as lots of other random days off, it’s seems rare they work a full week. Have been openly saying that they intend to take unpaid leave because they can’t see how they will possibly manage on 25 days when they were used to 40 days and asking how does anyone do that with kids? I have not dissimilar aged kids and have managed with 25 days for my whole career. There are no special needs or circumstances. Their job is flexible and from home.
AIBU that they should learn to manage within their holiday allowance that they accepted by contract? Or as the extra leave is unpaid is this an acceptable strategy? It seems to me they intend to exploit parental leave just because they feel entitled to more holiday than they are contracted to have.
Our company charges customers rates for their time and will therefore lose revenue as we can’t charge when they are OOO. I am their line manager.
I have managed people for 20 years and have never come across anyone with this attitude before, when I have managed people who have taken parental leave it has been for understandable reasons.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 05/05/2023 09:36

HunterHearstHelmsley
That sounds like a management issue to be fair and the person being last minute.

It shouldn't be a surprise to anyone (parents or managers) that parents are going to need to make arrangements for school holidays.

Someone I know said their company spreads the school holidays leave our across the team once everyone puts their leave requests in at the start of the year. That way nobody ends up working all of them (and paying childcare) whilst others get most of them off. It seemed like a fair system.

PicturesOfDogs · 05/05/2023 09:31

HunterHearstHelmsley · 05/05/2023 09:27

Parental leave, annual leave, unpaid leave, whatever kind of leave is very much the beeswax of someone's line manager.

Only insofar as when it occurs. They can’t stop it from happening.

And has been mentioned, parental leave can not be denied, only deferred.

What is actually done on this leave is nobodies business.

And all the people saying he’s dine things without his kids with his AL, so what? You can use AL for whatever you want.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 05/05/2023 09:27

ItsCalledAConversation · 05/05/2023 09:16

YABU, and a nosey Parker. This really is none of your beeswax. You come off quite jealous and superior in your OP.

Parental leave, annual leave, unpaid leave, whatever kind of leave is very much the beeswax of someone's line manager.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 05/05/2023 09:26

Parental leave is a fab idea. I've found it doesn't always work well though. I used to work with someone who would always request 4 weeks over the summer holidays, a month before the holidays. Every year, she was told no and offered September or October but she needed the summer holidays for obvious reasons. Unfortunately so did half of the team and the leave calendar was always full.

I never did understand why she didn't just request it earlier!

ihavespoken · 05/05/2023 09:22

Thanks for the thread!
I am a manager and responsible for staff issues in our small organisation - thanks to this thread I'm going to make sure all our employees are aware of this entitlement as I don't think any of them know about it.

Rawandreal1974 · 05/05/2023 09:21

As long as she’s been there for a year she can take the annual leave she’s entitled to
all completely fair !
what is also fair is if she wants time off here and there for anything at all in her work time then it is also only fair that every hour taken is part of her parental leave also
I suggest you ensure all sick leave is accurately recoded / covered by sick notes also just in case she is not able to take her parental leave yet.
Im sure people wfh are also monitored rigorously for their performance / attendance also ?
Rights work both ways

ItsCalledAConversation · 05/05/2023 09:16

YABU, and a nosey Parker. This really is none of your beeswax. You come off quite jealous and superior in your OP.

LlynTegid · 05/05/2023 09:12

I assume the holiday amount and policies were known to him when he accepted the job, or beforehand?

PumpkinSoup21 · 05/05/2023 09:06

Friendlybreadbin · 04/05/2023 12:58

Agree what he does on his leave is his business and no I’m not judging it. That comment was made to address those who thought his holiday/leave was all about spending time with the kids - it isn’t. But that is completely his business how he spends his leave.
The comment above about ‘how can it possibly affect the business as everyone has has the same leave’ is exactly the point. He is planning on taking far more leave than everyone else in the business. And we charge his customers for his services on an annual basis, which has set hours associated which he has only now announced he won’t fulfil.
I have approved all his leave requests so far as he is entitled to his leave and I’m not actually an arse. I just commented to him that he had used a lot of his leave so early in the year, and that’s when he announced his unpaid leave plan, followed by parental leave when he’d been there a year. So this was news to me, having been fairly approving his leave to that point.

The point is that either he is entitled to this leave or he is not, under your company policies and the law. If he is entitled to it then he is entitled to it. It’s not cheeky or out of order to take the leave you are entitled to. It’s healthy and shows you have good boundaries.

Leave requests should only be denied if there are business critical circumstances (e.g. the head of accounts can’t book the week off just before the end of the tax year because then the accounts won’t get done and the company could be penalised financially). It doesn’t sound like this is the case because ‘over the course of the year he might not do everything we want’ set against his entitlement to leave isn’t a business critical argument.

The fact that your company only works as well as it should if no one takes their full leave entitlement is the problem.

As a line manager I would actually be using this as a prompt to have a conversation with my team and those higher up about how we can ensure everyone does take their leave and understands that they are entitled to it. If workloads are too high to allow for that then that needs to be addressed.

The research on 4 day weeks and flexible working suggests that flexibility and time off aids productivity.

80s · 05/05/2023 09:03

the absences are causing issues for the business.
If the business's profits and operations are based on employees not taking the leave they are entitled to, OP, then that is not your fault or the fault of this one employee. It's the company's poor policy making your job harder than it should be.

Elaina87 · 05/05/2023 09:01

I was confused about why you were bothered until you said you were their line manager. As their LM it's you're responsibility to manage their holiday allowance and you have the autonomy to decline a request if it's going to be a problem for the team (obviously with good reason) . And to ensure they manage and spread their holidays out appropriately so they aren't left with nothing by the middle of the year, meaning they start taking sickness absence or requesting lots of unpaid leave (obviously parental leave is a right). I do think 25 days per year is difficult for someone with kids, and it's a shame more companies don't offer buying holidays etc, life is for living afterall! We shouldn't have to sell our souls to our employer.

Olios · 05/05/2023 08:51

Wow you sound jealous. If he chooses to take UNPAID leave to manage his work life balance then good on him for taking control of his life.

You are his manager you should be helping him achieve a good balance. Company profits don't trump good employee mental health. You may find he is more productive when he works if he feels happier and healthier.

ImAvingOops · 05/05/2023 08:39

OP, I certainly wouldn't be approving all their requests unless it truly didn't disadvantage other employees and the business. I think it's taking a job under false pretences tbh, so I wouldn't be prioritising them getting the time off that everyone wants, if that means other employees having to cover their work at busy periods or not getting an equal opportunity for time off themselves. It has to work for the business and be fair to other workers.
You can say no to them just deciding on an ad hoc basis when they want to work and make them schedule parental leave for when it doesn't negatively impact the business.

silverbubbles · 05/05/2023 08:37

Can't believe I never knew this existed. Would have made my life a whole lot easier.....

Livelifelaughter · 05/05/2023 08:30

I had a colleague who asked to reduce his hours to a 4 day week. The company refused so he took a parental leave day (teenage children) one day a week until it was used up and then left; he was excellent at his job and it was a great loss. I don't have children and am too old to have them now but I still think PR is a great idea for larger companies because what tends to happen is that when these policies are in place companies tend to try and make better policies for all staff.
I get 30 days a year and buy 5 and it's a major incentive for me to stay with the company.

SteakExpectations · 05/05/2023 08:25

With parental leave though, you only get 13 weeks and so what does he plan to do once those have all been used up??

He took the job knowing what the holiday entitlement is. I think it’s time for a frank chat!

Dibbydoos · 05/05/2023 08:19

They're obviously paid well, lol!

You can approve or otherwise unpaid leave based on business need - Id read that as actual work load being too high for the rest of the team to cope and not turnover, though turnover could be considered as business critical if the company is struggling.

The use of parental leave is evidence based. Childcare during school holidays falling through, illness etc.

You need to speak to them. Be very clear the business imperatives and where it is acceptable to use parental leave. You could offer them a part-time contract. This may in fact solve your and their problems eg 4 day week versus 5, assuming your workload can accommodate this.

The point is with someone who feels entitled to abc they will do whatever it takes to obtain whatever it is they feel entitled to, so make that outcome best for you.

Good luck, I dislike entitled views, they're the same as people behaving like they have privilege.

ImAvingOops · 05/05/2023 08:13

Maybe I'm odd but I think if you take a full time job and then try to engineer it so you are only working 4 days per week, or want to take lots of time off (even unpaid), then you aren't doing the job you were hired for and agreed to do.

When she is taking unpaid leave, who is covering her job?

I think there's a responsibility for parents to assess whether they can manage on the holiday allowance before accepting a new job - I don't think it's right to take on a job and assume you can just work when it suits you.

icanneverthinkofnc · 05/05/2023 08:13

Another example of the haves and have nots. I had heard of parental leave, but only having worked in low paid retail. The only people I knew taking it was for emergency days off when a child was sick. Most couldn't really afford unpaid time off. I didn't know they could just take an extra holiday.

Most just exploited sick, so they still got paid to the point of keeping reminder on their phones of when they could take another week without instigating disciplinary action. We all knew who did it.

FarmGirl78 · 05/05/2023 08:12

Sissynova · 05/05/2023 07:21

  1. @FarmGirl78 Parental, or dependents/emergency carers leave is for emergencies only, such as your child being sick, or husband needing help at home after a car crash. Once it's beyond a couple of days it's not an emergency and instead other plans should really be made, such as using annual leave. If you don't have enough annual leave left then it's unpaid.

Totally wrong. Emergency carers leave is not the same as parental leave. Parental leave is not for emergencies. It is a statutory leave entitlement that every company has to allow their employees to take. It is booked in 1 week blocks. It is for spending time with your children, even taking them on holidays.

Yep I've learned that now.... Someone else pointed it out. Apologies! I'm lucky that my organisation is really good with stuff like this - flexibility with work/life balance when it's needed is REALLY valuable and much appreciated.

MyFaceIsAnAONB · 05/05/2023 08:11

DH took 2 weeks last year. It was brilliant 😄We have 3 kids but yes, he wouldn't take 12 weeks every year because it's unpaid. But the option to take a few weeks every year to be with the kids is invaluable. And an entitlement. So we'll take what we're entitled to! Reminds me to get him to plan this years'!

Dguu6u · 05/05/2023 08:03

Wow I'm glad you're not my manager, what an old-fashioned attitude. People are so set on putting their job before their kids. If he can afford it, let him have his days off. Offer that flexibility and chances are he'll be a good and loyal worker.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 05/05/2023 08:01

Friendlybreadbin · 04/05/2023 21:21

He hasn’t said yet how much he intends to take. But he used to have 30 days and buy 10, so I am anticipating that he will be taking 40 instead of 25.

Try saying this;

”no, you won’t be able to do that this year, but once you’ve been here a year you can request parental leave in line with company policy. Also, for the remainder of your first year with us, we will only be able to authorise leave that you’ve already accrued. Hope that clears things up.”

why did he take a job with the leave that doesn’t suit him? I get 25 days plus bank hols plus can buy 10, I just wouldn’t go anywhere that didn’t have a good leave package unless I was desperate, in which case I’d have to just suck it up.

GracePalmer33 · 05/05/2023 07:58

I guess if it is starting to negatively impact the "needs of the business" then you should discuss it with HR and see if there are any policies etc.

Tbh I think it would probably be a good thing if more people started doing things like this... like someone else posted, maternity leave didn't used to be a legal requirement and it's good that it is (although could be a lot lot better). I would prefer more holidays or more flexibility to spend more time with my family.

Some people stay late and work unpaid overtime every single day (my sister as an example) and get resentful at the people who can't and won't saying that it is "expected in this line of work". Why? Why should companies be getting free labour from people. If people stopped doing it they'd stop expecting it. If people started requesting more leave then perhaps companies would start to offer that as a company benefit/perk and things then might make their way to actual legislation.

Cherryblossoms85 · 05/05/2023 07:58

Wish people would actually read the OP before jumping in. Don't have to RTFT but the post was quite clear about the situation.