Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not what parental leave is for?

409 replies

Friendlybreadbin · 03/05/2023 21:07

I may well BU but interested in people’s opinions. My company offers a fairly standard 25 days plus bank holidays leave package. New colleague comes from a company where they had been for over 20 years and so had got up to 30 days, their old company also offered a ‘buy an additional 10 days leave’ package. Our company doesn’t. Having passed their 3 month probation period (where they also took a lot of leave) they are using leave days like they are going out of fashion, and have already had a skiing holiday and an all inclusive this year. As well as lots of other random days off, it’s seems rare they work a full week. Have been openly saying that they intend to take unpaid leave because they can’t see how they will possibly manage on 25 days when they were used to 40 days and asking how does anyone do that with kids? I have not dissimilar aged kids and have managed with 25 days for my whole career. There are no special needs or circumstances. Their job is flexible and from home.
AIBU that they should learn to manage within their holiday allowance that they accepted by contract? Or as the extra leave is unpaid is this an acceptable strategy? It seems to me they intend to exploit parental leave just because they feel entitled to more holiday than they are contracted to have.
Our company charges customers rates for their time and will therefore lose revenue as we can’t charge when they are OOO. I am their line manager.
I have managed people for 20 years and have never come across anyone with this attitude before, when I have managed people who have taken parental leave it has been for understandable reasons.

OP posts:
Wallywobbles · 05/05/2023 12:18

Will he meet his KPIs? I'd be looking for an early performance review to outline the danger of taking excessive leave.

HurryShadow · 05/05/2023 12:17

I'm an employer. He is within his rights to use parental leave, obviously, but ensure you are au-fait with the rules. Parental leave is limited to a maximum of 18 weeks per child up to their 18th birthday. You should, therefore, find out from their previous employer if they have previously used any parental leave there, to keep a record of it.

Then, it must be taken in whole weeks, not individual days, unless your employer agrees otherwise. At this point, check your company's employee handbook and the contracts to see whether there are any specific references to this.

Our handbook says "If you are entitled to take parental leave... you should discuss your needs with a Director, who will identify your entitlements and look at the proposed leave periods dependent upon your child's particular circumstances and the operational aspects of the business".

The rules say that leave can't be postponed/delayed if the employer doesn't have a "significant reason", e.g. it would cause serious disruption to the business. Therefore you can postpone it if it does cause issues. If you do postpone it as employer you have to write to them within 7 days of the original request explaining why, suggest a new start date (within 6 months of the requested date) and you can't amend the amount of leave being requested.

So, ultimately, if agreeing to it creates a massive problem, you can tell him no and suggest an alternative date but firstly, he must properly request it (not demand or expect it) and you must respond within the rules.

Sorry if this has all been said elsewhere - I started typing it ages ago and got waylaid!

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 12:16

Hmmm he may not be there for a full year, there’s a way to go on that.

Next year if he is still there is a new bridge to cross if and when you get there.

minipie · 05/05/2023 12:07

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 11:52

Legally employers cannot refuse unpaid parental leave (provided the employee has been there a year or more).

But he hasn’t been there a year RTFT

I have read the full thread, I know he hasn’t been there more than a year. See my first response. The thing is, he will presumably still be there next year so the problem doesn’t just go away.

Anyway the poster I was responding to didn’t appear to realise that employers ever have to allow this kind of leave, this is the point I was making.

Ferferksake · 05/05/2023 11:59

YANBU. Sack him. He's not been there two years so just go through the process and get rid.

You don't apply for a job, knowing ALL the benefits that are being offered, take the job and then say "You know what, I think I'm special and deserve more than we agreed and more than my colleagues".

His entitled attitude is costing the company money, will piss off his colleagues, which will eventually cost the company more money. No, sorry, you don't sign a contract intending to breach it from day one. Get rid before the cancer spreads.

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 11:52

Legally employers cannot refuse unpaid parental leave (provided the employee has been there a year or more).

But he hasn’t been there a year RTFT

shammalammadingdong · 05/05/2023 11:31

Friendlybreadbin · 03/05/2023 21:37

They intend to ask for unpaid leave this summer and then have parental leave once they have been here a year.
As I said in the OP, I may very well BU here, and indeed some have suggested that I am - fair enough, I’ll take that on board. But as I say, I have managed people for many years and have never before come across this sense of entitlement to take additional leave in this manner. So it surprised me.

They have a sense of entitlement to something they are legally entitled to. Don't we all?

minipie · 05/05/2023 11:28

SD1978 · 05/05/2023 11:22

I don't understand the issue- if it can't be facilitated surely then the time off, paid or otherwise just isn't granted?

Legally employers cannot refuse unpaid parental leave (provided the employee has been there a year or more). They can defer it up to 6 months, if there is a significant business reason, but cannot refuse it.

SD1978 · 05/05/2023 11:22

I don't understand the issue- if it can't be facilitated surely then the time off, paid or otherwise just isn't granted?

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 10:16

parental leave is unpaid so they have to take a financial hit if they want to use leave like this

He isn’t entitled to parental leave.

Companies employ people because they can make more money out of them than their salary. If everyone just took unpaid leave willynilly it impacts negatively on the business performance.

Completely agree with the poster above saying life is miserable on 25 days. Low holiday entitlements stop good people applying for jobs. Maybe this is why they’ve ended up with him.

MinnieGirl · 05/05/2023 10:14

I’ve never heard of parental leave so had to look it up…. Seems like a useful benefit especially for school hols. But in practice I suspect it could be a pain especially if you have several workers all wanting leave.

Surely when this person applied for the job the annual leave entitlement was made clear? And they accepted the job? They really can’t moan about it now! If their holidays are that important to them, and I know many people who go away every 8 weeks, then surely they could have negotiated at interview?

Also, during the probation period, they would only be able to take a set amount pro rata? When I worked the probation period was 3 months so you would only have been able to take annual leave that you were entitled to for that period of time. And no more.

If you are their line manager, surely you can refuse unpaid leave? And make it clear that the holiday entitlement was clearly stated. We all like our holidays, but if they are off on unpaid leave it might be that someone else can’t take their holiday entitlement. And it’s going to end up with bad feeling all round. They can apply for parental leave but extra unpaid leave on top of that is very cheeky. Hopefully they won’t like being told no and will leave…

tenbob · 05/05/2023 10:14

ItsCalledAConversation · 05/05/2023 10:07

Sorry, didn’t see that this was their line manager. And I have been a line manager, for 15 years, although I’m not now. Thanks for your snap judgement though.

Still I don’t see the issue, it’s a good thing that people are working more flexibly now and making companies pay for their responsibilities to families and employee mental health. If what the employee is doing is within the bounds of their contract then they should be able to do it without judgement.

Maybe try reading the OP again?

because first of all, you missed the bit where OP said she was the line manager

then you missed the bit where OP says it will cause problems with billing customers for colleague’s work (“I don’t see the issue”)

Then you missed the bit where OP says they are planning to attempt to take parental leave even though they aren’t entitled to it this year (“if what the employee is doing is within the bounds of their contract”)

Heronwatcher · 05/05/2023 10:11

Oh and beware of “survivorship bias”, I personally agree that managing a house and small kids on only 25 days leave is bloody miserable, and expensive- things have changed for the better and quite rightly.

UnionRep · 05/05/2023 10:11

I work in the public sector. When a staff member has a year's service and is entitled to Parental Leave, no problem. Before that. any unpaid leave has to be for a legitimate reason and can only be taken when ALL normal annual leave has been taken. So you have to manage with your leave, when it's all used you can apply for unpaid but there would have to be a good reason or it would be refused.

Heronwatcher · 05/05/2023 10:10

I think they are not necessarily being U as parental leave is unpaid so they have to take a financial hit if they want to use leave like this. But I would be encouraging them to make any application for parental leave asap (I don’t think you can insist), so you can make sure the business won’t suffer when they are off, and also reminding them that if necessary parental leave can be postponed for up to 6 months, so they should absolutely not be booking holidays etc until it’s been approved.

minipie · 05/05/2023 10:07

So OP your situation is pretty simple for now, colleague has not been there a year so is not entitled to unpaid parental leave. You simply need to make this clear before they “spend” any more days.

The problem will obviously arise next year as they will be entitled to it by then. However, that gives you time to think about how to deal with it.

Do you need to change the way you bill clients perhaps, so it doesn’t assume X days or hours are worked? What do you do about part time employees - or don’t you have any?

Do you need to speak to clients to find out if they are happy to have someone on their team who is likely to be unavailable for extra weeks? If clients are not happy then you may need to explain this to colleague and that this will affect what projects he is staffed on. However IME clients are generally fine as long as there is cover.

Do you need to tell colleague that you will only approve parental leave to be taken at certain particular times of year when there is more cover available and/or it will matter less to the clients’ businesses ( you are entitled to do this as an employer)? This will prevent him from taking AL for odd days and then using unpaid PL for family summer holidays.

Ultimately your job here is to protect the business’s interests, within the law. If it is genuinely causing business issues then first consider if they are solvable (eg change in billing approach). If they are not solvable then make him defer the leave to when it is least inconvenient for the business, and explain it will impact his performance/progress at work.

ItsCalledAConversation · 05/05/2023 10:07

tenbob · 05/05/2023 09:50

Tell me you’ve never been a line manager without telling me you’ve never been a line manager

Sorry, didn’t see that this was their line manager. And I have been a line manager, for 15 years, although I’m not now. Thanks for your snap judgement though.

Still I don’t see the issue, it’s a good thing that people are working more flexibly now and making companies pay for their responsibilities to families and employee mental health. If what the employee is doing is within the bounds of their contract then they should be able to do it without judgement.

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 10:07

I don’t think I could approve it if it wasn’t entitled to.

No one has asked for this though in 20 or so years of line management 🤷🏻‍♀️

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 05/05/2023 10:04

If the extra leave if effecting the company and other staff, you don’t have to approve it. He can ask till he is blue in the face but you can say no if it doesn’t work for the team. Just because you are entitled doesn’t mean it can be so.

WilsonMilson · 05/05/2023 10:03

I’d have just got rid at end of probationary period as this attitude towards holidays was clearly evident during.

It’s going to become an issue. Also I think you have to be much stronger in not allowing leave that they are not entitled to, unpaid or not, surely the needs of the business are the priority for you as line manager. If this person cannot fulfil their role and are taking leave willy nilly, just get rid while you can.

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 09:56

The only reason I can think of is that it was agreed before he started as they were desperate for him to work for them and he wouldn’t accept the holiday entitlement. I have some sympathy for that I wouldn’t want 25 days either having been used to more.

ThreeFeetTall · 05/05/2023 09:54

Why would anyone be granted unpaid leave in the first 12 months unless it was some sort of emergency? Only time I've heard of it was when people were stuck abroad due to flights being cancelled

tenbob · 05/05/2023 09:50

ItsCalledAConversation · 05/05/2023 09:16

YABU, and a nosey Parker. This really is none of your beeswax. You come off quite jealous and superior in your OP.

Tell me you’ve never been a line manager without telling me you’ve never been a line manager

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 09:50

I am a manager and responsible for staff issues in our small organisation - thanks to this thread I'm going to make sure all our employees are aware of this entitlement as I don't think any of them know about it.

Anecdotally parental leave is frowned upon in many work places. It is an entitlement but that doesn’t always help if they tell you it’s too busy in the school holidays and you have to defer to outside the holidays.

It’s pretty rare that people use it ime.

Teateaandmoretea · 05/05/2023 09:47

Why would he be granted unpaid leave if he isn’t entitled to parental leave in the first 12 months?

Unless your organisation has odd policies then the answer would be a big fat no at most companies.

You need to talk to your manager / HR about what to say to him. It’s utterly bizarre he’d think this was going to be agreed. It would be if he was entitled to parental leave but he isn’t.