Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not what parental leave is for?

409 replies

Friendlybreadbin · 03/05/2023 21:07

I may well BU but interested in people’s opinions. My company offers a fairly standard 25 days plus bank holidays leave package. New colleague comes from a company where they had been for over 20 years and so had got up to 30 days, their old company also offered a ‘buy an additional 10 days leave’ package. Our company doesn’t. Having passed their 3 month probation period (where they also took a lot of leave) they are using leave days like they are going out of fashion, and have already had a skiing holiday and an all inclusive this year. As well as lots of other random days off, it’s seems rare they work a full week. Have been openly saying that they intend to take unpaid leave because they can’t see how they will possibly manage on 25 days when they were used to 40 days and asking how does anyone do that with kids? I have not dissimilar aged kids and have managed with 25 days for my whole career. There are no special needs or circumstances. Their job is flexible and from home.
AIBU that they should learn to manage within their holiday allowance that they accepted by contract? Or as the extra leave is unpaid is this an acceptable strategy? It seems to me they intend to exploit parental leave just because they feel entitled to more holiday than they are contracted to have.
Our company charges customers rates for their time and will therefore lose revenue as we can’t charge when they are OOO. I am their line manager.
I have managed people for 20 years and have never come across anyone with this attitude before, when I have managed people who have taken parental leave it has been for understandable reasons.

OP posts:
rosiebl · 03/05/2023 22:23

I work in the industry of clients paying for time and this situation is a disaster for planning in pipeline if work and ensuring the right levels of billability to be profitable as an organisation.
I think I would involve your HR team as what's happening is setting up custom and practice for the future. I would suggest that you organise a meeting with her to review her absences, and start to problem solve on why she is absent so frequently. It might be better for her to go part time if she prefers?
Honestly though, I would get rid.

AfraidToRun · 03/05/2023 22:22

It would annoy me as an employer, would make cover and resourcing very difficult but I can see why people take it.

I think it's fine as long as there's a conversation about when was best for both parties (e.g in my job any leave in April is usually very restricted but July would be fairly open).

Stokey · 03/05/2023 22:22

@JandalsAlways I've recently started a new job but already had a 2 week break booked over Easter. So I worked for 4 weeks and then was off for 2 weeks. I was totally up front about it but wasn't prepared to cancel my holiday just because I was changing jobs.

If they've taken lots of leave during their probation period OP, presumably they'll have less later in the year. This is what will happen to me.

JandalsAlways · 03/05/2023 22:21

GeraltsBathtub · 03/05/2023 22:18

Never had a job where my probation was contingent on showing sufficient enthusiasm. Usually it’s about meeting objectives and work being up to scratch…

I agree generally, but I would think this also might be a factor. (I've also taken leave in the first 3 months, I'm just saying this may be an indication as many things are, and as OP has said its now becoming an issue 🤷‍♀️)

Tigofigo · 03/05/2023 22:19

Oinkypig · 03/05/2023 21:49

People don’t realise that while entitled to annual leave they are not entitled as to when that is taken so if it doesn’t fit with activity in the business then decline the leave. Parental leave people are entitled to but if it doesn’t work for legitimate business reasons it can be declined (although an alternative week has to be offered within the next 6 months) Hopefully you can work it out

It can only be postponed - not declined - for good business reason. Unless you work in a very seasonal business you're just kicking the can down the road and pissing your employee off.

OP the unpaid leave thing is definitely a risky strategy for that employee unless it's in their contract.

But parental leave can absolutely be taken for ANY reason related to your children pretty much, and your attitude towards it needs checking. How can you exploit something you are legally entitled to?

Plus - 25 days off would cover 5 weeks. Children have 13 weeks' holiday per year. Plus another 5 or 6 days in strikes this year with 2/3 yet to come. Plus they get ill and have inset days. Overall this year it will probably total 15 weeks off school for my DC.

Most families would like at least 2 weeks' a year together over say Christmas and summer, I don't think that's unreasonable. That leaves 7 weeks not covered - even if parents spent every day of their leave looking after their kids (god forbid they actually take a day off leave only for themselves!!). So by that logic, you think children should spend 7 weeks of their holidays in full time childcare and parents shouldn't even have a day off holiday for themselves.

Sounds like a pretty shit life.

GeraltsBathtub · 03/05/2023 22:18

JandalsAlways · 03/05/2023 21:58

Taking lots of leave would be a red flag to me, usually this is where you're trying to get up to speed etc, depending on other factors it would indicate to me that the person wasn't that interested in their job (and it sounds like they aren't if they're always wanting to go away).

Never had a job where my probation was contingent on showing sufficient enthusiasm. Usually it’s about meeting objectives and work being up to scratch…

Facetyme · 03/05/2023 22:16

JandalsAlways · 03/05/2023 21:58

Taking lots of leave would be a red flag to me, usually this is where you're trying to get up to speed etc, depending on other factors it would indicate to me that the person wasn't that interested in their job (and it sounds like they aren't if they're always wanting to go away).

Tell me you’re over 40 without telling me you’re over 40.

GeraltsBathtub · 03/05/2023 22:14

@Womencanlift I was offered a job last year at a company that only offered 25 days and no option to buy more. I turned it down for that reason + them only offering SMP!

Snoopsnoggysnog · 03/05/2023 22:13

Cantstaystuckforever · 03/05/2023 21:16

Maybe it's a sign for you to take some more leave with your kids?

I've often had the same guilt feelings you have about taking leave, letting down my team etc - and now I look back and wonder why I passed up spending precious weeks with my kids when they were so little, for the sake of a week's pay or for showing my 'willing' to bosses or coworkers who I'm unlikely to see again and who ultimately didn't care that much.

So long as when they are in the office, they're working properly, that's most important. They're not being paid for their extra time off, even if they're also not earning. And instead of feeling jealous, either acknowledge that you have different priorities, or let them do some extra cover when you reorganise things so you can do the same and take the leave.

Totally this!

I’ve taken it myself and have just put a request in to take some again this year. I’m amazed people don’t know about it. But can understand it’s not affordable to everyone.

OP my firm also charges clients for our time daily. I worked out how much my time off would cost them in terms of lost revenue. It was something like 0.01% of annual sales. So I’m not going to lose any sleep over it.

Wexone · 03/05/2023 22:12

God you would hate me. we were flat out during lockdowns aswell as short staffed. we weren't allowed to take holidays sometimes hence a good bit of annula leave was built up. am using up a good bit between this year so far. took 8 weeks off last year. so far this year took 3 days off Jan week off Feb and March 3 days easter and will be 3 days in May. some of them have been sporadic days here and there like your employee. there has been no issue taking them some were last minute too. made sure my work was done caught up when back. boss happy. hope to take altogether 8 weeks off this year and that will get my leave balance down a good bit. to me taking sporadic days off means I can get some things done at home help out bringing family to hopistal or babysitting nieces and nephews or recently enjoying the fab weather we have been having recently. I work hard at work but alos love my days off doing what I wnat to do.

Whichnumbers · 03/05/2023 22:12

In my previous job I had 28 days annual leave, 8/9 days bank holiday, an extra day at Xmas and also for many years flex time ( with rules) but flex was stopped in covid and never reinstated

I could take 12 days flex per year, if obviously I’d got the hours, which a generally had as my rota would often have me starting at 8.30 instead of 9am and finishing at 5:30 instead of 5pm, if a client ran over then it’d be 6pm

so I’d book a bank holiday week, Tuesday flex, 3 days annual leave and I’d got 9 days. I be savage with my annual leave and pretty much have a week a month

I worked well in return, was on the ball & it was a good life work balance. I actually enjoyed the work & challenges but probably due to the decent balance

Womencanlift · 03/05/2023 22:10

I have never known a company not to offer the chance to buy holidays, I thought that was a pretty standard part of benefits packages. So if they are used to it, and have built their life and childcare, if they need it, around having 40 days then it will take them time to adjust

They are the ones that are paying for it by having lower wages as this leave is unpaid, so if they are entitled to it then they are not doing anything wrong

You as the manager though have it in your gift to decline the leave. So YABU to not be managing this to suit the needs of the business which is what you should be doing

Evenin · 03/05/2023 22:08

I took 8 weeks one year - 4 weeks for each child.

I'm planning on taking more at some point - that's on top of my 35 days of annual leave, shock horror!!

LuciferRising · 03/05/2023 22:08

For some reason I did not know about this. Going to read up tomorrow. I'd like more time over the summer with DD.

CorporaINobbyNobbs · 03/05/2023 22:07

I don’t really understand what you mean by saying ‘they intend to take unpaid leave’. In my company you can’t just take unpaid leave when you feel like it (not parental) - don’t you have to approve it as pp have said?

QuickGuide · 03/05/2023 22:07

Parental leave is there to allow them to spend time with children.

Beyond that, when they apply for unpaid leave, you need to manage that if it doesn't suit the business.

Invisimamma · 03/05/2023 22:04

Yabu. It's about time more people and companies re-evaluated annual leave, anything that promotes a positive work-life balance is good.

I have a similar attitude to your colleague. I work to live I don't live to work and try to stroke a balance between earning enough for a decent standard of living and enjoying and living life to the full. Can't do that if we're always at work, we don't get these years back. It's not a race to the bottom.

But when I'm at work I work bloody hard and I'm good at what I do.

Spiderboy · 03/05/2023 22:02

I’ve never seen it either OP as most parents probably can’t afford to. But it is legal and something employers need to work with.

GiltEdges · 03/05/2023 22:02

LolaSmiles · 03/05/2023 21:17

Why shouldn't they take unpaid parental leave? If it's been agreed with the line manager then why is it your business?

If you have concerns about your workload or your job then raise that with your line manager. It's their job to appropriately manage workflow.

You sound like one of those people who thinks other people shouldn't have nice things because "I made do without nice things".

Did you miss the bit where OP is the line manager?

JandalsAlways · 03/05/2023 21:58

GeraltsBathtub · 03/05/2023 21:54

Why is taking leave during the probation period a red flag if it was approved by their manager? Since their probation is 3 months you’d expect them to take at least 1/4 of their leave allowance.

Taking lots of leave would be a red flag to me, usually this is where you're trying to get up to speed etc, depending on other factors it would indicate to me that the person wasn't that interested in their job (and it sounds like they aren't if they're always wanting to go away).

Gymmum82 · 03/05/2023 21:56

My workplace has a generous sick leave (6 months full pay) many people work 6 months then take 6 months off sick. People will get away with what they can get away with

JandalsAlways · 03/05/2023 21:55

Glencococo · 03/05/2023 21:46

I’m sure this has been said but if you’re their line manager shouldn’t you be clued up on the different types of leave and what they are entitled to? Do they have to book leave through you? If so can’t you just say no (unless they are entitled to it), where I work unpaid leave is discretionary, parental leave entitlement is obviously not.

This too. As a manager you should be clued up on this it's part of your job. If you have an HR department then engage them as well.

TillyTollyTully · 03/05/2023 21:54

AIBU that they should learn to manage within their holiday allowance that they accepted by contract?

Yes yabu.

They're not asking for additional holiday allowance. They're telling you that they intend to take unpaid parental leave, which is their right.

I wouldn't tie yourself up in knots over it because it's pointless - your opinions are irrelevant and once they've been there a year you cannot decline their request - only delay it slightly.

Lots of people are unaware of the right to unpaid PL. If you have other employees with dc I'd brace yourself because there will probably be more taking advantage once they're aware.

I took 6 weeks off last year, the whole summer. Once word got around there must have been another dozen or so applications from my dept for anything from 1-12 weeks. All people who never even knew it existed until I talked about it.

GeraltsBathtub · 03/05/2023 21:54

JandalsAlways · 03/05/2023 21:51

Why did they pass their probation period if they took lots of leave (red flag). Also I thought your leave being approved is dependent on your line manager (you) and the workload, deadlines, and impact on the team. If you're the line manager then you need to set the boundaries.

Why is taking leave during the probation period a red flag if it was approved by their manager? Since their probation is 3 months you’d expect them to take at least 1/4 of their leave allowance.

Fiorione · 03/05/2023 21:54

Friendlybreadbin · 03/05/2023 21:42

You might be right…I’ll think about that.

You're doing well to take the comments on board, OP. I'm sure that makes you a good manager in lots of ways.

I'm absolutely in favour people taking whatever holidays they can (legitimately) to do whatever works for them, makes them able to cope, allows them to feel happier, whatever.

Some people operate better on regular odd days off, others need 14 straight days full relaxation.

Work/life balance is different things for different people, and many employees are seeking to flex that post-COVID. I'm all for it, tbh (and I say that as a business owner myself).